Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='TeresaBenedicta' post='1600575' date='Jul 15 2008, 05:39 PM']Hey folks. Without going into a lot of details on what's going for me, I would like to ask a kind of general opinion on finances/paying for school/debt.

I'm the first in my family history to go to college, so my parents had no idea what to expect money-wise when I headed off last year. For a few different reasons, we didn't understand exactly how expensive college really is, especially going to a private university. Now my mom is beginning to freak out about finances, wants me to transfer to a state school or even community college (which is a bit difficult, considering I'm studying Philosophy & Theology) and has no idea how we're going to pay things off.

Now, I'm trying to look at this from a level point of view... Education costs money. A higher education is not cheap and most people come out of school with debt, right?

I can work it out to where I can graduate in three years, which saves $40,000. From my general calculations, that would leave me... about $50,000-60,000 in debt by the time I have my degree.

Is that typical? Or is that a number I should be scared of, and consider ditching my education for something else?[/quote]
Is this debt in your name or your parents' name? (You say your mother has no idea how "we're" going to pay things off.)

I had a small amount of debt coming out of college, about $8,000. I went to a small private school but got great financial aid. My parents were adamantly opposed to my taking on any debt at all, but I fought them on it and stayed in school. It was the right thing to do, but then again I was getting a degree in a field where jobs were relatively easy to get.

I think far too often people get degrees in areas where jobs are not plentiful or the pay is low. Especially in times where the economy is shaky, we have to be practical about school and the money we are putting into education. The degrees you say you're pursuing are typically not lucrative fields, particularly within the Catholic church and with you having only a bachelor's at this point. If you are certain you are called to be here, I would seriously consider going on and getting a master's degree in one of these areas so you can at the least open up academic work as an option.

Otherwise, you are looking at monthly payments of around $500, which is a lot to handle when you are also paying for things like an apartment, a car, food, utilities, and so on.

If I were you, I would head to my career counseling office and get a realistic assessment of the job market with the degrees you'll have, then sit down with your parents and practically analyze your options. Of course, continue to pray for discernment along the way, but arm yourself with as much information as you can.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Bachelor's and Master's combined, I owe about $25,000. Perhaps a bit less now as I've been making payments regularly since finishing up, and I consolidated and did not go through a private lender.

Some debts aren't as bad as others. Education loans and real estate are generally considered more meaningful debts that you have to take sometimes but do have some kind of payback or reward with them. I also think public lenders are much better to deal with and it's best to avoid private loans as much as possible. With private loaners like SallieMae, you have to get a co-signer and they are not nearly as flexible about paying back as the public ones are.

I have a friend who owes probably close to $150,000 from an undergraduate art degree at a private school. I think she's struggling just to get by and is just paying interest. She doesn't want to file for bankruptcy because she has co-signers with her loan and that would foul up their credit.

So if you want a college degree, debt is often unavoidable. But get loans wisely.

Posted

I am so not in favor of leaving school with large debt. I myself left with about $8,000 but my parents are in the hole about $20,000 for me.... I am hoping to get my end of the debt paid off by the end of the year. It is going to be painful.

The reason I tend to be against big debt is the huge barriers it can erect in pursuing your vocation. If you are called to married life, educational debt can absolutely DESTROY your marriage. I have actually heard of this happening quite a bit specifically with FUS grads, lots of divorces/anullments from people who meet there while students and marry with $150.000+ in debt between the two. It's "good debt" in that it's an investment in their educations - but when you think about it, that's a good-sized mortgage right there. And that's not a business degree, at FUS that's most likley a degree in theology, which is one of the least lucrative/employable degrees on offer. So the "investment" in some ways is actually pretty lousy. The stress on the marriage can be incredible, especially when it comes to the discussion about having children and how to afford that.

If you are called to the religious life, of course you have to pay off all that debt before you can enter. There are organizations that can help but in the end you mostly have to do it yourself. It can be years and years before you are able to finally enter on the vocation that God is calling you to, and meanwhile there is going to be a hard and difficult struggle.

Obviously if you have discerned God's will on this then you have to go with what God wants. But God also calls us to be prudent. I would double check again on whether state or community colleges offer the philosophy/theology major, I have one friend who I know studies philosophy at a community college, theology might be a bit tougher at a state school but they typically have some kind of Religion major under the Classics department... which might not be adequate if you really want specifically Catholic theology. One way to save money which I know many people do is take the first two years or school at a community college and then transfer the credits to a more expensive four-year school (which maybe would have those preferred Catholic theo courses?)

Posted

[quote name='Maggie' post='1601025' date='Jul 16 2008, 10:48 AM']Obviously if you have discerned God's will on this then you have to go with what God wants. But God also calls us to be prudent. I would double check again on whether state or community colleges offer the philosophy/theology major, I have one friend who I know studies philosophy at a community college, theology might be a bit tougher at a state school but they typically have some kind of Religion major under the Classics department... which might not be adequate if you really want specifically Catholic theology. One way to save money which I know many people do is take the first two years or school at a community college and then transfer the credits to a more expensive four-year school (which maybe would have those preferred Catholic theo courses?)[/quote]

I would advise against studying Religion/Theology or Philosophy even at a community or state university/college, especially if you want something that is orthodox. I took a Philosophy class at a State University and was horrified at what they were teaching, I quit the class within the first couple of weeks of school.

I spent two years at a State University as a Biology/Chemistry major under the PreVet program. Lucky for me all my credits transferred to FUS as electives and other such courses lol under at Theology major. I will say it can be quite difficult finishing up an entire Theology degree requirement within 2 years if you weren't able to take the correct courses at a State or Community college.

TeresaBenedicta
Posted

[quote name='Barbarus' post='1601008' date='Jul 16 2008, 11:09 AM']Is this debt in your name or your parents' name? (You say your mother has no idea how "we're" going to pay things off.)

I had a small amount of debt coming out of college, about $8,000. I went to a small private school but got great financial aid. My parents were adamantly opposed to my taking on any debt at all, but I fought them on it and stayed in school. It was the right thing to do, but then again I was getting a degree in a field where jobs were relatively easy to get.

I think far too often people get degrees in areas where jobs are not plentiful or the pay is low. Especially in times where the economy is shaky, we have to be practical about school and the money we are putting into education. The degrees you say you're pursuing are typically not lucrative fields, particularly within the Catholic church and with you having only a bachelor's at this point. If you are certain you are called to be here, I would seriously consider going on and getting a master's degree in one of these areas so you can at the least open up academic work as an option.

Otherwise, you are looking at monthly payments of around $500, which is a lot to handle when you are also paying for things like an apartment, a car, food, utilities, and so on.

If I were you, I would head to my career counseling office and get a realistic assessment of the job market with the degrees you'll have, then sit down with your parents and practically analyze your options. Of course, continue to pray for discernment along the way, but arm yourself with as much information as you can.[/quote]

My mom and my grandmother have cosigned loans with me. My parents are doing their best to pay off what they can, when they can, as they can.

Luckily I came into my college with extra credits from AP classes I took in high school, which took care of a lot of the required classes. I've dropped my Theology major to a minor (our theology program isn't the best, it's not horrible, but it's not worth paying that much money) and have kept my Philosophy major. With all of that, I will be graduating a year early.

Studying what I'm studying, I'm probably going to have to go to get my master's-- which I want to do anyways. But it seems like that's super expensive too. I'd likely be looking at FUS for the masters program. I'd want to do my Masters in Theology, but looking at their website, it might be more plausible to just continue with Philosophy.

I want to teach (or DRE or Youth Minister) and I want to write.

I don't like the thought of having to incur so much debt... but I'm rather confused as to what any other options would be at this point, except for dropping out of school. If I were to transfer even to a state school, it would be like starting all over again because the classes I've taken at my school have mostly been to do with my fields. Plus I wouldn't be able to finish a year early at a state school. And I'd have to figure out a different major.

See... what I don't get, is unless you're a business or pyschology major (or med), there's basically no job outlook. I hear people say all the time that all that matters is that you have a degree (from a liberal arts school), and I hope that's true if I have to get a job outside of the Church at first. But I don't know.

It's just a scary time because I feel like I need to have the rest of my life planned out for me right now. And I don't. I don't know what I'm going to do once I get my degree. I don't know what type of job I'll find. Or if I'll go on to my masters. So, I don't know if it's worth it. Or if I'll be able to make things work.

All I know is the 'now'. And I love studying what I'm studying. There's nothing I'd prefer. But does that still mean that's what God wants me to study? The only thing I feel like I can do is keep doing what I'm doing, trusting in God, and hoping that if He wants something different for me, then He'll speak a little bit louder.

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

Loans can come in pretty big numbers after a degree. Lucky for me I get federal and state funds to pay my loans off because I'm a teacher in a high-need area both in subject and location. Its going to help me get rid of mine really fast!

My advise is to not be in a hurry to accept a loan, make sure you understand and agree with their terms because so many times it will be very difficult to pay later on if you did not pay attention when you signed it.

Posted

I can't advise your specific situation, but I would suggest that you not be so set in your dreams, that you ignore reality. Maybe going to another school, or even leaving school for a few years, might be the best option. Maybe you should work for a while, and pursue your academic goals in the future. Only you know what is best in your situation, but sometimes hard decisions have to be made. It is nice to follow dreams, but sometimes we have to settle for reality. It sounds like your family is really supportive and is willing to help you as much as they can, but you may need to protect them from themselves. They may be willing to help with debt, because they love you, but you have to prudently decide how much is too much burden to place on them.

Even if you cannot live your dreams right now, that doesn't mean God will not give you opportunities in the future. Don't stake your whole life on a dream. The important thing is serving God, whether in dreams or reality. But I hope you are able to remain in school and study what you want to study. :)

Posted

[quote name='TeresaBenedicta' post='1601338' date='Jul 16 2008, 05:48 PM']My mom and my grandmother have cosigned loans with me. My parents are doing their best to pay off what they can, when they can, as they can.

Luckily I came into my college with extra credits from AP classes I took in high school, which took care of a lot of the required classes. I've dropped my Theology major to a minor (our theology program isn't the best, it's not horrible, but it's not worth paying that much money) and have kept my Philosophy major. With all of that, I will be graduating a year early.

Studying what I'm studying, I'm probably going to have to go to get my master's-- which I want to do anyways. But it seems like that's super expensive too. I'd likely be looking at FUS for the masters program. I'd want to do my Masters in Theology, but looking at their website, it might be more plausible to just continue with Philosophy.

I want to teach (or DRE or Youth Minister) and I want to write.

I don't like the thought of having to incur so much debt... but I'm rather confused as to what any other options would be at this point, except for dropping out of school. If I were to transfer even to a state school, it would be like starting all over again because the classes I've taken at my school have mostly been to do with my fields. Plus I wouldn't be able to finish a year early at a state school. And I'd have to figure out a different major.

See... what I don't get, is unless you're a business or pyschology major (or med), there's basically no job outlook. I hear people say all the time that all that matters is that you have a degree (from a liberal arts school), and I hope that's true if I have to get a job outside of the Church at first. But I don't know.

It's just a scary time because I feel like I need to have the rest of my life planned out for me right now. And I don't. I don't know what I'm going to do once I get my degree. I don't know what type of job I'll find. Or if I'll go on to my masters. So, I don't know if it's worth it. Or if I'll be able to make things work.

All I know is the 'now'. And I love studying what I'm studying. There's nothing I'd prefer. But does that still mean that's what God wants me to study? The only thing I feel like I can do is keep doing what I'm doing, trusting in God, and hoping that if He wants something different for me, then He'll speak a little bit louder.[/quote]
TB:
[url="http://www.payscale.com/research/US/Job=Youth_Minister/Salary"]Here is a payscale link for youth ministry salaries[/url].
As you can see, for about five years you can expect to earn in the neighborhood of $30,000. This of course will vary depending on the church and area you're in. That works out to take-home pay of about 22,500 (taxes are roughly 25%). That's about 1,875 per month. Out of that, you can expect to pay somewhere between $150-400/month in health insurance costs. Then you'll have a car payment (unless you're very lucky and get or already have a car that is paid for). You'll have car insurance. You'll have housing costs. Telephone. Food. Entertainment. Gasoline. Incidental expenses. Plus $500 in student loan costs. It goes pretty quick. And, working as a youth minister, it would be difficult to have a second job.

Now, you can lower the payments so it's less per month, but when you lower the monthly payment you stretch out the length of time you'll be paying, so you pay more overall in interest. And you need to remember that your mom and grandma are on the hook if for some reason you cannot pay. That is a [i]big[/i] gift they are giving you. My parents would not do that for me.

Dropping out of school might not be the answer. In fact, from the perspective of a complete stranger, I would think it probably isn't the answer, because your degree will position you to make higher pay, and if you quit before you're done you will have to start making payments on your loans sooner without having the extra earning power of a degree. But I would not foreclose looking at other school options, and thinking very carefully about the type of job you want to have. Like I said, do the research, work out the practicalities of the money (painful as that is), and then make your decision. Continuing to go forward unarmed with information is not, in my view, ever the right way to go, particularly when information is so easily available.

Posted

Dave Ramsey, financial expert, does not believe student loans are good debt. I agree now that i am done with school and have huge debt from college. I bought into all those ideas that college debt is good debt and it isn't. No debt is good debt. Unless you are in a field that you are going to make good money such as a doctor or dentist or something and you have to take out loans for med school. But if you are like me and have an degree in education then it is not good. I went to a private school and have a lot of debt. I have found that in most areas that need teachers such as North and South Carolina, Arizona, Nevada(Las Vegas), etc. I would not even be able to live on a teachers salary with my loan debt. It has really put a hamper on my plans and i am probably going to have to look into another field. If i could do it all over again I would have worked full time and went to school part time and paid my tuition myself even if it took 8 years to graduate. Basically, i would have found any way possible to come out of school with no debt. I can tell you it's not worth it having all this debt. I am limited by soo much in what i can do now. I don't have a lot of options. I can't move to the places i want, i may have to work a second job while i teach and in the summers. I'd give anything to have this debt gone.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Look into teaching in a rural area with a state debt forgiveness package.

I checked with my son, his current debt is about $50,000 as he is starting his 2nd year of grad school.

Anastasia13
Posted

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1600651' date='Jul 15 2008, 05:12 PM']Over here, student loans don't have to be paid back until you earn at least £15,000 ($30,000), and even then it is interest free, and quite reasonable. If after 25 years (I think), you haven't paid it off, the debt is written off.[/quote]
Is there any way I can transfer my loans to there or should I just go to grad school there?

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Jennie and I each owe $20,000. It's doable, but not easy.

A note on loans and marriage: when you get married, your loan company may ask you if you want to consolidate your loans with your husband's. Keep this in mind: if your spouse dies, his/her loans are forgiven and you only owe on your own, but if you consolidate your loans with your spouse's, both your names go on the paperwork and if one spouse dies, the remaining spouse is responsible for paying off all the loans.

Just keep that in mind if this situation ever arises.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1601469' date='Jul 16 2008, 10:31 PM']Look into teaching in a rural area with a state debt forgiveness package.

I checked with my son, his current debt is about $50,000 as he is starting his 2nd year of grad school.[/quote]

Rural? I think you mean Urban. The ones that have debt forgiveness are usually really bad urban school and you have to teach five years there to get the debt forgiveness. Most people don't make it working 5 years in those kind of schools. I know i couldn't handle it.

Lisieux Flower
Posted

[quote name='littleflower+JMJ' post='1601350' date='Jul 16 2008, 05:05 PM']Loans can come in pretty big numbers after a degree. Lucky for me I get federal and state funds to pay my loans off because I'm a teacher in a high-need area both in subject and location. Its going to help me get rid of mine really fast![/quote]
What are the names of the grants that you recieved? I'd like to teach special ed in a high needs area, but I'm going to have tons of loans to pay off. :( It would be awesome to have some federal help with my loans.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='JoeyP' post='1602017' date='Jul 17 2008, 03:49 PM']Rural? I think you mean Urban. The ones that have debt forgiveness are usually really bad urban school and you have to teach five years there to get the debt forgiveness. Most people don't make it working 5 years in those kind of schools. I know i couldn't handle it.[/quote]

You don't know until you try :)

Posted

[quote name='TeresaBenedicta' post='1601338' date='Jul 16 2008, 05:48 PM']My mom and my grandmother have cosigned loans with me. My parents are doing their best to pay off what they can, when they can, as they can.

Luckily I came into my college with extra credits from AP classes I took in high school, which took care of a lot of the required classes. I've dropped my Theology major to a minor (our theology program isn't the best, it's not horrible, but it's not worth paying that much money) and have kept my Philosophy major. With all of that, I will be graduating a year early.

Studying what I'm studying, I'm probably going to have to go to get my master's-- which I want to do anyways. But it seems like that's super expensive too. I'd likely be looking at FUS for the masters program. I'd want to do my Masters in Theology, but looking at their website, it might be more plausible to just continue with Philosophy.

I want to teach (or DRE or Youth Minister) and I want to write.

I don't like the thought of having to incur so much debt... but I'm rather confused as to what any other options would be at this point, except for dropping out of school. If I were to transfer even to a state school, it would be like starting all over again because the classes I've taken at my school have mostly been to do with my fields. Plus I wouldn't be able to finish a year early at a state school. And I'd have to figure out a different major.

See... what I don't get, is unless you're a business or pyschology major (or med), there's basically no job outlook. I hear people say all the time that all that matters is that you have a degree (from a liberal arts school), and I hope that's true if I have to get a job outside of the Church at first. But I don't know.

It's just a scary time because I feel like I need to have the rest of my life planned out for me right now. And I don't. I don't know what I'm going to do once I get my degree. I don't know what type of job I'll find. Or if I'll go on to my masters. So, I don't know if it's worth it. Or if I'll be able to make things work.

All I know is the 'now'. And I love studying what I'm studying. There's nothing I'd prefer. But does that still mean that's what God wants me to study? The only thing I feel like I can do is keep doing what I'm doing, trusting in God, and hoping that if He wants something different for me, then He'll speak a little bit louder.[/quote]

Dear,

Don't worry too much about credits transferring. If 54 Credits consisting of Biology, Chemistry, and Physics can be applied toward a Theology major lol I don't think you would have a problem with your credits transferring and applying to your degree.

The Masters program in Theology at FUS is very cheap compared to most places, believe me I've looked. I'll be spending about 1,200 a semester for 2 classes for their Masters in Theology, not bad compared to Univ. Dallas which was going to charge 3,000 for 2 classes.

When it comes down to it, hon, if you feel that DRE/Ministry is where God is calling you then that is where you go. I was scared to death when I made that leap. I had been talking about being a Vet from about the age of 5. I loved animals and had a huge passion for Biology/Science. By my 2nd year into the program I was completely depressed in my current major. I had the love of animals to drive me but that wasn't enough. I had realized that for so many years it was about "my plans" for "my future" instead of "God's plan for me". God sure knows how to knock you off your high horse. Now don't get me wrong, money played a huge role in what was going on with my transfer from Bio/Chem/Vet to Theology. I was about to give up a free ride. I applied to FUS, because they were the cheapest and gave me the greatest Fin Aid. Sadly, I could not get my loans in order in time and had to cancel going about 2 weeks before I was supposed to start school there. I was heartbroken. My dad reminded me that sometimes God makes us wait for the things He's calling us to until we are truly ready. He explained to me about how maybe it was someone elses time first. I didn't let it stop me. I applied for the next semester, found a student loan I could sign on my own, and packed my bags and graduated 2 years later. lol Lesson of the story, if this is where God is calling you, then go. I haven't regretted my choice for a single moment. Yeah so I do have 20,000 to pay off in debt. I'm a parish receptionist lol (almost making the same as my youth minister hubby). I use my degree to help out the Deacons and other staff members that are unsure about certain things. All in all I'm happy and grateful that God showed me where I was supposed to be, no amount of debt could take that away.

Posted

[quote name='Light and Truth' post='1601884' date='Jul 17 2008, 11:37 AM']Is there any way I can transfer my loans to there or should I just go to grad school there?[/quote]

+

I can't imagine this applies to non-natives (citizens). Tax money must pay for this, and not citizens haven't been paying taxes! There's no such thing as "free money"!

Lilllabettt
Posted

[quote name='JoeyP' post='1601396' date='Jul 16 2008, 08:50 PM']Dave Ramsey, financial expert, does not believe student loans are good debt. I agree now that i am done with school and have huge debt from college. I bought into all those ideas that college debt is good debt and it isn't. No debt is good debt. Unless you are in a field that you are going to make good money such as a doctor or dentist or something and you have to take out loans for med school. But if you are like me and have an degree in education then it is not good.[/quote]

It's interesting, I am hearing this more and more from people, about educational debt being just awful awful debt. The old idea is that you spend al the money on the degree and then you get a great job which helps you pay back the loans. But the bachelor's degree isn't worth very much any more, what with everyone and his brother going and getting one. A lot of people, especially with non-technical liberal arts degrees, end up doing jobs where the minimum requirement is a high school diploma. I know I work a job which is a mix of high school grads and college grads. We college grads are kind of interiorly appalled that this is what all our money and time got us. Don't get me wrong, it's a good job, great benefits etc. But a degree is NOT required and so you sort of feel like you wasted thousands of dollars. Of course maybe it will come in handy down the line...

Posted

Now I'm not thrilled by having student loan debt, but it's not as depressing as some people make it out to be. I'm not in a job, currently, where I'm officially using my degree, although I do help out with baptisms, helping the Deacons, writing an adoration newsletter, pre-cana stuff, etc. My degree is in Theology and I'm the Church receptionist. I make pretty decent money and I have weekends off and I'm off at 4:30. Now while this isn't my idle job it does pay the bills, especially those student loans. I work in a wonderful environment and there's always a great chance for advancement here given my degree (there's a school k3-8 attached to this parish). Now while my main job doesn't have me using my degree to the fullest extent, God has a plan for my degree or else He would not have called me toward it. If anything I'll be a great catechist for my children, which is the most important thing.

Posted

I think when you are talking about jobs such as teacher or social worker, it is hard to put a cost benefit analysis on it to make it look like it's a good financial decision. However, I've never met a teacher or social worker who picked those fields expecting to make a lot of money.

In my first semester in college they made us take an introduction class that among other things we had to do a cost/benefit on our education. Not on education debt, but on the money on the education itself, versus working. It was eye-opening, and made us realize that we weren't going to come out the much ahead, so we'd better be in college because we wanted to be there training for a job we really wanted to do.

Legal obviously ranked high on being able to recoup the cost of education. I guess that would have worked out better for me if I hadn't become disabled. All the planning in the world doesn't help if God throws you a curveball.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...