Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Lounge Daddy
Posted

[url="http://www.fairtax.org/site/PageServer"]The FairTax[/url]--so simple and practical, it is just too mind-blowing for many politicians.

[img]http://www.redplanetcartoons.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2007/08/8222007_fairtax_cavemen.jpg[/img]

Posted

Couldn't agree more, my friend. When I read up on the Fair Tax, I actually had one of those moments of clarity and said "Wow, what a good idea. Why don't we use that?" Then I heard John Edwards start talking about the "two Americas" and it all made sense.

Posted

Neanderthals were, according to all archaelogical evidence, much more intelligent, caring, and even possibly religious than our ancestors that were their contemporaries.

lol... I suppose that misses the point though :cyclops:

Posted

[quote]Here is my principle: Taxes shall be levied according to ability to pay. That is the only American principle.[/quote]
FDR

Posted

in addition, taxes should be levied according to what the government has legitimate authority to collect them from. income tax is arguable at best. but taxes on transactions that occur in the public domain like sales are basically legitimate as they do not attack the productivity of a person only his spending... limit those taxes on public domain transactions like sales

i am of the firm opinion that the payment of a salary to an employee should NOT be considered a transaction in the public domain. I think I've had some wildly ridiculous debates with dairygirl on this issue before that really goes off into left field topics a million times lol, but that is my opinion: the wealth which an individual produces through his work he deserves to be granted and because he earns and fully deserves every cent of the fruit of his labor, this is not a public transaction. it is a full and absolute debt owed by the employer to the employee privately. the employer does not owe it to the government and is not engaging in some public purchase but is engaging in a private payment of debt for services and Uncle Sam should not be skimming off the top.

a sale, on the other hand, is a public transaction. sales of non-necessities should be taxed; everything from video games to tobacco to alcohol to yachts makes perfect sense to be taxed... food, property, income, transportation vehicles (excepting, possibly, luxury cars), and gasoline should not be taxed. I disagree with the principal that a government even has the authority to tax such things. in addition, a sales tax does not consist of skimming off the top, but rather of charging a certain price to the vendor (passed on to the consumer) for the right to sell things in the public marketplace for which the state provides the freedom.

FDR... sorry, don't like him as a president. in the persuit of solving the problems of his day, he created many more long term problems. i am of the opinion that many other things could have been done to better and more efficiently solve the problems of his day in a more lasting way. am I a monday morning quarterback? yep. are criticizers of Herbert Hoover monday morning quarterbacks? you betchya. I'd side with a good man like Hoover any day of the week. anyway, I don't look up to FDR as a man on whom I base my american political principals, no matter how loomingly he looks at me from mount rushmore.

  • 3 weeks later...
Lounge Daddy
Posted

The Fair Tax [url="http://grandrapidslibertarian.wordpress.com/2008/07/16/fairtax-featured-on-wikipedia/"]was featured on Wikipedia[/url] the other day. :cool:

Posted

FDR isn't on Mount Rushmore.

I remember having a discussion/debate about taxes in tax law class in law school. My professor was for a national sales tax. Those with low income would be able to get percentages of their refunded (like they do with GST in Canada). This would get money from wealthier people just because they buy more. It would also tax those who avoid taxes or work cash only like drug dealers, prostitutes, mafia, etc. It would trim a few jobs out of the government from the IRS, and put H&R Block in bankruptcy. If someone didn't want to be taxed as much, they could buy a cheaper car, or just keep using their old one. I guess that wouldn't be too good for an economy based on buy, buy, buy.

Posted

I actually sent letters concerning FairTax to both my senators and received answers from both. :) I love Brownback.

Posted

Obama said that he would support fair tax if the whole system was starting over, but he thinks reform would be too tough now :rolleyes:

Posted

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1601322' date='Jul 16 2008, 04:29 PM']Obama said that he would support fair tax if the whole system was starting over, but he thinks reform would be too tough now :rolleyes:[/quote]


He's correct. Unless you think it is presently likely for a constitutional ammednment to get passed.


As for the fair tax, how is it working in Iraq? What has the feedback been?

Posted

They passed a constitutional amendment to get the income tax. What's the problem with passing an amendment again, Hassan?

Posted

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1601339' date='Jul 16 2008, 04:49 PM']They passed a constitutional amendment to get the income tax. What's the problem with passing an amendment again, Hassan?[/quote]


The country is to ideologically divided and angry. The fairtax is seen as a neo-conservative brainchild. After these last eight years liberals/(most)democrats seem to view anything associated with the neo-conservatives as toxic. I'm not saying it's fair, I know very little about the fair tax(in terms of it's viability). After Iraq, Gitmo, and the numerous other antics of Mr. Bush and his friends a large portion of the population just isin't willing to listen to the right on anything.

I just don't think that the necessary unity is present in the country. And given the present economey most people arn't keen on playing with the structure of our economic system. The income system may be despised, however "better the evil you know than the evil you don't know". People won't be willing to make such a radical move without strong empericle evidence that the model is viable.

in my oppinion.

Lounge Daddy
Posted

Ya, it cracks me up when the FairTax is dismissed as a "neo-conservative brainchild" when it is the only tax system that places the power of taxation out of the hands of the politicians and into the hands of "We The People," and it effectively un-taxes the poorest Americans.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted (edited)

it's deceptively simple. as is often the case with simple things.

www.fairtax.org

at first glance, it's easy and simple... and in a sense it's progressive. poorer people get a pay back for what they pay out up to a certain amount. so even if it's a necessity, it does not matter cause poor get pay back refund. effectively, that pay back also creates a staired income scale, cause everyone gets the pay back, but the richer are affected by it less, such taht they pay closer to the 23% flat sales tax in the end.

the flaw that many don't know about,,,, or won't say... it that while it's progressive in that sense, and it appears on the surface to be legit.... the rich don't pay more as a percentage, they only pay more in dollars. this is because they dont spend enough: if A has 1000 and spends 100, and B has 10000 and spends 500, A still spent more than B did as a percentage.

so while it might be promoted as progressive.... it's really progressively regressive. ultimately regressive.
most conservatives are pretty reasonable, at least as far as saying they promote the flat tax.... and they wouldn't often go so far as to say hey want something regressive where the poor pay th same dollar value as the rich or less as a percentage. (of course, there's some who want a flat tax in terms of not a percentage but a set dollar amount) yet, this is essentially a regresive tax that they'd not normally go for, had they know what this tax really means.
maybe you're the type that goes for all pay the same dollar values,,, or you see that the rich pay more dollars but less as a percent, as a trade off.
whatever you believe.... just make sure you know what you're advocating. know that it's a regressive tax, that most even conservatives don't go for, when they know the details.

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
Lounge Daddy
Posted

[quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1602258' date='Jul 17 2008, 06:32 PM']the flaw that many don't know about,,,, or won't say... it that while it's progressive in that sense, and it appears on the surface to be legit.... the rich don't pay more as a percentage, they only pay more in dollars.[/quote]
Oh they say it. There are at least two books, and one audio-book that detail it all. It effectively un-taxes the poor, while at the same it doesn't punish people for making economic gains. (As a bonus, this makes it impossible for politicians to use the tax system for class warfare purposes every election season)

Our current tax system both taxes the poor, and strongly punishes success (therefore it discourages productivity). The FairTax is win-win for everyone.

One other very attractive element. It places a great amount of political leverage in the hands of regular ordinary citizens. If you don't like something that your government is considering, you can actually threaten to not pay taxes! This is because you are not taxed for the regular necessities of life. You can decide not to make any purchases outside of that for a time if you wish--or order extra items outside of your un-taxed necessities online. It's fantastic! :cool:

dairygirl4u2c
Posted (edited)

i do concede the proofs, are in the details and the mathematical models.
i might be wrong. but, what i said seems to me to be the common sense answer, given how much the rich would have ot spend, to actually make it truly progressive, or even like a flat tax.
i've never seen places like fairtax.org, or any real attempt to prove my statements wrong, and i've looked around.
i have seen, though,,,, proofs that it's income netural... which i believe.

also,,, there are even with what i said many advantages as mentioned in previous posts.
i used to be a fair tax advocate, but something always haunted me in the back of my mind, and then i started realizing what i said in my last post.
i'd rather have a progressive, or at least a flax tax system...despite all the other benefits, like th ability to not pay taxes, and not tax productivity etc.
if i am wrong, then i'd be all for the fair tax.
i'm not super certain on this (i'm not certain on global warming either but more certain about that than this,,,, but i'm even less certain about this, to put it in perspective)

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
dairygirl4u2c
Posted (edited)

if you say you're not for regressive taxes, then you shouldn't be for the fair tax, either. cause it's ultimately regressive, in the sense that's usually meant by the word regressive.
to prove my point........

consider real world and realistic examples.

A is poor, at 15k per year. he gets all refunds, so truly the fair tax has some benefits to it. as he pays 0% because of his refund. if the refund is up to 5k. and let's say he spends 5k, he got taxed at twenty three percent, but he got it all back, and so his overall taxes on income is zero percent.

B is medium, at 50k per year. he spends ten thousand. he gets back five k factor. so his tax on stuff, instead of 23 percent, is 12.5 percent. overall, a fourth of ten thousand, is 2500, and half of that is 1200. he gets taxed at 2.4%overall....
remembert these are realistic but still hypothetical.

C is high, at 100k per year. he spends twenty thousand. he gets back five k. so his tax on stuff, instead of 23 percent, is 18%. we see how it's called a progressive tax. he spends 1800 in taxes, and so overall, he pays.... 1.8% ovrall.

and now you can see my point illustrated. it can be called progressive in a sense, as the rich man paid eighteen instead of 12.5 percent, and rich man paid more in terms of dollars, ie 1800 instead of 1200. but, the point that most don't know about.... is that the total tax in terms of proportion tohis income,,,, is two point four for hte medium man, and only one point eight for the rich man.

and.... as the persons get richer, that effect is only exacerated. they'll pay closer and closer to twney three percent on the sale... but overall, they'll pay less and less as a percentage of their total income, cause the rich simply do not spend enough to make it work.
a house and a car even at luxury, is less andless of a drop in the bucket for the more an more rich. they'd have to up it a lot more, to make it proportional to what a poor man buys. ie, as a poor man spends a fourth of his income on gas.... the rich man pays a percent,,,, a fourth on buying a car, compared to a percent in buying a car etc.

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
Posted

I had a conversation with my friend Dan the other day about this. He was admittedly more knowledgable than I on the issue of taxation and he kind of threw me for a loop. He referred to the fair tax (and the flat tax) as a regressive tax, saying that "the rich won't feel it" while the poor while "suffer." How do I combat this charge?

Posted

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1601322' date='Jul 16 2008, 05:29 PM']Obama said that he would support fair tax if the whole system was starting over, but he thinks reform would be too tough now :rolleyes:[/quote]

I thought that he was all for "Change"?

Posted

[quote name='mommas_boy' post='1604471' date='Jul 21 2008, 12:13 PM']I thought that he was all for "Change"?[/quote]
I guess not if it takes too much effort. He's all for Easy Change though!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...