Lisieux Flower Posted July 7, 2008 Posted July 7, 2008 I wikipedia-ed the movie because I completely forgot what it was about, and now I remember... its sooo sad but there are some graphic scenes, right? I think I'm going to rewatch this movie because I remember it being really really good. I like movies that make me cry.
kujo Posted July 7, 2008 Author Posted July 7, 2008 [quote name='Lisieux Flower' post='1593848' date='Jul 7 2008, 03:35 PM']I wikipedia-ed the movie because I completely forgot what it was about, and now I remember... its sooo sad but there are some graphic scenes, right? I think I'm going to rewatch this movie because I remember it being really really good. I like movies that make me cry. [/quote] Yeah, the whole movie has some serious moral corruption, including a storyline involving a grown man lusting after a high school age girl. There's some nudity as well...
Madame Vengier Posted July 8, 2008 Posted July 8, 2008 [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1593789' date='Jul 7 2008, 12:52 PM']I never watched it. I noticed the USCCB gave it an "O" rating, which convinced me it wasn't really worth my time...[/quote] [mod]Catholic vs Catholic Debate A post or comment that results in doctrinal debates that might cause scandal among the faithful. [b]*Effective immediately, any negative criticism of religious or the current Magisterium will result in deletion, and a warning from the moderators.[/b] This includes but is not limited to criticism of the Novus Ordo mass and/or our Holy Father. - Lil Red [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s=&showtopic=51798&view=findpost&p=972833"]See also d.USt's post on religious.[/url][/mod] I distinctly remember seeing AB and afterwards seeing the O rating from USCCB (it was in the local Catholic newspaper). To this day I will never understand what is "morally objectionable" about this movie. It only reinforces my belief that the average Christian doesn't know how to watch a movie as a critical thinker, and only knows how to look for sin and then condemn it and every human involved. Granted, the married husband in the movie develops a disordered attraction to the a teenage neighbor and he almost acts on it. But he doesn't act on it. And it's not just a salacious attraction. The man has a real problem that many married men encounter when their marriages become cold and distant. The wife certainly has her issues as well. What I liked about the movie is the arc of grace, the fall, sin, and finally redemption. More than anything I would call this very close to being a real Catholic movie. I was stunned how the Christian community castigated this movie. Everything this movie was about went right over their heads.
Madame Vengier Posted July 8, 2008 Posted July 8, 2008 [quote name='Lisieux Flower' post='1593848' date='Jul 7 2008, 01:35 PM']I wikipedia-ed the movie because I completely forgot what it was about, and now I remember... its sooo sad but there are some graphic scenes, right? I think I'm going to rewatch this movie because I remember it being really really good. I like movies that make me cry. [/quote] I don't remember any graphic scenes. There's one brief topless scene involving a teenage girl, but I would hardly call that graphic. Oh wait, there are TWO topless scenes involving teenage girls. It doesn't bother me personally--I don't like it--but it doesn't make me hate the movie. These scenes were not in the context of sex scenes, so I was more liberal about it. Sex scenes are out of the question, though.
kujo Posted July 8, 2008 Author Posted July 8, 2008 [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1594839' date='Jul 8 2008, 08:34 AM'][mod]Catholic vs Catholic Debate A post or comment that results in doctrinal debates that might cause scandal among the faithful. [b]*Effective immediately, any negative criticism of religious or the current Magisterium will result in deletion, and a warning from the moderators.[/b] This includes but is not limited to criticism of the Novus Ordo mass and/or our Holy Father. - Lil Red [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s=&showtopic=51798&view=findpost&p=972833"]See also d.USt's post on religious.[/url][/mod] I distinctly remember seeing AB and afterwards seeing the O rating from USCCB (it was in the local Catholic newspaper). To this day I will never understand what is "morally objectionable" about this movie. It only reinforces my belief that the average Christian doesn't know how to watch a movie as a critical thinker, and only knows how to look for sin and then condemn it and every human involved. Granted, the married husband in the movie develops a disordered attraction to the a teenage neighbor and he almost acts on it. But he doesn't act on it. And it's not just a salacious attraction. The man has a real problem that many married men encounter when their marriages become cold and distant. The wife certainly has her issues as well. What I liked about the movie is the arc of grace, the fall, sin, and finally redemption. More than anything I would call this very close to being a real Catholic movie. I was stunned how the Christian community castigated this movie. Everything this movie was about went right over their heads.[/quote] I generally agree with your point of view here, MV, despite the fact that you won't see this. I think the objection that people have to this movie is that it appears to accept the father's disordered attraction to the girl, his use of pot, his verbal outbursts towards his wife and daughter, etc. While I agree that the redemption story is beautifully tragic, I would stop short of calling this a "Catholic movie." But yeah...I'm with you about 80%, particularly about the USCCB. I mean, I first read their review of [u]Brokeback Mountain[/u] and it was given an L. Then, when it was released nationally, it was given an O. [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1594841' date='Jul 8 2008, 08:37 AM']I don't remember any graphic scenes. There's one brief topless scene involving a teenage girl, but I would hardly call that graphic. Oh wait, there are TWO topless scenes involving teenage girls. It doesn't bother me personally--I don't like it--but it doesn't make me hate the movie. These scenes were not in the context of sex scenes, so I was more liberal about it. Sex scenes are out of the question, though.[/quote] I think that the first topless scene was acceptable, but the second involved [spoiler]what was going to be a "sex scene" before she told he was a virgin. It was bizzare...and kind of reminded me of a father changing his daughter's diaper. Creeped me out a bit.[/spoiler] (***SPOILER ALERT***)
Jaime Posted July 8, 2008 Posted July 8, 2008 [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1594839' date='Jul 8 2008, 07:34 AM'][mod]Catholic vs Catholic Debate A post or comment that results in doctrinal debates that might cause scandal among the faithful. [b]*Effective immediately, any negative criticism of religious or the current Magisterium will result in deletion, and a warning from the moderators.[/b] This includes but is not limited to criticism of the Novus Ordo mass and/or our Holy Father. - Lil Red [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s=&showtopic=51798&view=findpost&p=972833"]See also d.USt's post on religious.[/url][/mod][/quote] That is not true and completely out of line. You're kinda new to these parts but we don't criticize the bishops
dominicansoul Posted July 10, 2008 Posted July 10, 2008 I truly believe as a Dominican and devout Roman Catholic, that I should try as best I can to watch movies with overall decency that will prove to be efficacious to me. As far as "critical thinking" or viewing movies as an art form, I could never go for this movie as "art." I have not watched it, because after reading the plot and seeing some of the scenes, I just couldn't continue. I think people soak up media like a sponge. I didn't want some of these scenes stuck in my head. I also think we have come so far to accept immoral behaviors on the screen because we have become so numb and it just doesn't shock us anymore. It does become a part of our observations of real life. As much as we think it doesn't, movies do have an affect on us. That being said, I know I watch way too many things on television that can harm me, and listen to bad music, too. Am I being paranoid? Am I ruining all my fun? I don't think so. When I entered the convent, all "entertainment" as far as watching television and listening to the radio were no longer in our control. Only very rarely did we watch television. We watched a lot of videos of some movies, like "The Reluctant Saint" and even "The Princess Bride!" We always watched the Super Bowl, but Mother Superior made us turn the television off at every commercial break! Because she was protecting us from the immorality and sexually saturated society we live in... Does this make me a prude? To the world, probably...to all of you my brothers and sisters on Phatmass....I hope you can relate!
kujo Posted July 10, 2008 Author Posted July 10, 2008 [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1596595' date='Jul 9 2008, 11:36 PM']I truly believe as a Dominican and devout Roman Catholic, that I should try as best I can to watch movies with overall decency that will prove to be efficacious to me. As far as "critical thinking" or viewing movies as an art form, I could never go for this movie as "art." I have not watched it, because after reading the plot and seeing some of the scenes, I just couldn't continue. I think people soak up media like a sponge. I didn't want some of these scenes stuck in my head. I also think we have come so far to accept immoral behaviors on the screen because we have become so numb and it just doesn't shock us anymore. It does become a part of our observations of real life. As much as we think it doesn't, movies do have an affect on us. That being said, I know I watch way too many things on television that can harm me, and listen to bad music, too. Am I being paranoid? Am I ruining all my fun? I don't think so. When I entered the convent, all "entertainment" as far as watching television and listening to the radio were no longer in our control. Only very rarely did we watch television. We watched a lot of videos of some movies, like "The Reluctant Saint" and even "The Princess Bride!" We always watched the Super Bowl, but Mother Superior made us turn the television off at every commercial break! Because she was protecting us from the immorality and sexually saturated society we live in... Does this make me a prude? To the world, probably...to all of you my brothers and sisters on Phatmass....I hope you can relate! [/quote] You totally rock!!!
rhetoricfemme Posted July 10, 2008 Posted July 10, 2008 [quote name='kujo' post='1595287' date='Jul 8 2008, 01:39 PM']I think the objection that people have to this movie is that it appears to accept the father's disordered attraction to the girl, his use of pot, his verbal outbursts towards his wife and daughter, etc.[/quote] I agree with what you say, Kujo. The film isn't condoning these acts, it's simply telling a story. I can entirely understand folks not wanting to watch something because they wish not to put themselves in a position of corruption or temptation. But even then, the opinion can still be held that there is something to be learned from the movie. Personally, I loved this American Beauty It's tragic, but it's also an honest look at these characters' lives and it sugarcoats nothing. The bold use of red was really interesting to me, as was the whole concept of color, but the red was great. And yeah, the ending is sad, but [spoiler]had the father died at any other point, he wouldn't have reached that moment of peace and clarity that he had at the end. Still, sad to think he could've started over with a more positive disposition...[/spoiler] Also, for anyone who did like American Beauty, I highly recommend [url="http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0119349/"]The Ice Storm[/url]. I saw this after American Beauty, and loved it even more.
JoeyP Posted July 10, 2008 Posted July 10, 2008 [quote name='Alycin' post='1593141' date='Jul 6 2008, 10:43 PM']I know that most people either love it or hate it... and then there's the group that "don't get it." lol. I am not really surprised that a lot of people here hate it... but it's one of my favorite movies. I love Thora Birch.[/quote] One of my favorites also!!!
Seven77 Posted July 14, 2008 Posted July 14, 2008 USCCB 'O' rating is on point. Heck yeah its sad...nothing short of depressing. The movie does indeed condone and glorify the culture of death---Spacey's character was at peace BECAUSE he knew he could successfully have sex with a teenager. The daughter runs off with a pyscho nudist. Ain't nothing beautiful about this movie. Should be called American Ugly.
kujo Posted July 15, 2008 Author Posted July 15, 2008 [quote name='Seven77' post='1600044' date='Jul 14 2008, 06:33 PM']USCCB 'O' rating is on point. Heck yeah its sad...nothing short of depressing. The movie does indeed condone and glorify the culture of death---Spacey's character was at peace BECAUSE he knew he could successfully have sex with a teenager. The daughter runs off with a pyscho nudist. Ain't nothing beautiful about this movie. Should be called American Ugly.[/quote] A "psycho nudist?" Did you possibly mean the bland drug-dealer-voyeur? The least you could do is accurately describe the characters. And he was "at peace" because he realized how wrong that desire was and how his depression and numbness had obscured his vision and caused him to miss out on the "beauty" in his life: his wife, his daughter, his job. The everyday tasks we all take for granted.
tinytherese Posted July 20, 2008 Posted July 20, 2008 Here's a review of the film from a Catholic perspective. The critic is a solid Catholic that still keeps the art of films in mind. www.decentfilms.com/sections/reviews/americanbeauty.html
Madame Vengier Posted July 21, 2008 Posted July 21, 2008 [quote name='Seven77' post='1600044' date='Jul 14 2008, 04:33 PM']USCCB 'O' rating is on point. Heck yeah its sad...nothing short of depressing. The movie does indeed condone and glorify the culture of death---Spacey's character was at peace BECAUSE he knew he could successfully have sex with a teenager. The daughter runs off with a pyscho nudist. Ain't nothing beautiful about this movie. Should be called American Ugly.[/quote] What?? Spacey's character certainly was NOT "at peace". The entire movie hinges upon this one single fact. He was not at peace. He was a lonely man who was tormented by his own bad decisions. When he realized that and wanted to change it was too late. He did not have sex with the teenage girl because at the last moment he realized how low he had fallen and how indecent this all was.
kujo Posted July 21, 2008 Author Posted July 21, 2008 [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1604391' date='Jul 21 2008, 10:34 AM']What?? Spacey's character certainly was NOT "at peace". The entire movie hinges upon this one single fact. He was not at peace. He was a lonely man who was tormented by his own bad decisions. When he realized that and wanted to change it was too late. He did not have sex with the teenage girl because at the last moment he realized how low he had fallen and how indecent this all was.[/quote] She is right.
Seven77 Posted July 21, 2008 Posted July 21, 2008 [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1604391' date='Jul 21 2008, 08:34 AM']What?? Spacey's character certainly was NOT "at peace". The entire movie hinges upon this one single fact. He was not at peace. He was a lonely man who was tormented by his own bad decisions. When he realized that and wanted to change it was too late. He did not have sex with the teenage girl because at the last moment he realized how low he had fallen and how indecent this all was.[/quote] i guess so... but i don't remember thinking that he thought it was indecent... i remember thinking that he was thrilled to see how far he could go-- and did not do anything merely because she was a virgin and did not want to. and that was it--- but it could have been my general repulsion with the movie making me that scene differently. i do agree with Greydanus though.
Madame Vengier Posted July 22, 2008 Posted July 22, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Seven77' post='1604701' date='Jul 21 2008, 05:00 PM']i guess so... but i don't remember thinking that he thought it was indecent... i remember thinking that he was thrilled to see how far he could go-- and did not do anything merely because she was a virgin and did not want to. and that was it--- but it could have been my general repulsion with the movie making me that scene differently. i do agree with Greydanus though.[/quote] Well, none of us condoned the fact that some of the themes are repulsive. We agree on that. But sin is respulsive. Dysfunction is repulsive. You and I do things all the time that are repulsive to God. Where's our self-righteous indignation when we do personal repulsive things that only God can see? But we judge a movie--which is simply lifting the veil of hidden family dysfunction and saying "look how repulsive it is and look how much tragedy it brings", a movie which does not glorify sin but rather makes it look exactly like what it is: repugnant, pathetic, demeaning, shameful and embarassing--we judge a movie for showing us how repulsive and destructive hidden sin can be. He stopped short of having sex with this girl because her virginity contrasted sharply with his own uncleaness. Suddenly, when he realized she was a virgin he saw clearly what impact his actions would have. And he stopped. Edited July 22, 2008 by Madame Vengier
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now