Lucy Lionheart Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 i don't mean one of those lies where you only say part of the truth i mean a flat out lie like if you were trying to get away from someone who was going to hurt you bad or kill you and you lie and say you are going one place and really go to another so you can be safe and then you lie to keep the bad people away cause they want to do bad things and won't stay away and the poliece don't lisen
Archaeology cat Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 This is the closest thing I can find in the CCC to that situation: [quote]IV. RESPECT FOR THE TRUTH 2488 The right to the communication of the truth is not unconditional. Everyone must conform his life to the Gospel precept of fraternal love. This requires us in concrete situations to judge whether or not it is appropriate to reveal the truth to someone who asks for it. 2489 Charity and respect for the truth should dictate the response to every request for information or communication. The good and safety of others, respect for privacy, and the common good are sufficient reasons for being silent about what ought not be known or for making use of a discreet language. The duty to avoid scandal often commands strict discretion. No one is bound to reveal the truth to someone who does not have the right to know it.283[/quote]
homeschoolmom Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 It is better to be silent rather than flat out lie, but someone does not have a right to know the truth if their intentions are bad.
Lucy Lionheart Posted June 25, 2008 Author Posted June 25, 2008 like if someone is interogating you and you have to say somethin or then you get hurt or will be hurt after their all done askin can you lie and then run away
Totus Tuus Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 It's hard to understand your question but I do believe it has already been answered in those two posts.^^ You are asking about a specific situation. Apply the general answers to the specific situation you are wanting specifically addressed and deduce the answer: If the people interrogating you do not deserve to know the truth and silence is not sufficient to keep you safe, then you are not obligated to be truthful in your answers.
Justin86 Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 I was always taught that if you feel you feel you must lie to save your life, or that of another it would only amount to a venial sin. For example, Germans who secretly housed Jews during the Holocaust and lied about it to Nazis searching their homes were not guilty of mortal sin. However, I was also taught that if you make a statement that could be interpeted multiple ways even though the most obvious one isn't the interpetation you were meaning, it's not technically a lie and therefore not a sin at all. For example, say you are hiding Jews from Nazis in an underground bunker beneath your house (ok, maybe they didn't really use underground bunkers, but work with me for the example here). If the Nazis ask you, "Are there any Jews in your house?", and you replied "No.", that's not really a lie because there aren't any Jews [i]in[/i] your house, they're actually [i]underneath[/i] your house. I honestly don't know how true that is, but it did make sense to me when I heard it.
prose Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 Yes, I could flat out lie to save my or someone else's life. For any other reason, no, I don't think I could.
rckllnknny Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 yeah, i guess that would be my answer too, to be honest. lol. i probably shouldnt lie, but absolutely, i would!
homeschoolmom Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1582898' date='Jun 25 2008, 12:10 PM']I was always taught that if you feel you feel you must lie to save your life, or that of another it would only amount to a venial sin. For example, Germans who secretly housed Jews during the Holocaust and lied about it to Nazis searching their homes were not guilty of mortal sin. However, I was also taught that if you make a statement that could be interpeted multiple ways even though the most obvious one isn't the interpetation you were meaning, it's not technically a lie and therefore not a sin at all. For example, say you are hiding Jews from Nazis in an underground bunker beneath your house (ok, maybe they didn't really use underground bunkers, but work with me for the example here). If the Nazis ask you, "Are there any Jews in your house?", and you replied "No.", that's not really a lie because there aren't any Jews [i]in[/i] your house, they're actually [i]underneath[/i] your house. I honestly don't know how true that is, but it did make sense to me when I heard it.[/quote] You are thinking of mental reservations and/or equivocations.
CatherineM Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 Yes I could, but not if it meant someone else would get hurt instead.
Lucy Lionheart Posted June 25, 2008 Author Posted June 25, 2008 (edited) what about if in lying you save yourself but the bad people's feelings get hurt then is it wrong Edited June 25, 2008 by Lucy Lionheart
homeschoolmom Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 Are the bad people entitled to the truth? Are you lying about them?
Totus Tuus Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 [quote name='Lucy Lionheart' post='1582976' date='Jun 25 2008, 01:30 PM']what about if in lying you save yourself but the bad people's feelings get hurt then is it wrong[/quote] Let's look at it logically: Do the "bad people's feelings" mean more than your own life? Obviously not.
Lucy Lionheart Posted June 25, 2008 Author Posted June 25, 2008 lying to the bad people but then their feelings get hurt cause they like hurting you and they want to keep doing it and they can't if you runn away
prose Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 Is there a bigger picture here? If you are being harmed, you should not only run away, but contact the police and get help.
Archaeology cat Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 [quote name='prose' post='1582989' date='Jun 25 2008, 06:43 PM']Is there a bigger picture here? If you are being harmed, you should not only run away, but contact the police and get help.[/quote] Seconded.
Lucy Lionheart Posted June 25, 2008 Author Posted June 25, 2008 i alredy did but i feel bad and the police don't listen to kids
Lucy Lionheart Posted June 25, 2008 Author Posted June 25, 2008 (edited) and the people who hurt me say i make them sad still and lying is a sin and i saw on other threads people say lying is a sin Edited June 25, 2008 by Lucy Lionheart
prose Posted June 25, 2008 Posted June 25, 2008 If you feel that way, you need to speak to a priest, or a counsellor, or another officer. Do not quit asking for help.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now