Vincent Vega Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1607999' date='Jul 24 2008, 09:52 PM']You do realize that by knowing their language, you can effectively teach them English faster and better? You think they just come here and magically know how to learn English?[/quote] I would say that learning a language to communicate with immigrants unwilling to try to learn to communicate in the language of the land is quite different from learning a language to help said immigrants learn the language of the land.
Madame Vengier Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1607999' date='Jul 24 2008, 09:52 PM']You do realize that by knowing their language, you can effectively teach them English faster and better? You think they just come here and magically know how to learn English?[/quote] Wrong. You learn a language by LEARNING it, not by having your teacher speak YOUR native language to you while you learn a foreign language. This makes no sense.
Fidei Defensor Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1608239' date='Jul 25 2008, 09:42 AM']Wrong. You learn a language by LEARNING it, not by having your teacher speak YOUR native language to you while you learn a foreign language. This makes no sense.[/quote] Unless of course you come here knowing absolutely no English and people are screaming at you to learn the language or go home, and you're afraid and just wanting to get by. Believe it or not, something as petty as this is not the most important thing to people who just want to get by. You can teach them english and also be willing to help them by also speaking their language for the most important things.
homeschoolmom Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 If you've ever spent time in an ESL classroom, you will notice that often times (depending on where you are), you have children from all over the place. Is the ESL teacher supposed to learn all of those languages in order to teach them all English? Or would it be better for him/her to understand the machanics of English, phonics, etc. in order to teach English?
Fidei Defensor Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1608255' date='Jul 25 2008, 09:53 AM']If you've ever spent time in an ESL classroom, you will notice that oftentimes (depending on where you are), you have children from all over the place. Is the ESL teacher supposed to learn all of those languages in order to teach them all English? Or would it be better for him/her to understand the machanics of English, phonics, etc. in order to teach English?[/quote] That's not the same thing. Right now, we seem to have it out for spanish speakers. I don't disagree with the methods that are used by teachers of English. I do disagree, though, that being so hateful towards those who only speak spanish is somehow going to make them want to learn english. My friend's mom is a teacher of ESL and she speaks fluent spanish. Ask her how helpful it is to know spanish in those situations. Sometimes there are other things to take care of besides just teaching english. How would you like it to be in a country where you don't know the language and no one will take the time to communicate with you when you just need help? Sure, they're learning english, but that doesn't mean they can communicate with it yet. So you'd rather just leave them on their own and be cold and unhelping? Sounds Christian to me.
homeschoolmom Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 Not at all. I used to volunteer my free time in high school in the ESL room, I volunteered in the local junior high's ESL room while I was in college. I considered making TESOL (Teaching English to Speakers of Other Languages) my major. I minored in Spanish. I know it can be helpful. (though how helpful it would have been in college in an ESL room full of Hmong students is questionable). The point is not all non-English speaking immigrants are Spanish speaking. To suggest that native English speakers learn Spanish to accommodate that particular immigrant group (as Obama was doing in the clip in question) is ridiculous.
Fidei Defensor Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1608270' date='Jul 25 2008, 10:07 AM']Not at all. I used to volunteer my free time in high school in the ESL room, I volunteered in the local junior high's ESL room while I was in college. I considered making TESOL (Teaching English to Speakers of Other Languages) my major. I minored in Spanish. I know it can be helpful. (though how helpful it would have been in college in an ESL room full of Hmong students is questionable). The point is not all non-English speaking immigrants are Spanish speaking. To suggest that native English speakers learn Spanish to accommodate that particular immigrant group (as Obama was doing in the clip in question) is ridiculous.[/quote] I agree. However, I think it's a moot point. I don't think Obama was specifically suggesting that everyone learn Spanish. His overall point what that we need to embrace diversity a bit more and be more open to the fact that other cultures and specifically, languages, exist out there. There is nothing wrong with wanting English to be spoken in our country and wanting others to learn it when they come to live here. However, we shouldnt be so against people also speaking other languages. Sometimes I think people here forget that immigrants are people, too.
homeschoolmom Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 I have no problem with immigrants (or anyone for that matter) speaking whatever language they want in their homes, with their friends and whatnot. What I don't like is immigrants being told that they don't have to learn English. I believe it is in everyone who lives here's best interest to learn English. I understand that older immigrants are probably not going to be able to become proficient in it. I have no problem with immigrants who come here legally to make a better life for themselves and their children. That's what makes this country great.
Mercy me Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1608273' date='Jul 25 2008, 12:14 PM']I don't think Obama was specifically suggesting that everyone learn Spanish. His overall point what that we need to embrace diversity a bit more and be more open to the fact that other cultures and specifically, languages, exist out there. There is nothing wrong with wanting English to be spoken in our country and wanting others to learn it when they come to live here. However, we shouldnt be so against people also speaking other languages.[/quote] I am not against learning other languages. Obama did specify Spanish. He used other languages as examples of American ignorance but he did say we should learn Spanish. He did say that they will learn English. But this wouldn't be such a big deal it they were learning English. They aren't.
Mercy me Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 (edited) Double post Edited July 25, 2008 by Mercy me
Madame Vengier Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 [quote name='Mercy me' post='1608313' date='Jul 25 2008, 12:07 PM']But this wouldn't be such a big deal it they were learning English. They aren't.[/quote] And they don't want to. This is the elephant in the room that most people ignore. They carry on about how we should learn Spanish to "help" them, or they complain that there aren't enough ESL resources available to them to ealrn English. None of this is true. The elephant truth is they don't want to learn English.
Madame Vengier Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1608281' date='Jul 25 2008, 11:26 AM']I have no problem with immigrants (or anyone for that matter) speaking whatever language they want in their homes, with their friends and whatnot.[/quote] Oh my gosh, ME EITHER. I actually WANT American children to be immersed in the culture of their immigrant parents or immigrant grandparents. I think it's wonderful. But they need to assimilate here--for our sake and for their sake. The problem is that people have made "assimilation" a dirty word. This word does not mean they have to abandon the culture they come from. They can be BOTH. Be fully American and fully in touch with their heritage.
Madame Vengier Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1608255' date='Jul 25 2008, 10:53 AM']If you've ever spent time in an ESL classroom, you will notice that often times (depending on where you are), you have children from all over the place. Is the ESL teacher supposed to learn all of those languages in order to teach them all English? Or would it be better for him/her to understand the machanics of English, phonics, etc. in order to teach English?[/quote] You start the way WE started when were little American boys and girls. We started with our ABCs. This reminds me of an argument I was in last year. I had a friend who was teaching ESL in Korea. She was saying that she has a hard time teaching them certain things in English becuase there is no equivalent in Korean. My argument was, "You don't NEED an equivalent in Korean. Just teach them the ENGLISH word. You are there to teach English." She argued that you need to know the equivalent, then she got angry and said she's been doing this for 4 years and she knows what she's talking about. Actually, she could be doing this for 40 years and the fact remains that she is wrong. For example, in Korean there is no ONE word for "brother". You call your elder brother one thing and you call your younger brother something different. Same with sister. I was telling my friend, the ESL teacher, to just teach them the word BROTHER and SISTER. That's all you need to do. Period. She kept arguing that they don't understand because in Korean they don't have one single word for their siblings. Man, it was like arguing with a brick wall. Just teach them the WORD in ENGLISH. Period.
Madame Vengier Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1608254' date='Jul 25 2008, 10:53 AM']Unless of course you come here knowing absolutely no English and people are screaming at you to learn the language or go home, and you're afraid and just wanting to get by. Believe it or not, something as petty as this is not the most important thing to people who just want to get by. You can teach them english and also be willing to help them by also speaking their language for the most important things.[/quote] This is all nonsense. They can learn English if they want to. You start with the alphabet. The same way we learned as children. No foreign language skills required for a person to teach English to a non-American. Period.
homeschoolmom Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 What I think is funny is that in this thread we have the "you need to teach them English using their native language" folks.... and in Open Mic when discussing various language-learning programs (Rosetta Stone etc), pretty much the consensus is that programs that immerse the student in the language work better.
Madame Vengier Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1608395' date='Jul 25 2008, 01:41 PM']What I think is funny is that in this thread we have the "you need to teach them English using their native language" folks.... and in Open Mic when discussing various language-learning programs (Rosetta Stone etc), pretty much the consensus is that programs that immerse the student in the language work better. [/quote] LOL.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now