cmotherofpirl Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 I'll bet some of the Apostles were not happy with the multitudes that followed Jesus either.
goldenchild17 Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 (edited) very true Edited July 18, 2008 by goldenchild17
XIX Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 [quote]"It has become an occasion for a very secular approach to religion, it's become just a happy party - a week of partying and concerts and world activities with very little that is truly holy and sacred and prayerful and Catholic for that matter," he said. [b]This is definitely an unfair criticism. the inference here is that fun and holiness are mutually exclusive. Give me a break. And consider all of the people who get to meet the Pope or at least be in his presence. I think that qualifies as more than just "very little that is truly holy and sacred.[/b] Father Scott is sharply opposed to the strong secular atmosphere around the event. "They'll have a few masses, a few experiences, but they'll be very liberal, easy-going, secular unsacred kinds of things. [b]The Papal Mass leaves itself open to tons of liturgical abuse, so they have a point there. Plus, it's very hard to pay attention to what is going on during the Mass, as I recall. But there are a lot of Masses during the week that are very holy. And consider the fact that a lot of the people who go there are not regular church-goers. Maybe WYD is more geared towards getting people back into the fold instead of keeping already-devout catholics in the fold.[/b] "We consider ourselves, that we are the mainstream. We are the true Catholics. [b]Wow, that's not condescending or anything. It would be different if this seemed like an isolated comment, but the SSPX has practically made a living off of such comments. Unlike some PM members, I do respect the Society for their level of devotion to the Eucharist and to Mary and such. But they have to pull the pride back a few notches. Or at least give the appearance of being more humble.[/b] "We are doing what the church has always done. We follow Catholic tradition, we have the traditional mass only, and every other traditional liturgical and spiritual practice which is necessary to sanctify our lives on this earth and go to heaven," he said.[/quote]
Maria Posted July 19, 2008 Posted July 19, 2008 I've been to two WYD's. There are certainly things that could be improved, but they are definitely valuable. But, as I've observed before (dunno if ever on Phatmass), if you're used to a certain kind of atmosphere around religion, it's hard to recognize, say, reverence when it doesn't look the same. For example, I'd love it if at WYD's they could express their appreciation for, say, a prayerful song through silence instead of clapping. Silence is better suited toward the moment, but clapping doesn't mean that they aren't feeling reverence etc. It means that they haven't learned how to express it fittingly. Of course, the obvious response to this is that they should be in a setting that would teach them to express it fittingly, and I agree that that's important and that WYD's do not fulfill this function, but I believe that, despite this, WYD is still valuable; that, though they do not fulfill this role, they do many other valuable things. That's one point. The other is that there's nothing wrong with Catholics getting together and celebrating for the joy of being Catholic and loved by God, even if the celebrations aren't solely liturgical.
goldenchild17 Posted July 19, 2008 Posted July 19, 2008 [quote name='Maria' post='1603053' date='Jul 18 2008, 10:30 PM']That's one point. The other is that there's nothing wrong with Catholics getting together and celebrating for the joy of being Catholic and loved by God, even if the celebrations aren't solely liturgical.[/quote] agreed, but one might ask if the liturgies should be liturgical? I'm all for fun and games, when its appropriate. Is it appropriate at Mass I think is the objection that this group raises.
mortify Posted July 19, 2008 Posted July 19, 2008 [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1603199' date='Jul 19 2008, 02:07 AM']agreed, but one might ask if the liturgies should be liturgical? I'm all for fun and games, when its appropriate. Is it appropriate at Mass I think is the objection that this group raises.[/quote] It's what's in the heart that's important, not the external signs of the liturgy.
picchick Posted July 19, 2008 Posted July 19, 2008 (edited) [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1603199' date='Jul 19 2008, 03:07 AM']agreed, but one might ask if the liturgies should be liturgical? I'm all for fun and games, when its appropriate. Is it appropriate at Mass I think is the objection that this group raises.[/quote] I agree with you...I do not think that "fun and games" belong in the Mass and I think that it is good that this group or any group for that matter raise an objection against that. However, you and SSPX, and I do not see eye to eye as to what constitutes as a proper Mass. I go right now to the Novus Ordo...I attended a Tridentine but there are many things that I do not understand. I do perfer the Eastern Rite though. So my Mass may contain "fun and games" that to me are not. [quote name='mortify' post='1603249' date='Jul 19 2008, 09:20 AM']It's what's in the heart that's important, not the external signs of the liturgy.[/quote] Not necessarily. The external signs of the liturgy are signs of who were are and our respect towards Jesus. By liturgy, I think we are referring to the Mass. I am fine with P+W hymns being sung and what not although I don't really care for it. However, we reflect what is in our hearts by the external signs. One thing that people seem to forget is that WYD has many different cultures coming together. I do not like dancing, hand clapping, and so forth. But, if you remember the canonization of St. Juan Diego, you will find that the Mass was VERY different due to the culture of the Mexican Indians. I am ok with that. WYD I think does a really good job combining cultures and still keeping it as respectful as possible. I do not care for the SSPX. I have had really bad experiences with them. However, I do not think that we are showing a Catholic charity to them by insulting them. Meg Edited July 19, 2008 by picchick
dominicansoul Posted July 19, 2008 Posted July 19, 2008 (edited) Is it just me, or hasn't anyone else seen these same abuses in their everyday Masses at their home parishes??? These things are happening because of lack of Catechesis. With the numbers of vocations up in religious orders (particularly the Dominicans), the Church is getting to the root of this problem... I think this is going to be a very slow process returning to the reverence and the splendor and the glory of our Liturgies. In the meantime, most of these abuses or whatever you'd call them, in particular at WYD, are not done with sinister intentions, but because people just don't know how to act reverently (how can they, they see this happening in their own parishes at home!) And as far as the Holy Eucharist falling on the ground, etcetera, because it's such a huge crowd these mistakes happen more so...they need to really look at solutions to that problem, definitely...but as far as crumb-particles go, as Sacred as His Flesh is, I do believe the Good Lord can take care of Himself under these circumstances...especially if there is nothing humanly possible to prevent such occurrances from happening... If these things were done intentionally, it would be a different story. What would the SSPX have them do? Not distribute Holy Communion to as many people? Designate only a few numbers to receive? Do they honestly think the Lord would want that? The Lord wants to come to every single one of the participants! this is just "phooey" fluff from the mouths of the SSPX....the greatest abuse is disobedience, which they so much participate in. I don't pay any attention to what they have to "correct" us for... Edited July 19, 2008 by dominicansoul
Madame Vengier Posted July 19, 2008 Posted July 19, 2008 I don't usally post in threads like this, mainly because I don't feel I have anything to contribute other than agreeing that yes, these people are in deep rebellion. But I had to touch on this one a bit. I totally and completely feel for some of the angst and disappoitment people like this are experiencing. I could not -- and with the Grace of God, will not -- ever leave the Church, but I do think that the cultural and theological war that is going on in the Church is extremely daunting and I can get where people feel like they just want to "go back to the way it was". Humans are more fragile than we know that we are and even the strongest can feel weakened by the constant state of dissension and chaos in the Church today and for the past 40-some-odd-years. So yeah, I get the rebellion. I don't condone it or agree with it, but I get it. I just think it's extremely unfortunate that they left the Church in order to make a point that the Church is in disarray. They would serve the Church FAR BETTER by joining forces with the true Church to defend her. This article about the condemnation of the festivities of WYD shows how badly an effect rebellion can have on the psyche. It makes a person lose their joy. These dissenters have lost their sense of joy. They are just angry and miserable and it infuriates them to the see "the liberals" (as they regard anyone who is obedient to Rome) having fun, being joyful and living out their Faith in happiness. Naturally, this makes them even more bitter. They can't imagine how we can revel in our wickedness. They want to see us in misery so they can say "See? Look how miserable the liberals are." Actually, it's these dissenters who are the most miserable of all.
mortify Posted July 19, 2008 Posted July 19, 2008 [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1603364' date='Jul 19 2008, 12:00 PM']Is it just me, or hasn't anyone else seen these same abuses in their everyday Masses at their home parishes??? These things are happening because of lack of Catechesis. With the numbers of vocations up in religious orders (particularly the Dominicans), the Church is getting to the root of this problem...[/quote] You're right in saying the abuses are in just about every parish, however I wouldn't put the whole blame on poor catechesis, the problem is deeper and higher up the ladder.
Maria Posted July 20, 2008 Posted July 20, 2008 [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1603364' date='Jul 19 2008, 02:00 PM']Is it just me, or hasn't anyone else seen these same abuses in their everyday Masses at their home parishes???[/quote] A lot of them, yes. Or in other parishes around. Strangely enough, in a way that makes me mind them less, because I know people are doing it because everybody does it, and perhaps they don't even know how it should be done. The abuses I mind more are when a priest/liturgy committee takes it upon himself to change the liturgy, because then it really is a statement that he thinks he's above the rubrics. If it's one of the abuses that everyone does, perhaps the parish is working to better things, bit by bit. Of course, there are specific problems that come with having hundreds of thousands of people on a field or tens of thousands in a stadium for Mass.
Aloysius Posted July 21, 2008 Posted July 21, 2008 are you all prepared to say that there is NOTHING in WYD that can be scandalizing? Come on now... it's not all bad but it's not all good either and this good priest recognizes the bad stuff and condemns the whole lot of it. all of these comments are very ironic... talking about how pride blinds him when you're all just having your pride hurt by his perspective (which is understandable albeit a bit overboard) on the way events like this go. I'm not saying he's right... but for God's sake recognize that there is a point to be made and he's not just some loon... disagree, but disagree respectfully rather than going off on some diatribe of anger and bitterness... you do realize this group is about 2 centimeters from coming back into full communion, right? and this is a singular priest with a singular attitude... I have met priests not affiliated with semi schismatic groups that have problems with many of the goings on at world youth day... heck, I have friends who have had hugely immoral times on world youth day trips because guess what? they immersed themselves in the large amount of secular activities and didn't really have to try AT ALL to avoid the religious parts, it's very easy. again, it's not that what he's saying is right... it's that what you all are saying ALSO isn't right.
Madame Vengier Posted July 21, 2008 Posted July 21, 2008 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1604248' date='Jul 20 2008, 09:22 PM']are you all prepared to say that there is NOTHING in WYD that can be scandalizing? Come on now... it's not all bad but it's not all good either and this good priest recognizes the bad stuff and condemns the whole lot of it. all of these comments are very ironic... talking about how pride blinds him when you're all just having your pride hurt by his perspective (which is understandable albeit a bit overboard) on the way events like this go. I'm not saying he's right... but for God's sake recognize that there is a point to be made and he's not just some loon... disagree, but disagree respectfully rather than going off on some diatribe of anger and bitterness... you do realize this group is about 2 centimeters from coming back into full communion, right? and this is a singular priest with a singular attitude... I have met priests not affiliated with semi schismatic groups that have problems with many of the goings on at world youth day... heck, I have friends who have had hugely immoral times on world youth day trips because guess what? they immersed themselves in the large amount of secular activities and didn't really have to try AT ALL to avoid the religious parts, it's very easy. again, it's not that what he's saying is right... it's that what you all are saying ALSO isn't right.[/quote] It would be really helpful if you pointed out who (or which comments) you are referring to when you say "what you all are saying". Do you mean all of us? Some of us? Parts of some of us? What?
dominicansoul Posted July 21, 2008 Posted July 21, 2008 I know there is plenty of things to speak of on this subject. I only object hearing it from a priest who is in disobedience to the Holy Father and the Church. I object hearing it from a schismatic. If they are so concerned with what we do, why did they leave???? ...the IRONY!
Madame Vengier Posted July 21, 2008 Posted July 21, 2008 [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1604262' date='Jul 20 2008, 09:43 PM']I know there is plenty of things to speak of on this subject. I only object hearing it from a priest who is in disobedience to the Holy Father and the Church. I object hearing it from a schismatic. If they are so concerned with what we do, why did they leave???? ...the IRONY![/quote] Bingo.
lilac_angel Posted July 21, 2008 Posted July 21, 2008 [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1603369' date='Jul 19 2008, 12:15 PM']I don't usally post in threads like this, mainly because I don't feel I have anything to contribute other than agreeing that yes, these people are in deep rebellion. But I had to touch on this one a bit. I totally and completely feel for some of the angst and disappoitment people like this are experiencing. I could not -- and with the Grace of God, will not -- ever leave the Church, but I do think that the cultural and theological war that is going on in the Church is extremely daunting and I can get where people feel like they just want to "go back to the way it was". Humans are more fragile than we know that we are and even the strongest can feel weakened by the constant state of dissension and chaos in the Church today and for the past 40-some-odd-years. So yeah, I get the rebellion. I don't condone it or agree with it, but I get it. I just think it's extremely unfortunate that they left the Church in order to make a point that the Church is in disarray. They would serve the Church FAR BETTER by joining forces with the true Church to defend her.[/quote] I completely agree.
lilac_angel Posted July 21, 2008 Posted July 21, 2008 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1604248' date='Jul 20 2008, 09:22 PM']you do realize this group is about 2 centimeters from coming back into full communion, right?[/quote] I sure hope so!!...that would rock...
Aloysius Posted July 21, 2008 Posted July 21, 2008 Cardinal Castrillon was pleased with Bishop Fellay's response to Rome's "ultimatum"... so yeah, 2 centimeters seems about right to me. Fellay's trying to get his house in order so that it's a whole package deal instead of the SSPX splitting in two with some coming back and others not, as well as trying to get clarification from Rome on some of the ambiguities of their offer... as he had no real problem with what they offered just had to understand the details that would be expected. sorry, I was directing my post mostly at the stuff the posts that seemed to go on a diatribe against the man and the SSPX, not at everyone. if I had to single anyone out, Raph's post qualifies most for what inspired my response. for the love of God, the state of the SSPX does not justify the level of outrage that is spewed at them every time one of them makes a comment... if an Eastern Orthodox priest said something similar to this and people responded to him the way they are responding to this SSPX priest, it'd be very clear that the anger is misplaced. but no one responds to Eastern Orthodox priests this way (except maybe, ironically, some rad-trads lol)... even though Eastern Orthodoxy is in formal schism whereas the status of the SSPX is simply that they are founded upon a schismatic act and are not back in full communion with Rome.
mortify Posted July 21, 2008 Posted July 21, 2008 [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1604262' date='Jul 20 2008, 09:43 PM']I know there is plenty of things to speak of on this subject. I only object hearing it from a priest who is in disobedience to the Holy Father and the Church. I object hearing it from a schismatic. If they are so concerned with what we do, why did they leave???? ...the IRONY![/quote] The question is whether we must always be obedient to our prelates. According to St Thomas there is only one case where a subject may publicly disobey their superior, and that is when the Faith is in danger. Archbishop Lefebvre and his followers call on this principle since in their opinion the pastoral and doctrinal changes after the Second Vatican Council endangered the faith. Since preservation of the Faith supersedes obedience and unity, they can't in good conscience remain in full union with the Vatican, because in their opinion that would mean going against the "eternal magesterium" or the ancient teachings and practices of the Church. So, certainly from their position criticizing WYD relates to many of their past criticisms. This is my understanding of the schismatic position, though I may be wrong.
lilac_angel Posted July 23, 2008 Posted July 23, 2008 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1604529' date='Jul 21 2008, 12:31 PM']Cardinal Castrillon was pleased with Bishop Fellay's response to Rome's "ultimatum"... so yeah, 2 centimeters seems about right to me. Fellay's trying to get his house in order so that it's a whole package deal instead of the SSPX splitting in two with some coming back and others not, as well as trying to get clarification from Rome on some of the ambiguities of their offer... as he had no real problem with what they offered just had to understand the details that would be expected.[/quote] Interesting... I stumbled across this recent interview today with Fellay, and I wasn't even looking for anything remotely tied to this... [url="http://wdtprs.com/blog/2008/07/angelus-interviews-with-sspx-excommd-bishops-part-i-fellay/"]http://wdtprs.com/blog/2008/07/angelus-int...-part-i-fellay/[/url] He doesn't seem too enthused about things in it, but hopefully it's just a front of pride and whatnot.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now