Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

When It Becomes Wrong To Teach Catholicism In A Catholic Church...


Recommended Posts

Brother Adam
Posted

I apologize that I have to be vague about the details of this, but it was brought to my attention today that someone I go to graduate school with is being forced to resign as a youth minister over teaching her senior high school students that Jesus is fully God and fully man. Apparently this doctrine is far too much above the heads of high school students. She was formerly shielded by a good priest but her parish just got a new priest who is as "liberal" as the DRE. Please pray for this person.

homeschoolmom
Posted
:blink: Above the heads of HSers? Isn't it above the heads of us all? Doesn't make it unteachable.
Brother Adam
Posted

We teach it in 1st grade here...

homeschoolmom
Posted

Yeah... silly.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='1614481' date='Jul 31 2008, 09:45 PM']I apologize that I have to be vague about the details of this, but it was brought to my attention today that someone I go to graduate school with is being forced to resign as a youth minister over teaching her senior high school students that Jesus is fully God and fully man. Apparently this doctrine is far too much above the heads of high school students. She was formerly shielded by a good priest but her parish just got a new priest who is as "liberal" as the DRE. Please pray for this person.[/quote]
Sounds like we need to pray for the priest , parish and diocese as well.
Is this a "going to the bish" kind of deal?

HisChildForever
Posted

This sounds insane.

Posted

I'm speechless (which is rare), and angry. I was afraid my school was starting to go down that path, but the new Archbishop has recently fired 3 liberal professors, and put an orthodox priest in as dean. When stuff like this happens, you have to complain up the chain of command until someone orthodox listens.

Posted

GAAH! Above their heads?

Prayers :(

lilac_angel
Posted

Sounds like they're on the verge of heresy... I mean, if they refuse to teach that simple truth about Jesus ...

why?... *sigh* prayers ...

Posted

Not just wrong to teach Catholicism, but a basic tenet of Christianity in general, Protestant or Catholic...

Posted (edited)

God (if He exists) forbid that Christianity be taught in Church!

If this liberal priest doesn't believe in Christ's divinity, [i]he's [/i]the one who should resign. Really, if Jesus is not God, what's the point of being a priest?

Edited by Socrates
Brother Adam
Posted

Thank you for those that prayed. This is a very good friend of mine who this happened to. I am sorry that I really can't go into any more detail right now. It's not that the priest and DRE don't believe in Catholic doctrine, they would both say that the teaching itself is correct, simply that it is far too complicated and unteachable to high school students. My friend is resigning because she has been told she has to stop teaching Catholic doctrine to her students. It's basically resign or be fired. Where this youth minister lives right now students from orthodox Catholic schools are almost un-hireable because they are considered "militants with no pastoral sense". I've found the opposite to be true.

thessalonian
Posted

The Lord's judgment on that parish. Sad. He has better plans for him/her through this trial. Praise God for those who stick to there faith in the midst of adversity.

Posted

Definitely praying Adam. This happens so often, especially to those coming from very orthodox schools and backgrounds. Sadly, many of them either don't get hired or they get fired or forced into resigning.

Posted

Wow, that's crazy. The Incarnation isn't even fully understood by angels, but that doesn't mean they can't know what it is and believe it. Honestly, if High School students can't learn about the Incarnation, what about their faith [i]can[/i] they learn?

Fr. Antony Maria OSB
Posted

As a recent high-school graduate, this really hits a chord since this is effecting people my age. This is simply insane. I find it really sad that this school is not teaching the Incarnation to high-school seniors and firing those who are trying to teach the Catholic Faith in a Catholic school. I will definately be praying for this and for your friend.

May God bless and protect you and your friend always in all of your endeavors!

Your Brother in Christ,

Joe

lilac_angel
Posted

Yet another proof that anti-Catholicism isn't dead, even among "Catholics."

Posted

i'll be praying for her...

this kinds of stuff isnt rare in california.. one of my friends was "fired" as a catechist in a different parish as me because he taught Hell.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='1614926' date='Aug 1 2008, 09:01 AM']Thank you for those that prayed. This is a very good friend of mine who this happened to. I am sorry that I really can't go into any more detail right now. It's not that the priest and DRE don't believe in Catholic doctrine, they would both say that the teaching itself is correct, simply that it is far too complicated and unteachable to high school students. My friend is resigning because she has been told she has to stop teaching Catholic doctrine to her students. It's basically resign or be fired. Where this youth minister lives right now students from orthodox Catholic schools are almost un-hireable because they are considered "militants with no pastoral sense". I've found the opposite to be true.[/quote]
Sigh. I haven't faced any flack from anyone official for teaching my kids higher-end doctrine, but I've heard it from the parents a few times..."why can't you just play games with them?" The implication that our faith is boring is one thing (wrong though it is), but to say that our faith is boring, useless, or silly, and then complain about how we don't have enough youth in our program (allegedly because of my teaching) is just illogical...why do we even care whether or not they're involved if we don't have anything of substance to offer them?

I will continue on my end to teach orthodoxy. My kids know the meaning of Transubstantiation (and they can say it!). I think that's a good thing. And it's having an impact on them...they're starting to go to Adoration on their own (which pleases me) and they're also starting to grow in communio with one another (which pleases parents) and they're branching out into service (which pleases the social justice types).

The idea that we orthodox people are militants with no pastoral sense is absurd. We have plenty of pastoral sense...we just think sometimes it's best to speak up...that's a pastoral decision. When did "being pastoral" become synonymous with being a coward?

My youth have a saying down here that they got from somewhere, "Jesus said, 'don't be a pansy.'"

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...