Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

There is this question that I have been pondering for a while and would like to get your opinions if I may.

We know that when we die, but we have venial sins on our soul, temporal punishment due to sin, or other little imperfections, we go to Purgatory where those blemishes are removed and we are fully prepared to meet Our Beneficent Lord.

We also know that, on the last day at the end of time, there will only be the new heaven and the new earth, all else will have passed away. This includes Purgatory - Purgatory is not an eternal state so it will pass away at the end of time as well.

So what happens to those people who happen to be alive in the flesh on the last day? If they have a venial sin on their soul, or temporal punishment due to sin, then they don't get to go to Purgatory, because there will be no more Purgatory. So do they just go to hell, because nothing imperfect can enter God's Presence? Or do they just go immediately to heaven?

Either way seems unjust. If they just go to hell, then that is not really just because their sin is only venial. Just because they had the BAD fortune to be alive in the flesh on the last day, they don't get the same opportunity to go through Purgatory to get rid of their little sins, like everyone else did. But if they just go right to heaven, then that seems unfair to all those who went before them who had to go through the sufferings of Purgatory in order to enter heaven. Just because the person had the GOOD fortune to be alive in the flesh on the last day, they get to escape the pains of Purgatory and just go straight to heaven.

What are your opinions?

Edited by Theosopher
Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Theosopher' post='1617822' date='Aug 5 2008, 01:19 AM']There is this question that I have been pondering for a while and would like to get your opinions if I may.

We know that when we die, but we have venial sins on our soul, temporal punishment due to sin, or other little imperfections, we go to Purgatory where those blemishes are removed and we are fully prepared to meet Our Beneficent Lord.

We also know that, on the last day at the end of time, there will only be the new heaven and the new earth, all else will have passed away. This includes Purgatory - Purgatory is not an eternal state so it will pass away at the end of time as well.

So what happens to those people who happen to be alive in the flesh on the last day? If they have a venial sin on their soul, or temporal punishment due to sin, then they don't get to go to Purgatory, because there will be no more Purgatory. So do they just go to hell, because nothing imperfect can enter God's Presence? Or do they just go immediately to heaven?

Either way seems unjust. If they just go to hell, then that is not really just because their sin is only venial. Just because they had the BAD fortune to be alive in the flesh on the last day, they don't get the same opportunity to go through Purgatory to get rid of their little sins, like everyone else did. But if they just go right to heaven, then that seems unfair to all those who went before them who had to go through the sufferings of Purgatory in order to enter heaven. Just because the person had the GOOD fortune to be alive in the flesh on the last day, they get to escape the pains of Purgatory and just go straight to heaven.

What are your opinions?[/quote]

First, I would venture to guess that things will be so bad in the at the end of days that those who are still alive and will be sent to heaven will have gone through a great amount of purgation while on earth, so I'm not sure this is as big an issue as it seems. It just seems to me that anyone still alive and living for God at that time will be very holy because of the great evil that person has been able to resist.

That having been said, there is no reason that God could not accomplish in an "instant" of purgatory what He normally accomplishes in "years" of purgatory (I speak figuratively, as purgatory is outside of time).

Lastly, purgatory is considered the antechamber or vestibule of heaven, and it could in some way be considered a part of heaven. I believe it is possible to say that purgatory exists more in the souls of those in purgatory than in the reality around those people, i.e. their attachment to sin keeps them from being able to see and enjoy entirely the beatific vision and the glory that surrounds them. This is speculative theology, of course, but it makes some sense in view of the position Pope Benedict mentions positively in Spe Salvi (I don't have the paragraph number on hand).

God bless,

Micah

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...