HisChildForever Posted June 26, 2008 Posted June 26, 2008 1. I read the thread here about Noah already - i.e., that God would either let everyone dance about in sin or force them to convert (that being the opposite of free wll). The people did not just commit a sin here or there, but viciously [b]lived[/b] sin. I am thinking greedy, lustful, cruel, manipulative, murderous people. Noah and his family, of course, where the good seeds. But here are my questions. (a) Surely there were babies and infants and small children. Since nothing in Scripture indicates their survival, are we to believe that God murdered them alongside their wicked parents and wicked adults? Innocent children? Some who had, perhaps, only been alive for a week? You could say that God knew that they would fall into the same ugly lives of sin that their parents did, but if this is the case, why not even allow a serial killer in this day and age to be born? This leads to... (b) Did God admit that He made a mistake? Okay, so He looks at all the sinful people and is so disgusted that He actually regrets making mankind. But why is He surprised if He knew that WAY before Adam and Eve, this would happen? He gave us free will, so wouldn't He have known that something like this was entirely possible? 2. The punishments given to Adam and Eve. Has anyone else noticed that all of Adam's punishments for eating the apple (like, difficulty farming is one, I believe) can be applied to Eve as well, but all of Eve's punishments (such as labor pains) can not be applied to Adam, thus [i]technically[/i] giving Adam less punishments than Eve. Scripture does not even say that Adam's punishments overlap with Eve's since she was the first one to taste the fruit and then led Adam into the sin. (a) Since this story can be debated as literal or metaphorical, if we see it metaphorically, can we blame an old school patriarchal society for making woman as the first to sin, woman as more deserving as punishments, so man can appear more righteous? Let's face it, the Bible is a bit one-sided at times. I recall that there is an entire chapter in one of the Old Testament books regarding the "perfect wife" but no where is the "perfect husband" mentioned. You can try and appease me and say that it's mentioned countless times that the man is to respect the woman and cherish her, yadda yadda, but when most passages come up in Scripture regarding a woman, it's basically about how she must serve man, her being inferior, submissive, etc. [b]Slaves[/b] were approved of in parts of the Bible, but clearly we don't believe in that now, and it was probably more the work of man than of God to throw that in the Bible. So why do so few acknowledge the possibility that man (literally) included in the Bible how women must be so submissive to them? Is this because our Church is still very patriarchal? I'm not trying to suggest female priests, but let's face it, [b]man[/b] is in charge, when it comes to humans.
StColette Posted June 26, 2008 Posted June 26, 2008 I’ll take the last section of your post, because I’m more familiar with the Biblical exegesis of the passages that you quote. And this might be better coming from a woman since there seems to be some male vs. female issues going on, so a woman’s point of view might be more accepted. I actually did an entire 25 page exegetical paper on the Fall of Man for one of my Scripture classes. I don't have my exegesis handy so I'm going from memory lol When I find it though I'll post that as well. [quote]2. The punishments given to Adam and Eve. Has anyone else noticed that all of Adam's punishments for eating the apple (like, difficulty farming is one, I believe) can be applied to Eve as well, but all of Eve's punishments (such as labor pains) can not be applied to Adam, thus technically giving Adam less punishments than Eve. Scripture does not even say that Adam's punishments overlap with Eve's since she was the first one to taste the fruit and then led Adam into the sin.[/quote] I would actually argue that Adam’s punishment is more than the punishment that Eve will suffer, because the result of Adam’s sin reaches out to all of humanity not just to a particular sex of humankind. 17 To the man he said: "Because you listened to your wife and ate from the tree of which I had forbidden you to eat, "Cursed be the ground because of you! In toil shall you eat its yield all the days of your life. 18 Thorns and thistles shall it bring forth to you, as you eat of the plants of the field. 19 By the sweat of your face shall you get bread to eat, Until you return to the ground, from which you were taken; For you are dirt, and to dirt you shall return." Do you notice that the discourse of Adam’s punishment is greater in length than the punishment of Eve and has many different aspects piled on top of one another. Eve’s punishment is one of painful children, which affects humankind in a more direct sense and only half of the human population will suffer from this punishment, women. But Adam’s punishment will affect all of humankind. His sin caused a curse upon the ground, meaning all the land. This is a more universal punishment for all humankind not just one half of humankind. It’s greater because it is universal rather than just choosing a certain sex. God goes on to tell Adam that in “toil shall you eat its yield all the days of your life”. Let’s face it childbirth doesn’t occur everyday of each of our lives. It’s more of a once every however many months or years for each woman. Where as when you read the punishment of Adam it seems to be saying that each day of his life will be spent in toil. Childbirth only lasts about 9 hrs on average, which seems to me to be a lot better than every day of my life. Verse 3:18 speaks of how the curse of the ground will cause not very much bounty to come from the earth as originally planned. Because of Adam’s sin there will not be food as easily provided as was previously. Again this sin reaches out universally to all instead of just to a sex of the human race. In Verse 3:19 we see the curse of death, which is transmitted from the sin of Adam to all of humanity. Again Adam’s sin is not only causing death to come upon him but upon all of humanity, which I find much greater than pains during childbirth. I’ve read several Church Theologians and Biblical Scholars who say that Adam’s sin was greater than Eve. It can be proven Biblical as well. Adam’s job was to watch over the garden, the animals, and especially his wife, Eve. God directly spoke to Adam and in return Adam would convey what God spoke to him to Eve. Adam’s job was to care and protect the garden and Eve. Did you ever wonder where Adam was when Eve was speaking to the serpent? How did the serpent get in there if Adam was supposed to keep watch over the garden and his wife? Adam is actually a silent bystander in the dialogue between Eve and the serpent. I mean, seriously, why didn’t Adam speak up? Many Church Theologians and Biblical Scholars point out this as to why Adam’s sin was greater, because he failed to do the job that God had given him. Adam is rebuked by God for listening to his wife rather than listening to the command that God had given him. Because everything that God told Adam was passed on to Eve through Adam, he (Adam) had the greater responsibility of making sure the precepts that God had put in place were followed and to make sure that Eve understood and followed them as well. [quote](a) Since this story can be debated as literal or metaphorical, if we see it metaphorically, can we blame an old school patriarchal society for making woman as the first to sin, woman as more deserving as punishments, so man can appear more righteous? Let's face it, the Bible is a bit one-sided at times. I recall that there is an entire chapter in one of the Old Testament books regarding the "perfect wife" but no where is the "perfect husband" mentioned. You can try and appease me and say that it's mentioned countless times that the man is to respect the woman and cherish her, yadda yadda, but when most passages come up in Scripture regarding a woman, it's basically about how she must serve man, her being inferior, submissive, etc.[/quote] According to the Church we are bound to believe in the deposit of faith that we had original parents and those original parents fell from grace and caused sin and death to enter into the world. I think I’ve address the issue of the woman’s punishment compared to the man’s quite enough above. But again, Adam’s is considered great because his punishment is on all of humankind not just a particular sex of humankind. I won’t appease you with verses that speak of how a husband must love and cherish his wife. Most verses regarding women aren’t about how she must serve man or her being inferior. I would really advise you to read of some of the women in the Bible. They are very powerful figures throughout all of Scripture. Did you ever notice how Christ always had women close to him and when he appeared first after his resurrection it was to a woman. And let’s face it Mary is by far the most awesome person, save Christ, who has ever walked this earth. Did you know that after Christ’s death, resurrection, and ascension into Heaven that the Apostles looked to Mary for guidance and reassurance, according to a lot of Church Tradition. Woman play such an amazing role in Salvation History. I never realized how much a role women played and how important they were until I started studying the Bible and delving deep into Biblical commentary and Church tradition. I’ll share something very awesome with you about Genesis. Have you ever noticed how different the creation of Adam compares to the creation of Eve. It’s really amazing when you start to look at it. Adam was formed from the dirt by God. And the word that is used for when God made Adam just means formed or made. But did you know that the verb in Hebrew used to describe the forming of Eve means that she was something that was given great care and very complex in the making. God took great care in the crafting of woman, and it can be seen in the very language of the Bible. Now, I already mentioned how Adam was made from the dirt of the earth, but do you remember that Eve was made from bone. Bone is a much sturdier material than dirt by far and also a very precious material. Adam only had so many ribs and there weren’t any other people running around that could give any bones over either. Eve was made from something that was so precious and very hard to come by. Many Theologians, even early century ones, as well as Biblical Scholars have poured over these verses and all come to a similar conclusion that woman is the crown of creation. She is the last to be made and she is made from a very precious and rare material. I don’t know about you but that make me very proud to be a woman. And very thankful to the writers of Genesis for seeing woman as see is. [quote]Slaves were approved of in parts of the Bible, but clearly we don't believe in that now, and it was probably more the work of man than of God to throw that in the Bible. So why do so few acknowledge the possibility that man (literally) included in the Bible how women must be so submissive to them? Is this because our Church is still very patriarchal? I'm not trying to suggest female priests, but let's face it, man is in charge, when it comes to humans.[/quote] I must make clear that man doesn’t just “throw” things into the Bible. All words in the Holy Scripture are protected and inspired by God, that’s why we call them Holy. Man just doesn’t get to throw things in there where he pleases; it just doesn’t work that way. I wish submissiveness didn’t have such a bad rap that it has grown to receive. Did you know that the verse in the New Testament that speaks of how a woman must be submissive to her husband also tells the husband to turn around and do the same thing? A woman being submissive to her husband is not the same thing as a woman being a slave to her husband; in fact Scripture really speaks out against a man treating his wife in this way. A marriage is to be equal submission to one another. Believe me, Micah would never dream of forcing me to do anything against my will or that he knew was not right or good for me. For example, I have a huge fear of hospitals and well this pregnancy has been very hard. I’ve had to go to the ER twice. If I had my way I would have never gone to the ER and most likely jeopardized the health of myself as well as my unborn child. Micah, being the loving husband that he is, pretty much explained to me the urgency of why I needed to go and it was the best thing for myself and for the baby. I absolutely hated going but at the same time I knew he was right. I see this as a great example of a wife being submissive to her husband. Being submissive doesn’t mean your husband is always right and always wrong. A wife is to be submissive when there is a disagreement over a particular situation, ie going to the ER, and the husband can show clearly that he knows the right decision is to do what he thinks is for all parties involved, ie Jennie, you and the baby really need to go to the ER. Any man who abuses this duty that he has to his wife is very wrong. I know how hard it is for my husband to make a decision that I may or may not agree with. I mean I’ve watched him agonize over the littlest of decisions that affect the both of us. That’s what submissive is. It’s not being a slave. It’s beings someone’s spouse. And with every decision that Micah makes for us, he always asks my input just to get another way of looking at things, like he really wanted to take out a mortgage on a home and I helped break down all the expenses to show him that we really just couldn’t afford it. In the end, Micah saw that I was right and now we are in a new apartment instead of a home, hehe. Btw, I had that Bible passage read at my wedding lol and Micah as well as any of the theology men on phatmass well tell you, I’m not one that is pushed around and I can play hardball right along with the best of them lol Hope this helps. God Bless, Jennie
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now