Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What Constitutes 'grave Matter'?


Recommended Posts

CatholicCid
Posted (edited)

Well, we know that for one to mortally sin, three conditions have to be met: One has to have full knowledge of the sin, freely choose to sin, and the sin in question has to constitute a grave matter. These first two conditions seem to be quite clear. If one or more of these conditions is not met, a person has commited a venial sin.

My question is, what exactly defines grave matter?


My thoughts:

Looking at the question with a bit of scrupples, it always seems that any sin constitutes grave matter. Regardless of the specifics, you are still going against God, cutting at your relationship with him. How can such actions not be grave?

Or you can attempt to look at the sin itself compared to natural law and the commandments. If you have not broken one of the major laws, how can the matter be considered grave? While it may be implied that such an action is sinful and wrong, if it has not be revealed and recorded as inherently wrong, it would seem a less servere matter.

You can also give it a subjective viewpoint, that the gravity of an action depends entirely on the person commiting the action. The seriousness of the action depends soley on the individual and the circumstances surrounding the event.

I think I generally combine the previous two thoughts, that there is a natural law that always constitutes grave matter, yet that the rest of the spectra depends on the individual. What might be the smallest venial sin for one farthest from the Church could seem the greatest mortal sin from one closest to God.

When examing my own conscience, though, I admit I fall hardly into scrupples. Looking at the call to holiness we are to strive for, and seeing everywhere I fall under a microscope, every act always seems to be a very grave matter. Every action harms my relationship with God, and that itself is enough to constitute all sin a grave matter. At times, I cannot even seperate actions that can put one in temptation's path to mortal sin, to the mortal sin itself. However, I know that I am flawed when discerning my own actions. How do you constitute grave matter?

The Church calls us to examine our conscience before approaching Communion, so it is a question we must consider quite frequently.

Edited by CatholicCid
Posted

If you want to know what sins are grave I would consult the the Catechism of the Catholic Church, a document of the Magisterium or a moral theology book.

  • 3 weeks later...
Saint Therese
Posted

The real question is: What constitutes dark matter?

Posted (edited)

Anything that would destroy the charity between God and you or possibly God and another person is grave matter.

Quite simply put, making something the god of your life in place of God is grave matter. For instance, sex before marriage is a disordering of goods in your life so great that you have replaced God as your Supreme Good and have sought sex in such a manner.

The ten commandments are a great resource for knowing what constitutes grave matter, and from there we can see what sins can be mortal sins.

Here is a simple chart:

God = Supreme Good of your life
^
various other goods ordered under Him
(e.g. obedience to parents)
(e.g. reading a book for fun)
(e.g. earning money)

An sinful act is one in which you have destroyed the order of goods. For example, if you were reading something frivolous after your parents told you to go to bed, this is probably a sinful act. Reading is a good act in itself, but doing it when your parents tell you know is a disordering of how that act should be used (as is hinted by the fourth commandment).

A mortal sin is when you have greatly disordered your goods or have replaced God as your highest good. If you were to make your life completely about earning money, you have replaced God at the top.

If this makes it more confusing I'll try to clean up what I said.

Edited by qfnol31
Posted

How about the 10 commandments and the 7 deadly sins. That will cover most of the biggies.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...