Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

An old high school teacher of mine just got in touch with me on Facebook. I'm concerned that he's lost his once-Catholic faith. He claims that he is "Spiritual" in regards to his religious preferences on his profile.

He also sent me a couple messages:

[quote]On another note, have you ever heard of Bart Ehrman?  He is a leading historian of Early Christianity.  He is the Dept. head of Religious Studies of North Carolina - Chapel Hill.  He has been on the History Channel, Discovery Channel and CNN quite a bit. I have been reading a lot of his books lately: Misquoting Jesus, Lost Christianities, Lost Scriptures; it's interesting stuff and I think you may like it - that is - if you are interested in early Christian History.  

I got interested in it because the Catholic and Protestant Churches never discuss early Christian History - only scripture and theology - and I always wondered - why?  The first 300 hundred years of Christianity is full of diversity and is awesome!! Anyway, I thought you might like it..:-)[/quote]

[quote][url="http://bartdehrman.com"]http://bartdehrman.com[/url][/quote]

I am wondering if Dr. Ehrman is the cause of my teacher's falling-away, or if he could be a positive influence on him. I'm not quite sure what to make of him, based on his Curriculum Vitae:

[url="http://www.unc.edu/depts/rel_stud/faculty/BartDEhrman/BartCV.html"]http://www.unc.edu/depts/rel_stud/faculty/...man/BartCV.html[/url]

He could either be a Christian in search of the Historical Jesus, or a skeptic trying to disprove Him. It's really tough to tell. Is anyone familiar with this guy? My teacher wants to get together with me for a beer or lunch sometime, so I'd like to be able to discuss this with him. I'm just looking for some ammo.

Thanks!

Posted

So there was diversity. Yeah, that goes with the whole free will thing.

Tell him congratulations: his doctor discovered the secret of free will!

What a doofus.

Posted

Doesn't look so good:

[url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ehrman"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ehrman[/url]

Anyone with any specific experience with him, please? Thanks in advance.

Pax Christi,
Kris

Posted

You don't need specific experience with this guy. We've always had people interpreting things differently. It has always existed. It's nothing new, and it hasn't stopped. What's interesting is that the Catholic Church has made it through. It survived Gnosticism, Arianism, Protestantism (which is currently in the throes of "No doctrine means anything goes? Oops." phase) and is holding to the same theology.

The Church does teach history. There are tons of books on it. Your old teacher's ignorance of them does not an argument make. Avail yourself of some good history books, but understand that the minor movements which have died out don't get coverage unless you really dig.

Because they were minor. And they died out.

That should tell teach something.

Posted

[quote name='Winchester' post='1621715' date='Aug 8 2008, 03:40 PM']You don't need specific experience with this guy. We've always had people interpreting things differently. It has always existed. It's nothing new, and it hasn't stopped. What's interesting is that the Catholic Church has made it through. It survived Gnosticism, Arianism, Protestantism (which is currently in the throes of "No doctrine means anything goes? Oops." phase) and is holding to the same theology.[/quote]

From what I've read, though, Ehrman's argument is that in the case of each heresy, it was the heretics who were right, and that the Orthodox changed biblical texts to support their views.

Fortunately for Ehrman, however, the original copies of the manuscripts have long since been destroyed. Which brings up the question of how he knew that they had been changed, if he didn't have the originals to compare them to. But then he can say that we don't have the originals to verify our claims, either.

To me, the only continuity comes from quotes of Early Church Fathers. As the Church Fathers' quotes are in line with current Church teaching 100%, we can see a continuity in belief EVEN IF Ehrman happens to be correct that the text of Scripture has changed. Continuity in belief implies that textual changes were minor enough so as to not affect the core beliefs themselves. So why is Ehrman getting his panties all twisted?

[quote]The Church does teach history. There are tons of books on it. Your old teacher's ignorance of them does not an argument make. Avail yourself of some good history books, but understand that the minor movements which have died out don't get coverage unless you really dig.

Because they were minor. And they died out.

That should tell teach something.[/quote]

Thank you again. I think I could still do with more specifics so that I don't get blasted. Thanks!

Posted

The very fact that he's been interviewed by The History Channel makes me say to doublecheck everything he says.

Posted

I studied a lot of those early heresies in my Creeds class a couple of semesters ago. Get a copy of "Dissent from the Creed" by Hogan. It puts them all in historical context, why they were heretical, etc. I don't know this Ehrman guy, but it sounds like he's in the Jesus Project crowd with Johnson and Crossan.

Posted

Erm ... not much money at the moment. And when I do have money, I'll be neck-deep in my first year of teaching without much time to read. Do you know of any internet resources?

Thanks! And God bless!

Posted

I don't know Dr. Ehrman and haven't read any of his books, but based upon the websites you posted he looks like a modernist.

Posted

If he discusses anything that goes against the Church you can always just tell him you prefer to trust the early Saints and the Church over some guy who came along 2000 years after the fact. That, and a little thing called faith. :lol:

MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1621885' date='Aug 8 2008, 04:13 PM']I studied a lot of those early heresies in my Creeds class a couple of semesters ago. Get a copy of "Dissent from the Creed" by Hogan. It puts them all in historical context, why they were heretical, etc. I don't know this Ehrman guy, but it sounds like he's in the Jesus Project crowd with Johnson and Crossan.[/quote]
Do you mean the Jesus Seminar?

Posted

[quote name='MissScripture' post='1622012' date='Aug 8 2008, 07:21 PM']Do you mean the Jesus Seminar?[/quote]

Yeah probably. Those guys make me so mad that I have trouble sometimes remembering exactly what they are calling themselves now. We used to just call folks like that atheists.

MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1622093' date='Aug 8 2008, 08:20 PM']Yeah probably. Those guys make me so mad that I have trouble sometimes remembering exactly what they are calling themselves now. We used to just call folks like that atheists.[/quote]
I was just trying to figure out if I was remembering correctly. And yes, they're full of it. I'm glad they know Jesus so well that they can decide what he really did and did not say. :rolleyes:

Posted

Yes, I'm familiar with Bart Eherman.

He was an Evangelical Christian that lost faith in the authenticity of the Bible. He writes popular books on textual criticism.

He wants to encourage disbelief.

Posted

I recommend reading this article:

[url="http://benwitherington.blogspot.com/2006/03/misanalyzing-text-criticism-bart.html"][u][b]Ben Witherington[/b][/u][/url]

Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1623141' date='Aug 9 2008, 10:57 PM']I recommend reading this article:

[url="http://benwitherington.blogspot.com/2006/03/misanalyzing-text-criticism-bart.html"][u][b]Ben Witherington[/b][/u][/url][/quote]

Ooh, thank you. I will be sure to include that in my response to my teacher.

Since he's apparently reading, I'd like to suggest some books to him to read. Anything that would be able to directly combat some of Ehrman's thoughts?

If not, I think CatherineM made some suggestions. I'd like something to directly refute Ehrman, though.

Posted

[quote name='mommas_boy' post='1621672' date='Aug 8 2008, 02:18 PM']An old high school teacher of mine just got in touch with me on Facebook. I'm concerned that he's lost his once-Catholic faith. He claims that he is "Spiritual" in regards to his religious preferences on his profile.

He also sent me a couple messages:
I am wondering if Dr. Ehrman is the cause of my teacher's falling-away, or if he could be a positive influence on him. I'm not quite sure what to make of him, based on his Curriculum Vitae:

[url="http://www.unc.edu/depts/rel_stud/faculty/BartDEhrman/BartCV.html"]http://www.unc.edu/depts/rel_stud/faculty/...man/BartCV.html[/url]

He could either be a Christian in search of the Historical Jesus, or a skeptic trying to disprove Him. It's really tough to tell. Is anyone familiar with this guy? My teacher wants to get together with me for a beer or lunch sometime, so I'd like to be able to discuss this with him. I'm just looking for some ammo.

Thanks![/quote]


He's a very good textual critic. Most of his books are elementary and seek to popularize textual criticism so it is accessible to the larger public.

I've read two books by him. I wasn’t particularly impressed, some of it was interesting.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...