Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Well, I am not sure if this thread has a "point", but, something I read on another forum bothered me, and I just wanted to share it with all of you, if that's okay.

I was visiting the Christian Teen Forums, and someone brought up the topic of praying to saints. Not surprisingly, a lot of people disagreed, but what I found to be really disturbing was what another user posted:

[url="http://www.christianteenforums.com/index.php?showtopic=40256"]http://www.christianteenforums.com/index.php?showtopic=40256[/url]

[quote]It is foolish on two parts.
1. You can talk directly to God.
[b]2. The dead don't care about you (why should they?)
Why would they want to deal with a sinful world when they are through with it?[/b] It's there Sabbath.(resting place)[/quote]

This just repulsed me when I read it. I don't understand how anyone could think that. We are a family, are we not? And, dead or alive, we still should care about each other and ask for the prayers of other Christians, "dead" or alive. I mean, I suppose I understand if one disagrees, but to say that they don't care? It just really sounded repulsive that this person could imply that we couldn't care less about our brothers and sisters on earth once we reach heaven, as if they don't matter anymore. It's really saddening to me, actually.

*sigh* sorry if this thread makes no sense...but what do you guys think about this?

Posted

Selah,

That is very sad. It's probably because they don't have an understanding of the Communion of Saints the way we do.

I would say if anything they care a lot more. They are in a state of complete adoration and love of God. I don't see how anyone in that state could not care for their fellow brethren who are not enjoying that state. Revelation speaks about the prayers of the Saints being poured out on the altar in Heaven. They've gotta be praying for something, I'm pretty positive it's pitiful us who have yet to achieve sanctification.

homeschoolmom
Posted

Why should the dead care about us? Because God does... duh...

:doh:

samfran08x3
Posted

thats a terrible and sad thing for someone to say.
I'd bug me too.

Posted

There are times that I ask my dad for help, and he's been dead many years. It's not any different than that. Sometimes you just have to get a group of people to work together to get something accomplished. We don't worship the saints, we just ask them to help us. Sometimes we can use all the help we can get.

Posted

Selah, this is coming from my perspective, Pure Protestant, before even considering the Catholic Church as the truth...you have hit the nail on the head as to why the whole idea of "The Rapture" and the "Woohoo, we're dead, screw Earth" things repulse me.

That, as you put it, "It just really sounded repulsive that this person could imply that we couldn't care less about our brothers and sisters on earth once we reach heaven, as if they don't matter anymore." That's a frighteningly common view, and indeed, a really sad one. I know people who are quite content and praying fervently for the Rapture, just so they don't have to "care about this old sin filled world no more, because in Heaven we'll be too blitzed to care".

What's worse is when you run into the type who hope for The Rapture just to laugh and mock the unfaithful who get "Left Behind" as they're tortured to death. Now I know that the reply you read wasn't about the Rapture, but the same principle holds...the sickening idea that those in Heaven don't care about Earth, that they no longer care whether or not a person knows Christ, that they no longer care if a loved one is dying, that they no longer care for the heartfelt prayers of their fellow men and women...

Farsight one
Posted

Please tell me you replied to that...

Posted

haha...well, I'm not a member of that forum, but I might join just to debate this fellow...:P

Posted

Always remember, when in debate it's not necessarily what you say to the person you are debating, if they believe you or not, it's the Lurkers! They are the ones who are generally open-minded and searching.

johnnydigit
Posted

i spent about a year on a protestant teen site, defending nonstop. it was great in that i was forced to learn a lot on my own in order to present the faith properly, and i learned great patience when doing apologetics. i learned a lot of charity as well, because i would get pretty mean and forget that i was outnumbered by mostly teen protestant girls there. the lasting impression i have is that it is like a vacuum that the evil one uses to smell of elderberries people into endless circular arguments. fortunately God was able to draw good out of it for me, but now i really try to stay away from pointless arguing. it takes a lot of strength to walk away. otherwise, it only gives you stress and keeps you stagnant. we should be moving forward and growing, not as if we're attached to a boat anchor, or even worse, fall backwards. granted you can help people, but you must choose your battles wisely.

apologetics = monumental time waster if not controlled. you could even make things worse. in the end i slowly disappeared after making several threads that clearly defined what we really believe, in a way they could easier understand it. if there was any need after that, i would just link them to it instead of repeating myself over, and over, and over, and over, and over again.

HisChildForever
Posted

I looked at that site and it looks chaotic. Everyone there has a different interpretation of what Christianity is. I bet there are debates everywhere, not just in their debate forum.

Galloglasses
Posted

Eccumenicalism gone wrong!

Posted

The person who wrote that must not have ever lost a loved one or they would be hoping that their loved one is still looking after them. They are young. Time will change their views.

Posted

Goodness gracious!

I just read most of that and honestly, it saddens me to see how "lost" so many of those people are. It is like they are programmed to reject anything that Catholics say.

How many protestants pray the apostle's creed? Hello??? Communion of Saints, anyone? It just proves how ignorant (not meant as an insult, but as in the true meaning of the word) they are of their own faith, as well as the faith of the Catholic church.

Someone tried to refute praying to saints by saying that we are only supposed to pray to the FATHER and kept saying that over and over again... but how many protestant churches do you know that don't open MANY of their prayers with, "Lord Jesus,..."... I mean really... unless they are completely and totally ignorant of the trinity, then they would know that praying to Jesus is not exactly the same as praying to God the Father. There would not be a trinity if their were no need to distinguish between the three entities.

And then someone said something about how asking Mary for protection was wrong/ anti-Christian... Mary is the mother of all mothers! It is a mother's job to protect her children.

This stuff is so basic... I absolutely cannot believe that so many people are so ignorant. :ohno:

The saddest thing to me is the jokes about the eucharist, making fun of it, because you know the person laughing and getting the biggest kick of of protestants rejection of Christ's presence is Satan himself.

:ohno:

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='Alycin' post='1572809' date='Jun 16 2008, 06:35 PM']How many protestants pray the apostle's creed? Hello??? Communion of Saints, anyone? It just proves how ignorant (not meant as an insult, but as in the true meaning of the word) they are of their own faith, as well as the faith of the Catholic church.[/quote]
My brother was actually asking about that the last time he was here (in January). He's Methodist, and they pray the Apostle's Creed at baptisms, and perhaps a few other times during the year. He'd never really thought about what that meant, so he was going to look to see what the Methodist church teaches about the communion of Saints. It kinda amuses me, actually, because my brother didn't look into Catholicism all that much when I converted (aside from the occasional question to me), but now that he's been going to Vienna for conferences a lot and has a good friend there who is Catholic, he's learning a lot more. :)

[quote name='Alycin' post='1572809' date='Jun 16 2008, 06:35 PM']The saddest thing to me is the jokes about the eucharist, making fun of it, because you know the person laughing and getting the biggest kick of of protestants rejection of Christ's presence is Satan himself.

ohno.gif[/quote]
I agree :sadder:

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Alycin' post='1572809' date='Jun 16 2008, 02:35 PM']How many protestants pray the apostle's creed? Hello??? Communion of Saints, anyone? It just proves how ignorant (not meant as an insult, but as in the true meaning of the word) they are of their own faith, as well as the faith of the Catholic church.[/quote]

I never did at least. :(

I remember though, when Third Day came out with the song "creed" which is basically the Apostle's Creed...remixed...shall we say. It just takes out all references to Catholicism. It's still pretty popular, some lyrics:

[quote]I believe in God the Father
Almighty Maker of Heaven and Maker of Earth
And in Jesus Christ His only begotten Son, our Lord
He was conceived by the Holy Spirit
Born of the virgin Mary
Suffered under Pontius Pilate
He was crucified and dead and buried

And I believe what I believe is what makes me what I am
I did not make it, no it is making me
It is the very truth of God and not the invention of any man

I believe that He who suffered was crucified, buried, and dead
He descended into hell and on the third day, rose again
He ascended into Heaven where He sits at God's mighty right hand
I believe that He's returning
To judge the quick and the dead of the sons of men

And I believe what I believe is what makes me what I am
I did not make it, no it is making me
It is the very truth of God and not the invention of any man

I believe it, I believe it
I believe it
I believe it, I believe it

I believe in God the Father
Almighty Maker of Heaven and Maker of Earth
And in Jesus Christ His only begotten Son, our Lord
I believe in the Holy Spirit
One Holy Church
The communion of Saints
The forgiveness of sin
I believe in the resurrection
I believe in a life that never ends

And I believe what I believe is what makes me what I am
I did not make it, no it is making me
I did not make it, no it is making me
I said I did not make it, no it is making me
It is the very truth of God and
not the invention of any man

I believe it, I believe
I believe it, I believe
I believe it, I believe it
I believe it, I believe it
I believe it, I believe it
I believe it[/quote]

Edited by BG45
Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='BG45' post='1572830' date='Jun 16 2008, 06:57 PM']I never did at least. :(

I remember though, when Third Day came out with the song "creed" which is basically the Apostle's Creed...remixed...shall we say. It just takes out all references to Catholicism. It's still pretty popular, some lyrics:[/quote]
I never said it as a Baptist, either. At the Methodist church I attended for a while, they just made sure they didn't capitalise "Catholic", or replaced it with the word "universal".

And I'd forgotten that song. I'm not sure I ever paid attention to the lyrics before, TBH.

MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='BG45' post='1572830' date='Jun 16 2008, 12:57 PM']I never did at least. :(

I remember though, when Third Day came out with the song "creed" which is basically the Apostle's Creed...remixed...shall we say. It just takes out all references to Catholicism. It's still pretty popular, some lyrics:[/quote]
That's actually by Rich Mullins, I think...I mean, I have no doubt Third Day sang it, but I think Rich Mullins wrote those lyrics and sang it first. And he was actually pretty close to becoming Catholic when he died.

Posted

I know that some "bible churches" don't say it, but I am pretty sure several protestant denoms say the apostles creed. When I was a methodist we said it every single sunday.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...