Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What's The Matter With Us?


Recommended Posts

catholicinsd
Posted

Well pham, about three or four in our ranks just drove a very important member of our phamily away. Theologian in Training is not with us anymore, as well as many other PMers.

But this is just a sign of what has been happening on this Phorum. We have just the love for the Holy Catholic Church. Instead we only have devotion to what benefits us and our ideals.

There are racial and homophobic undertones all around us. We have been so closed-minded we are the crowd calling for the Passion of Christ. I have talked to some of privately and there is a concenus that things on this phorum do not accuratly the Preaching of Holy Apostlic Truth that is the Holy Catholic Church.

May the Blood of Christ wash over us all.

CinSD

Ash Wednesday
Posted

What happened with Theologian in Training? :unsure: I've been too busy to follow some things on here lately...

catholicinsd
Posted

After he was attacked for his views on guns, and his murdered father, he left.

rizz_loves_jesus
Posted

I'm wondering that too. There are some attitudes on this phorum that I don't like, but I haven't seen anything bad enough to make me leave :(

Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' post='1587128' date='Jun 30 2008, 11:46 AM']After he was attacked for his views on guns, and his murdered father, he left.[/quote]

Wow...that's not even cool. I missed that. I'll pray for him.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I went back and read the thread in question. As someone who lost a parent under unjust circumstances myself, I can understand how an issue can touch a sore nerve like that, in this case with Father. It is one thing to disagree and want to advocate arguing with reason rather than emotion, but referring to someone who has lost a parent in that way as being a whiner or an overreactor is most definitely uncalled for.

I'm sad to see him go.

Posted

It saddens me to see Father leave the phorum...

I agree lately there is something going around the floors were people are looking to be spitefull which is sad. We all can get pretty emotional here and there are threads that may hurt our feeling or upset us. But, I also think that we are in controll here and can step away from a situation that can be harmful to ourselves and/or others.

I think that we should all pray for Fathers return. His posts will be missed :(

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I hope that he does come back and maybe he will reconsider later on. It could be that, as a priest, he believes it to be of great importance to show example and not post on here when getting emotionally charged or addressing issues that touch on deeply personal things. So it could be not soley a case of him being "driven away" but his decision to exercise prudence and avoid occasion of sin for himself as well. My prayers are with him and all of phatmass.

nowak.chris
Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' post='1587128' date='Jun 30 2008, 01:46 PM']After he was attacked for his views on guns, and his murdered father, he left.[/quote]

Justin's one post was inappropriate. His opinions, once made known, were open for discussion as anyone else's are.

Father was, in all honesty, insisting on his POV from an emotional appeal. Those who confronted him on that (the emotional appeal as bad argumentation) were correct.

There is a certain amount of prudence of knowing what you can handle in relation to emotional triggers (and the death of a parent is an extreme emotional trigger, as I know first-hand). To leave the board all-together over an argument on an issue you cannot handle... I'll leave that to each person to figure out.

BTW, why isn't that thread in the debate table?

Posted

Stow the apologetics on the comments. I find the lack of respect for Fr.'s loss and of his office deplorable.
I hope everyone of you has confession planned soon. It seems that more and more of the comments coming from people who easily list "Catholic" as their religion, do not resemble Catholics or Christians at all.
I am sure Christ loves you using his name as follower of his with remarks like some of these on this site.
Yes, I am responding with emotion. I too have lost someone who was shot in the head. It wasn't by a total stranger either. How nice he had one handy when she went to break up with him.

Posted

I'm sorry that Theologian in Training is leaving or has left and over his loss. I've read over all the posts that took place in that thread. None of them were in a bashing nature nor were they making any less of the loss of his father. Each person has the right to their own opinion, he has his and others have theirs. I see his points very clearly as to why he dislikes guns, but his personal experience does not have to be the point by which all other base their opinions, whether he is a doctor, priest, etc. A personal opinion toward something is still a personal opinion.

When Pope John Paul II spoke out in disagreement with the Iraq War many Catholics were at each others throats over it. Some agreed with the Pope and some did not. Those who did often told those who didn't that they were being unfaithful to the Church and to the Holy Father. The Holy Father was giving his personal opinion on an event or topic, he was not proclaiming something dogmatic nor was it a matter of faith and morals that was to become a teaching of the Church.

It has often been my experience that if a topic is likely to bring up too many emotions from a personal experience or personal belief, that isn't Church teaching, then we should refrain from getting started in those conversations. They often lead to emotions running so high that the person feels as if they are being attacked or the memory of someone they knew is being attacked, when it is often not the case. People are going to disagree with one another but we have to learn not to take disagreements as personal attacks.

I, for one, stay out of threads about the Iraq War, I disagree with it and have been called unpatriotic and that I don't care about the troops because of my not agreeing with it. They pass judgement without evening knowing that my oldest brother is on his third tour of duty there. I made the mistake of getting wrapped up in so many of the Iraq War threads that I almost left Phatmass as well because I felt my brother and I were being attacked, which wasn't the case, people were just merely disagreeing with my opinion.

Winchester's comment was not pointed at Theologian in Training it was pointed at "anyone." I'm in agreement with Winchester that to bring up personal experience or personal tragedies aren't great things to bring up in political threads, it only turns into a huge emotional mess. I know from personal experience.

[quote name='Deb' post='1587177' date='Jun 30 2008, 01:35 PM']I hope everyone of you has confession planned soon.[/quote]

To disagree with Fr. Brian's point of view is not cause for Confession. I point this out because we have many scrupulants on Phatmass who would then start thinking that any disagreement would be cause for Confession. From all of those posts that I read in disagreement with Fr. Brian all expressed their sympathies for his loss.

Posted

Thank you, StC.

homeschoolmom
Posted

I really don't think that it is our place to rehash who said what and who has a right to what opinions etc.

I think that anytime tempers flare and people are driven away from the phorum it's a shame. We do not know Fr. Brian's reasons, so it is wrong to speculate about them....

That being said, I am closing this thread. Anyone who would have liked to post in it can say a brief prayer for charity on the phorum instead. Thanks

--HSM

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...