HisChildForever Posted July 13, 2008 Posted July 13, 2008 Is Satan in Hell, suffering with all the souls and other fallen angels? I've heard somewhere that God gave him the "power" (not sure if that's the best word choice) to linger on Earth so that he can test mankind. Are his demons also given this privilege? - after all, Satan isn't omnipresent. Anyway, if his demons aren't about, then how can Satan tempt those on Earth in more direct ways - individual ways, not like trashy lustful TV ways. And if he's not suffering in Hell, why? Wouldn't God be just in punishing him? Why would God permit the Devil to trouble us so much? It's bad enough we're inclined to sin (due to Original Sin), why would God let the Devil influence us when He doesn't want any to perish? I don't see how Satan has anything to do with Free Will. When most people reject God, they don't think "I'm accepting the Devil" they think "I'm rejecting God and all thoughts of faith" which means they don't even believe in the Devil. I'm thinking that if the Devil wasn't around, people would still turn their backs on God for their own selfish reasons. Wow, many questions. Thanks.
StColette Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 Thank you for asking these questions! They are all very interesting one to think about. I will add a suggestion though. I would suggest not too focus too much curiosity into Satan and the other fallen angels. When studying Angelology my Professor instructed us that if we studying demonology we need to study Angelology 10 times as much. Studying demonology deeply can be very dangerous for the soul if it is not balanced properly. Not that you are doing this, it is just a general warning of precaution for anyone interested in the topic of demonology. [quote]Is Satan in Hell, suffering with all the souls and other fallen angels?[/quote] The Church teaches that Satan as well as all the other fallen angels are in Hell. [quote]I've heard somewhere that God gave him the "power" (not sure if that's the best word choice) to linger on Earth so that he can test mankind. Are his demons also given this privilege? - after all, Satan isn't omnipresent. Anyway, if his demons aren't about, then how can Satan tempt those on Earth in more direct ways - individual ways, not like trashy lustful TV ways.[/quote] Power is the correct word choice. The power that Satan and the other fallen angels possess comes completely from God. He is their Creator and has ultimate control over what abilities or powers they are given and possess. And yes, Satan has been given a type of dominion over the Earth by God. I would say that yes the other fallen angels could be given the same privilege to go about the Earth. Think of the prayer to St. Michael the Archangel: [font="Calibri"][size=3]"cast into hell, satan and all the evil spirits, who roam throughout the world seeking the ruin of souls."[/size][/font] Pope Leo XIII wrote the prayer to St. Michael the Archangel after seeing a vision (described below) "One day, after celebrating Mass, the aged Pope Leo XIII was in conference with the Cardinals when suddenly he sank to the floor in a deep swoon. Physicians who hastened to his side could find no trace of his pulse and feared that he had expired. However, after a short interval the Holy Father regained consciousness and exclaimed with great emotion: "Oh, what a horrible picture I have been permitted to see!" He had been shown a vision of evil spirits who had been released from Hell and their efforts to destroy the Church. But in the midst of the horror the archangel St. Michael appeared and cast Satan and his legions into the abyss of hell. Soon afterwards Pope Leo XIII composed the following prayer to Saint Michael, which is the original version: " Pope Leo XIII was an amazing man and has been given the title of "the Great" which isn't thrown around loosely. I believe his vision and the writing of the Prayer to St. Michael the Archangel is proof enough of the reality that Satan and the other fallen angels roam about the Earth seeking the destruction of souls, sometimes in direct ways but more often in indirect ways (like through lustful tv shows etc.) I notice you mention Satan not being omnipresent, this is true because only God is omnipresent. But Satan is also still Angel. Angel is what he was created as and that cannot change. With being created an angel there are certain faculties that come with being an angel. Angels are outside of time and space just like God and are allowed to move among man as messengers (which is the Hebrew meaning of the word for Angel). All good angels, including our guardian angels, are in constant adoration of God (pretty awesome to think about) and at the same "time", so to speak, they can be aiding us in times of need. Being outside of time and space is a hard thing for us to wrap our minds around. But just as the good angels are outside of time and space so are Satan and the other fallen angels. Meaning the presence can both be acting in hell and acting on Earth. We have a hard time understanding this because we associate "presence" with time. St. Thomas Aquinas explains it a lot better in the Summa Theologica under the subject of angels, if you want more information on that subject. [quote]And if he's not suffering in Hell, why? Wouldn't God be just in punishing him?[/quote] I addressed this above, Satan is suffering in Hell with the other fallen angels and the souls of the damned. [quote]Why would God permit the Devil to trouble us so much?[/quote] The Book of Job is an excellent source for understanding this. If you haven't read it, I really do suggest that you do. Job was a very faithful servant of God, and God knew Job's faithfulness. He allowed Job to be tormented by the devil for example the death of all his children; he was afflicted with illness, and lost everything, etc. Job at one point falters and wants to know why. God reminds Job of His [font="Calibri"][size=3]omniscience and almighty power. Job regains his humility and trusts in God.[/size][/font] I believe that the reason that God permits the Devil to trouble us so much is because He is trying to have us trust solely on Him. Often times when we fall on hard times or we are faced with troubles we try to take it all onto ourselves. We aren't supposed to do that. God is there to help us with our burdens. Christ tells all who are heavy laden to come unto Him because his yoke and burden are light. Remember the devil can't be blamed for every sin we commit because some sins are because of our natural inclination towards certain things, When the devil is directly troubling us it is often a test from God to see how faithful we are to Him, does that make sense? He tests us to see how much we will depend upon Him instead of ourselves for the answer. Now if we fail and realize what we did was wrong we know that God is there ready and waiting with open arms to receive us back into His fold. [quote]It's bad enough we're inclined to sin (due to Original Sin), why would God let the Devil influence us when He doesn't want any to perish?[/quote] God of course doesn't want anyone to perish, but He also doesn't want us to live in our mediocrity either. We shouldn't just want to "get by" with our faith, doing the mere minimum. Often times when we are challenged by sin we come out even stronger than before, but only with the help of God. And again, the Devil can't be blamed for all of our struggles. Satan is the root of all sin but he is also not the direct cause for every sin. [quote]I don't see how Satan has anything to do with Free Will. When most people reject God, they don't think "I'm accepting the Devil" they think "I'm rejecting God and all thoughts of faith" which means they don't even believe in the Devil. I'm thinking that if the Devil wasn't around, people would still turn their backs on God for their own selfish reasons.[/quote] The Church view is often that of when someone sins venial and mortal that they are rejecting God and His grace, more so in the case of mortal sin because it is a direct action against God with complete knowledge of the sin. There's a quote, I forgot by who, that says that when we sin against God we put ourselves into company of Satan and the other fallen angels (paraphrasing the quote). If you mean if Satan were not created then people would still turn their backs on God for their own selfish reasons, we really have know way of knowing. If Satan weren't created and man never fell then we would still be in a state of natural grace, like Adam and Eve were before they fell. If you are meaning if the Devil wasn't directly seeking out the destruction of souls and we still had original sin then I would say yes some people would still turn their backs on God. I hope these answers help clear things up a little bit. If you have any more question feel free to PM me. I will post them into the Q&A forum on this thread so that others may see them and other Church Scholars can have a chance to state their knowledge on the subject.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now