Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Communion In Independent Catholic Church?


Recommended Posts

Guest WeingartDude
Posted

I have a question. A good friend of mine attends an independent non-Roman Catholic church. Sometimes I attend a mass with him at his Church just to shop support. In fact I never let that mass count as my Sunday obligation. What is the teaching regarding me, a Roman Catholic receiving communion in his Church? I know the teaching regarding receiving communion in a protestant church and vise versa but is an independent Catholic Church considered protestant? In fact the independent Catholics believe the same way we do in regards to the Blessed Sacrament. I would appreciate any answers!

While I'm at it...thought I would always seek the sacrament of penance from a Roman Catholic confessor...what does our Church teach in regards to the sacrament of Penance in an independent Catholic Church?

Thanks for your help!

PaX Christi!
Eddie Weingart

<>< "Follow Me" - XP

CatholicCid
Posted

A Priest needs faculties from the local Bishop to hear confessions. I'm assuming an independent Catholic Church isn't actually in Communion with the Church, so the local Bishop would grant them faculties.

Posted

I know that others on phatmass will let you know more about this, but I attended, for a short time, some services at an independent catholic church...believe it was called an American Catholic. It was interesting, and I went to support a friend, who I was happy was attending ANY church. It never felt right to me. I recieved their communion, but I did not believe in my heart it was the TRUE body and blood of our Lord. They had woman priests, and they were both lesbian.
It was interesting, but did not appeal to me. I do not think confessing there would be a good idea. It is not Roman catholic and do not have the same rules.
On the other hand, the leaders were very interested in the people and gave some great sermons. They had some great fellowship among them and a true caring. Also the congragation was small, only about 15 people attended, so I really liked that. Our Mass is jam packed, far too many people.
Just know where your heart lies, be sure of your faith. Like I said, I just never felt that this was 'authentic' so stopped going.

melporcristo
Posted

JMJ

I wouldn't recieve communion at this church, nor confession. Just like what CatholicCid said, if it ain't reppin the Pope, don't even mess with it.

CoffeeCatholic
Posted

Catholic churches not in communion with Rome that have a proper understanding of holy orders do have the true presence. These include most Greek and Russian Orthodox churches. Your pastor can tell you more specifically which ones. At these churches, if you are obliged to go (there are no other churches in communion with Rome in the area) you may receive communion. However, you probably will be denied the sacrament as most priests in these denominations do not look kindly on Roman Catholics.

However, any other Catholic church not in communion with Rome- like the Anglican Catholic for instance- that does not have a proper understanding of holy orders does not have the sacrament of Holy Eucharist. Therefore you should not receive communion at these communities. In fact, unless you are going with the express purpose of attempting to bring your friend into the one true church, you shouldn't really be attending, but then again, I'm not your spiritual director. If you have received communion, be sure to go to confession before receiving the Eucharist at your church.

homeschoolmom
Posted

How can a church be both "independent" and "catholic" at the same time?

CatholicCid
Posted (edited)

[quote name='CatholicCid' post='1605721' date='Jul 23 2008, 12:01 AM']A Priest needs faculties from the local Bishop to hear confessions. I'm assuming an independent Catholic Church isn't actually in Communion with the Church, [b]so the local Bishop would grant them faculties[/b].[/quote]

Typo: so the local Bishop wouldn't grant them faculties. (Confessions aren't valid).

Edited by CatholicCid
Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1605859' date='Jul 23 2008, 09:26 AM']How can a church be both "independent" and "catholic" at the same time?[/quote]


Independent Catholic Churches are also known to us as the Old Catholic Church.

homeschoolmom
Posted

Yes, I know, but how can a church call itself "independent" (meaning "we are on our own") and "catholic" (meaning "universal"). It's an oxymoron.

Posted

20 years ago in my old testament class, there was a priest from the Ecumenical Catholic Church who invited me to come see his service. It seemed very high church, almost Byzantine, but I found out later that almost everyone there was gay. I remembered thinking at the time that I hoped no one I knew saw me coming out of the place. And no, I didn't receive communion there. I went out of curiosity more than anything. We had a ceremony for the pastoral ministry program in the pastoral center that the archbishop was presiding at, and this priest was invited, but the nun who was director of the program asked him to please not wear a clerical collar because she was afraid the archbishop would see him, and ask him to come up and co-celebrate. I think she was afraid of having to answer too many questions.

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1605975' date='Jul 23 2008, 11:34 AM']Yes, I know, but how can a church call itself "independent" (meaning "we are on our own") and "catholic" (meaning "universal"). It's an oxymoron.[/quote]

I've never heard them called Independent. I've always known them as Old Catholics. They have very liberal Theology. Micah and I were discussing them a few days ago. If I remember correctly he said that they are considered heretics and do not have valid sacraments.

WeingartDude, if that is true, that they are heretics which I believe I remember correctly, then I would avoid going to their church altogether. It could put yourself in the danger of causing scandal to fellow faithful Catholics. It could also give the Old Catholics the impression that you approve of their heresy, which as a Catholic you should not.

edited for clarification.

homeschoolmom
Posted

If you're addressing me, I don't.

Posted

Because the Church claims to be "independant" of Rome, they are in schism, and therefore are not "in communion" with Rome. If they are not "in communion" with Rome, then you cannot receive communion from them. So long as their priests are ordained by a validly consecrated bishop, their sacraments are valid, but you should not partake in these sacraments, unless in dire need (ie. imminent death).

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1606035' date='Jul 23 2008, 12:34 PM']If you're addressing me, I don't.[/quote]


Wasn't addressing you lol was addressing the topic in general lol

Posted

[quote name='mommas_boy' post='1606037' date='Jul 23 2008, 12:36 PM']Because the Church claims to be "independant" of Rome, they are in schism, and therefore are not "in communion" with Rome. If they are not "in communion" with Rome, then you cannot receive communion from them. So long as their priests are ordained by a validly consecrated bishop, their sacraments are valid, but you should not partake in these sacraments, unless in dire need (ie. imminent death).[/quote]

As I stated above, if I remember correctly this group isn't only schismatic but is heretical. They have no issue with ordaining women to the priesthood or diaconate. And they have ordained women to the priesthood and diaconate

Posted

had one in our diocese.

They believed the Pope was the Anti-Christ, but were posers and trying to get Catholics to go to their church, claiming everything was legit.

We were told by priests, (Bishop told them to tell parishoners) during announcements at Mass to take precaution (from their "church" and their "catholic shoppe") and that they were not in line with the Church. Also, the fact that the "founder" or whatever would go around telling people the Pope was the Anti-Christ kinda gave it away too. :club:

But man, they sold beautiful statues. Too bad. I couldn't support them.

Posted

[quote name='StColette' post='1606064' date='Jul 23 2008, 01:04 PM']As I stated above, if I remember correctly this group isn't only schismatic but is heretical. They have no issue with ordaining women to the priesthood or diaconate. And they have ordained women to the priesthood and diaconate[/quote]

Thank you. You are correct. I didn't read the whole thread like I should have, but instead just posted a reply.

Last I checked (and please correct me if I'm wrong), there is no heresy in the ordination of women to the [b]diaconite[/b], though? Is this correct?

[url="http://www.usccb.org/comm/archives/2003/03-133.shtml"]http://www.usccb.org/comm/archives/2003/03-133.shtml[/url]

"The ordination of women to the diaconate through the laying-on-of-hands by the bishop is also known in the Armenian Church, but it has almost died out in recent years. There are plans in Armenia and elsewhere to revive this ministry. Historically this was a local phenomenon never dispersed throughout the church, and women deacons always had a range of duties more narrowly defined than that of men deacons."

But this is the [b]Armenian[/b] Church. But I'm assuming that they are Eastern Rite Catholics?

I'm able to find other sources as well, but nothing as reputable as the USCCB. I fully accept Church teaching in all regards, and I'm curious if there is heresy in ordination of women to the diaconate. Thank you.

Posted

[quote name='mommas_boy' post='1606106' date='Jul 23 2008, 01:43 PM']Thank you. You are correct. I didn't read the whole thread like I should have, but instead just posted a reply.

Last I checked (and please correct me if I'm wrong), there is no heresy in the ordination of women to the [b]diaconite[/b], though? Is this correct?

[url="http://www.usccb.org/comm/archives/2003/03-133.shtml"]http://www.usccb.org/comm/archives/2003/03-133.shtml[/url]

"The ordination of women to the diaconate through the laying-on-of-hands by the bishop is also known in the Armenian Church, but it has almost died out in recent years. There are plans in Armenia and elsewhere to revive this ministry. Historically this was a local phenomenon never dispersed throughout the church, and women deacons always had a range of duties more narrowly defined than that of men deacons."

But this is the [b]Armenian[/b] Church. But I'm assuming that they are Eastern Rite Catholics?

I'm able to find other sources as well, but nothing as reputable as the USCCB. I fully accept Church teaching in all regards, and I'm curious if there is heresy in ordination of women to the diaconate. Thank you.[/quote]

The Church does not allow nor will it ever the ordination of women to the diaconate because the diaconate is part of Holy Orders.

I really hope they are only referring to the ancient term of deaconess as it is properly known. A deaconess during ancient times was not ordained to the Sacrament of Holy Orders. She did assist the priest with the baptism of women because during that time baptisms were done completely nude (the person receiving baptism not the priest). For modesty sake, a deaconess was there for that reason. Now, today we don't do baptisms in the nude so the need for a deaconess is not there. And remember they were not seen as ordained into the Holy Orders.

According to the Catechism of the Catholic Church

Those who may receive Holy Orders (which means priesthood, bishop, or diaconate) are

[b]1577[/b] "Only a baptized man ([i]vir[/i]) validly receives sacred ordination."[sup]66[/sup] The Lord Jesus chose men ([i]viri[/i]) to form the college of the twelve apostles, and the apostles did the same when they chose collaborators to succeed them in their ministry.[sup]67[/sup] The college of bishops, with whom the priests are united in the priesthood, makes the college of the twelve an ever-present and ever-active reality until Christ's return. The Church recognizes herself to be bound by this choice made by the Lord himself. For this reason the ordination of women is not possible.[sup]68[/sup]

Posted (edited)

[quote name='StColette' post='1606119' date='Jul 23 2008, 01:55 PM']The Church does not allow nor will it ever the ordination of women to the diaconate because the diaconate is part of Holy Orders.[/quote]

Thank you for the clarification.

[quote name='StColette' post='1606119' date='Jul 23 2008, 01:55 PM']I really hope they are only referring to the ancient term of deaconess as it is properly known.[/quote]

I don't know, but they seem to be referring to something formalized:

[quote name='mommas_boy' post='1606106' date='Jul 23 2008, 01:43 PM']"[b]The ordination of women to the diaconate through the laying-on-of-hands by the bishop[/b] is also known in the Armenian Church, but it has almost died out in recent years.[/quote]

Emphasis being on the "laying-on-of-hands by the bishop". Perhaps they don't mean to suggest that this is of sacramental character? That is, they are servants that are [b]commissioned[/b] through the laying-on-of-hands, but that no indelible mark is imposed through the action. Still, it's confusing and misleading.

Edited by mommas_boy
Posted

[quote name='mommas_boy' post='1606130' date='Jul 23 2008, 02:02 PM']Emphasis being on the "laying-on-of-hands by the bishop". Perhaps they don't mean to suggest that this is of sacramental character? Still, it's confusing and misleading.[/quote]

The Coptic Church seems to be going with the idea of the more ancient form of the job of a deaconess

"In their ministry they are to work exclusively with women and children. They assist at the baptism of women, visit sick women in hospitals, supervise women’s activities in parishes, and clean the church building except for the sanctuary area which they may not enter. "

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...