Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

School Boys Given Detention For Not Praying To Allah


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote]By Nick Britten Last Updated: 12:37AM BST 05/07/2008

It was claimed that the boys, from a year seven class of 11 and 12-year-olds, were given detention after refusing to take part in a practical demonstration of how Allah is worshipped. Yesterday parents accused the school of breaching their human rights by forcing them to take part in the exercise.

One, Sharon Luinen, said: "This isn't right, it's taking things too far. I understand that they have to learn about other religions. I can live with that but it is taking it a step too far to be punished because they wouldn't join in Muslim prayer.

"Making them pray to Allah, who isn't who they worship, is wrong and what got me is that they were told they were being disrespectful." Another parent Karen Williams, 38, whose 12-year-old daughter is a classmate of the boys, said: "I am absolutely furious my daughter was made to take part in it and I don't find it acceptable.

"The teacher had gone into the class and made them watch a short film and then said 'we are now going out to pray to Allah'.

"Then two boys got detention and all the other children missed their refreshments' break."

She added: "Not only was it forced upon them, my daughter was told off for not doing it right.

"They'd never done it before and they were supposed to do it in another language."

She said the pupils were asked if they had water on them, and when one girl produced a bottle, the teacher began washing her feet with it.

Her husband Keith, 44, a painter and decorator, said: "The school is wonderful but this one teacher has made a major mistake. It seems to be happening throughout society. People think they can ride roughshod over our beliefs and the way we live."

The alleged incident, at the Alsager school, one of Cheshire's top performing schools, happened on Tuesday afternoon. The teacher, Alison Phillips, the school's subject leader in RE, is understood to be staying away from the school until the furore dies down, although she has not been suspended.

She is said to have got prayer mats out of the cupboard and also asked children to wear Islamic headdresses.

Deputy headmaster Keith Plant said: "I have spoken to the teacher and she has articulately given me her version of events."

Sources at the school said the incident could have been down to Miss Phillips instigating a role play and not properly briefing the pupils, all aged around 12, what she was doing.

A spokesman for Cheshire County Council said they were investigating. He added: "The headteacher contacted the authority immediately complaints were received. Enquiries are being made into the circumstances as a matter of urgency and all parents will be informed accordingly.

"Educating children in the beliefs of different faiths is part of Cheshire's diversity curriculum on the basis that knowledge is, of course, is essential to understanding.

"We accept that such teaching has to be conducted with commonsense and sensitivity."[/quote][url="http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2247388/Schoolboys-disciplined-for-%27refusing-to-pray-to-Allah%27.html"]http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2247388/Sc...o-Allah%27.html[/url]



It is also on other sites as well :ohno: This is not producing awareness in other religions...it is totally different.

Meg

Posted

i) Is this an Islamic private school?

ii) Is the teacher Muslim?

dominicansoul
Posted

ecumenism gone way too far!!!

Posted

at my school we had to "avoid" praying openly so as to not get detention....

dominicansoul
Posted

[quote name='corban711' post='1592071' date='Jul 5 2008, 12:55 PM']at my school we had to "avoid" praying openly so as to not get detention....[/quote]

wow.

Madame Vengier
Posted

Yet again, I knew this was the UK before I even click on it.

Madame Vengier
Posted (edited)

[quote]Her husband Keith, 44, a painter and decorator, said: "The school is wonderful but this one teacher has made a major mistake. It seems to be happening throughout society. People think they can ride roughshod over our beliefs and the way we live."[/quote]

Get used to it, Keith. This is what England is now. And no one is fighting it--rather, they're kow-towing to it.

[quote]Deputy headmaster Keith Plant said: "I have spoken to the teacher and she has articulately given me her version of events."[/quote]

Sure. And the teacher's version will be accepted over the students and the parents, and the teacher will only receive "a talking-to". Just wait and see. There will be no real condemnation for this outrageous sequence of events that NEVER should have happened.

Edited by Madame Vengier
Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='corban711' post='1592071' date='Jul 5 2008, 12:55 PM']at my school we had to "avoid" praying openly so as to not get detention....[/quote]


I would rather my children be told NOT to pray openly (in a public school) than to be FORCED to pray to a false god of a false religion and its false prophet in a language where they don't even understand WHAT they are being forced to pray, whilst having their feet washed and their heads covered.

Huh-uh, no way.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='picchick' post='1592013' date='Jul 5 2008, 12:06 PM'][url="http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2247388/Schoolboys-disciplined-for-%27refusing-to-pray-to-Allah%27.html"]http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2247388/Sc...o-Allah%27.html[/url]
It is also on other sites as well :ohno: This is not producing awareness in other religions...it is totally different.

Meg[/quote]


Oh, you can be certain they aren't teaching kids about the Rosary or the Talmud.

There have been numerous stories about non-Muslim schools allowing teachers to hold classes and workshops to teach kids about Islam, under the false pretense of "combatting Islamophobia and misunderstandings".

Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1592018' date='Jul 5 2008, 01:12 PM']i) Is this an Islamic private school?

ii) Is the teacher Muslim?[/quote]

i) It is not an islamic private school...it would have been acceptable. The teacher was teaching religious awareness.

ii) I don't know.
[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1592080' date='Jul 5 2008, 01:59 PM']Sure. And the teacher's version will be accepted over the students and the parents, and the teacher will only receive "a talking-to". Just wait and see. There will be no real condemnation for this outrageous sequence of events that NEVER should have happened.[/quote]

Agreed. The teacher is always defended. It is the system really because if the school does not stand by their teachers, they get a bad rap...

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1592096' date='Jul 5 2008, 02:07 PM']Oh, you can be certain they aren't teaching kids about the Rosary or the Talmud.[/quote]

Totally true. Even in my Catholic University this was true. We had to be careful about showing that we Catholic. I was even told that I needed to be careful when I was praying my breviery in class before it started. But we can share our chapel so that they could pray and we had to be accepting of them :ohno:

Meg

homeschoolmom
Posted
:maddest:
Posted

I should have clarified. I don't mind that the muslims at my university prayed. I didn't mind learning about their religion. However, it seemed one sided. They could not strive to learn about us.

Our Chapel had to have Jesus in a separate room and curtains to cover the statues and the stained glass and removable chairs. There were other locations that they could have gone to pray. I actually had an argument with a guy on campus who was Catholic about this. He didn't like me too well after that. He took it as I didn't want them on campus at all and that I was anti-muslim. As much as I tried to say, that it was fine that they are here and great that they are here, they should not be able to use our chapel where we have to accomodate and shove Jesus, our cornerstone out. They can either fund to build something on campus for themselves or use another room that is has an open floor space area.

Meg

CatherineM
Posted

When we were in 5th grade, our religious education teacher, a Carmelite nun, had us celebrate and learn about the Jewish holidays as the year went on. I don't remember anyone having a problem with it. Of course playing with a draydel and eating chocolate coins isn't quite like praying in a different way than we are comfortable doing. Some of the parents might have complained, but I don't remember there being any trouble.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1592137' date='Jul 5 2008, 02:46 PM']When we were in 5th grade, our religious education teacher, a Carmelite nun, had us celebrate and learn about the Jewish holidays as the year went on. I don't remember anyone having a problem with it. Of course playing with a draydel and eating chocolate coins isn't quite like praying in a different way than we are comfortable doing. Some of the parents might have complained, but I don't remember there being any trouble.[/quote]

I remember learning about Jewish holidays as well and playing draydel. But that wasn't praying like you said.

Posted

Makes me think of [url="http://www.amazon.com/Caliphate-Tom-Kratman/dp/1416555455"]Caliphate[/url]. Except Europe isn't part of a Pan-Islamic Empire, nor is the USA absorbing countries via nuking them. Really makes me think of the flashbacks though, to when Europe is kow-towing more and more to radical immigrants.

Posted

[quote name='dominicansoul' post='1592020' date='Jul 5 2008, 11:12 AM']ecumenism gone way too far!!![/quote]
The term "ecumenism" really only applies to inter-Christian dialogue.

Madame Vengier
Posted

I started a new thread on the topic of Muslim crime in the UK, for anyone who is interested. There are several good links there which will take you to various news stories of Muslim youth carrying out "street jihad" all over Britain. In addition there is a link to some news stories of how UK is having a hard time dealing with Muslims breaking the law in hospitals:

[url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=82338"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=82338[/url]

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='BG45' post='1592155' date='Jul 5 2008, 02:09 PM']Makes me think of [url="http://www.amazon.com/Caliphate-Tom-Kratman/dp/1416555455"]Caliphate[/url]. Except Europe isn't part of a Pan-Islamic Empire, nor is the USA absorbing countries via nuking them. Really makes me think of the flashbacks though, to when Europe is kow-towing more and more to radical immigrants.[/quote]


The Caliphate is coming. In any case Islam will take Europe before it takes the US because it has a head-start with Europe. What we are seeing in, for example, the UK has already been going on for at least a couple of decades. Europe has "jokingly" been referred to as "Eurabia" for at least the past 20-25 years. And not without good cause.

America will be a tougher nut to crack because we Americans love our freedom so much and we deeply value our individuality, plus there are still many Americans of all ethnicities who will not give up their own religious values and beliefs so easily. However, Islam has begun its advancement here too already. Hopefully, with enough education and information-sharing we can learn from what is happening in Europe and Africa, and be in a position to put our foot down before it takes hold on our shores. Because if Islam wins Europe and then America, Far East Asia follows next. And then that's it, folks.

puellapaschalis
Posted
:madrant:

Although I must point out that contrary to what was said above, it's actually far more likely that the child gets the benefit of the doubt in disputes. The school and public will assume that the teacher is in the wrong and he can expect various disciplinary actions; the child and his family will revel in the media attention. It's far from unheard of that an innocent teacher's life and career has been ruined by a pupil lying.

I'm not saying this is what's happened here. But it's the norm.
Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='picchick' post='1592128' date='Jul 5 2008, 01:32 PM']I should have clarified. I don't mind that the muslims at my university prayed. I didn't mind learning about their religion. However, it seemed one sided. They could not strive to learn about us.[/quote]

Exactly. And they never will. The best way to enter into a good, fruitful dialogue with Muslims is to reach them one-on-one, and to never discuss Islam. Only talk about the wonderful things about YOUR religion and how happy and healthy it makes you feel, and all the benefits it brings to your life and your relationships. Do not try to have conversations with them where you are comparing the two. They won't stand for it. They are inculcated with the belief that Islam is supreme and Islam has a right to the whole earth, "from the very top of every mountain, to the very bottom of every valley". So they have NO REASON (in their thinking) to "strive to learn from us" whatsoever. We are no match for this kind of brain-washing. Stick to raving joyfully about what you know and love, without making comparisons, and that will work wonders.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...