Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Catholics, Conservatives, And Those That Hate


Recommended Posts

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I have a friend who... really isn't much of a friend.
She's Protestant, and I don't know what denomination, but that's not the problem. The problem is that she finds it necessary to, when debating with me (I'm the only one interested), do her very best to twist my words, and undermine my beliefs.
I don't like that. I haven't 'debated' with her in months.
The last time we 'debated' it was directed towards politics and religion. She finds it absolutely unfathomable that I can be a conservative. (I find it funny too, actually. I'm [almost] 17, and [almost] everyone my age is hardcore socialist. ;))

In any case, what she said, more or less specifically was, "How can you be conservative? Christianity is basically socialism anyway."
Now... I know my politics as well as most people. Better than most people my age. Ditto in terms of faith and theology. I was at a complete loss at this point though. I just didn't know how I could continue. I know that socialism is generally considered incompatible with Catholicism, but at that point, my brain just started to hurt and I didn't know what else to say.

I would really love to know the sorts of things you guys would say in the same situation.
Thanks. :)

Posted

JMJ
6/23 - Twelfth Monday

Nihil Obstat,

There's a really funny song out there right now that I heard on the radio recently. It's got simple title - [i]Fish and Paint Are the Same[/i]. Indulge me as I write the lyrics for you.
[quote]Fish and paint are the same.
Fish and paint are the same.
Both come in many colors,
they don't have legs,
and they both hate turpentine![/quote]

Having once been a socialist, I can say with utter conviction that Christianity and socialism are NOT "the same." There may be many incidental similarities, such as concern for the poor. However, they are clearly two different realities if one reads the requisite documents. I assume your friend has not read [i]The Communist Manifesto[/i] or [i]Das Kapital[/i]. Suffice it to say that socialism, in its finer forms, seeks to supplant religion entirely. The religion which Karl Marx so proudly claimed was the "opiate of the masses" was to be replaced by the worship of the state. The supernatural was to give way completely to a natural worldview. Socialists see the building of a near-perfect world as within the grasp of humanity, whereas Christianity knows that such is never possible this side of the Eschaton.

I hope this helps. I invite the other scholars to respond to this as well.

Yours,
Pio Nono

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...