Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Obama Vs. Bush


Obama vs. Bush  

33 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Galloglasses
Posted

[quote name='the great bustin' bodacious air dUStin' post='1586254' date='Jun 29 2008, 11:42 AM']Really? Well, I was only highlighting the pro-life stuff (because the popular opinion is that he did nothing for the pro-life movement, which is utterly ridiculous), but you can read this list if you want:

[url="http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1163304/posts"]http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1163304/posts[/url][/quote]
*whistles* That's quite a privatisation rap sheet.

Posted

I don't read things from free republic or world net daily for fear of my IQ dropping.

;)

Galloglasses
Posted

Actually you could do with reading it. It does bring up alot of surprisingly good things. (altough there things that even I find sketchy at best)

Posted

[quote name='the great bustin' bodacious air dUStin' post='1586254' date='Jun 29 2008, 12:42 PM']Really? Well, I was only highlighting the pro-life stuff (because the popular opinion is that he did nothing for the pro-life movement, which is utterly ridiculous), but you can read this list if you want:

[url="http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1163304/posts"]http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1163304/posts[/url][/quote]

[quote][size=18]Education & Employment Training[/size]

1. Signed the No Child Left Behind Act, delivering the most dramatic education reforms in a generation (challenging the soft bigotry of low expectations). The very liberal California Teachers union is currently running radio ads against the accountability provisions of this Act.

[b]The educational system definitely needs more accountability, but I fervently believe that NCLB was the wrong way to go about it. For one, schools that don't meet expectations (called AYP or "Adequate Yearly Progress", which is defined arbitrarily) are required to meet the next year's expectations. The problem is that these expectations increase every year. So what we see is that schools that have a problem of getting a score of say, 50, for one year have the bar set higher for them the following year. A better way of doing this would be to leave the bar at the same level until the school can meet that bar, and [i]then[/i] move it up.[/b]

[b]Then there is the question about efficacy of the assessments used in determining progress. For example: here in Illinois, a recent law stated that tests are only to be given in English, even to non-English speakers. Now, I agree that everyone in America needs to learn English (and, let's face it, Spanish too), but these tests are not designed to assess English language acquisition, but rather ability within content areas. We need tests that separate both of these variables.[/b]

[b]Further, I don't like how the article states that "The very liberal California Teachers' Union is currently running radio ads against the accountability provisions of this Act". This seems a little ad hominem to me: the implication seems to be that "Liberals are bad; therefore anything that they support must be bad, also".[/b]

2. Announced "Jobs for the 21st Century," a comprehensive plan to better prepare workers for jobs in the new millennium by strengthening post-secondary education and job training, and by improving high school education.

[b]Great.[/b]

3. Is working to provide vouchers to low-income students in persistently failing schools to help with costs of attending private schools. (Blocked in the Senate.)

[b]Don't get me wrong; I love private schools. I am myself the proud product of 13 years of Catholic Education. I can't wait to get to heaven and give St. Angela Merici a huge hug for founding the Ursulines; I owe them so much.[/b]

[b]That said, vouchers scare me. I don't like the attitude that they create within the people: if your school is not up to par, don't worry; just go somewhere else. This is bad for accountability; rather than communities taking stock in their schools and working together to improve them, the policy instead advocates jumping ship when it starts to sink.[/b]

4. Requires annual reading and math tests in grades three through eight.

[b]Only "reading and math"? Surely there are other important things that students are learning, too. Let's make sure that we are encouraging teachers to teach those things too, rather than punishing them for teaching things not on the test, but still necessary for creating high-functioning adult citizens.[/b]

5. Requires states to participate in the National Assessment of Education Progress, or an equivalent program, to establish a national benchmark for academic performance.

[b]National benchmarks carry with them the problem of being national. They don't recognize that each state, school district, school, and yes even student each have their own challenges to be overcome. Conservatives everywhere should be appalled at the level of government involvement here. These benchmarks need to be created and applied at the lowest-level possible.[/b]

6. Requires school-by-school accountability report cards.

[b]Great.[/b]

7. Established a $2.4 billion fund to help states implement teacher accountability systems.

[b]Great. Accountability is always awesome, so long as it's placed correctly. But, let's make sure that we're holding administrators accountable as well, in addition to everyone else involved in the process, including politicians, parents, et al (I really want to see some accountability placed on parents that don't make sure their kids are getting to school). It takes a village, after all.[/b]

8. Increased funding for the Troops-to-Teachers program, which recruits former military personnel to become teachers.

[b]I'm having trouble seeing exactly what the logic is behind this program here. That's not to say that I think that former soldiers would be poor teachers; I think that you would see the same numbers of mediocre, average, good, and excellent teachers that come from any other swathe of the population. I just don't see former troops as being uniquely qualified. So, I don't understand the reasoning behind wanting to focus here, apart from helping ex-military find jobs in an undersaturated market, as well as providing an outlet for these soldiers wishing to serve their country post-duty.[/b][/quote]

Comments in bold.

Posted

I don't think Obama would be better than Bush in any way.

From a moral standpoint alone, an Obama presidency would be disastrous. Not only would Obama undo all the positives for the pro-life movement the great bustin' bodacious air dUStin has listed, but he has promised he would sign the "Freedom of Choice Act" into law, which would ban any and all restrictions on abortion. Such an act would set the pro-life movement back decades, and would require a lot of work to overturn.
As Illinois state senator, Obama voted against the Infants Born Alive Act giving legal protection to the life of infants that have survived abortion.
All records indicate Obama would be the most pro-abortion president in American history.

Obama has also promised to give active support for the "gay rights" movement, and use the "bully pulpit" to advance the "gay" agenda.

Obama really scares me - he is truly an antichrist.

And I seriously doubt an Obama presidency will do squat for the economy. The "soak the rich" socialism he offers, while making liberals feel good about themselves, will not help make anyone else be more prosperous, and can only hurt the economy.

I think we have many serious economic troubles which are beyond the power of any president to fix, and are likely to get worse. I don't see this reversing under Obama. The only good thing is that after Obama, the bleeding hearts will not be able to blame all their troubles on Bush, and Obama will be revealed to be the worthless sham that he is.

While many may like the fact that he promises an immediate withdrawal of all troops from Iraq, I think such a sudden withdrawal with no other plan will be seen by America's enemies as a concession of defeat and sign of weakness.
Obama also seems uncomfortable with basic patriotism, and often seems unsure who's side he's on. His naive let's-sit-down-and-have-tea with all the world's murderous dictators is certainly troubling.


And this whole "nobody could possibly be worse than Bush" attitude that's so popular here is incredibly naive to say the least, and is every bit as moronic and mindless as the Bush-haters claim Bush to be.

There is certainly no reason for anyone to support Barrack Hussein Obama.

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1586680' date='Jun 29 2008, 10:07 PM']I don't think Obama would be better than Bush in any way.

From a moral standpoint alone, an Obama presidency would be disastrous. Not only would Obama undo all the positives for the pro-life movement the great bustin' bodacious air dUStin has listed, but he has promised he would sign the "Freedom of Choice Act" into law, which would ban any and all restrictions on abortion. Such an act would set the pro-life movement back decades, and would require a lot of work to overturn.
As Illinois state senator, Obama voted against the Infants Born Alive Act giving legal protection to the life of infants that have survived abortion.
All records indicate Obama would be the most pro-abortion president in American history.

Obama has also promised to give active support for the "gay rights" movement, and use the "bully pulpit" to advance the "gay" agenda.

Obama really scares me - he is truly an antichrist.

And I seriously doubt an Obama presidency will do squat for the economy. The "soak the rich" socialism he offers, while making liberals feel good about themselves, will not help make anyone else be more prosperous, and can only hurt the economy.

I think we have many serious economic troubles which are beyond the power of any president to fix, and are likely to get worse. I don't see this reversing under Obama. The only good thing is that after Obama, the bleeding hearts will not be able to blame all their troubles on Bush, and Obama will be revealed to be the worthless sham that he is.

While many may like the fact that he promises an immediate withdrawal of all troops from Iraq, I think such a sudden withdrawal with no other plan will be seen by America's enemies as a concession of defeat and sign of weakness.
Obama also seems uncomfortable with basic patriotism, and often seems unsure who's side he's on. His naive let's-sit-down-and-have-tea with all the world's murderous dictators is certainly troubling.
And this whole "nobody could possibly be worse than Bush" attitude that's so popular here is incredibly naive to say the least, and is every bit as moronic and mindless as the Bush-haters claim Bush to be.

There is certainly no reason for anyone to support Barrack Hussein Obama.[/quote]

Can't argue with you here, Soc.

Posted

[quote name='Galloglasses' post='1586321' date='Jun 29 2008, 01:52 PM']Actually you could do with reading it. It does bring up alot of surprisingly good things. (altough there things that even I find sketchy at best)[/quote]


I have read it before on a blog, but I seriously laugh whenever people link to freerepublic or worldnetdaily. I mean really? REALLY?

lol.

that would be like me linking to motherjones.com or huffington post to try to make a point... ;)

Posted

[quote name='Alycin' post='1586717' date='Jun 29 2008, 10:38 PM']I have read it before on a blog, but I seriously laugh whenever people link to freerepublic or worldnetdaily. I mean really? REALLY?

lol.

that would be like me linking to motherjones.com or huffington post to try to make a point... ;)[/quote]

:lol_roll:

Posted

[quote name='the great bustin' bodacious air dUStin' post='1586097' date='Jun 28 2008, 11:40 PM']Hmmm... Here's some things Bush has done...

[b]- Banned Partial Birth Abortion — by far the most significant roll-back of abortion on demand since Roe v. Wade.

- Reversed Clinton's move to strike Reagan's anti-abortion Mexico Policy.

- By Executive Order, reversed Clinton's policy of not requiring parental consent for abortions under the Medical Privacy Act.

- By Executive Order, prohibited federal funds for international family planning groups that provide abortions and related services.

- Upheld the ban on abortions at military hospitals.

- Made $33 million available for abstinence education programs in 2004.

- Denied federal funds for the U.N. Population Fund, which promotes world-wide population controls through abortion, and birth control.

- Nominated pro-life federal judges to the Supreme Court.
[/b]

Oh, but I'm sure if Obama is elected president he'll do all he can to make sure these pro-life accomplishments stand. Mmm hmm.[/quote]

so, so far Bush has done 8 half decent things succesfully over the course of nearly eight years. not so impressive. he has certainly made a cockup of just about everything else.

the road to hell is paved with good intentions, which seem to be all that bush has. i may not be on the same side as obama on several issue, but i am inclined to think he will actually be a better leader than bush.

Posted

[quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1586747' date='Jun 29 2008, 11:11 PM']so, so far Bush has done 8 half decent things succesfully over the course of nearly eight years. not so impressive. he has certainly made a cockup of just about everything else.

the road to hell is paved with good intentions, which seem to be all that bush has. i may not be on the same side as obama on several issue, but i am inclined to think he will actually be a better leader than bush.[/quote]

Other than the pro-life victories Bush has presided over during his tenure, I think he's done very little positive for this nation; however, I am not sure Obama is going to be better, though you can bet that the media will try to doll him up anyway.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Alycin' post='1586717' date='Jun 29 2008, 09:38 PM']I have read it before on a blog, but I seriously laugh whenever people link to freerepublic or worldnetdaily. I mean really? REALLY?

lol.

that would be like me linking to motherjones.com or huffington post to try to make a point... ;)[/quote]
or linking to Al-Jazeera? *cough EENS cough*

:lol:

Edited by notardillacid
kenrockthefirst
Posted

[quote name='the great bustin' bodacious air dUStin' post='1586097' date='Jun 29 2008, 12:40 AM']Hmmm... Here's some things Bush has done...

[b]- Banned Partial Birth Abortion — by far the most significant roll-back of abortion on demand since Roe v. Wade.

- Reversed Clinton's move to strike Reagan's anti-abortion Mexico Policy.

- By Executive Order, reversed Clinton's policy of not requiring parental consent for abortions under the Medical Privacy Act.

- By Executive Order, prohibited federal funds for international family planning groups that provide abortions and related services.

- Upheld the ban on abortions at military hospitals.

- Made $33 million available for abstinence education programs in 2004.

- Denied federal funds for the U.N. Population Fund, which promotes world-wide population controls through abortion, and birth control.

- Nominated pro-life federal judges to the Supreme Court.
[/b]

Oh, but I'm sure if Obama is elected president he'll do all he can to make sure these pro-life accomplishments stand. Mmm hmm.[/quote]
Can we get some metrics, please? What has the above *actually* accomplished?

In the meantime, how many thousands of lives were lost, and how many tens of thousands irreparably damaged in an unnecessary war of choice? How many lives were lost, how many ruined as a great American city was simply washed away while Bush and McBush celebrated the latter's birthday? How long will it take, if ever, to pay off the national debt engendered by the unnecessary war of choice and reckless fiscal policies of this administration?

Again, we'd be better off if things were simply left to chance. At least there wouldn't be an agent *actively* doing things to cause harm.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...