Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey guys,

I'm talking to an ex-Catholic, currently Pentecostal friend of mine tonight (or soon) about how I came home to the Church after being Protestant.

I know her main concern is that the Church doesn't slam home "accept Jesus or go to hell, have a personal relationship, evangelize". She said that when she became a Protestant she learned about having a personal relationship and getting saved, and that the Church never teaches getting saved.

Admittedly, I had this same argument from my days as a Protestant--I said they never taught the Gospel. I know they do, but I can understand it now that I *did* learn that "accept and be saved" lifestyle.

How should I approach this with her? How does the Church communicate the saving message of Christ?

Above all, please pray for me, that I might speak with charity and truth.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Well, one of the things is that the Church was so focused on orthodoxy for so long (which is a good thing, don't get me wrong), that people often got the perception that knowing the doctrines was more important than knowing Christ...not that knowing the doctrines is in reality unimportant, but we know the truth in order to know the True God, you know? Of course, this wasn't actually the Church's teaching, it was just the common perception.

Since the Second Vatican Council, this has been changing, although, admittedly, there have been errors on the part of some theologians.

Accepting Christ on a personal level is very important and I would say that this is now heavily emphasized in many places. I think most of JPII's documents are pretty clearly geared toward that message.

As for evangelization, the Church often doesn't have as many catechized lay people, but we certainly have good media and communications through which we spread the Gospel. I would say though, that the lack of fervor in many Catholics is not a proof against the Church.

Posted

Thanks, Micah.

Of course, in Protestant traditions there is usually a definitive moment where the sinner recognizes his/her need for salvation, and asks for it. The Gospel teaches that all who confess the name of the Lord, repent, and believe will be saved.

I imagine she will say that Catholics don't have those "getting saved" moments, where they asked Jesus to be Lord of their life.

We become Christians at baptism. For most, as they are baptized as children they don't make that decision for themselves. Oftentimes these same cradle Catholics are forced into Confirmation by their families--such was the case with me, and most in my CCD class.

While it's true we [i]don't[/i] often say at Mass--"You need to accept Jesus!!!", we do preach the Gospel. Christ died so that we might live in Him. By being at Mass, and praying at home, we are part of that life in Christ.

Stream of consciousness. Thoughts? Help? Bible verses?

TeresaBenedicta
Posted

I'd say that everytime we go to Mass or to Confession or receive Holy Communion, we're accepting Jesus as our personal Lord and Savior. I mean, this is obviously not in the same way that evangelicals talk about, but it is a definite moment.

Everytime I pray the Creed, I am accepting Jesus as personal Lord, as Savior. Everytime I pray "Lord, I am not worthy to receive you, but only say the word and I shall be healed", I am accepting Jesus as personal Lord, as Savior. And especially everytime that the priest says, "The Body of Christ", I give my vocal "Amen" and then I receive Jesus as personal Lord, as Savior.

Obviously this is not the same as the once saved always saved mentality. It can't be. We're working out our Salvation with fear and trembling. We profess the name of Jesus. We are doing are best to accept him as our own personal Lord and Savior. But accepting him is not a one-time thing. It's an every day thing, it's an every moment thing. It's a struggle. And when I sin, when I turn my back and when I reject Christ as personal Lord and Savior (which is essentially what I am doing when I sin), I need to come back and ask for his forgiveness and accept him back again: yay for Confession.

Posted

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1588371' date='Jul 1 2008, 02:45 PM']Thanks, Micah.

Of course, in Protestant traditions there is usually a definitive moment where the sinner recognizes his/her need for salvation, and asks for it. The Gospel teaches that all who confess the name of the Lord, repent, and believe will be saved.

I imagine she will say that Catholics don't have those "getting saved" moments, where they asked Jesus to be Lord of their life.

We become Christians at baptism. For most, as they are baptized as children they don't make that decision for themselves. Oftentimes these same cradle Catholics are forced into Confirmation by their families--such was the case with me, and most in my CCD class.

While it's true we [i]don't[/i] often say at Mass--"You need to accept Jesus!!!", we do preach the Gospel. Christ died so that we might live in Him. By being at Mass, and praying at home, we are part of that life in Christ.

Stream of consciousness. Thoughts? Help? Bible verses?[/quote]

The problem often faced is the common Protestant idea of "once saved always saved" Where as Catholics we are saved, are being saved, and hope to be saved, does that make sense? We accept Jesus as our personal Lord and Savior, of course. But salvation is also a process. If a person were to accept Jesus in the sense of once saved always saved and then murder someone and not repent for it and they die they would be in state of mortal sin and sadly go to hell. So in saying that salvation is a process, it's just not a one time acceptance of Jesus. If we keep the commandments and remain faithful to God and die in a state of grace, meaning no mortal sins, we have hope that we are saved.

Micah and I just returned from Steubenville on the Bayou with the high school youth from our parish as well as 3,000 other high school youth throughout the country (mostly the south). They did a type of altar call, not during Mass mind you lol, where the kids made a public profession of their faith and acceptance of Christ as their Savior. It was wonderful to see sooo many young people making that public profession. In reality everytime we attend Mass we are making a public profession that we accept Christ as Our Savior, even if we aren't shouting it from the roof tops.

Posted

How about showing her a few passages from Pope Benedict; there is no better reference for Church teaching. You can also take the Catechism. Or just type "Pope Benedict being saved" or anything like that on your search engine, and you'll find a lot of resources. Ask your friend if she knows the title of his last encyclical... You can also offer it to her. She'll find out that he talks as well about the possibility to get lost...
God bless.

Fr. Bruno

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted (edited)

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1588371' date='Jul 1 2008, 08:45 PM']Thanks, Micah.

Of course, in Protestant traditions there is usually a definitive moment where the sinner recognizes his/her need for salvation, and asks for it. The Gospel teaches that all who confess the name of the Lord, repent, and believe will be saved. I imagine she will say that Catholics don't have those "getting saved" moments, where they asked Jesus to be Lord of their life.[/quote]

St Paul had his extraordinary life-changing encounter with Christ on the road to Damascus, but he kept accepting Jesus as his personal Lord and Saviour in every decision he took after that. In every word that he spoke. Catholicism makes it clear that 'God walks among the pots and pans' (St Teresa of Avila) and that our acceptance and knowledge of Christ grows deeper in a thousand and one ordinary and unremarkable situations that may not 'feel' spectacular or tremendous. So yes, we do have those 'getting saved' moments. There are millions of such moments in a day.

Compare it to meeting a good friend at the airport, a friend whom you haven't seen in a while. After the initial hugging and jumping around is over, you may be content to sit with them in silence and just drink hot chocolate, doing nothing outwardly special. But that's important too. It is easy to mistake a state of high emotion for saving faith, when such emotion may actually have little to do with genuine and lasting joy.

Talk to her, too, about how St Paul describes salvation throughout his letters. He makes it clear that it's not just a one-off process, but something that happens continually - past, present, future.

You should also make it clear that Catholics aren't perfect. As the saying goes, the Church is a hospital for sinners, not a country club for saints. Don't attempt to hide our imperfections. Jesus is present in our weaknesses. He's mending them.

Edited by Cathoholic Anonymous
Posted

You all are wonderful, thank you. :)

Jennie--I had actually written a blog post on this very subject, salvation being a process rather than a one-time experience. I'd forgotten all about it, and really, that's what I think I can use when I talk to my friend.

Moving on--what about coercion? As I mentioned previously, the vast majority of Catholics I know/knew never truly believed in our Faith. They were forced to Mass each week, forced to Confession (where we all lied--something that I say with shame now, looking back), only went through the motions as they found us rigid and boring. Why does this happen to so many? When I sit in Mass now, I understand Christ being presented to me in Word and Flesh better than I ever did my "first time around". So many attend a Protestant service to hear a "Gospel" they say they never heard proclaimed from our altar.

What causes this? I have explained this to others by saying yes, the Gospel is with us--but you have to listen. Should we really have to "search" for the Gospel underneath our liturgy?

(Again, these are questions I imagine I might be faced with.)

Posted

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1588422' date='Jul 1 2008, 03:28 PM']You all are wonderful, thank you. :)

Jennie--I had actually written a blog post on this very subject, salvation being a process rather than a one-time experience. I'd forgotten all about it, and really, that's what I think I can use when I talk to my friend.

Moving on--what about coercion? As I mentioned previously, the vast majority of Catholics I know/knew never truly believed in our Faith. They were forced to Mass each week, forced to Confession (where we all lied--something that I say with shame now, looking back), only went through the motions as they found us rigid and boring. Why does this happen to so many? When I sit in Mass now, I understand Christ being presented to me in Word and Flesh better than I ever did my "first time around". So many attend a Protestant service to hear a "Gospel" they say they never heard proclaimed from our altar.

What causes this? I have explained this to others by saying yes, the Gospel is with us--but you have to listen. Should we really have to "search" for the Gospel underneath our liturgy?

(Again, these are questions I imagine I might be faced with.)[/quote]

If you study our liturgy it is greatly rooted in Biblical verses and practices. I know I made a post on this a looooong time ago about the Biblical proofs for parts of the Mass.

As for being "forced" to do something. Parents are to be the first Catechists for their children from the day they bring them home from the hospital and from then on. I wouldn't say that kids are "forced" to go to Mass. If Micah and I are going to Mass our kids are coming with us, because we want them to know Christ and know His Church. We definitely aren't going to leave them at home. But a parent should not just bring their kids to Mass and then not talk to them about what is going on or what went on at Mass. A child will most likely not figure out what is going on and will be completely bored out of their mind if they aren't taught what is going on. Dr. Miravalle at FUS made the point to us in one of his classes that it's important to sit right up front if you have kids. That way they can see everything that is going on and you can explain to them what's taking place. Sadly most parents just drag their kids along with them like a purse and don't take time to explain the Mass or the faith to their children.

You would be amazed what even a very small child knows. One of my coworkers has a granddaughter who just turned one a few weeks ago. Whenever she comes into the parish office there's a big St. Joseph holding baby Jesus behind my desk. She sees it and points to it and goes "baby Jesus, baby Jesus". Where Micah and I went to Mass at in Steubenville there was a couple with two pretty small children. The youngest child I know was less than a year old and whenever he would go in front of the altar walking in or out of the Church he would always genuflect.

Also, let's face it, worship of God is not about being entertained. I've been to several Protestant churches with friends. And I remember thinking while I was in there "where's Jesus?" because there was no tabernacle of course, there was a crucifix, or even a cross on most occasions. It was difficult knowing that I was in a church without some type visual stimulation lol I'm not easily fed by someone just telling me "oh Jesus loves you" end of homily. I want someone who isn't going to ignore the Theological understandings that are within the Scriptures we read in Mass.

Posted

I just gave a talk at a retreat this last weekend and the title was, "Jesus as Lord." The bible states that no one can call Jesus, Lord, except through the Holy Spirit. Too many Catholics and Christians do not understand the importance of the Holy Spirit in receiving and maintaining a close personal relationship with Jesus.

I believe Jesus saved me from my life of sin as he also died on the cross to save me. From here on out though, it is up to me to make sure I remain in that state of grace and just walking around saying I am saved isn't enough. It means confession and receiving the Eucharist and reading scripture. Faith comes to us through scripture and we need to read it every day.

I have heard other protestants say that Catholics don't use the gospel. What is that all about? We have a scripture and gospel reading every day in Mass. Our homily is on that gospel or reading. We are in Mass to hear the word of the Lord, celebrate his life and death and receive his precious body in communion.

The present church is changing and the children being brought up now are enjoying going to church. Catechism is actually teaching the beauty and wonder of our faith rather than memorizing doctrine without explanation of the same. Catholics can go to Mass every day of the week and do not need to have the Word shouted at us in order to hear it and live it. Every confirmed Catholic should know that it is their obligation to bring the word of the Lord to the entire world, just as it was for the first disciples. We are now starting to realize that.

Jesus is my Lord but the way to salvation is more than just acknowledging that. Jesus wants two things from us, Love and Obedience. One without the other will not get us to heaven. Just stating that Jesus is your Lord is not the deciding factor. Jesus also said that many who call him Lord will not see his heavenly kingdom. Your friend needs to go read about that.

dominicansoul
Posted

Totally agree with Deb's post!

You can also tell your friend (in a very charitable way) that although most Catholics don't memorize bible verses, we do receive Holy Scripture everyday at Mass. Explain the Mass to her, that it is a model of the Bible itself in that we have the Word first and then the Word made Flesh in the second part. Sort of how the Bible is structured, with the Old Covenant of the Word in the Old Testament, and the New Covenant, Jesus, God made Flesh in the New Testament!

Tell her Catholics have an intimate relationship with Jesus in that we eat His Flesh and drink His Blood (you can't get any closer than that!)

Explain to her some verses from St. Paul, especially since it is his year! The verses that come to mind is the one in which St. Paul explains we need to make up for what is lacking in the sufferings of Christ. What does that mean? It means Christ did it all for us, yes, but being the Loving and Awesome God He is, He decided there would be a way for His children to take part in the Redemptive suffering He had on the cross! Our sufferings are combined to His sufferings on the Cross...so as He was dying for us....here we are centuries later, able to lift up all the sufferings we encounter in our daily lives to Him and His Ultimate Sacrifice on the Cross. We become part of this beautiful act of Love of Our Savior and our King!

Also, those verses in which St. Paul speaks of this life as a race to be won. And also the verses where he states, only by the Grace of God goes he, and the verses where he points out he's living out his salvation each day with fear and trembling....all these verses point to something more than just speaking some magic formula that automatically saves us....they all speak of a TRUE relationship with Jesus Christ, where we give and not just receive...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...