picchick Posted June 29, 2008 Posted June 29, 2008 I have never lost anyone related to gun crimes. However, I believe that there needs to be a ton of education about gun safety because it is a skill for trap shooting (i like to trap shoot). I could never point it at a person unless they were harming someone I loved (a family member). I know gun safety. My father and mother taught me this. Theo in Training. I understand where you are coming from. I am sorry for the comments made to you here. I am praying for you and for your father's soul. Meg
KnightofChrist Posted June 29, 2008 Posted June 29, 2008 Father, I respect you and your office very much. I very much tried not to be, but for any reason I was rude or hurtful I am truly sorry.
Totus Tuus Posted June 29, 2008 Author Posted June 29, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1585705' date='Jun 28 2008, 03:24 PM']Yes, but a gun is solely designed to hurt, kill, maim or destroy (plate shooting), it is made for that purpose, a dining room table leg is designed to support a table, it is made for that purpose. You are comparing apples to pineapples, the two are in no way related, save for the fact that someone used the leg to kill someone, which was contrary to its purpose.[/quote] And the [i]purpose[/i] of a gun is good, according to the Catechism, when it is being used for [i]self-defense[/i]. I sincerely hope that you are not making the argument that guns are immoral to own. As far as the Case goes, our rights to owning a gun were simply reaffirmed. Edited June 29, 2008 by Totus Tuus
Archaeology cat Posted June 29, 2008 Posted June 29, 2008 [quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1585587' date='Jun 28 2008, 05:20 PM']Someone who lost his father to one, knowing that the 7th shot to the head was the fatal shot that killed him instantly...[/quote] My condolences, Father.
Galloglasses Posted June 29, 2008 Posted June 29, 2008 Guys hold up here. Alot of us don't agree with the Father's veiw of guns. (In his way, his dislike of them is utterly justified), so be more respectful here.
Socrates Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1585705' date='Jun 28 2008, 02:24 PM']Yes, but a gun is solely designed to hurt, kill, maim or destroy (plate shooting), it is made for that purpose, a dining room table leg is designed to support a table, it is made for that purpose. You are comparing apples to pineapples, the two are in no way related, save for the fact that someone used the leg to kill someone, which was contrary to its purpose.[/quote] [quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1585926' date='Jun 28 2008, 09:19 PM']Yes, though I pray it will never happen, unless someone close to you is taken by a gun, you will never understand the pointlessness in owning one. Seriously, I don't even know why I bother.[/quote] While you have my sincerest condolences, Father, and your aversion to guns may be understandable, the misuse of guns should not be used to deny others of their legitimate American rights. You are making an appeal based on emotion, not reason. My uncle was killed by a drunk driver while riding his motorcycle decades before I was born, and for that reason my father has had a strong aversion to motorcycles ever since (he said he'd disown me if I bought a motorcycle). However, this should not mean that motorcycles, cars, or even alcohol, should be banned by the government. (And, yes, more people are killed by these these things than by guns in this country). It's not the place of the government in a free society to ban everything that can be lethally misused. And guns most certainly do have legitimate purposes. Many out here use them to hunt. I know this is an activity that raises the ire of many bleeding hearts, yet it is a legitimate sport, and provides food for people, and is needed to keep the deer population under control (even with hunting, the deer are out-of-control out here, and so hunting is a much-appreciated public service, as well as a sport, and means of providing people with nutritious venison.) And firearms have legitimate use in self-defense, or defense of others. Try telling any of the many people whose lives were saved by owning or using a gun that owning a gun is pointless! I know it's a bumper-sticker cliche, but the fact remains that if you outlaw guns, then only outlaws will have guns. Law-abiding citizens will be at their mercy. And as I've shown in one of these threads, even the Pope himself recognizes that firearms have legitimate purpose and are not intrinsically evil. Edited June 30, 2008 by Socrates
Alycin Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 [quote name='Socrates' post='1586704' date='Jun 29 2008, 09:26 PM']While you have my sincerest condolences, Father, and your aversion to guns may be understandable, the misuse of guns should not be used to deny others of their legitimate American rights. Yous are making an appeal based on emotion, not reason. My uncle was killed by a drunk driver while riding his motorcycle decades before I was born, and for reason my father has had a strong aversion to motorcycles ever since (he said he'd disown me if I bought a motorcycle). However, this should not mean that motorcycles, cars, or even alcohol, should be banned by the government. (And, yes, more people are killed by these these things than by guns in this country). It's not the place of the government in a free society to ban everything that can be lethally misused. And guns most certainly do have legitimate purposes. Many out here use them to hunt. I know this is an activity that raises the ire of many bleeding hearts, yet it is a legitimate sport, and provides food for people, and is needed to keep the deer population under control (even with hunting, the deer are out-of-control out here, and so hunting is a much-appreciated public service, as well as a sport, and means of providing people with nutricious venison.) And firearms have legitimate use in self-defense, or defense of others. Try telling any of the many people whose lives were saved by owning or using a gun that owning a gun is pointless! I know it a bumper-sticker cliche, but the fact remains that if you outlaw guns, then only outlaws will have guns. Law-abiding citizens will be at their mercy. And as I've shown in one of these threads, even the Pope himself recognizes that firearms have legitimate purpose and are not intrinsically evil.[/quote] Father Brian probably won't see your post... he left phatmass last night.
Totus Tuus Posted June 30, 2008 Author Posted June 30, 2008 [quote name='Socrates' post='1586704' date='Jun 29 2008, 09:26 PM']While you have my sincerest condolences, Father, and your aversion to guns may be understandable, the misuse of guns should not be used to deny others of their legitimate American rights. Yous are making an appeal based on emotion, not reason. My uncle was killed by a drunk driver while riding his motorcycle decades before I was born, and for reason my father has had a strong aversion to motorcycles ever since (he said he'd disown me if I bought a motorcycle). However, this should not mean that motorcycles, cars, or even alcohol, should be banned by the government. (And, yes, more people are killed by these these things than by guns in this country). It's not the place of the government in a free society to ban everything that can be lethally misused. And guns most certainly do have legitimate purposes. Many out here use them to hunt. I know this is an activity that raises the ire of many bleeding hearts, yet it is a legitimate sport, and provides food for people, and is needed to keep the deer population under control (even with hunting, the deer are out-of-control out here, and so hunting is a much-appreciated public service, as well as a sport, and means of providing people with nutricious venison.) And firearms have legitimate use in self-defense, or defense of others. Try telling any of the many people whose lives were saved by owning or using a gun that owning a gun is pointless! I know it a bumper-sticker cliche, but the fact remains that if you outlaw guns, then only outlaws will have guns. Law-abiding citizens will be at their mercy. And as I've shown in one of these threads, even the Pope himself recognizes that firearms have legitimate purpose and are not intrinsically evil.[/quote] Agreed. Nicely put.
catholicinsd Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 [mod]Post removed for being off-topic. --Era Might[/mod]
Jesus_lol Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 [img]http://i146.photobucket.com/albums/r267/diablo_man/april_08_2_36.jpg[/img]
Deb Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 [quote name='Socrates' post='1586704' date='Jun 29 2008, 09:26 PM']While you have my sincerest condolences, Father, and your aversion to guns may be understandable, the misuse of guns should not be used to deny others of their legitimate American rights. You are making an appeal based on emotion, not reason. My uncle was killed by a drunk driver while riding his motorcycle decades before I was born, and for that reason my father has had a strong aversion to motorcycles ever since (he said he'd disown me if I bought a motorcycle). However, this should not mean that motorcycles, cars, or even alcohol, should be banned by the government. (And, yes, more people are killed by these these things than by guns in this country). It's not the place of the government in a free society to ban everything that can be lethally misused. And guns most certainly do have legitimate purposes. Many out here use them to hunt. I know this is an activity that raises the ire of many bleeding hearts, yet it is a legitimate sport, and provides food for people, and is needed to keep the deer population under control (even with hunting, the deer are out-of-control out here, and so hunting is a much-appreciated public service, as well as a sport, and means of providing people with nutritious venison.) And firearms have legitimate use in self-defense, or defense of others. Try telling any of the many people whose lives were saved by owning or using a gun that owning a gun is pointless! I know it's a bumper-sticker cliche, but the fact remains that if you outlaw guns, then only outlaws will have guns. Law-abiding citizens will be at their mercy. And as I've shown in one of these threads, even the Pope himself recognizes that firearms have legitimate purpose and are not intrinsically evil.[/quote] Being killed by a drunk driver with a car is not comparable to being shot and killed by someone using a handgun, an item that is made for one purpose only and that is to kill other human beigns. Using the tired worn out argument that guns are for hunting have nothing to do with this at all. No one has ever attempted to ban the ownership of rilfes or shotguns and you know it. If you can't own a shotgun and defend your family, then what do you think a handgun is going to do for you? I would rather have someone pointing a handgun at me rather than a shotgun. The bottom line is that the country has been brainwashed on this issue, just like those who promote abortion, that somehow you are entitled to own something to kill someone else. You say that handguns are not intrinsically evil yet they are made to do evil deeds. What kind of guns do our soldiers train on? What do they carry in battle? I rarely see our well regulated miliita going after another army wielding their handguns. Lets try it for a while. Melt down every single handgun in this country, make using one or possessing one punishable by thirty years in prison, give it fifty years and then lets see what the crime rate and suicide rate is by those using handguns. If no difference, bring them back. The issue is too many people make too much money off them and no one wants to give them up and they have convinced enough people with power that the sky will fall if no one has a handgun. Look at the glee expressed over this bill. Look at the attacks on Fr. Then tell me that handguns are not intrinsically evil. I am ashamed of some of you guys.
aalpha1989 Posted June 30, 2008 Posted June 30, 2008 Ok, regardless of our own beliefs, the Supreme Court upheld the Constitution, which is their job. If we believe the Constitution should be amended, that is the job of the legislature, not of the Supreme Court. Whether handgun bans are moral or not, that is not the job of the Supreme Court to decide. That being said, the Second Amendment was created with the idea that people could defend themselves from a tyrannical government. Remember that the colonists had to stock pile their weapons before the war began. Personally I don't think that we COULD overthrow a tyrannical government anymore. Even if we COULD, I don't believe a new government could be established quickly enough to prevent anarchy. The US would completely crumble. That also being said, I personally think that people should be permitted hand guns. I agree with Soc that, were guns outlawed, only outlaws would have guns.
Recommended Posts