Archaeology cat Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1585190' date='Jun 28 2008, 12:58 AM']It's fine to have a private opinion about something like this, but when people virtually mock it openly, it is completely wrong. I will keep my own opinion to myself, and let the Church decide when the time comes.[/quote] Agreed.
nowak.chris Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1585132' date='Jun 27 2008, 08:03 PM']Unfortunately, some people condemn others for making their own decisions, rather than looking at what the Church has to say, yet they do the same thing themselves. I'm convinced that even if the Church does declare the apparitions as being authentic, there will still be people on Phatmass who think they know better.[/quote] But "it is possible to refuse to accept such revelations and to turn from them, as long as one does so with proper modesty, for good reasons, and without the intention of setting himself up as a superior." [De Serv. Dei Beatif.] I doubt I will ever be convinced of the validity of the current apparitions in Medjugorje. There are too many little things that don't add up. There may have been a true apparition there in the beginning, but the whole traveling roadshow aspect is a bit much for me to accept. As Medjugorje is not approved it doesn't even fall under the umbrella of private revelation, although either way I am well within the Catholic faith to have deep reservations about it.
Noel's angel Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 I never said you couldn't have reservations, for all you know I may have reservations too. It's when people openly mock it, that bothers me. It is, and has always been a silly idea to keep debating about this subject because no one knows, and funnily enough, our opinion has no bearing on whether they are real or not. In situations like this, it is best to keep our opinions to ourselves, and wait for the Church to lead us. Why can't we just leave this at 'no one knows', and move on? Debating it is a waste of energy because nothing will change. The Church isn't going to look at our 300 threads on this topic and say, 'Oh, I think Noel's angel or whoever has convinced me that the apparitions are true/false.' Irk.
Mercy me Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 I doubt that I will live long enough for the Church to decide on it. I personally am not big on private revelation but that said have a strong devotion to Divine Mercy which is private revelation. But that is about it for me in the way of private revelation. I don't practice the many devotions attributed to Mary's appearances. As to Medjugorje, I have seen some incredible fruits. And yes there are vocations to the religious life that have come from there. I personally know people that received their vocations there. I also, and more importantly know people who were given the gift of faith and had their lives transformed after a pilgrimage there. For me, it has not resonated. I see the fruits but what I have seen of the message doesn't really strike me. I have not really pursued it. I won't deride people for believing. As I said, I have seen lives transformed. People who have had radical conversions there have done amazing things for the Church. Certainly conversions of this kind are not Satanic. Interestingly enough those people that I know who had conversions due to Medjugorje are not the ones active in spreading the message of Medjugorje. That speaks volumes for me too. Who am I to say if it is authentic or not.
Sister Rose Therese Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 (edited) On the original note, the visionaries from La Sallette and from Banneux never became religious. The visionary at Banneux married and had children. The main message from Medugorje is Mass and the Eucharist, Prayer (especially for peace) and the rosary, confession and conversion and fasting. Nothing too questionable there. Regardless of your opinions on the truth of the apparitions, we cannot deny the importance of what is recommended. Edited June 28, 2008 by Sister Rose Therese
Ash Wednesday Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 Meh. People should remember that even among approved apparitions, Catholics are NOT required to believe in them. If people choose not to believe in them even though the Church hasn't closed the case, that is their right. I won't entirely close the door on the possibility of their authenticity, but I'm mostly skeptical.
Lil Red Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 +J.M.J.+[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1584942' date='Jun 27 2008, 12:47 PM']Nah, nobody's perfect all the time. We receive the Eucharist, go to Confession, say our prayers, and then turn around and cut someone off in traffic or yell at our spouse. Contact with God doesn't automatically grant us immunity from imperfection.[/quote] darnit!! [quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1585127' date='Jun 27 2008, 04:58 PM']I STILL don't understand how people can make such firm judgments one way or another before the Church makes a decision herself. It is beyond me how anyone could firmly believe that the visions are heaven-sent OR satanic and look down on anyone else for thinking otherwise when the Church hasn't taken a stand yet.[/quote] [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1585537' date='Jun 28 2008, 08:38 AM']I never said you couldn't have reservations, for all you know I may have reservations too. It's when people openly mock it, that bothers me. It is, and has always been a silly idea to keep debating about this subject because no one knows, and funnily enough, our opinion has no bearing on whether they are real or not. In situations like this, it is best to keep our opinions to ourselves, and wait for the Church to lead us. Why can't we just leave this at 'no one knows', and move on? Debating it is a waste of energy because nothing will change. The Church isn't going to look at our 300 threads on this topic and say, 'Oh, I think Noel's angel or whoever has convinced me that the apparitions are true/false.' Irk.[/quote] [quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1585677' date='Jun 28 2008, 12:45 PM']Meh. People should remember that even among approved apparitions, Catholics are NOT required to believe in them. If people choose not to believe in them even though the Church hasn't closed the case, that is their right.[/quote] and i honestly do not like people trying to 'shove' their opinion down my throat either way on this topic.
Chiquitunga Posted June 28, 2008 Posted June 28, 2008 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1585537' date='Jun 28 2008, 08:38 AM']I never said you couldn't have reservations, for all you know I may have reservations too. It's when people openly mock it, that bothers me. It is, and has always been a silly idea to keep debating about this subject because no one knows, and funnily enough, our opinion has no bearing on whether they are real or not. In situations like this, it is best to keep our opinions to ourselves, and wait for the Church to lead us. Why can't we just leave this at 'no one knows', and move on? Debating it is a waste of energy because nothing will change. The Church isn't going to look at our 300 threads on this topic and say, 'Oh, I think Noel's angel or whoever has convinced me that the apparitions are true/false.' Irk.[/quote] I totally agree. Also, here's something I just stumbled upon, not meaning to cause more debate or comments or anything, [url="http://wdtprs.com/blog/2008/06/vatican-investigation-of-medjugorje/"]http://wdtprs.com/blog/2008/06/vatican-inv...-of-medjugorje/[/url] God bless!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now