Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

A friend of mine that's a girl just broke up with her boyfriend today, and I want to be there for her, but don't want our realtionship to evolve anymore than just friends. I'm taking her out for ice cream after work (how very girly of me, but hey she's my friend). Any advice? Thanks.

missionarybelle
Posted

tell her that.

Posted

do you suspect that she has prior feelings for you or are you just concerned that in her vulnerable state she may develop feelings for your if you are her shoulder to cry on? Do you have significant feelings for her, but are reticent to let the relationship bloom into something more because she is vulnerable?

Posted

well, normally its the girl wanting to remain friends, that the way it has been with me <_<

well, show her you dont have good hygiene, maybe make an ass out of yourself a few times, and then you will never date!

seriously now, dont bring it up right now, it would just put up a wall between you when you need to be close. later on, go for a long walk and just really hash out what you like or dont like with the way things are between you, and make sure their are no misunderstandings.

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

I think you should be fine if you haven't given her a reason to think anything more than just friends. Just make it obvious and emphasize it by not being misleading and you should be okay.

Posted

[quote name='Veridicus' post='1587892' date='Jul 1 2008, 03:15 PM']do you suspect that she has prior feelings for you[/quote]
Maybe. But she could have been joking when she said it. She was asking the guys around the clinic the critiea for the wife they would marry. For me, one of mine was that she had to be Catholic (she's Protestant). She giggled and said, "I'm very sorry that I can't be your dream girl, Justin."

She is an attractive girl, and yeah, I kinda am worried about my sex drive taking the best of me, espically in her vulnerable state, and the situation above was back when she was talking about breaking up with her boyfriend.

I know that despite my sex drive, I can control my behavior, however, I guess I'm looking for any signs that she might be getting interested, and stop it there before we both take things out of hand.

Posted

[quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1587893' date='Jul 1 2008, 01:16 AM']...
well, show her you dont have good hygiene, maybe make an ass out of yourself a few times, and then you will never date!
...[/quote]

In my limited experience, I have found these attempts just have the vulnerable girl thinking you are even more cute and in need of a woman to keep you out of trouble...attraction is a strange thing.

Posted

[quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1587893' date='Jul 1 2008, 03:16 PM']well, normally its the girl wanting to remain friends, that the way it has been with me <_<

well, show her you dont have good hygiene, maybe make an ass out of yourself a few times, and then you will never date!

seriously now, dont bring it up right now, it would just put up a wall between you when you need to be close. later on, go for a long walk and just really hash out what you like or dont like with the way things are between you, and make sure their are no misunderstandings.[/quote]

Your post confuses me.

Posted (edited)

And with regard to my second query in the post above?

Edited by Veridicus
Posted

[quote name='Veridicus' post='1587892' date='Jul 1 2008, 03:15 PM']Do you have significant feelings for her, but are reticent to let the relationship bloom into something more because she is vulnerable?[/quote]
No.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Justin86' post='1587920' date='Jul 1 2008, 01:44 AM']No.[/quote]

If you are being honest about that, then you should have nothing to lose by being honest should a situation arise necessitating that honesty. If she shows more outward signs of being attracted to you, then you should definitely say something (in my opinion). If she desists from demonstrating an attraction to you, I would just keep playing it cool and not make things awkward for her by bringing it up. You may just being thinking to hard about it if you yourself aren't interested and you just have a single vague insinuation that she was possibly at one point int he past interested in you.

Edited by Veridicus
missionseeker
Posted (edited)

so... Tuesday.. my best friend, a guy, and I, realized that it just doesn't work. :(


over the past two years, he was there for me, he looked out for me, he cheered me up. I fell fast and hard. We were super close. People always thought we were dating. Even though we never did. He knew I liked him. So.. at first he kind of was harsh and rude to try and make it stop. Then he just talked to me about it. Made it perfectly clear (even though it HAD been perfectly clear. as much as he knew where I stood, I knew where he stood...) then we went on "being just friends" But.. he got a girlfriend and thought I was going to pose some sort of problem. I wished him well, but thought it hopeless. he didn't really understand that I was NOT jealous. I just don't get jealous. It sounds strange, but it wasn't jealousy. Anywho, she broke up with him a couple weeks later (and while they hadn't been dating long, they had been talking a long time). He came to me. They got back together but then started having problems. He told me about them and when he broke up with her, he came to me again. It kind of sucked, not gonna lie. And he continued to treat me like... trash. All this time, I still liked him. And it was mostly because we were still close even while he was dating the other girl (which yes, I should have stopped him [cuz it was him- i wouldn't start conversations with him]) but eventually, he only called me if he needed something and such. Yet, we still had a "friendship" going. I march, I gave him a lettter, telling him that I needed him to go away for a lot of reasons which I explained to him. It wasn't a nasty letter. I pretty much poured my soul out to him on those pages. He got mad. We had a fight. And things ended. But not really. His dad died in April; he called me. (And before that he sent me updates about his dad's health)

About a month ago, I got an apology. A very good apology. And so we started talking again. But we had all sorts of rules that I set. he followed to a T . If I was scared about something, I let him know the problem. And if he noticed something, he told me. All this time, we were still being "just friends". But then I realized that people only work that hard for serious relationships. That as much as we may want to be friends, we can't. One of us (me! me!) will wind up hurt. So... I sent him an email saying "we've always acted like we were dating (even though it really wasn't intentional) and now, we're putting ourselves in extremely vulnerable position like you would put yourself in with someone you cared about deeply and trusted completely." (more/better than thatlol) Then I asked him why. And I told that unless we were actually going to label how we're acting as what it is, then we don't need to be doing it.


And so... now I'm missing him because I'm having nightmares about childhood trauma and he always could cheer me up. (though that is certainly not the only reason)


:sadsmile:

My two cents. I've never really heard of a guy/girl thing where they COULD keep it just friends. (Now I know why...) They always wind up not friends or married...


this is way longer than I thought it was. lol.

Edited by missionseeker
Posted

I'd say be really sarcastic and borderline rude to her. Ya know, just be yourself! That oughta scare her away.

TOTALLY playing, dude. I would be gentle with her feelings. She's fragile right now...don't bombard her with it, but be firm if it comes up.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='kujo' post='1588006' date='Jul 1 2008, 03:34 AM']She's fragile right now...don't bombard her with it, but be firm if it comes up.[/quote]

My sentiments exactly, but with greater concision.

Edited by Veridicus
Posted

I want to point out that my joke towards Justin was a [b]JOKE[/b]....

Posted (edited)

[quote name='kujo' post='1588028' date='Jul 1 2008, 03:55 AM']I want to point out that my joke towards Justin was a [b]JOKE[/b]....[/quote]

I kept finding myself having to say things like that all evening...does that annoy you that we have to keep walking on ice on PM nowadays because people jump all over things and argue with straw men for no reason?

Edited by Veridicus
Posted

[quote name='kujo' post='1588028' date='Jul 1 2008, 05:55 PM']I want to point out that my joke towards Justin was a [b]JOKE[/b]....[/quote]

It's ok. I'm a pretty observant guy when it comes to people joking. You could have just said "jk" afterwards, and you would've been cool.

Besides, I'm not one of those here that jumps on every little perceived offense against charity. Remember? :P


Anyway, me and my friend went for our ice cream, and it went fine. Her, me and some more friends are going to go see "Get Smart" tonight at the base theater. Should be fun.

Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1588053' date='Jul 1 2008, 06:18 AM']It's ok. I'm a pretty observant guy when it comes to people joking. You could have just said "jk" afterwards, and you would've been cool.

Besides, I'm not one of those here that jumps on every little perceived offense against charity. Remember? :P
Anyway, me and my friend went for our ice cream, and it went fine. Her, me and some more friends are going to go see "Get Smart" tonight at the base theater. Should be fun.[/quote]

Hahaha. I was more saying it so that OTHERS would understand. I know you get my humor.

Glad to hear it went well.

Posted

[quote name='Veridicus' post='1588032' date='Jul 1 2008, 05:58 PM']I kept finding myself having to say things like that all evening...does that annoy you that we have to keep walking on ice on PM nowadays because people jump all over things and argue with straw men for no reason?[/quote]
:yes:

Posted

Thanks to everyone for your suggestions. I think it was pretty obvious to me what I should do, but I guess I wanted everyone else to say that. Thanks.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...