Resurrexi Posted June 23, 2008 Posted June 23, 2008 The Ultimatum of the Vatican to Lefebvre's rebels: peace, if you accept the Council by Andrea Tornielli In exchange, they will receive a Prelature. But they must choose before June 28. ROME -In the relations between the Holy See and the Lefebvrians the countdown has begun: by this 28 June, the Fraternity of St. Pius X, founded by the French Archbishop who would not suffer the post-conciliar liturgical reform, will in fact have to decide whether to accept the five conditions proposed by the Vatican in order to reenter into full communion with Rome. Some days ago, the superior of the Lefebvrians, Bishop Bernard Fellay, met with Cardinal Darío Castrillón Hoyos, president of the Commission Ecclesia Dei, which deals on behalf of Benedict XVI with negotiations with the traditionalist group. Fellay, who previously had written to the Pope asking for the revocation of the excommunication imposed by John Paul II in 1988 to Lefebvre and the four new bishops that he had wanted to consecrate without the consent of the Holy See (among them Fellay himself), has received a letter with the five points set by the cardinal [Castrillón] and will discuss them during the next chapter of the fraternity, to be held at the end of the month. Never like at this moment the negotiations have come close to an agreementwhich would heal the mini-schism which had been created now two decades ago, allowing the full reentering of the Lefebvrians into the Catholic communion. Among the points that the Holy See asked to sign there would be, according to the indiscretions gathered, the acceptance of the II Vatican Council and the declaration of full validity of the Mass according to the reformed liturgy: two conditions that Lefebvre had already signed with the then cardinal Joseph Ratzinger in 1988. The Vatican, for its part, offers the traditionalist group a canonical framework similar to that of Opus Dei, namely a [personal] "prelature", which would allow the Fraternity to continue its activities and to train its seminarians. The march of rapprochement was started in 2000, when the Lefebvrians made a Holy Year pilgrimage to Rome. It was followed by a brief audience granted by Pope Wojtyla to Monsignor Fellay and the beginning of the long and laborious negotiations with Cardinal Castrillón. Many things have changed since then however. The Lefebvrians asked, before making any step towards an agreement, that the old preconciliar missal, which fell into disuse after the liturgical reform, be liberalised. The new pope, Benedict XVI, particularly sensitive to these issues, a year ago published the Motu proprio declaring the full citizenship of the old Mass allowing it in every parish, in fact stripping the bishop of the possibility of prohibiting it. The application of the new papal directives has not been easy, there are a lot of cases of resistance - some blatant, as is known - but it is beyond doubt that by declaring the existence of an extraordinary Roman rite (the old one) and an ordinary (the reformed one), the Pope has authorized throughout the Church and without restrictions the celebration of the Tridentine Mass. Moreover, Ratzinger has reintroduced the Cross at the centre of the altar, has begun to distribute communion to the faithful kneeling, has restored ancient vestments: all signals that go in the direction of emphasizing the continuity of tradition. Conditions this favourable for a reentering into full communion will in all likelihood not repeat themselves. Many faithful, now that they have obtained the Mass according to the ancient rite, do not understand why the Fraternity does not definitively make peace with Rome. The Lefebvrians have come to realize what is happening, even if Fellay has some problems of internal resistance. The choice is whether to make an agreement and reenter into full communion with the Holy See, or rather to remain a small separate body with the risk of turning into a little sectarian and uninfluential group. (Translated by Gregor Kollmorgen, for The New Liturgical Movement). [url="http://www.ilgiornale.it/a.pic1?ID=271075"]http://www.ilgiornale.it/a.pic1?ID=271075[/url] [url="http://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2008/06/tornielli-sspx-rome-agreement-near.html"]http://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2008/06/t...ement-near.html[/url]
CatherineM Posted June 23, 2008 Posted June 23, 2008 It sounds like an agreement that will allow them to come into communion and save face at the same time. One small schism at a time.
fides quarens intellectum Posted June 23, 2008 Posted June 23, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1580352' date='Jun 23 2008, 02:21 PM']It sounds like an agreement that will allow them to come into communion and save face at the same time. One small schism at a time.[/quote] indeed.
jeffpugh Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 Remarkable! This is amazing. I hope this comes through. . I know that they've been mad about the repression of the Extraordinary form since vatican two, but I was talking to a (deacon) seminarian about this today, and he said it was probably done to let the "new" liturgy take seed. Pope Benedict has seen that it is time to let the leashes go and see what happens. By the way, what are the problems they were having before? I think the article mentioned 5 terms...
Resurrexi Posted June 24, 2008 Author Posted June 24, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1580999' date='Jun 23 2008, 08:42 PM']Remarkable! This is amazing. I hope this comes through. . I know that they've been mad about the repression of the Extraordinary form since vatican two, but I was talking to a (deacon) seminarian about this today, and he said it was probably done to let the "new" liturgy take seed. Pope Benedict has seen that it is time to let the leashes go and see what happens. By the way, what are the problems they were having before? I think the article mentioned 5 terms...[/quote] Questioning validity of sacramental rites promulgated after the Council and issues on religious liberty and other doctrines of the Council. Edited June 24, 2008 by StThomasMore
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 not going to happen. We have seen this all before.
Resurrexi Posted June 24, 2008 Author Posted June 24, 2008 Summorum Pontificum has changed the whole situation. It could definitely happen.
CatholicCid Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' post='1581039' date='Jun 23 2008, 10:08 PM']not going to happen. We have seen this all before.[/quote] That's what I was thinking. I hope and pray that it does happen, however, I'll wait until June 29th to get my hopes up. If they do not, I wonder what reasons they will cite. I do agree with the article that this really is the prime time to return. If they do not, I don't think Rome can do anything other than leave this offer on the table. Edited June 24, 2008 by CatholicCid
Aloysius Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 If the deal includes reversing the excommunication of Lefebvre, I'm prepared to welcome them back as heroes.
Deus te Amat Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 I hope that they do. My future roommate is SSPX... and I did a lot of research when I found that out. They refer to themselves as "Roman Catholics" and us as the outsiders, so unity would make life a lot easier. Kidding about that. Catholic means Unity. I want them home.
Jaime Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1581280' date='Jun 24 2008, 02:26 AM']If the deal includes reversing the excommunication of Lefebvre, I'm prepared to welcome them back as heroes.[/quote] Heroes? Welcome back as brothers, fine. But you need better role models then those who refuse to assent their will to the Church.
TotusTuusMaria Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 (edited) Prayers for this. Question: If they do enter back into communion with Rome will all of the religious communities founded under them be considered in union with Rome as well, like the Dominican communities (thinking of the one posted over in vocation station a couple weeks ago) and others? Will they be recognized? Edited June 24, 2008 by TotusTuusMaria
TotusTuusMaria Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 [quote name='TotusTuusMaria' post='1581415' date='Jun 24 2008, 11:31 AM']Prayers for this. Question: If they do enter back into communion with Rome will all of the religious communities founded under them be considered in union with Rome as well, like the Dominican communities (thinking of the one posted over in vocation station a couple weeks ago) and others? Will they be recognized?[/quote] Question II: What is the likelihood that if he does decide to enter back into communion with Rome that all of those under him will join him in this? Is there a likelihood that they will separate from him and consider themselves, still, to be separate from Rome?
Maggyie Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 I worry there would be another little mini-schism within the SSPX. Bishop Williamson, for instance, is just the kind of guy who would go off and found his own little sect if some of the more level-headed SSPX bishops reunited with the Pope.
goldenchild17 Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1580335' date='Jun 23 2008, 01:58 PM']The Ultimatum of the Vatican to Lefebvre's rebels: peace, if you accept the Council by Andrea Tornielli In exchange, they will receive a Prelature. But they must choose before June 28. ROME -In the relations between the Holy See and the Lefebvrians the countdown has begun: by this 28 June, the Fraternity of St. Pius X, founded by the French Archbishop who would not suffer the post-conciliar liturgical reform, will in fact have to decide whether to accept the five conditions proposed by the Vatican in order to reenter into full communion with Rome. Some days ago, the superior of the Lefebvrians, Bishop Bernard Fellay, met with Cardinal Darío Castrillón Hoyos, president of the Commission Ecclesia Dei, which deals on behalf of Benedict XVI with negotiations with the traditionalist group. Fellay, who previously had written to the Pope asking for the revocation of the excommunication imposed by John Paul II in 1988 to Lefebvre and the four new bishops that he had wanted to consecrate without the consent of the Holy See (among them Fellay himself), has received a letter with the five points set by the cardinal [Castrillón] and will discuss them during the next chapter of the fraternity, to be held at the end of the month. Never like at this moment the negotiations have come close to an agreementwhich would heal the mini-schism which had been created now two decades ago, allowing the full reentering of the Lefebvrians into the Catholic communion. Among the points that the Holy See asked to sign there would be, according to the indiscretions gathered, the acceptance of the II Vatican Council and the declaration of full validity of the Mass according to the reformed liturgy: two conditions that Lefebvre had already signed with the then cardinal Joseph Ratzinger in 1988. The Vatican, for its part, offers the traditionalist group a canonical framework similar to that of Opus Dei, namely a [personal] "prelature", which would allow the Fraternity to continue its activities and to train its seminarians. The march of rapprochement was started in 2000, when the Lefebvrians made a Holy Year pilgrimage to Rome. It was followed by a brief audience granted by Pope Wojtyla to Monsignor Fellay and the beginning of the long and laborious negotiations with Cardinal Castrillón. Many things have changed since then however. The Lefebvrians asked, before making any step towards an agreement, that the old preconciliar missal, which fell into disuse after the liturgical reform, be liberalised. The new pope, Benedict XVI, particularly sensitive to these issues, a year ago published the Motu proprio declaring the full citizenship of the old Mass allowing it in every parish, in fact stripping the bishop of the possibility of prohibiting it. The application of the new papal directives has not been easy, there are a lot of cases of resistance - some blatant, as is known - but it is beyond doubt that by declaring the existence of an extraordinary Roman rite (the old one) and an ordinary (the reformed one), the Pope has authorized throughout the Church and without restrictions the celebration of the Tridentine Mass. Moreover, Ratzinger has reintroduced the Cross at the centre of the altar, has begun to distribute communion to the faithful kneeling, has restored ancient vestments: all signals that go in the direction of emphasizing the continuity of tradition. Conditions this favourable for a reentering into full communion will in all likelihood not repeat themselves. Many faithful, now that they have obtained the Mass according to the ancient rite, do not understand why the Fraternity does not definitively make peace with Rome. The Lefebvrians have come to realize what is happening, even if Fellay has some problems of internal resistance. The choice is whether to make an agreement and reenter into full communion with the Holy See, or rather to remain a small separate body with the risk of turning into a little sectarian and uninfluential group. (Translated by Gregor Kollmorgen, for The New Liturgical Movement). [url="http://www.ilgiornale.it/a.pic1?ID=271075"]http://www.ilgiornale.it/a.pic1?ID=271075[/url] [url="http://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2008/06/tornielli-sspx-rome-agreement-near.html"]http://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2008/06/t...ement-near.html[/url][/quote] an agreement is not necessarily immanent. The offer exists, but who's to say the SSPX will agree to it, or that the Vatican will agree to any counter-offers? We just don't know yet, and based on his holiness Bp. Fellay's recent comments regarding Benedict XVI as a "perfectly liberal pope" I think it'll take a little more work that what is being reported. But we'll see. If they are allowed to maintain their own jurisdiction (for lack of a better word) and work as an order that can ordain/consecrate according to the Old Rite, then I am definitely in support of a reunion, so long as they don't make too many concessions. But we'll just have to wait and see what happens.
goldenchild17 Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1581043' date='Jun 23 2008, 10:09 PM']Summorum Pontificum has changed the whole situation. It could definitely happen.[/quote] Changed the whole situation? Possibly, and if so only to a degree. Remember, Bp. Fellay has already spoken out on this and said that, while good, it was definitely not enough.
goldenchild17 Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 [quote name='Maggie' post='1581426' date='Jun 24 2008, 11:01 AM']I worry there would be another little mini-schism within the SSPX. Bishop Williamson, for instance, is just the kind of guy who would go off and found his own little sect if some of the more level-headed SSPX bishops reunited with the Pope.[/quote] oh I'm positive that a good number of the SSPX clergy will not join the rest of the group in accepting the Vatican's offer. Whether that includes Bp. Williamson or not, I couldn't say. I don't know if they would continue as they were, or become sedevacantist, though if I had to guess I would lean towards the latter, but who knows at this point. Knowing that a good number of them will not reconcile (I'm almost positive of this) along with the rest of SSPX, then as long as the group is allowed to maintain pre-vat Ordination/Consecation rites, then I support the reconciliation definitely.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now