Deus te Amat Posted June 17, 2008 Posted June 17, 2008 Last night I attended a seminar regarding Humanae Vitae and the Theology of the Body. There were three speakers, and they touched on some Metaphysics ideas. Some of the things they said really got me thinking and connecting the dots, and I brought them up to my priest on the ride home. He wasn't sure of their validity, but said that they made logical sense. I thought I'd bring up my conclusions here and ask you for opinion or, in the case of the Scholars, if my assertions are correct. One of the speakers said that man is made up of two parts. The Material part, i.e. the body, and the Spiritual part, the Soul. He said that the body is united to the soul in such a way that they are one. The body is the soul and the soul is the body. John Paul II used to say that "I am my body" because the body and soul are so closely aligned. The body and soul are united as fertilization occurs--as the body is formed, so is the soul. (I asked afterward if the soul existed before the body was conceived, and he said no.) He also touched on the Angels as being pure spirit. (He used this to prove the existence of a soul, because we don't see angels to know they are there, just as we don't need to see our soul to know we have one.) I also asked him about the verse "Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you", and if this was because God is outside of time and not because our soul pre-existed, and he said yes. From this I concluded (or inquired)... 1) If angels are pure spirit, are they simply a soul without the material aspect? Or are they an entirely different being unto themselves? 2) If angels don't have a material side, how did they appear, like in the case of the Angel Gabriel, to humans? He appeared in a dream to Joseph, but how did he appear to Mary without a physical body? 3) In the cases of Marian apparitions, does it make sense to conclude that Mary appeared in bodily form to the visionaries because of her Assumption, body and soul, into heaven? Saints have recorded touching her or hearing her voice. St. Catherine Labore is recorded as putting her hands in Mary's lap as she knelt before her. St. Juan Diego, St. Bernadette, and others all heard her voice. 4) When we die, our soul is released from our body. Is this a logical proof of heaven because then our spiritual side, non-visible, transcends to the spiritual side, of heaven or purgatory? My priest quoted a scholar-I don't remember who, and the quote when something like "There is a great difference between a problem and a mystery. The problem needs to be solved, whereas the mystery doesn't have an answer." It was more profound than that, but that was the gist. I realize that these inquiries delve into the mysterious aspect of faith, but I like the Thomastic way of thinking--taking something by faith and then proving it by reason.
StColette Posted June 17, 2008 Posted June 17, 2008 [quote name='Deus_te_Amat' post='1573972' date='Jun 17 2008, 02:53 PM']1) If angels are pure spirit, are they simply a soul without the material aspect? Or are they an entirely different being unto themselves?[/quote] [url="http://www.ccel.org/a/aquinas/summa/FP/FP050.html#FPQ50A2THEP1"]http://www.ccel.org/a/aquinas/summa/FP/FP0...ml#FPQ50A2THEP1[/url] [quote]2) If angels don't have a material side, how did they appear, like in the case of the Angel Gabriel, to humans? He appeared in a dream to Joseph, but how did he appear to Mary without a physical body?[/quote] [url="http://www.ccel.org/a/aquinas/summa/FP/FP051.html#FPQ51OUTP1"]http://www.ccel.org/a/aquinas/summa/FP/FP051.html#FPQ51OUTP1[/url] I can answer this one without having to go too deep though. They can use material such as dirt, mud, whatever to form a body that appears to be human. God doesn't create an empty human body so that the angel can live in it for a little while. The Angel has the power, through God, to use material to form a body. When the Angel is through with it's mission the body goes to the material that it was, ie dirt. St. Thomas Aquinas addresses these things in the first part of his Summa Theologica. I will go more indepth when I get home. I took a Theology of Angels class at FUS, but I'm at work and my notes are at home lol
rkwright Posted June 18, 2008 Posted June 18, 2008 As to your first question. I'm nearly 100% that Angels are a different being in and of themselves. Part of metaphysics is the nature of the being itself; it is this nature that defines the being. Just because something has the property of a spiritual being does not make it a soul. God is a spiritual, non-material being and we don't call Him a soul.
LouisvilleFan Posted June 18, 2008 Posted June 18, 2008 [quote name='Deus_te_Amat' post='1573972' date='Jun 17 2008, 03:53 PM']1) If angels are pure spirit, are they simply a soul without the material aspect? Or are they an entirely different being unto themselves?[/quote] In a talk I heard a couple years ago by a priest and exorcist, he talk about three levels of beings: Natural - humans and all the created world, including animals and plants Preternatural - angels, both good and fallen Divine - God, obviously, but this is also the destiny of all people who die in God's grace and will share in his divinity in the Resurrection Thus, while we are currently "lower" beings than angels, through Christ and our natural death, we become greater than the angels. [quote name='Deus_te_Amat' post='1573972' date='Jun 17 2008, 03:53 PM']2) If angels don't have a material side, how did they appear, like in the case of the Angel Gabriel, to humans? He appeared in a dream to Joseph, but how did he appear to Mary without a physical body?[/quote] I'd say simply that God is able to make an angel appear in whatever physical form he desires. Of course, the same may also apply to fallen angels. [quote name='Deus_te_Amat' post='1573972' date='Jun 17 2008, 03:53 PM']3) In the cases of Marian apparitions, does it make sense to conclude that Mary appeared in bodily form to the visionaries because of her Assumption, body and soul, into heaven? Saints have recorded touching her or hearing her voice. St. Catherine Labore is recorded as putting her hands in Mary's lap as she knelt before her. St. Juan Diego, St. Bernadette, and others all heard her voice.[/quote] No doubt that it's possible. Whether she definitely did or not, I'm not sure that it matters. Of course, we won't receive the resurrection body until after Christ returns. I don't know if Mary and the saints live in that post-resurrection reality or something else. That may be something left up to mystery. [quote name='Deus_te_Amat' post='1573972' date='Jun 17 2008, 03:53 PM']4) When we die, our soul is released from our body. Is this a logical proof of heaven because then our spiritual side, non-visible, transcends to the spiritual side, of heaven or purgatory?[/quote] I'm pretty sure all souls -- in heaven and hell -- will have physical bodies. As for logical proof of heaven... if one has already accepted the supernatural world as a reality, heaven should seem pretty logical. The problem is that most convinced atheist/agnostic types won't accept anything that isn't in the natural and scientifically observable world. [quote name='Deus_te_Amat' post='1573972' date='Jun 17 2008, 03:53 PM']My priest quoted a scholar-I don't remember who, and the quote when something like "There is a great difference between a problem and a mystery. The problem needs to be solved, whereas the mystery doesn't have an answer." It was more profound than that, but that was the gist. I realize that these inquiries delve into the mysterious aspect of faith, but I like the Thomastic way of thinking--taking something by faith and then proving it by reason.[/quote] I might add that sometimes the best solution to a problem is to chalk it up to mystery Of course, not that asking questions should be discouraged, but I think our Western mindset sometimes needs a greater appreciation of the mysterical side of such questions. On the flip side, perhaps the Eastern mindset too frequently leaves too much to mystery... so I suppose we should breathe with both lungs (to borrow from another quote, I think by John Paul II).
Nunsense Posted June 18, 2008 Posted June 18, 2008 This is from Catholic Doors Ministry, and it helped me a lot to understand more about the body, the spirit and the soul... [url="http://www.catholicdoors.com/know/"]Knowing God[/url]
rckllnknny Posted June 18, 2008 Posted June 18, 2008 something ive...um...been learning lately...alot of it has to do with the way you "word" the relationship and reasoning.....to connect the dots.... mite just b me tho...
abercius24 Posted June 19, 2008 Posted June 19, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Deus_te_Amat' post='1573972' date='Jun 17 2008, 02:53 PM']1) If angels are pure spirit, are they simply a soul without the material aspect? Or are they an entirely different being unto themselves? 2) If angels don't have a material side, how did they appear, like in the case of the Angel Gabriel, to humans? He appeared in a dream to Joseph, but how did he appear to Mary without a physical body?[/quote] I think others have sufficiently answered these already. [quote name='Deus_te_Amat' post='1573972' date='Jun 17 2008, 02:53 PM']3) In the cases of Marian apparitions, does it make sense to conclude that Mary appeared in bodily form to the visionaries because of her Assumption, body and soul, into heaven? Saints have recorded touching her or hearing her voice. St. Catherine Labore is recorded as putting her hands in Mary's lap as she knelt before her. St. Juan Diego, St. Bernadette, and others all heard her voice.[/quote] If the body and spirit make the whole person, and Mary's body and spirit have never been separated due to the Assumption, I can't see how she could have legitimately appeared in any way other than in bodily form. Christ's appearance to Thomas was clearly in bodily form. And when He appeared to the Apostles on the beach, they thought He was a ghost, which He proved false by eating a fish in their presence. Now the perception of the one experiencing the Marian apparition does seem to change from person to person, though. St. Juan Diego saw a lady of his own ethnicity when he spoke with the Virgin Mary, as we clearly can see in the Tilma of Our Lady of Guadalupe (clearly not a woman of Hebrew ancestry). The Scriptures give us a precedent to this phenomenon, actually. If you remember, the apostles on the Road to Emmeaus experienced a similar situation with the Lord. They spoke with Him for quite some time before they were able to perceive His identity (which occured only after they celebrated mass with Him). [quote name='Deus_te_Amat' post='1573972' date='Jun 17 2008, 02:53 PM']4) When we die, our soul is released from our body. Is this a logical proof of heaven because then our spiritual side, non-visible, transcends to the spiritual side, of heaven or purgatory?[/quote] I believe St. Thomas Aquinas would agree with this statement, as would Aristotle. Edited June 19, 2008 by abercius24
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now