Vincent Vega Posted July 30, 2008 Posted July 30, 2008 Quick question: Does it say anywhere in the bible NOT to pray to saints/angels/Mary/so forth? Thanks, Mitch
CatherineM Posted July 30, 2008 Posted July 30, 2008 Off the top of my head only Exodus 20:4-5, but here's some that say the opposite. Joshua 5:14, Daniel 8:17, Tobit 12:16, Matthew 18:10, 2Kings 13:20-21, Acts 19:11-12, Exodus 25:18-19, Numbers 21:8-9, 1Kings 6:23-29, 1Kings 7:25-45, Romans 15:30, Col 4:3, 1Thess 5:25, 2Th 1:11; 3:1, Eph 6:18-19, Tobit 12:12, Rev 5:8, Mark 9:4, Luke 16:19-30, Wisdom 3:1-6
Vincent Vega Posted July 30, 2008 Author Posted July 30, 2008 Great, thanks Miss Catherine (Back to the spiritual battlefields with this newfound ammo)
thessalonian Posted July 30, 2008 Posted July 30, 2008 Ex 20 doesn't actually say "don't pray to them". We also have to consider that the word pray, like every other word in English has many meanings. So the meaning is always important. Matt 23:2 says call no man father... Protestants often use this to say we shouldn't call preists father. But then of course they are willing (and rightly so) to qualify it and say "well in the case of your physical father you can". But then they fail to recognize that Paul calls himself father in the spiritual context in 1 Cor 4:15 or therebouts. So one must figure out what Jesus really meant when he said call no man father. In context it seems to indicate that God is ultimate fatherhood and all fatherhood must be subordinate to his. With prayer there certainly is a context in which we should not pray to anyone but God alone. Yet when we pray to the saints and Mary we know that they can do nothing for us except by the grace (power) of God. What they do is subordiante to and dependent on him. There is no usurping his role as the scribes and pharasees did in Matt 23. Some protestants bring up when Jesus taught his disciples to pray he said "when you pray say Our Father who art in heaven...". This is of course problematic because it rules out calling out to Jesus or to the Holy Spirit. Hope that helps.
rckllnknny Posted August 1, 2008 Posted August 1, 2008 [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prayer"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prayer[/url] general overview/ but provides a good point..
Theosopher Posted August 5, 2008 Posted August 5, 2008 No it does not. While there are much deeper theological meanings, to "pray" can essentially mean to make a request. For example, when I write a legal pleading, I end it with something like this: "WHEREFORE, Plaintiff prays that this Court render judgment in his favour..." or "WHEREFORE, Defendant prays that this case be dismissed..." Does that mean I am worshipping the Court? Clearly not - though some Courts seem to feel that they deserve to be worshipped. I am making a request to the Court. When we "pray" to a saint, we are talking with them, conversing with them, telling them things that are important to us, but mainly we are making a request. We're asking for their help, for them to pray for us, for their intercession, for their guidance, et cetera. In this sense, it is no more wrong to "pray" to a saint (that is, making a request of him or her) than it is for me to make a request of a court.
Vincent Vega Posted August 7, 2008 Author Posted August 7, 2008 [quote name='Theosopher' post='1617836' date='Aug 5 2008, 12:30 AM']No it does not. While there are much deeper theological meanings, to "pray" can essentially mean to make a request. For example, when I write a legal pleading, I end it with something like this: "WHEREFORE, Plaintiff prays that this Court render judgment in his favour..." or "WHEREFORE, Defendant prays that this case be dismissed..." Does that mean I am worshipping the Court? Clearly not - though some Courts seem to feel that they deserve to be worshipped. I am making a request to the Court. When we "pray" to a saint, we are talking with them, conversing with them, telling them things that are important to us, but mainly we are making a request. We're asking for their help, for them to pray for us, for their intercession, for their guidance, et cetera. In this sense, it is no more wrong to "pray" to a saint (that is, making a request of him or her) than it is for me to make a request of a court.[/quote] Yes, I understand this, and I can explain pretty well, but some people refuse to believe things unless they're explicitly stated in the bible. ( which is ridiculous, considering that things like sola scriptura and the word "bible" are not in the bible, yet these people have no problem believing those things...sorry, another topic).
Nihil Obstat Posted August 8, 2008 Posted August 8, 2008 [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1619830' date='Aug 6 2008, 09:25 PM']Yes, I understand this, and I can explain pretty well, but some people refuse to believe things unless they're explicitly stated in the bible. ( which is ridiculous, considering that things like sola scriptura and the word "bible" are not in the bible, yet these people have no problem believing those things...sorry, another topic).[/quote] Speaking of which, what about those last two verses in the gospel of John? Does that not SPECIFICALLY say that you can't find everything in the Bible? Something like "and if all the things Jesus did were written down, I don't believe that every book in the world could contain the writings." or something along those lines? I'm too lazy to pull up vatican.va to check though.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now