RosaMystica Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 I just got this article in an e-mail and it pretty much made my blood boil. It makes me wonder if these "crtics" actually read Humane Vitae or Theology of the Body because they sound so ignorant, especially that last remark at the end of the article. I also hate it when NFP is called the rhythm method!! Anyway, I posted the article below for anyone who wants to read it: [indent]Critics Urge Pope to Lift Birth Control Ban ROME (July 25) - More than 50 dissident Catholic groups published an unusually frank open letter to Pope Benedict on Friday saying the Church's ban on contraception has been "catastrophic" and urging him to lift it. The letter was published as a paid half-page advertisement in Corriere della Sera, Italy's largest newspaper, on the 40th anniversary of the late Pope Paul VI's controversial encyclical "Humanae Vitae," which enshrined the ban. While criticism of the Vatican and its views is fairly common in articles and editorials in Italian newspapers, it is unusual for a group to take out paid advertising against the pope, particularly in a large-circulation mainstream newspaper. The letter, written in Italian, said the Church's anti-contraception policy "has had a catastrophic impact on the poor and powerless around the world, endangering women's lives and leaving millions at risk of HIV." It also said that 40 years on, the encyclical continued to be "a source of great conflict and division in the Church" and because most Catholics use contraception and feel they are not sinning, the policy has been "an utter failure." Pope Paul's encyclical, written in 1968, has been defended by his successors John Paul and Benedict. The Church teaches that nothing should block the possible transmission of life and approves only natural methods of birth control such as the rhythm method, in which a couple abstain from intercourse during a woman's fertile time. Paul's encyclical, written at the height of the 1960s sexual revolution, is perhaps the most controversial and divisive in modern Church history. As recently as last May, Benedict defended the encyclical as far-sighted and said it was "all too often misunderstood and misinterpreted." 'GIFT OF LIFE' At the time, Benedict said love between a married couple could not "remain closed to the gift of life." The letter was signed by groups such as Catholics for Choice, which is U.S. based, We Are Church, which has branches in numerous countries, and New Ways Ministry, which helps minister to gay Catholics. "We thought the establishment in Rome and the Vatican pay close attention to the Italian media and the letter would be seen by the people to whom we want to deliver this message," Jon O'Brien, president of Catholics for Choice, told Reuters by telephone from Washington. The Vatican said it would likely issue a statement on the letter later on Friday. "It is clear to us that the Catholic church cannot move forward until it honestly confronts the paradox of Humanae Vitae," the letter said. "Most Catholics use modern contraceptives, believe it is a moral choice to do so and consider themselves Catholics in good standing, yet the Catholic hierarchy completely denies this reality, forcing the clergy into silence on this and most other issues related to sexuality," it said. The letter concluded: "Pope Benedict, we call on you to use to use this anniversary as an opportunity to start the process of healing by being true to the positive aspects of Catholic teachings on sexuality and lifting the ban on contraception to allow Catholics to plan their families safely and in good conscience."[/indent] [url="http://news.aol.com/article/critics-urge-pope-to-lift-birth-control/100609"]http://news.aol.com/article/critics-urge-p...-control/100609[/url]
Barbarus Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 I was literally [i]just going to post[/i] that today is the anniversary. A fascinating encyclical, and the response to it has been equally fascinating.
Lil Red Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 +J.M.J.+ seriously, these people just don't get it. prayers for them. question, did they happen to attach their names to it?
Ash Wednesday Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 I always felt like Pope Paul VI kind of got the short end of the stick from a lot of people. He had to put up with a lot of whining from radical liberals and heterodox traditionals alike.
Fr. Bruno Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 [quote name='MandyKhatoon' post='1608418' date='Jul 25 2008, 09:59 PM'][indent]... The letter concluded: "Pope Benedict, we call on you to use to use this anniversary as an opportunity to start the process of healing by being true to the positive aspects of Catholic teachings on sexuality and lifting the ban on contraception to allow Catholics to plan their families safely and in good conscience."[/indent] [url="http://news.aol.com/article/critics-urge-pope-to-lift-birth-control/100609"]http://news.aol.com/article/critics-urge-p...-control/100609[/url][/quote] " Father, forgive them, for they don't know what they are doing " (Luke, 23:34)
Apotheoun Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 The Latin Church's Oakland Diocese is more interested in "preaching" about the LGBTQ community than about [i]Humanae Vitae[/i].
Vincent Vega Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 [quote name='MandyKhatoon' post='1608418' date='Jul 25 2008, 01:59 PM']...and lifting the ban on contraception to allow Catholics to plan their families safely and in good conscience.[/quote] Yeah, let's change the rules so people can do what they want and not have to feel guilty. We'd hate people to feel guilty, right? Let's just rearrange things a little so they can do as they wish and not have to feel like they've got a dirty conscience. Give me a break, people. Plus, they're not even really Catholic. What do they care what the Pope thinks?
Archaeology cat Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1608431' date='Jul 25 2008, 08:19 PM']+J.M.J.+ seriously, these people just don't get it. prayers for them.[/quote] I know! I just don't understand it. I mean, I do understand it, because I used to think like that, but I can't imagine it now. Not now that I know what the Church teaches & why, and know what contraceptives really [b]do[/b]. Hmm, well, going back to reading the book I just got: The Billings Method. My other course materials should arrive soon (becoming certified to teach BOM).
thessalonian Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 B16 just sung the praises of HV in May so I don't think this will have much effect. Happy b-day to you, happy b-day to you, happy b-day HV. Happy b-day 2 you. AND MANY MORE!!!!
Archaeology cat Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 (edited) [quote name='thessalonian' post='1608509' date='Jul 25 2008, 10:34 PM']B16 just sung the praises of HV in May so I don't think this will have much effect. Happy b-day to you, happy b-day to you, happy b-day HV. Happy b-day 2 you. AND MANY MORE!!!![/quote] Quite true. And nice little ditty there. Edited July 25, 2008 by Archaeology cat
RosaMystica Posted July 25, 2008 Author Posted July 25, 2008 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1608431' date='Jul 25 2008, 04:19 PM']+J.M.J.+ seriously, these people just don't get it. prayers for them. question, did they happen to attach their names to it?[/quote] I didn't see names attached to this article but I do imagine that they did attach their names to actual letter given to the Pope.
Didacus Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 [quote name='Fr. Bruno' post='1608470' date='Jul 25 2008, 03:25 PM']" Father, forgive them, for they don't know what they are doing " (Luke, 23:34)[/quote] Yes, I agree, with tears in my eyes. They do more wrong to themselves than the wrong they intend to others. The more HV is opposed, the more I grow convinced that it was just what the world needed, at the the right time, just as the Holy Spirit intended.
CatherineM Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 The anniversary is a perfect time to educate. I truthfully believe that inadequate catechesis is the root of a bunch of the church's problems, and HV is a perfect example. Everyone seems to know it is opposed to things like the pill, but they don't read it or study it long enough to understand why.
Didacus Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1608489' date='Jul 25 2008, 03:55 PM'][snip] Plus, they're not even really Catholic. What do they care what the Pope thinks?[/quote] My brother, I find you in error. They are catholic. The baptism leaves an indelible mark that cannot be erased. They are dissenting - yes I'll give you that nad invite you to pity them or have compassion for them. But they are catholic, they are amongst the people of God, and they are our brothers and sisters andit is an error to deny this, even a sin I would add.
Didacus Posted July 25, 2008 Posted July 25, 2008 Does anyone else fell a discomfort at using the acronym HV which is spookingly close to HIV? I don't know, maybe I'm just being childish avbout this. It happens to me sometimes. Back to you Bob...
cmotherofpirl Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 [quote name='MandyKhatoon' post='1608418' date='Jul 25 2008, 03:59 PM']I just got this article in an e-mail and it pretty much made my blood boil. It makes me wonder if these "crtics" actually read Humane Vitae or Theology of the Body because they sound so ignorant, especially that last remark at the end of the article. I also hate it when NFP is called the rhythm method!! Anyway, I posted the article below for anyone who wants to read it: [indent]Critics Urge Pope to Lift Birth Control Ban ROME (July 25) - More than 50 dissident Catholic groups published an unusually frank open letter to Pope Benedict on Friday saying the Church's ban on contraception has been "catastrophic" and urging him to lift it. The letter was published as a paid half-page advertisement in Corriere della Sera, Italy's largest newspaper, on the 40th anniversary of the late Pope Paul VI's controversial encyclical "Humanae Vitae," which enshrined the ban. While criticism of the Vatican and its views is fairly common in articles and editorials in Italian newspapers, it is unusual for a group to take out paid advertising against the pope, particularly in a large-circulation mainstream newspaper. The letter, written in Italian, said the Church's anti-contraception policy "has had a catastrophic impact on the poor and powerless around the world, endangering women's lives and leaving millions at risk of HIV." It also said that 40 years on, the encyclical continued to be "a source of great conflict and division in the Church" and because most Catholics use contraception and feel they are not sinning, the policy has been "an utter failure." Pope Paul's encyclical, written in 1968, has been defended by his successors John Paul and Benedict. The Church teaches that nothing should block the possible transmission of life and approves only natural methods of birth control such as the rhythm method, in which a couple abstain from intercourse during a woman's fertile time. Paul's encyclical, written at the height of the 1960s sexual revolution, is perhaps the most controversial and divisive in modern Church history. As recently as last May, Benedict defended the encyclical as far-sighted and said it was "all too often misunderstood and misinterpreted." 'GIFT OF LIFE' At the time, Benedict said love between a married couple could not "remain closed to the gift of life." The letter was signed by groups such as Catholics for Choice, which is U.S. based, We Are Church, which has branches in numerous countries, and New Ways Ministry, which helps minister to gay Catholics. "We thought the establishment in Rome and the Vatican pay close attention to the Italian media and the letter would be seen by the people to whom we want to deliver this message," Jon O'Brien, president of Catholics for Choice, told Reuters by telephone from Washington. The Vatican said it would likely issue a statement on the letter later on Friday. "It is clear to us that the Catholic church cannot move forward until it honestly confronts the paradox of Humanae Vitae," the letter said. "Most Catholics use modern contraceptives, believe it is a moral choice to do so and consider themselves Catholics in good standing, yet the Catholic hierarchy completely denies this reality, forcing the clergy into silence on this and most other issues related to sexuality," it said. The letter concluded: "Pope Benedict, we call on you to use to use this anniversary as an opportunity to start the process of healing by being true to the positive aspects of Catholic teachings on sexuality and lifting the ban on contraception to allow Catholics to plan their families safely and in good conscience."[/indent] [url="http://news.aol.com/article/critics-urge-pope-to-lift-birth-control/100609"]http://news.aol.com/article/critics-urge-p...-control/100609[/url][/quote] They are right about the effect on the church, most people did and do feel the church has no business in their bedroom, so they simply started using condoms or the pill and stopped going to confession. These people still do consider themselves good catholics.
RosaMystica Posted July 26, 2008 Author Posted July 26, 2008 Well, just because they think that they are Catholics in good standing with the Church it doesn't mean that they are. Also, has anyone listened to Dr. Janet E. Smith's CD, "Contraception Why Not?" She explains so well why contraception is wrong and it's consequences and why the Church doesn't allow any type of artificial contraception. Didacus- I don't feel uncomfortable using the acronym HV just because it's close to the acronym HIV. I think that if all people practiced the teachings of HV in their lives then we wouldn't see HIV as prevelant often as we do now
Vincent Vega Posted July 26, 2008 Posted July 26, 2008 [quote name='Didacus' post='1608583' date='Jul 25 2008, 06:54 PM']My brother, I find you in error. They are catholic. The baptism leaves an indelible mark that cannot be erased. They are dissenting - yes I'll give you that nad invite you to pity them or have compassion for them. But they are catholic, they are amongst the people of God, and they are our brothers and sisters andit is an error to deny this, even a sin I would add.[/quote] I sincerely appreciate your admonishment. Would they not be separated brethren, though? If they don't adhere to the teachings of the Magisterium, how are they different from the WomenPriest movement, or those who are admittedly protestant Christians? (Serious questions)
Didacus Posted July 27, 2008 Posted July 27, 2008 [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1608944' date='Jul 25 2008, 11:43 PM']I sincerely appreciate your admonishment. Would they not be separated brethren, though? If they don't adhere to the teachings of the Magisterium, how are they different from the WomenPriest movement, or those who are admittedly protestant Christians? (Serious questions)[/quote] Even the 'woman-priests' remain catholics although excommunicated ones. And I don't know about separated brethen, but certainly brethens in error and affected by sin. Please note we are al in error and affected by sin. Saying things like 'they are not catholics' or 'not real catholics' supposes a rejection of them by the Church, which is absolutely not the case and the lack of distinction in such instance forms an opportunity that anti-catholics use on a regular basis; 'the catholic Church rejects homosexuals' is a common example. I think we need to be dilligent on how we say things and what/when we throw words around - they do havea tendency to come back to us you know.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now