TotusTuusMaria Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 My cousin was married in the Church to a young woman last year. About two months after they married they got a divorce. He was 19 she was 21. They did not go through marriage preparation. No one even knew he was getting married until a week before the wedding. It was very, very odd. The Catholic priest just married them and didn't require anything from them. When he got the divorce his parents took care of most of the divorce stuff for him, and when asked if he got a divorce or an annulment he says he does not know. I know he just got a divorce though. There was no annulment. Now he is getting married again. He has been seeing this girl for a while and he loves her and she loves him. She is not Catholic. He is just going to marry her, I guess in either a civil ceremony or a ceremony with some form of Protestant preacher. My brother has been asked to be the best man, which makes things even stickier. Can I attend this "wedding" or not? Would it be a sin? Can my brother, who is a practicing Catholic, attend and take part in this "wedding."
EstoVir_TheWay_4 Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 I struggled with the idea of my cousin having a non-religious, outdoor wedding. Luckily, it turned out to be at least a Christian service. That still didn't change the fact that the open bar was the main attraction of the evening. It was depressing, but at the same time, at least their union was made before God. Even Protestants, can have a marriage under God. Just hope for the best, and if it turns out to be just a civil ceremony, just pretend you're at something else like a birthday. I woudn't consider going to that a sin. Is it a sin when you watch chick flicks with civil ceremony weddings at the end?
TotusTuusMaria Posted July 18, 2008 Author Posted July 18, 2008 (edited) [quote name='EstoVir_TheWay_4' post='1602590' date='Jul 18 2008, 07:51 AM']I struggled with the idea of my cousin having a non-religious, outdoor wedding. Luckily, it turned out to be at least a Christian service. That still didn't change the fact that the open bar was the main attraction of the evening. It was depressing, but at the same time, at least their union was made before God. Even Protestants, can have a marriage under God. Just hope for the best, and if it turns out to be just a civil ceremony, just pretend you're at something else like a birthday. I woudn't consider going to that a sin. Is it a sin when you watch chick flicks with civil ceremony weddings at the end?[/quote] It is really not the civil ceremony I am worried about the most. I have attended a Protestant-Christian Wedding service before. It is the idea that he does not have an annullment. That is really what I am struggling with. He is still married and then he is marrying this girl. Thanks for the post! Edited July 18, 2008 by TotusTuusMaria
EstoVir_TheWay_4 Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 You're welcome. I agree with and share your concern about this guy remarrying. It happens all the time, and not many people know that it's wrong to remarry. They don't fully realize that what they are doing takes away the fufilment of marriage. When marriage becomes less than unconditional, it destroys the trust and the covenant that the couple share, making marriage just "dating with added benefits + a tax break." It's very unfortunate.
cmotherofpirl Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 [quote name='TotusTuusMaria' post='1602570' date='Jul 18 2008, 05:07 AM']My cousin was married in the Church to a young woman last year. About two months after they married they got a divorce. He was 19 she was 21. They did not go through marriage preparation. No one even knew he was getting married until a week before the wedding. It was very, very odd. The Catholic priest just married them and didn't require anything from them. When he got the divorce his parents took care of most of the divorce stuff for him, and when asked if he got a divorce or an annulment he says he does not know. I know he just got a divorce though. There was no annulment. Now he is getting married again. He has been seeing this girl for a while and he loves her and she loves him. She is not Catholic. He is just going to marry her, I guess in either a civil ceremony or a ceremony with some form of Protestant preacher. My brother has been asked to be the best man, which makes things even stickier. Can I attend this "wedding" or not? Would it be a sin? Can my brother, who is a practicing Catholic, attend and take part in this "wedding."[/quote] Are you sure there was not an annulment? Considering there was no prep or formation it would probably not be hard to get. Are you sure it was a real catholic priest to start with? Why is there such a rush to remarry?
StColette Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1602652' date='Jul 18 2008, 10:46 AM']Are you sure there was not an annulment? Considering there was no prep or formation it would probably not be hard to get. Are you sure it was a real catholic priest to start with? Why is there such a rush to remarry?[/quote] I agree with Cmom. It's difficult to be absolutely certain that an annulment had not taken place. The lack of prep from a Priest or Deacon would make a huge case for an annulment, especially if the couple did not fully understand the gravity of the Sacrament of Marriage, nor what it means. Also, there are other reasons that an annulment could have been processed. If the girl or your cousin had been against having children at all and did not inform the other, this could be grounds for annulment. I agree with Cmom again as well on the fact that are we sure the person who married them was an actual priest?
CatherineM Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 My brother got married in front of a guy in a clerical collar, but he wasn't a Catholic priest, at least not anymore. I wouldn't view it as a valid first marriage, which means it wasn't valid from that point even if it takes years to actually come to the point where he seeks an annulment. When faced with a similar situation, I went to the wedding, but refused to be a member of the wedding party. I explained it very nicely, but wished them well anyway. She told me later that I was the only one who spoke up, but it stuck in her head, and after they started having kids, she took the steps to get her marriage properly blessed. It sounds as if your cousin has some serious immaturity issues, and I hate to say this, but not being married properly will make things easier to clean up later once he does grow up.
TotusTuusMaria Posted July 18, 2008 Author Posted July 18, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1602662' date='Jul 18 2008, 11:02 AM']I agree with Cmom. It's difficult to be absolutely certain that an annulment had not taken place. The lack of prep from a Priest or Deacon would make a huge case for an annulment, especially if the couple did not fully understand the gravity of the Sacrament of Marriage, nor what it means. Also, there are other reasons that an annulment could have been processed. If the girl or your cousin had been against having children at all and did not inform the other, this could be grounds for annulment. I agree with Cmom again as well on the fact that are we sure the person who married them was an actual priest?[/quote] It was an actual priest. He performs a lot of sacraments with out the prep usually required. My cousin and his wife are part of an ethnic group that lives in our diocese and the priest has always performed the sacraments for the group of more then 500 families with out any prep or anything. He does it, no questions asked. What he does is wrong, but ... it gets done anyway. I don't know how he handles other couples or people who come to him for sacraments, but for the last 10 or 15 years he has been performing these sacraments without the prep for this group of people. I also believe there are major grounds for annulment in this case and I do not believe the marriage was valid because of various reasons (both of them had drinking problems and more going into the marriage, there was something really fishy going on - in that they were just married with a two week notice and thrown into a "group" marriage where three couples were married by this priest at the same time. Neither of them truly comprehend the gravity of the Sacrament of Marriage and I truly believe neither of them had intentions of being open to life). However, they were married by the priest. When they split up two months later my cousin went to the priest and asked for an annulment. The priest told them that he didn't see a reason why they should get an annulment and that he would like to counsel them. They do not comprehend that an annulment is not given by the priest. They just walked away thinking they were not going to do counseling, they were finished, and they would just get a divorce because the Church was not being helpful in complying with them. They could have just gone to the diocese and asked for the application for an annulment, right? They don't know this. And honestly, I don't think they are interested. They have their divorce now, and they are just fine with that. They were not practicing Catholics to begin with... so an annulment is not important to them. However, they were married. It was a real priest. And as much as I think the marriage wasn't valid because of so many reasons - right now, we can't say that because the Church has to decide that and they have not given the Church the opportunity too. Now he is getting married again outside the Church. And I don't know what to do concerning if I should attend or not.
TotusTuusMaria Posted July 18, 2008 Author Posted July 18, 2008 I am for sure this priest is an actual priest. He has been serving in our diocese for years and is pastor of a parish in our diocese.
StColette Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 My advice would be this, if you feel that your being there could cause scandal to others, then I would not go.
TotusTuusMaria Posted July 18, 2008 Author Posted July 18, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1602717' date='Jul 18 2008, 12:33 PM']My advice would be this, if you feel that your being there could cause scandal to others, then I would not go.[/quote] See, I don't think anyone that is going to be there is going to care. I'm going to pray about it. Thanks for the advice, Colette.
LouisvilleFan Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 (edited) Can't say for sure without knowing them personally, but I probably wouldn't go. Annulment or not, he's displaying a pattern that shows disrespect for the sacrament of Marriage. What's to celebrate? If it turns out you're wrong, you can be there for the 25th anniversary party, or whatever. Edited July 18, 2008 by LouisvilleFan
cmotherofpirl Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 Did you go to the first one? I myself would not go, but tell them I love them and get an annulment. I would also write a letter to the bishop of the diocese pointing out there is no marriage prep and possibly not even valid marriages, with a copy to the papal nuncio.
StColette Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1602750' date='Jul 18 2008, 01:13 PM']I would also write a letter to the bishop of the diocese pointing out there is no marriage prep and possibly not even valid marriages, with a copy to the papal nuncio.[/quote]
Fr. Bruno Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1602750' date='Jul 18 2008, 08:13 PM']Did you go to the first one? I myself would not go, but tell them I love them and get an annulment. I would also write a letter to the bishop of the diocese pointing out there is no marriage prep and possibly not even valid marriages, with a copy to the papal nuncio.[/quote] I had the same idea : if a priest is not doing what the bishop expects him to do, then the bishop should no about it, especially when there are consequences that dramatic.
Fr. Bruno Posted July 18, 2008 Posted July 18, 2008 I just thought about the attitude of saint Thomas More regarding Henry's marriage : if I remember well, he refused to assist... I would recommend to talk to your brother first, in order to find out more, if possible, and eventually try to ask some good questions or to give some wise advice. And not go unless he agrees to undertake the necessary steps for a recognized marriage.
TotusTuusMaria Posted July 18, 2008 Author Posted July 18, 2008 [quote name='Fr. Bruno' post='1602792' date='Jul 18 2008, 02:48 PM']I had the same idea : if a priest is not doing what the bishop expects him to do, then the bishop should no about it, especially when there are consequences that dramatic.[/quote] I wouldn't know what to say or where to start. I don't know if it is my place to point that out. I am 18. And I don't have a lot of evidence. I can just say "Hey, this priest has been doing this." But I have no hard evidence besides the testimony of the group of people, and they absolutely LOVE that priest because he does this for them. All of them have been married by him and their children have been baptized by him. I just feel so overwhelmed with the idea of writing the Bishop and the papal nuncio about this in such a way. I know what is happening is wrong... but... I wouldn't know what to do.
TotusTuusMaria Posted July 18, 2008 Author Posted July 18, 2008 [quote name='Fr. Bruno' post='1602793' date='Jul 18 2008, 02:53 PM']I just thought about the attitude of saint Thomas More regarding Henry's marriage : if I remember well, he refused to assist... I would recommend to talk to your brother first, in order to find out more, if possible, and eventually try to ask some good questions or to give some wise advice. And not go unless he agrees to undertake the necessary steps for a recognized marriage.[/quote] Thank you Father for this advice. I appreciate it.
Maria Posted July 19, 2008 Posted July 19, 2008 If you're going to write the letter, don't put down what this priest is doing, especially since everyone else loves it. Instead point out the advantages that having the prep would give. And write to the priest first. Something like, thank you for exercising your ministry for us, and wouldn't it be wonderful if, through prep, these couples and families were able to get so much more out of your ministry, etc.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now