Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Today at work, one of my coworkers (who is a Buddhist) claimed that the Catholic Church has a canonized saint who is actually Buddhist. Didn't make any sense to me whatsoever, considering it's contradictory to a canonized saint stands for. I did find this though while searching in google: [url="http://terry58.stblogs.com/2007/11/27/st-buddha/"]St. Buddha?[/url]

Your thoughts?

aalpha1989
Posted

Don't think so. Not that Buddha couldn't be in heaven, but I don't think the Church would claim that Buddha was in heaven. The official teaching is that one must be baptized and that Jesus is "the Way, the Truth, and the Life". Buddha could have gotten in by baptism of desire, but honestly I don't think the Church would canonize a non-Christian.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='aalpha1989' post='1595770' date='Jul 9 2008, 01:08 AM']Don't think so. Not that Buddha couldn't be in heaven, but I don't think the Church would claim that Buddha was in heaven. The official teaching is that one must be baptized and that Jesus is "the Way, the Truth, and the Life". Buddha could have gotten in by baptism of desire, but honestly I don't think the Church would canonize a non-Christian.[/quote]


Bhudda pre-dates the birth of Christ, so I don't think baptism by desire was an option.

This person is obviously mistaken.

Posted

He's not in the Byzantine liturgical calendar. :P

aalpha1989
Posted

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1595771' date='Jul 9 2008, 02:14 AM']Bhudda pre-dates the birth of Christ, so I don't think baptism by desire was an option.

This person is obviously mistaken.[/quote]


Gentiles pre-Christianity couldn't be baptized by desire? I guess a more appropriate term would be "circumcized by desire", as baptism replaced circumcision, but still... heaven's open to them, isn't it?

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='aalpha1989' post='1595776' date='Jul 9 2008, 01:22 AM']Gentiles pre-Christianity couldn't be baptized by desire? I guess a more appropriate term would be "circumcized by desire", as baptism replaced circumcision, but still... heaven's open to them, isn't it?[/quote]

Baptism didn't exist yet, so obviously someone couldn't have baptism by desire.

Doesn't Dante talk about the noble souls who couldn't go into heaven pre-Christianity, so they were essentially in a type of state of happiness but not heaven, until Jesus released them? Folks like Aristotle would have been in this group. Anyway, maybe Siddhartha Gautama was among them. I dunno.

Maximilianus
Posted

This sounds like one of those sea stories like Pope Joan.

aalpha1989
Posted

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1595778' date='Jul 9 2008, 02:28 AM']Baptism didn't exist yet, so obviously someone couldn't have baptism by desire.

Doesn't Dante talk about the noble souls who couldn't go into heaven pre-Christianity, so they were essentially in a type of state of happiness but not heaven, until Jesus released them? Folks like Aristotle would have been in this group. Anyway, maybe Siddhartha Gautama was among them. I dunno.[/quote]


Yeah, I don't know either. But then to get into heaven even after Jesus "releases them" they'd have to go through Him, i.e. baptism. Maybe their baptism is post mortum. (If I'm wandering into some heretical waters here let me know, because I certainly don't mean to)

Fr. Fessio at Ave Maria says that the souls which died before Christ were treated in the same way as the souls which died after Him because of the way that heaven and hell transcend time. He would say that they go either to heaven, hell, or purgatory when they die, and they do not have to "wait" for the rest of the souls such as you or I to die and go to heaven, they just see us there because heaven is timeless. Personally I don't know about that, but it is the only explanation I have heard which seems to answer all my questions... Maybe it's just a mystery? :idontknow:

Posted

aren't buddhists atheists? :huh:

Posted

i was pretty sure that one can be both Christian and Buddhist without conflict. if you dont think so feel free to let me know.

when i read the buddhist "text" ,cant remember its name now maybe "the way of the buddha" but sort of the equivalent of the bible, i dont remember it making any claims as to what/who created the earth, sky and everything.

aalpha1989
Posted

[quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1595811' date='Jul 9 2008, 04:05 AM']i was pretty sure that one can be both Christian and Buddhist without conflict. if you dont think so feel free to let me know.

when i read the buddhist "text" ,cant remember its name now maybe "the way of the buddha" but sort of the equivalent of the bible, i dont remember it making any claims as to what/who created the earth, sky and everything.[/quote]

I think that according to buddhist teachings one can be a Christian and a buddhist, but according to Catholic (Christian) teachings one cannot be a buddhist and a Christian.

I'm pretty sure about the Catholic teachings, but as far as buddhist teachings I'm not sure, so it could be that buddhists don't believe one can be Christian as well. Anyway I guess even if buddhists think you can be both and Christians teach that you can't, then you can't anyway.

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='aalpha1989' post='1595770' date='Jul 9 2008, 01:08 AM']Don't think so. Not that Buddha couldn't be in heaven, but I don't think the Church would claim that Buddha was in heaven. The official teaching is that one must be baptized and that Jesus is "the Way, the Truth, and the Life". Buddha could have gotten in by baptism of desire, but honestly I don't think the Church would canonize a non-Christian.[/quote]

I'm not sure if they would officially canonize any of them (at least not yet) but the idea that there can be saints who were from other faiths doesn't seem to be so far off. I can't remember off top of my head exactly, but I think ut unum sint might briefly give reference to the idea, whether or not its infallible is up for ya'll to argue. I wouldn't touch that with a 50ft pole.

Posted

[quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1595811' date='Jul 9 2008, 02:05 AM']i was pretty sure that one can be both Christian and Buddhist without conflict. if you dont think so feel free to let me know.[/quote]
i doubt that unless someone can show me some sort of document that says one can be catholic and buddhist.

aalpha1989
Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1595813' date='Jul 9 2008, 04:09 AM']I'm not sure if they would officially canonize any of them (at least not yet) but the idea that there can be saints who were from other faiths doesn't seem to be so far off. I can't remember off top of my head exactly, but I think ut unum sint might briefly give reference to the idea, whether or not its infallible is up for ya'll to argue. I wouldn't touch that with a 50ft pole.[/quote]


Well the Church teaches that people of other faiths can enter Heaven, and therefore can be saints (with a little "s"), but I really don't think the Church would [i]ever[/i] canonize them. They could therefore never be Saints with a big "S". Peter Kreeft is awesome in his book "Ecumenical Jihad". Which sorta relates.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='aalpha1989' post='1595812' date='Jul 9 2008, 03:09 AM']I think that according to buddhist teachings one can be a Christian and a buddhist, but according to Catholic (Christian) teachings one cannot be a buddhist and a Christian.

I'm pretty sure about the Catholic teachings, but as far as buddhist teachings I'm not sure, so it could be that buddhists don't believe one can be Christian as well. Anyway I guess even if buddhists think you can be both and Christians teach that you can't, then you can't anyway.[/quote]


Although there are certainly important similarities, they certainly have just as many conflicting ideas. Actually, Buddhism is not even truly a religion--it is more like a spiritual philosophy or a spiritual path.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1595811' date='Jul 9 2008, 03:05 AM']i was pretty sure that one can be both Christian and Buddhist without conflict. if you dont think so feel free to let me know.[/quote]

No, of course it's not possible.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='doe-jo' post='1595806' date='Jul 9 2008, 02:59 AM']aren't buddhists atheists? :huh:[/quote]


There's some conflict with this because some people will argue that they are and some will argue that they are not. I am somewhere in the middle: they DO acknowledge some kind of higher power, a loving and compassionate force or presence at work in the universe, but they don't acknowledge this as God.

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='aalpha1989' post='1595816' date='Jul 9 2008, 03:13 AM']Well the Church teaches that people of other faiths can enter Heaven, and therefore can be saints (with a little "s"), but I really don't think the Church would [i]ever[/i] canonize them. They could therefore never be Saints with a big "S". Peter Kreeft is awesome in his book "Ecumenical Jihad". Which sorta relates.[/quote]

possibly. This being the case (if it is such, won't get into that here), it doesn't seem too far a jump to go from saying someone is a saint because they are in heaven, and then canonizing such a person.

aalpha1989
Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1595826' date='Jul 9 2008, 04:47 AM']possibly. This being the case (if it is such, won't get into that here), it doesn't seem too far a jump to go from saying someone is a saint because they are in heaven, and then canonizing such a person.[/quote]

The Church cannot say for certain who is and who is not in heaven. The Saints are, but as for non-Christians... the Church pretty much leaves it at "it's possible". I do not think that any pope would claim that he "knows for certain" that a specific non-Christian is in heaven.

The difference between our arguments is that you are claiming that the Church might possibly say that it knows for certain that a specific non-Christian is in heaven (and therefore is a saint), and could then canonize that person as a Saint. I am saying that the Church says non-Christians "could" go to heaven, but would never say that a specific one was either a "saint" or a "Saint".

So basically, yes, I do think it is a pretty far jump.

Posted

the story in Paladin's link is of a saint whose life is attributed to many of the same things in the life of the Buddha. this is not a problem, and it does not mean that it is Buddha who is the saint there.

it reminds me of St. Bridgit of Ireland and how she replaced the celtic god Brid.

whether Saint Josaphat actually did live a life similar to that of Siddhartha, or if his hagiography was just made similar in evangelical technique, who knows? however, it seems to me that it is not too much of a coincidence for two people to have lived a life of luxury, then left that life and saw misery, and as a result decided to live a radical monastic type existence (Siddartha did so in buddhist philosophy, but Josaphat did so in Christian monasticism)

St. Josaphat is NOT Siddartha, but he is probably a similar type of person (a rich man who saw suffering and lived a radical life as a result)... heck... St. Francis is kinda similar (not as much, but kind of): he had his life made in the shade with his father and decided to live in radical poverty. It would seem that those converts with Buddhist backgrounds might find a good patron saint in St. Josaphat.

as to the question of those who died before Christ: though heaven and hell transcend time, God kept those who died before Christ within time in what is called the Limbus Patrem, the "limbo of the fathers". It is a de fide dogma of the faith that this truly existed and that anyone who was deemed just by God prior to Christ would have waited there until Christ freed them when He descended into "hell" or the "abode of the dead". (when Christ freed them, they had a choice to make, and it is likely enough that some would have made the wrong one and gone to eternal hell) Proto-Christians, as the medievals called them, like Aristotle... ie those who we tend to believe would have been Christian had they had the oppurtunity, may have had that same fate... though Dante and many others place them in an eternal limbo. but none of them went

it is not wise to try to blur the lines of time just because heaven is eternal. though we may think we know what eternal means, our limited understanding cannot grasp its true relationship to the timeline. if we were to consider the blurring of the timeline in that way, what would stop us from praying to our potential future selves in hopes that we had gone to heaven and thus were eternally there? God has ordained that we are to treat the afterlife from within our timeline. those who died before Christ waited for Christ within time; those who die now we can hope go to heaven in some way AFTER they die.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...