dominicansoul Posted June 17, 2008 Posted June 17, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Didymus' post='1573457' date='Jun 16 2008, 10:24 PM']hmmm... i personally don't believe it's always best to represent religious leadership and political leadership at the same time in the same place. I don't know if the priest being is in violation of the whole 'stay out of politics thing,' but Im sure some on here are better at this topic than I am. I do ask one thing however, and this is unless cinsd was aiming this thread in another direction: there was a priest at the Republican rally vid that dust (the ultra-handsome) (the ultra-handsome) (the ultra-handsome) posted a few weeks ago, and that would be another example of a priest in a prominent spot at a political rally. So the fact that the two examples of rallies originally posted were in support of pro-choice candidates really have no regard to the topic as I am concerned. the way I see it this thread has to do with clerical and religious involvement within the political scene and what level is appropriate, and I would rather this not go in the direction of 'why a cleric would be supporting a pro-choice candidate'... but I could be wrong.[/quote] I apologize for taking it there, but obviously, that's what the discussion is about. I personally don't think it is wrong for religious to be present at a political rally where the candidate is Pro-Life. It is when they are present at Pro-Abort Murderers rallies that I have a problem with it. (And the Church has a problem with that, too.) Edited June 17, 2008 by dominicansoul
Didymus Posted June 17, 2008 Posted June 17, 2008 but the Church has a problem with religious being too politically involved in any campaign. I figured this discussion could remain about whether or not being actively present at a rally would objectively be considered to be too involved in politics.
dominicansoul Posted June 17, 2008 Posted June 17, 2008 I think the Church teaching is that no religious should hold public office. I don't think it's wrong for them to be present at political rallies if the candidate's views do not go against Catholic teachings...
fides quarens intellectum Posted June 17, 2008 Posted June 17, 2008 (edited) nvm - re-read it. Edited June 17, 2008 by fides quarens intellectum
Archaeology cat Posted June 17, 2008 Posted June 17, 2008 As for the question of whether religious should be at political rallies, I think it could cause confusion or scandal (depending on the candidate in question) for a religious to be at a rally in their religious garb, because then some people will take that as an endorsement for that candidate by the Church. Just a priest is not to endorse a particular candidate during a homily, I don't think he should endorse a candidate by showing up wearing his collar. I personally don't really think they should help at such events, either. Bear in mind that this is all my personal opinion, though. [quote name='Alycin' post='1573563' date='Jun 17 2008, 05:31 AM']Then she was not a nun, but a sister, at best.[/quote] I never knew there was a difference, so I just looked it up to learn more. Thanks.
Didymus Posted June 18, 2008 Posted June 18, 2008 [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1573931' date='Jun 17 2008, 02:03 PM']I think the Church teaching is that no religious should hold public office. I don't think it's wrong for them to be present at political rallies if the candidate's views do not go against Catholic teachings...[/quote] but doesn't the Church also forbid a priest from endorsing a candidate from the pulpit? It's not just running for office.
HisChildForever Posted June 18, 2008 Posted June 18, 2008 If the religious were in the audience - say, way in the back, so as not to attract much attention - supporting a candidate the Church approved of (or, a candidate who is in line with Catholic teaching), I think it would be fine for them to be in their religious garb.
dominicansoul Posted June 18, 2008 Posted June 18, 2008 The Church does say a priest shouldn't endorse a candidate on the pulpit. But that doesn't mean a priest can't say who he's supporting or voting for anywhere else! He just can't tell the congregation, "YOU SHOULD VOTE FOR _________" on the pulpit. I never understood why, though, especially if the person is a Pro-life candidate. When I was in the convent, the whole community was invited to go to a Bush rally in Pontiac, MI. THE WHOLE COMMUNITY went. Of course, we were all wearing our habits. You should have seen the reaction. People were applauding, and then the media went crazy over us, asking us a lot of questions. They wanted to know why we were showing support for Bush when Kerry was Catholic. I remember telling one of them, "Kerry is NOT Catholic." I also remember telling them I wasn't totally in support of Bush, but that he was a better man than Kerry for the job, just for the fact Kerry was Pro-Abortion-Murder. We got a stronger reaction at the polling place on election day...we had people stopping us at the door and saying we weren't allowed to vote! CAN YOU IMAGINE THAT? I told them, "I'm an American citizen and I have every right to vote!" I guess people really take literally, seperation of Church and state in every circumstance! I know that Bush for me is a great disappointment, in that I don't think he's done enough for the Pro-life cause...but I am happy that he was able to stop the infanticide Obama is for (at least for a little while.) The Mother Superior and Prez Bush are good friends now. He really appreciated our community at the rally, and they have remained good friends ever since...
MissScripture Posted June 18, 2008 Posted June 18, 2008 [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1575088' date='Jun 18 2008, 01:00 PM']The Church does say a priest shouldn't endorse a candidate on the pulpit. But that doesn't mean a priest can't say who he's supporting or voting for anywhere else! He just can't tell the congregation, "YOU SHOULD VOTE FOR _________" on the pulpit. I never understood why, though, especially if the person is a Pro-life candidate.[/quote] I think (but I could be wrong) that it isn't legal, because churches are tax exempt or something along those lines...?
Archaeology cat Posted June 18, 2008 Posted June 18, 2008 [quote name='MissScripture' post='1575092' date='Jun 18 2008, 07:04 PM']I think (but I could be wrong) that it isn't legal, because churches are tax exempt or something along those lines...?[/quote] I've heard that before.
Didymus Posted June 18, 2008 Posted June 18, 2008 [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1575088' date='Jun 18 2008, 02:00 PM']The Church does say a priest shouldn't endorse a candidate on the pulpit. But that doesn't mean a priest can't say who he's supporting or voting for anywhere else! He just can't tell the congregation, "YOU SHOULD VOTE FOR _________" on the pulpit. I never understood why, though, especially if the person is a Pro-life candidate. When I was in the convent, the whole community was invited to go to a Bush rally in Pontiac, MI. THE WHOLE COMMUNITY went. Of course, we were all wearing our habits. You should have seen the reaction. People were applauding, and then the media went crazy over us, asking us a lot of questions. They wanted to know why we were showing support for Bush when Kerry was Catholic. I remember telling one of them, "Kerry is NOT Catholic." I also remember telling them I wasn't totally in support of Bush, but that he was a better man than Kerry for the job, just for the fact Kerry was Pro-Abortion-Murder. We got a stronger reaction at the polling place on election day...we had people stopping us at the door and saying we weren't allowed to vote! CAN YOU IMAGINE THAT? I told them, "I'm an American citizen and I have every right to vote!" I guess people really take literally, seperation of Church and state in every circumstance! I know that Bush for me is a great disappointment, in that I don't think he's done enough for the Pro-life cause...but I am happy that he was able to stop the infanticide Obama is for (at least for a little while.) The Mother Superior and Prez Bush are good friends now. He really appreciated our community at the rally, and they have remained good friends ever since...[/quote] I really didnt want this to go in this direction but here ya go... If I recall, Bush ran for office with the rape, incest, and life of mother exceptions to abortion. This would go against Church teaching. Why would an entire convent go to his rally? I can see how the 'lesser of two evils' argument could apply when voting for a candidate, but to actually be visibly seen supporting the candidate at their rally?? If you bring up the fact that the priest/religious goes against the Church when they support a pro-choice candidate, then you need to apply that universally to all candidates.
Didymus Posted June 18, 2008 Posted June 18, 2008 Church: 'Oh that candidate is pro-choice... you CANNOT actively support that candidate by attending their rally...' Church: 'Oh that candidate is only [i]a little [/i]pro-choice... go ahead and cheer em on!' HOW DOES THIS MAKE SENSE???
Didymus Posted June 18, 2008 Posted June 18, 2008 (edited) btw, I don't actually believe the Church is saying that. I am only saying that this what dominicansoul's argument sounds like to me... Edited June 18, 2008 by Didymus
dominicansoul Posted June 19, 2008 Posted June 19, 2008 To be honest with you, I don't believe there is such a thing as "only in cases of rape and incest" because there is really no limit for Abortions. Abortions are performed on unborn, born, it doesn't matter the circumstances. For Bush to have said this would probably have been because he didn't want to sound "too extreme" to the status quo. He wanted to be "electable." I recall an interview when a journalist asked him, if he was to be elected, would he do away with Roe V. Wade? And Bush said, before laws could change, people had to change. I thought this was a very poignant answer. It was a very clever answer, because, again, I know Bush would want Roe V. Wade to be overturned. But he always had to portray himself as not being totally against it, because than he would feel like he wouldn't stand a chance. His addresses at the Pro-life march in Washington, D.C. made me feel that Bush is truly against Abortion in every sense of the word. That year, it was a very close race, and we were all on pins and needles for him at the time. I don't think it was a foolish thing for us to show our support, because it was more a sign of being against Kerry and his very PRO-ABORTION-MURDER ticket. It wasn't at all a sign of support for a wishy-washy view on life. It didn't even cross Mother's mind, and without a moment's doubt, she accepted the invitation. I trusted Mother Superior, because she is very close to God, and I never doubted a thing she led us to. Plus, she knew the Prez. If she felt it was okay, it was okay by all of us. I think we really made a statement, too, because Kerry was boasting of being Catholic, and we were showing that he really isn't...he really wasn't the voice of us...and it was great talking to the media about our Pro-Life stance, and why we didn't want Kerry to win... I think we will be surprised if Prez Bush does become Catholic in the future...and then we will know what he really feels inside. It's a shame that this country wouldn't elect anyone for being 100% against Abortion. In this next election, I'm with those Catholics who feel we need to vote for the lesser of the evils. McCain may not feel very strongly against Abortion, and may even think it's not much of the issue...but I'll take him over Obama any day... ...yes..I guess I would vote for someone who is a little Pro-life than for someone who is totally 100% backed by and supportive of Abortion-Murder. Sadly, in this country...this is what we have to do!
kujo Posted June 19, 2008 Posted June 19, 2008 This simply defies logic. Have these people read the Church's stance on abortion????
Socrates Posted June 19, 2008 Posted June 19, 2008 [quote name='kujo' post='1575514' date='Jun 18 2008, 08:13 PM']This simply defies logic. Have these people read the Church's stance on abortion???? [/quote] They just don't care about the Church's stance. "Liberal Catholicism" in a nutshell.
MissScripture Posted June 19, 2008 Posted June 19, 2008 [quote name='kujo' post='1575514' date='Jun 18 2008, 08:13 PM']This simply defies logic. Have these people read the Church's stance on abortion???? [/quote] Well, considering many of these same people are of the variety that would like women to be priests, they don't really care much about what the Church says...
Norseman82 Posted June 19, 2008 Posted June 19, 2008 (edited) [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1573870' date='Jun 17 2008, 12:52 PM']I know you are barely 18,[/quote] And people jump all over me for playing the "age and experience card" Edited June 19, 2008 by Norseman82
Lounge Daddy Posted June 19, 2008 Posted June 19, 2008 [quote name='Socrates' post='1575566' date='Jun 18 2008, 09:47 PM']They just don't care about the Church's stance. "Liberal Catholicism" in a nutshell.[/quote] Word.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now