Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Archaeology cat
Posted

From what you wrote, it sounds like you handled it very well, and I don't think you were wrong in doing that.

Posted

i'm in agreement with the others here. as long as you were not rude about it, i think you are more than ok...i think you were right to do so :)

Caramelonion
Posted

I think you did the right thing...and that grandmother should have been grateful for the information. If it had been me, I would have thanked you!

Posted

Thank you all for your kind words. This really makes my feel better. I did use kind words and only expressed my confussion on feeling angry to erik (Knightec). He also said that I did the right thing....


:console:

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1593246' date='Jul 6 2008, 10:26 PM']This whole "leave it up to the priest" thing doesn't actually work unless he actually knows... they most likely received from an EMHC[/quote]
I don't think it's fair to say that they received because they went to an EMHC and not a priest. Not all EMHCs are poorly trained or flippant. For all we know the children could have gone to the priest. And even if such was not the case this time, it is possible that this happens on a daily or weekly basis. Some parishes are quite large and have many visitors each week. I dare say it is near impossible (except by the grace of God) to know every person who is or is not to receive.

I've seen on MANY occasions persons who should not be receiving, receive. I trust that the priest not only knows of the situation (state of grave sin) but also that he has made a pastoral decision to do what he feels the Holy Spirit is guiding him to do. I do not know [b]why[/b] but I do know it's none of my business.


As to the question of the OP, I would say what one early poster said. If you felt compelled by the Spirit to say something, good for you. As long as we remain prayerful in our Christian correction, I believe it's perfectly alright to say something. Ignorance is not bliss. We are responsible, as members of the body of Christ, to preserve the sanctity of the sacrament. If the decision to speak up weighs heavy on your heart, talk to your priest about it. If your anger was ongoing and sinful, confess it.



Just my thoughts. :)

Posted

I agree with the others that you did the right thing. The woman needed to be informed, and you were able to do it in a kind manner.

Guest deusmax
Posted

"Speak the truth in love" is the best motto I have found.

For some reason, people often feel judged by me even when I don't think I'm being judgmental!! (Hmmm self-examination) People sometimes need correction, but if you can't correct in love, but have to do it in anger, then perhaps it's not the Holy Spirit prompting.

You don't say how she responded, but from your own feelings I would guess it didn't go so well.
"I don't mean to be rude, but..." can help buffer a critical statement.

This is a really good issue because don't we want "visitors" at church? Every Catholic needs a response!

One possibility:

"Hi, I haven't seen you before, are you a visitor?"
"Ah! well, nice to have you here. I kind of guessed you might be a visitor because your girls didn't seem to know what to do. We don't actually have open communion here at this church. There's a section here in the Missalette about Catholic guidelines for communion. But if you are interested, and want to come back, we could talk to the priest about it. Where are you from?"

Definitely treating offenses as though they were innocent errors and not deliberate blasphemies--i.e., being sympathetic, not angry-- is helpful. No point in offending people unnecessarily.

Posted

[quote name='The one pump wonder' post='1593260' date='Jul 6 2008, 11:40 PM']you know what makes me angry ????????

When a person recieves communion then breaks it and gives it to a small boy next to her every sunday at mass. Why doesnt the boy receive directly from minister????[/quote]

A couple of questions, is the boy Roman Rite or Eastern Rite? If the child is younger than say age 7 or 8 and has not received First Communion and is part of the Roman Rite, then no he should not be receiving. If the child is Eastern Rite and looks or is younger than 7 or 8 it could be because the priest will not let the child receive even though he has received since his baptism. I've heard of a few cases where Roman Rite priests have refused to give Eastern Rite children the Eucharist because of their age. This could be the case here, but I would really hope not. I've heard of Eastern Rite parents receiving and breaking the Eucharist to share with their children. Regardless, the lady should not be breaking the Eucharist it could cause particles to go everywhere. I would possibly mention something to your priest.

Posted

I say you did exactly the right thing. We are to defend our faith and certainly the Eucharist. You did it in a nice, informative way and as she probably knows better anyway, it is nice to give her a reminder. Maybe it will make her think a little about the Eucharist itself.

Posted

great responses!

fury, shouting, rudeness, snapping---that is mean. and you don't look mean to me

Posted (edited)

I thought to myself really hard how I was going to make the correction.

I introduced myself, welcomed her to our church first ,and asked if she was a new member. Then I asked her if her granddaughters had made their first communion....

I let her know that my sons had made theirs and my daughters had not.... But we go as a family up to the alter and my boys and I receive communion and my girls get a blessing every Sunday.

She thanked me for the information and I am not sure that she was or was not upset. B

Does that make sense?

Edited by Faith 1st
Lisieux Flower
Posted

You did a great job :) it's important to lovingly and kindly let people know if they're disrespecting the Eucharist. Lots of props to you!

Noel's angel
Posted

Yeah, I'd actually like to say well done! I don't think I would have had the courage to say something, nevermind to say it in such a diplomatic way.

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1594366' date='Jul 8 2008, 01:03 AM']Yeah, I'd actually like to say well done! I don't think I would have had the courage to say something, nevermind to say it in such a diplomatic way.[/quote]
Same here.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...