Lil Red Posted June 14, 2008 Posted June 14, 2008 +J.M.J.+ i read [url="http://www.conversiondiary.com/"]Et Tu?[/url] blog, which is a great blog of a former atheist and she's got a post up about suffering ([url="http://www.conversiondiary.com/2008/06/hbtt-fear-of-suffering-and-culture-of.html"]here[/url]) that got me to thinking. [quote]Ever since I first came across these thoughts, over and over again I see that respect for human life and hatred of any kind of suffering are inversely proportional: as one increases, the other decreases. But I don't know how to articulate the situation any further than that.[/quote] then, she goes on to ask these questions, which i'm posing to you:[list=1] [*]Why is it that fear of suffering leads to decreased respect for human life? [*]How does the fact that people increasingly deny the existence of a real, personal, evil force (Satan) factor into all this, if at all? [*]What about fearing other people's suffering (or potential suffering) on their behalf -- how can we be deeply compassionate and helpful without falling into the dangerous "your life isn't worth living" territory? [*]If there is a connection, what can we do? How does rethinking suffering factor into working towards turning around the trend of decreasing respect for the dignity of human life in the world today? [*]Any other thoughts on this subject? [/list]definitely go read the whole post, and i'd love to hear your feedback.
Fr. Antony Maria OSB Posted June 14, 2008 Posted June 14, 2008 Well, here's my input in a nutshell (I hvae to go, but I wanted to comment on this): [quote name='Lil Red' post='1570942' date='Jun 13 2008, 09:56 PM']1. Why is it that fear of suffering leads to decreased respect for human life?[/quote] Suffering is a part of human life: we can't escape it. If you fear suffering enough, it can lead to hate (don't hate, appreciate) of suffering, and this, in effect, could lead to a decreased respect for human life, as suffering is a part of life. [quote]2. How does the fact that people increasingly deny the existence of a real, personal, evil force (Satan) factor into all this, if at all?[/quote] Doesn't Satan want us to deny his existence? I think this whole idea I got from Fr. John Corapi, but doesn't it go back to if you deny the existence of the enemy you can't fight him, so to speak, and then the enemy has a better chance at hurting you? The denial of Satan could factor into this by making more suffering for people, perhaps. [quote]3. What about fearing other people's suffering (or potential suffering) on their behalf -- how can we be deeply compassionate and helpful without falling into the dangerous "your life isn't worth living" territory?[/quote] I think here it would come down to how we could best help someone who is suffering. If we fear the suffering of another person, then wouldn't this fear drive us away from them, essentially irradicating all chance of compassion? I guess that's what the question is asking, lol. I guess all we could do here is come to the realization that as terrible as suffering can be, fearing it won't solve anything: in the worst case it can lead to the "your life isn't worth living" territory. In essence we have to come to the realization that suffering is not the end, just as the Cross wasn't the end, but the beginning. The whole concept of redemptive suffering. [quote]4. If there is a connection, what can we do? How does rethinking suffering factor into working towards turning around the trend of decreasing respect for the dignity of human life in the world today?[/quote] Better and more education in the Faith. It makes no sense to simple human reason that suffering can be used for good, especially in this age when everyone wants everything now and doesn't think of the effects that instances today can have later on in life. Or perhaps showing others how selfless suffering can help others and change the world for the better. I just started reading [i]Death Be Not Proud[/i] last night, and perhaps this can fit here: even though the boy was not very religious (if at all) the message he was able to spread by his simple love and concern for others, even in the face of his own death, teaches a lot. If you really think about it, wouldn't elimating the fear of suffering in and of itself eliminate a lot of the suffering that goes on in the world (mental and emotional, at least). Please note that I'm not talking about cases of abuse, torture, or the like, but suffering that is comes to everyone at different times (illness, death in the family, etc.) I'll just leave it at that: I don't really know where I was going with this. May God bless and protect you always in all of your endeavors! Your Brother in Christ, Joe
aalpha1989 Posted June 14, 2008 Posted June 14, 2008 I'm not really sure I agree that hatred of suffering is a bad thing. Is that 'official'? Where is it written, or is it just an amateur theologian's speculation? (that's a real question)... Basically I know and understand that sometimes suffering can bring a good result, and sometimes we need it. It's still not a good thing. Kinda like how a soldier sometimes needs to shoot an enemy. That's a horrible thing, but it can be necessary. In heaven there will be no suffering. The need for that evil will be past. Just like the unfortunate need for war (i'm not necessarily talking about the current war, or any specific war... just war in general) will be past. We should despise war. We should also despise suffering. God did not make us to suffer, he made us to know, love, and serve him. Those things are supposed to bring joy. We are fallen, however. I think that a better statement would have been "To hate (don't hate, appreciate) suffering above all else leads to decreased respect for human life." Hatred of suffering itself is actually a form of respect for that life, no? It is just when you place the absence of suffering above life itself that you encounter problems. Eh. I might want to think about a couple of those things a little more (particularly my third paragraph), but what do y'all think?
Lounge Daddy Posted June 14, 2008 Posted June 14, 2008 These are some great questions. Very good observations.
Lil Red Posted June 15, 2008 Author Posted June 15, 2008 [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1571006' date='Jun 14 2008, 12:47 AM']I'm not really sure I agree that hatred of suffering is a bad thing. Is that 'official'? Where is it written, or is it just an amateur theologian's speculation? (that's a real question)... Basically I know and understand that sometimes suffering can bring a good result, and sometimes we need it. It's still not a good thing. Kinda like how a soldier sometimes needs to shoot an enemy. That's a horrible thing, but it can be necessary. In heaven there will be no suffering. The need for that evil will be past. Just like the unfortunate need for war (i'm not necessarily talking about the current war, or any specific war... just war in general) will be past. We should despise war. We should also despise suffering. God did not make us to suffer, he made us to know, love, and serve him. Those things are supposed to bring joy. We are fallen, however. I think that a better statement would have been "To h.ate suffering above all else leads to decreased respect for human life." Hatred of suffering itself is actually a form of respect for that life, no? It is just when you place the absence of suffering above life itself that you encounter problems. Eh. I might want to think about a couple of those things a little more (particularly my third paragraph), but what do y'all think?[/quote] +J.M.J.+ is there anything wrong with people just speculating about this question of suffering? do they have to be 'official' theologians? definitely read her whole post, not just what i posted here.
Lil Red Posted June 15, 2008 Author Posted June 15, 2008 [quote name='Lounge Daddy' post='1571007' date='Jun 14 2008, 01:03 AM']These are some great questions. Very good observations.[/quote] +J.M.J.+ so what are your thoughts?
Lil Red Posted June 15, 2008 Author Posted June 15, 2008 [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1571006' date='Jun 14 2008, 12:47 AM']In heaven there will be no suffering. The need for that evil will be past. Just like the unfortunate need for war (i'm not necessarily talking about the current war, or any specific war... just war in general) will be past. We should despise war. We should also despise suffering. God did not make us to suffer, he made us to know, love, and serve him. Those things are supposed to bring joy. We are fallen, however. I think that a better statement would have been "To h.ate suffering above all else leads to decreased respect for human life." Hatred of suffering itself is actually a form of respect for that life, no? It is just when you place the absence of suffering above life itself that you encounter problems.[/quote] +J.M.J.+ interesting thoughts. i'll have to think about that.
aalpha1989 Posted June 15, 2008 Posted June 15, 2008 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1571678' date='Jun 15 2008, 09:48 AM']+J.M.J.+ is there anything wrong with people just speculating about this question of suffering? do they have to be 'official' theologians? definitely read her whole post, not just what i posted here. [/quote] No, I didn't mean there was anything wrong. I was just asking if it was official before I said I disagreed. I'd like to know before I tell the magisterium I think they're wrong, so I was asking if it was offical.
CatherineM Posted June 15, 2008 Posted June 15, 2008 Suffering isn't a theological/philosophical thing for me. I live with chronic pain. There are times while singing with the choir at church, that I don't think I can stand for one more second. I just look up at the cross, and offer the pain up. It is nothing compared to what Christ suffered, and I know that he will help me shoulder it. I don't fear the suffering anymore. I embrace it. I certainly don't think it is from Satan.
Justin86 Posted June 15, 2008 Posted June 15, 2008 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1570942' date='Jun 14 2008, 12:56 PM'][*]Why is it that fear of suffering leads to decreased respect for human life?[/quote] This might sound weird at first but give me a chance to explain. Our most basic human instinct is self-preservation. This is a normal, natural resource humans have used for thousands of years that has helped guaranteed our survival as a species. The culture of death, on the other hand, aims to turn basic human nature on it's head by saying the avoidance of suffering is more valuable than our instinct of self-preservation. By getting a culture to avoid suffering at all costs Hell can manipulate it's souls to gradually accept their own destruction. Instead of valuing each and every person as a gift from God we as a society immediately value only what we can get out of that person. We want avoid suffering more than we want value every human life, so it makes sense to use others for our own personal gain, to suit our own personal wants. This is the basic mentality behind contraception within marriage. Children are viewed as a burden here, as something to be avoided, and by golly we're married so we have every right to have it whenever we want. Whether because of finances or for the reason that children test the patience of their parents, or even just because the couple wants more sex it is all summed up in modern man wishes to avoid suffering, and get what we can out of life at all costs. Now from here, we can see the next logical step onto abortion. If we are going to do everything possible to avoid suffering why should we accept any negative consequences of using each other for personal gain and suffer? A child is an expense, as we have already seen. Just get rid of it, in a quick conveinet, non-suffering to us way. Euthanasia quickly follows. While even the most pro-euthanasia doctors agree that there are strong enough pain killers to make euthanasia as an escape of psychical pain uanessacry, there is always the pain of paralysis, or being strapped to a hospital bed for the rest of one's foreseen life, among other things. A culture that wants only to avoid suffering doesn't wan to have to deal the inconveniences of being paralyzed, or a hospital bed. I once had a woman comment to me that if she had to choose between losing her life, and losing her arm, she would rather lose her life. There was just too much suffering attached to only having one arm for her apparently. I was absolutely stunned. It is here with euthanasia we finally see Hell getting what it wants out of the culture of death: for cultures to kill themselves. By finally convincing them to deny their most basic divinely instated instinct, it has achieved the most unnatural, and most distrotive spin of God's plan imaginable. Suicide. If offers an escape for our sufferings, a final end to their perceived meaninglessness. [quote][*]How does the fact that people increasingly deny the existence of a real, personal, evil force (Satan) factor into all this, if at all?[/quote] A good question. The best I can think of right now is by denying there is any real evil we can get rid of the pain of guilt. After all, we're all capable of good and evil, and while its true most of us aren't Hitler or Mussolini when it comes to evil, we have still all committed wrongs in our lives. Would a culture who values only the avoidance of suffering want there to be any recognition of good and evil if it means negative consequences would befall them? [quote][*]What about fearing other people's suffering (or potential suffering) on their behalf -- how can we be deeply compassionate and helpful without falling into the dangerous "your life isn't worth living" territory?[/quote] The key difference between someone who wants to truly help the sick, and a euthanasia advocate is the former has love and the latter has [i]fear[/i]. By watching someone person suffer the euthanasia advocate, taught that the purpose of our life is to avoid suffering, fears that he himself may wind up in the same condition. For example, the woman I mentioned earlier who would rather die than lose her arm, was actually an EMT! Those in the medical profession work with the weak and the suffering more than any other segment of our society. It makes sense that we would see them advocating such things. Fortunately for the culture of life, our viewpoint on suffering it is not difficult to understand. By accepting our crosses with courage, and offering them up to God we can find a purpose in our suffering. We no longer fear it, as we know it has it's purpose, and place in God's plan for fallen humanity. This can be difficult to execute in our daily lives, but at least when one understands and believes this he should at least be able to avoid the culture of death mindset making him collaborative in his own destruction. There's more, but perhaps someone else could take what I said further. I have to go to work now. Peace...
Deb Posted June 16, 2008 Posted June 16, 2008 Nice post Justin. I am not sure there is any correlation between hatred of suffering and lack of respect for human life. I think there are so many more factors that shape ones viewpoints and actions regarding the life issues. Abortion is so wide spread not because one would have to suffer through pregnancy, it is because people are too selfish to want to give up their fun, their money, their time for another human being, even one they are carrying. Maybe to have the child would be looked on as suffering but, I think that is different from physical suffering. We all hate (don't hate, appreciate) to watch others suffer. I would prefer to be the one suffering than the one sitting around holding a hand and watching that. So, I suppose that could lead some to hope for euthanasia so someone you loved could have a peaceful death. I do not believe it is our disdain for human suffering that leads to tragic death and murder, but either our selfishness of not wanting to have to inconvenience ourselves with someone elses suffering or else our severe inner pain at watching someone we love suffering. Either way, it is all about us. I have sat through at least a dozen surgeries my youngest brother has gone through and months upon months of recoveries in hospitals and care centers. It would never enter my mind that his life should be cut short so he wouldn't be suffering. He is my inspiration to smell of elderberries it up myself. He told me once when he was young that he told God that he was so used to suffering with surgeries etc. that he wanted all suffering that had to come to our family to come to him and not to the rest of us. I believe that has happened for the most part. We have been very blessed in our family with health and no life threatening injuries for a very long time. My brother just freaks if anyone else in the family is ill but, he withstands so much pain on a daily basis and blows off us worrying about him. I believe that all detachment from concern for life comes from turning one's face from God. The more we sin, the more distance we put between us and the Lord until we can no longer hear his voice, see his light, know his truth and there is no room left in our heart to even let him in. This is when we stop carrying about human rights. I don't think that is tied to suffering in any way. I think Satan fuels us on to turn as far from God as we can. People who can't turn to God certainly aren't going to admit that Satan could possibly exist or be in control of their lives.
Lil Red Posted June 16, 2008 Author Posted June 16, 2008 +J.M.J.+[quote name='aalpha1989' post='1571833' date='Jun 15 2008, 11:59 AM']No, I didn't mean there was anything wrong. I was just asking if it was official before I said I disagreed. I'd like to know before I tell the magisterium I think they're wrong, so I was asking if it was offical. [/quote] gotcha. [quote name='Justin86' post='1572358' date='Jun 15 2008, 08:55 PM']Whoa, that was a longer post than I expected.[/quote] that was an amazing post! [quote name='Deb' post='1572708' date='Jun 16 2008, 10:01 AM']I believe that all detachment from concern for life comes from turning one's face from God. The more we sin, the more distance we put between us and the Lord until we can no longer hear his voice, see his light, know his truth and there is no room left in our heart to even let him in. This is when we stop carrying about human rights. I don't think that is tied to suffering in any way. I think Satan fuels us on to turn as far from God as we can. People who can't turn to God certainly aren't going to admit that Satan could possibly exist or be in control of their lives.[/quote] i'm going to have to think about this.
Deb Posted June 16, 2008 Posted June 16, 2008 The original sin is what brought death to mankind. Satan was behind that. When we sin, we die in Christ and if we sin enough, we no longer know God's truth on what is right and wrong. Satan jumps in and before you know it, abortion, homosexual marriage, euthanasia all seem like great ideas. They are so far from God as are the people who promotoe them.
prose Posted June 16, 2008 Posted June 16, 2008 Wow. I finally had the chance to go and read the article. I totally can understand how fear of suffering leads to lack of respect for life. It is not the suffering that is necessarily from Satan, it is the fear. It is possible to fear something so much that it would be better to destroy it than face it. This is why abortion is so common. People fear the suffering of the pregnancy, of the birth, of the child. Euthanasia - fear of the suffering of the disease of the aging process. It becomes much easier to offer to destroy life in what seems like a quick solution rather than face the fear associated with it. The fear clouds the hope. Does that make sense?
Lil Red Posted June 16, 2008 Author Posted June 16, 2008 [quote name='prose' post='1572930' date='Jun 16 2008, 01:55 PM']Does that make sense?[/quote] +J.M.J.+
CatherineM Posted June 17, 2008 Posted June 17, 2008 I remember a movie called "Defending Your Life," where they based your entrance to heaven, so to speak because the movie included reincarnation, on fear. They kept sending people back to Earth until they learned to get over fear, so they could move on. Fear does seem to keep us back and make us avoid things.
aalpha1989 Posted June 17, 2008 Posted June 17, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1572052' date='Jun 15 2008, 05:27 PM']Suffering isn't a theological/philosophical thing for me. I live with chronic pain. There are times while singing with the choir at church, that I don't think I can stand for one more second. I just look up at the cross, and offer the pain up. It is nothing compared to what Christ suffered, and I know that he will help me shoulder it. I don't fear the suffering anymore. I embrace it. I certainly don't think it is from Satan.[/quote] I do understand what everyone means. I do understand how hatred of suffering COULD lead to acceptance of euthenasia. However, Suffering is still not a good thing. We accept the need for it like we accept the need for war. I don't think it is necessarily from Satan, like many seem to think I meant, but I also don't think it is a good thing. It can have good results, just like war. Doesn't that make any sense?
Deb Posted June 17, 2008 Posted June 17, 2008 I watched my grandfather suffer and die and I did not come away with any fear. I came away with the awe and the privilege of being with him as he left this world. I knew without a doubt that he was seeing something that I could not envision. That was way before I found religion. Now, I have no fear of anything. I know that any suffering will be worth what is awaiting us after this world. I totally believe that is because my heart is totally turned towards God now. Oh. I lied. I am afraid of beetle like bugs.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now