Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

I Am In A Slight Bit Of A Pickle


Recommended Posts

missionseeker
Posted

Ok.. So.. I am working on a systematic defense of Sacred Music and in reading the new document from the American bishops, am finding.. not blatant contradictions, per se but... deliberate obfuscation of things that the Vatican says. It doesn't jive.

And people who oppose my "views" or "preferences" as they say use the documents from the bishops. (Because it justifies what they do).

SO... what do I do?

How does one say- "the bishops are wrong" without saying the bishops are wrong???

Posted

I would first have several others read the document from the Bishops and make sure that you are not reading it with a bias towards what you expect it to say. I am not saying you are, just saying get other opinions.
If they are not in direct opposition to the Vatican. I would just offer it up. If it is in direct opposition. I would just offer it up. :sign: :sign:

Posted

Maintaining humility does not mean that you cannot properly notice and point out differences between what is being said in documents. It is not unfaithful on your part to ask questions.

It can be both truthful and charitable, to indicate that the bishops are receiving and interpreting a document or a teaching in a way that is not simply linguistically the same as the original document or teaching. The next step is to ask if they are really saying something different (are they just using different words to express the same thing?) and if they are saying something different, then why is that the case (are they actually disagreeing with a previous teaching, or are they just emphasizing something that the original teaching pointed to but didn't quite articulate?).

There can be a number of reasons why things aren't matching up linguistically, and many of them have nothing to do with being unfaithful. Sounds like you have quite a project going on that will require some careful thinking--good luck!

Fr. Antony Maria OSB
Posted

I just spoke to my church's music minister today, and she said that currently a document submitted by the English speaking bishops for liturgical music to the Vatican for approval. I don't know if this is what you're talking about, but I thought I'd let you know in case it helps out at all. Good luck on your thesis either way!

May God bless and protect you always in all of your endeavors!

Your Brother in Christ,

Joe

homeschoolmom
Posted

Which document are you talking about?

Fr. Antony Maria OSB
Posted

I really don't know. My music minister didn't say...just that it was submitted to the Vatican and she was waiting to hear what the Vatican said before she made any changes according to that document.

missionseeker
Posted

The one I am reading is Sing to Lord. I mean, there is nothing blatant (just not correct... I know that doesn't make sense...) But everything is very easily twisted.

Noel's angel
Posted (edited)

Could you show some examples? You have sparked my interest.

I've flicked through it and it does seem very sketchy. It seems like the bishops don't really know what they're talking about.
They way they write about postures and actions in relation to singing worries me too. It leaves everything open to interpretation.

Edited by Noel's angel
Noel's angel
Posted (edited)

#89 talks about the use of cymbals, which have been clearly outlawed in the past, along with pianos etc.

The more I read, the worse it gets. It looks like someone has sat down and written this out from memory, without any re-draft or anything. What percussion instruments are 'apt'???
#99 mentions the piano specifically, I see.

Edited by Noel's angel
missionseeker
Posted

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1583208' date='Jun 25 2008, 05:54 PM']#89 talks about the use of cymbals, which have been clearly outlawed in the past, along with pianos etc.

The more I read, the worse it gets. It looks like someone has sat down and written this out from memory, without any re-draft or anything. What percussion instruments are 'apt'???
#99 mentions the piano specifically, I see.[/quote]


yeah.. that kind of thing...

I've not finished it yet. And the part about multi-culturalism and the age of the congregation seems kinda sketch...

Noel's angel
Posted

Yeah, I noticed that too.
The thing is, the bit about piano IS directly out of line with Church teaching, it's not just vague or slightly twisted. People are going to take this and use it to condone all sorts of 'music'.

TeresaBenedicta
Posted

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1583247' date='Jun 25 2008, 07:28 PM']Yeah, I noticed that too.
The thing is, the bit about piano IS directly out of line with Church teaching, it's not just vague or slightly twisted. People are going to take this and use it to condone all sorts of 'music'.[/quote]

Piano can't be used?

Noel's angel
Posted

"The employment of the piano is forbidden in church, as is also that of noisy or frivolous instruments such as drums, cymbals, bells, and the like" (TLS 19).

TeresaBenedicta
Posted

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1583303' date='Jun 25 2008, 08:44 PM']"The employment of the piano is forbidden in church, as is also that of noisy or frivolous instruments such as drums, cymbals, bells, and the like" (TLS 19).[/quote]

Now that's interesting. Do you have a link to that document? I'd like to send it to my campus music minister. (Can you imagine... we have an organ and a choir loft, yet of course, the choir is up at the front and using the piano, plus guitar and the like.)

Noel's angel
Posted (edited)

Oh dear :( You'll find a lot of good stuff on www.adoremus.org

That particular quote was from Tra le Sollecitudini (Pope Pius X)

And don't let anyone say "Oh but that's from 1903 and Vatican II changed all that." If they do, ask them where they found their information. Usually the challenge is met with silence or some mumblings about how such-and-such- a priest says it's okay etc.

Edited by Noel's angel
Posted

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1583303' date='Jun 25 2008, 07:44 PM']"The employment of the piano is forbidden in church, as is also that of noisy or frivolous instruments such as drums, cymbals, bells, and the like" (TLS 19).[/quote]
Facebook quote. :)

TeresaBenedicta
Posted

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1583313' date='Jun 25 2008, 08:53 PM']Oh dear :( You'll find a lot of good stuff on www.adoremus.org

That particular quote was from Tra le Sollecitudini (Pope Pius X)

And don't let anyone say "Oh but that's from 1903 and Vatican II changed all that." If they do, ask them where they found their information. Usually the challenge is met with silence or some mumblings about how such-and-such- a priest says it's okay etc.[/quote]

Thanks.

Hrm. I'll be interested in their answer when I get back on campus...

missionseeker
Posted

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1583247' date='Jun 25 2008, 06:28 PM']Yeah, I noticed that too.
The thing is, the bit about piano IS directly out of line with Church teaching, it's not just vague or slightly twisted. People are going to take this and use it to condone all sorts of 'music'.[/quote]


Exactly. I asked my philosophy professor/advisor about what I should do

He said
[quote]Do not object to the Bishops' words, just object to an argument that says the same thing. Mostly they will not remember their own argument. It is often written by some one who is in the Chancery and not by a Bishop directly. In short, keep it on point and not personal. Let me see it when you are finished.[/quote]

[quote name='XIX' post='1583317' date='Jun 25 2008, 08:06 PM']Facebook quote. :)[/quote]

No. Way. Awesome.

Posted

Ah... a fellow warrior in the sacred music movement is at it... hmm... well... I can't add anymore, except this little thought: the other documents that referred to sacred music were not written in a vacuum of thought: the documents were not new individual things, but reaffirmations and explanations on previous teachings. Interesting though, that even the non-sacred music-ers find ways of twisting those documents their way... or as one mentioned above say, "the document was written 100 years ago. it's irrelevant."

missionseeker
Posted

[quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1583405' date='Jun 25 2008, 11:36 PM']Ah... a fellow warrior in the sacred music movement is at it... hmm... well... I can't add anymore, except this little thought: the other documents that referred to sacred music were not written in a vacuum of thought: the documents were not new individual things, but reaffirmations and explanations on previous teachings. Interesting though, that even the non-sacred music-ers find ways of twisting those documents their way... or as one mentioned above say, "the document was written 100 years ago. it's irrelevant."[/quote]


lol. yes. I was trying to systematize things and get arguments together.

I am excited because I am going to record my choir at church (which consists of about 18 people aged 5- 50) singing panis angelicu in three parts. The average age is um... 8-10. Yeah... don't tell ME sacred music is hard. LOL


I've figured out that really it can be summed up that music at mass has to be appropriate to the MASS (which I already knew and have written about lol.) but it seems that one of the major arguments is appropriate to the time/age group/congregation. But THAT is a complete deviation from what sacred music is.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...