TotusTuusMaria Posted June 20, 2008 Posted June 20, 2008 Ok, so the Church has said some things about just war and the such. Bishops and priests can deny Communion to anyone they know to be in public sin. Well are soliders sinning who take part in unjust war? Can they be denied Communion? Why are they allowed to receive Communion but someone wearing a gay pride sash cannot? These are questions that I don't know how to answer or how to begin to answer. I think I could answer them, but I don't know if my answers would be correct. Please englighten me.
StColette Posted June 20, 2008 Posted June 20, 2008 [quote name='TotusTuusMaria' post='1577309' date='Jun 20 2008, 09:11 AM']Ok, so the Church has said some things about just war and the such. Bishops and priests can deny Communion to anyone they know to be in public sin. Well are soliders sinning who take part in unjust war? Can they be denied Communion? Why are they allowed to receive Communion but someone wearing a gay pride sash cannot?[/quote] Just War is a very tricky topic. Enlisted soldiers do not have a choice to be in a war or not. If you are enlisted you go where you are told and you do what you are told. A soldier to even possibly be remotely culpable would had to have known that the war was unjust but enlisted in the military anyway to go and fight. Even then it could be a little sketchy. Soldiers aren't sinning by taking part in an unjust war for the simple fact that they are already enlisted men and don't have a choice in the matter. War is not always unjust where as supporting homosexual relationships or behavior is always wrong. Wearing a gay pride sash says "I support the sins that you are committing". When I say that I don't mean that people who are homosexuals are sinful people, those who act on those behaviors are.
CatherineM Posted June 20, 2008 Posted June 20, 2008 I think if the war is viewed by the church publicly as unjust, there is still a difference between a soldier and a commander. Would a cook on a ship be considered in sin in an unjust war? How about a radio operator or mechanic? Following the orders of those in legitimate authority over you is a different matter in my mind to those ordering and planning the unjust war. I think there is more culpability in those who vote for the war, than those on the front line being ordered to fight, and who do so in large part to protect and support those in their unit in peril.
Galloglasses Posted June 20, 2008 Posted June 20, 2008 It may help you to look up my Militarisation Thread in the debate forum. We are dealing with just such spiritual and theological problems regarding war and war time soldiers. For the record, a soldier is alot like a Monk or other Religious in the sense he most obey a strict code of Obedience. His superior commands of him, it would be wrong of him to disobey. This is where such things get tricky. The sin, of course, will ALWAYS be held most responsible by the commander issueing the order as he is one in authority and power, (The amount of power you have on earth DOES influence how God will judge you, you have power, you are expected to use it for good. God makes no illusions that Power and authority are farcicle concepts, but are realities, all men are equal, but men can command other men, like how angels can command other angels), but the soldier committing the sin is still commiting the sin, but the ultimate price of the sin won't fall upon him directly, (though it is a mortal sin, "Thou Shalt Not Kill"), so he may be forgiven or at least be admitted to Purgetory for his sins, (if the war itself isn't considered punishment enough), he may or may not be judged harsely. For the sake of arguement, lets say a Commander ordered two soldiers to kill two POWs, (the method of execution plays a part too, but lets just say its a summery execution, bullet to the head), the Commander will ALWAYS be held mostly accountable for the two POWs Deaths, and for the sin of ordering others to kill. One soldier kills his POW swiftly, and without blinking, the other soldier hesitates and then obeys. Which one of them considered, even for a moment, the gravity of what he was doing? Should that soldier be judged more harsely then the other one? Should he be judged lighter? Should both be condemned for killing POWs, a crime in and of itself? Should they be judged lighter for fulfilling their roles as soldiers and obeying a command? See how this can get tricky? For the record, I love this little poem on the subject: [i]When he reaches Heaven, To Saint Peter he shall tell, "One more soldier reporting, sir, I've served my time in Hell."[/i]
TotusTuusMaria Posted June 21, 2008 Author Posted June 21, 2008 [quote name='Galloglasses' post='1577895' date='Jun 20 2008, 07:47 PM']It may help you to look up my Militarisation Thread in the debate forum. We are dealing with just such spiritual and theological problems regarding war and war time soldiers. For the record, a soldier is alot like a Monk or other Religious in the sense he most obey a strict code of Obedience. His superior commands of him, it would be wrong of him to disobey. This is where such things get tricky. The sin, of course, will ALWAYS be held most responsible by the commander issueing the order as he is one in authority and power, (The amount of power you have on earth DOES influence how God will judge you, you have power, you are expected to use it for good. God makes no illusions that Power and authority are farcicle concepts, but are realities, all men are equal, but men can command other men, like how angels can command other angels), but the soldier committing the sin is still commiting the sin, but the ultimate price of the sin won't fall upon him directly, (though it is a mortal sin, "Thou Shalt Not Kill"), so he may be forgiven or at least be admitted to Purgetory for his sins, (if the war itself isn't considered punishment enough), he may or may not be judged harsely. For the sake of arguement, lets say a Commander ordered two soldiers to kill two POWs, (the method of execution plays a part too, but lets just say its a summery execution, bullet to the head), the Commander will ALWAYS be held mostly accountable for the two POWs Deaths, and for the sin of ordering others to kill. One soldier kills his POW swiftly, and without blinking, the other soldier hesitates and then obeys. Which one of them considered, even for a moment, the gravity of what he was doing? Should that soldier be judged more harsely then the other one? Should he be judged lighter? Should both be condemned for killing POWs, a crime in and of itself? Should they be judged lighter for fulfilling their roles as soldiers and obeying a command? See how this can get tricky? For the record, I love this little poem on the subject: [i]When he reaches Heaven, To Saint Peter he shall tell, "One more soldier reporting, sir, I've served my time in Hell."[/i][/quote] Makes sense. Thanks for the reply and the link to the other thread.
JustJ Posted June 21, 2008 Posted June 21, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1577450' date='Jun 20 2008, 11:19 AM']When I say that I don't mean that people who are homosexuals are sinful people, those who act on those behaviors are.[/quote] I, like, totally disagree~ :limpwrist: [quote name='Galloglasses' post='1577895' date='Jun 20 2008, 07:47 PM']It may help you to look up my Militarisation Thread in the debate forum. We are dealing with just such spiritual and theological problems regarding war and war time soldiers. For the record, a soldier is alot like a Monk or other Religious in the sense he most obey a strict code of Obedience. His superior commands of him, it would be wrong of him to disobey. This is where such things get tricky. The sin, of course, will ALWAYS be held most responsible by the commander issueing the order as he is one in authority and power, (The amount of power you have on earth DOES influence how God will judge you, you have power, you are expected to use it for good. God makes no illusions that Power and authority are farcicle concepts, but are realities, all men are equal, but men can command other men, like how angels can command other angels), but the soldier committing the sin is still commiting the sin, but the ultimate price of the sin won't fall upon him directly, (though it is a mortal sin, "Thou Shalt Not Kill"), so he may be forgiven or at least be admitted to Purgetory for his sins, (if the war itself isn't considered punishment enough), he may or may not be judged harsely. For the sake of arguement, lets say a Commander ordered two soldiers to kill two POWs, (the method of execution plays a part too, but lets just say its a summery execution, bullet to the head), the Commander will ALWAYS be held mostly accountable for the two POWs Deaths, and for the sin of ordering others to kill. One soldier kills his POW swiftly, and without blinking, the other soldier hesitates and then obeys. Which one of them considered, even for a moment, the gravity of what he was doing? Should that soldier be judged more harsely then the other one? Should he be judged lighter? Should both be condemned for killing POWs, a crime in and of itself? Should they be judged lighter for fulfilling their roles as soldiers and obeying a command? See how this can get tricky? For the record, I love this little poem on the subject: [i]When he reaches Heaven, To Saint Peter he shall tell, "One more soldier reporting, sir, I've served my time in Hell."[/i] Swiss Family Robinson is tech. Cross-dressing women. <3[/quote] Isn't it nice when a mortal can decide on how god will judge?
Galloglasses Posted June 21, 2008 Posted June 21, 2008 [quote name='JustJ' post='1578812' date='Jun 21 2008, 02:02 PM']Isn't it nice when a mortal can decide on how god will judge? [/quote] What the hell are you talking about? I was spouting a bunch of questions relating to the issue that none of us are able to answer. How am I deciding how God will judge when I was putting forward possible ideas?
StColette Posted June 22, 2008 Posted June 22, 2008 [quote name='JustJ' post='1578812' date='Jun 21 2008, 03:02 PM']I, like, totally disagree~ :limpwrist:[/quote] You can disagree if you want. The Church speaks clearly on the matter. Those who are homosexuals are not bad people nor do we hate them. We, however, do not agree if those individuals are involved in homosexual behavior. You know the say Hate the Sin, Love the Sinner. [quote]Isn't it nice when a mortal can decide on how god will judge? [/quote] He was not acting as a judge. If you are wishing to turn this into a debate there's a designated part of the phorum for debate. Please remember the guidelines of this part of the phorum. This area is for Theological formation not debate. If you wish to debate please take it to the Debate Table.
Saint Therese Posted June 23, 2008 Posted June 23, 2008 (edited) One basic question in the discussion of just war is "Is war intrinsically evil?". Can it be compared to abortion which is always intrinsically evil? I think the obvious question is NO. Now I'm not arguing whether or not a particular war may or may not be just. But, I think there are several instances in which war is justified. The elected (or otherwise duly appointed) leaders of a nation have a duty to protect their fellow country men and women. There are numerous examples where a country might start a war as a result of mass injustice or violence towards its citizens, in other words, self-defense. In this case,as in others, the intent of the defending nation is not to kill innocent people but to defend their country. The Church as repeatedly affirmed that it is possible to remain faithful to the Church and serve in a nation's military. Edited June 23, 2008 by Saint Therese
Galloglasses Posted June 23, 2008 Posted June 23, 2008 (edited) I think wether or not war is intrinsictly evil has already been answered really. Think about it. The civil war in Heaven which resuted in Satan being cast down from Heaven by St.Micheal was a war. And God and His Angels fought it. Would God enter into something that was intrinsictly evil? Also, there is also the constant war between Good and Evil that regns in men's hearts. Is this intrinsictly evil? I doubt it. Absolute passiveism is not evil at all, but it means you willingly let evil things being done without fighting the evil with Good. Edited June 23, 2008 by Galloglasses
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now