Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Suppression Of A Latin-loving Parish


Recommended Posts

Posted

===quote===

[b]The suppression of a Latin-loving parish[/b]
Saturday, August 9, 2008, 06:45 AM GMT [General]
[url="http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/damian_thompson/blog/2008/08/09/the_suppression_of_a_latinloving_parish"][u]Link to article[/u][/url]
[color="#0000FF"]
I have been passed some correspondence which tells the shocking story of the apparent suppression of a traditionalist Catholic parish in the diocese of Leeds.

One hundred parishioners of St John the Evangelist, Allerton Bywater, have petitioned their bishop, the Rt Rev Arthur Roche, to allow the parish to celebrate Mass only in Latin, in both the old and new forms. Instead, he is closing the church this month and has told the parish priest, Fr Mark Lawler, that he will not be appointed to a new parish because his ministry is "divisive".

Fr Lawler told me today: "This is a parish that does exactly what the Holy Father tells us to do, celebrating the Mass reverently in the old and new forms. The bishop is determined to squash it, and to destroy me because he doesn't want me moving to another parish and doing the same thing."

The parish pastoral council has written to Bishop Roche asking why he has ignored its two formal petitions for the status of a "personal parish" celebrating Mass only in Latin, in accordance with Article 10 of Summorum Pontificum, Pope Benedict's apostolic letter liberating the traditional Latin Mass.

It has now retained the services of a leading canon lawyer to challenge Bishop Roche's decision to close the parish as part of a wider programme of closures.

Relations between Bishop Roche and Fr Lawler have been strained for years. The bishop told Fr Lawler some time ago that he wanted him to say Mass facing the people, and that because he had told him what to do it was therefore the will of the Holy Spirit.

Pope Benedict, in contrast, has written at length defending the ancient practice of celebrating the Eucharist facing east. He has also given priests the legal right to celebrate a public Mass in the traditional rite if they are approached by a stable group of the faithful, however small. At St John's, the vast majority of regular worshippers have asked for the old rite to be made available. On August 17, their church will be closed by the diocese.

Fr Lawler says he asked for a meeting with Bishop Roche, but to no avail. Instead, the Vicar General, one Mgr McQuinn, has written to him, telling him: "The Bishop ... believes your ministry to be divisive, is uncertain that ordinary pastoral care of parishioners is taking place and does not have confidence that you will celebrate the Ordinary Form of the Mass with a generous heart for the vast majority of parishioners who expect Sunday and weekday Masses to be in English and at an altar facing the people."

In an open letter to his parishioners, Fr Lawler describes this claim as "a slur on my character, an attack upon my priesthood and totally without foundation."

Clearly, this matter must now go to Rome. Perhaps the pontifical commission Ecclesia Dei might be persuaded to take a closer look at the scandal unfolding in Allerton Bywater.[/color]

===End Quote===

Nihil Obstat
Posted

It seems like this issue is 'divisive' no matter how we approach it.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

To be honest, I always feel, when we on Phatmass get to discussing this, like I'm being forced into deciding if I'm traditionalist or liberal. I don't like this feeling. I'm not being forced, or even asked to make this choice, but some opinions on both sides make me feel that I'm only 'sitting on the fence' with this view.

Posted

It does sound very divisive. Just look at the arguments that break out here when discussing things like modern music or latin masses.

I had this funny idea that diocesan priests were supposed to be obedient to their bishops. There are channels for him to use if he has an issue with his bishop that makes him feel that he can no longer be obedient to the bishops instructions. None of those channels are public. Making these kinds of disagreements public only opens us up to more division and gives our enemies fodder.

Posted (edited)

I think that the Roman Church is stuck with a certain amount of liturgical pluralism, which means that neither the so-called "traditionalists" nor the "liberals" will be entirely happy.

Personally I wouldn't mind seeing the Pauline Missal of the late 1960s suppressed in favor of the pre-Vatican II Roman Missal, but it would be nice to see that missal used in both Latin and in the vernacular.

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted (edited)

Ironically many prelates who disobey the Holy Father are contributing to the divisiveness.

We have to remember the TLM was unjustly suppressed for decades, so much so that to attend one was considered schismatic! There has developed over time some zealotry on both sides.

The Holy Father wills for the TLM to naturally sprout. Let the Holy Spirit work through the people and where they desire a Latin mass let them have it. Unfortunately the response of many prelates has been one of containment. Instead of permitting parishioners to establish a TLM locally, they are told parish X that is Y miles away already has a TLM!

So long as prelates inhibit the Holy Father's will, which I believe represents God's Will, the divisiveness will continue and the liturgical pluralism will never end. God may decide for a cross pollination to occur, or perhaps it's His will that one form triumph over the other, whatever happens the will of the people must be respected for the Spirit to accomplish His goal.

Edited by mortify
Brother Adam
Posted

In the world of the Roman Hierarchy the Bishop of Rome trumps the Bishop of Leeds. As Fr Lawler is following the explicit and clear decree of the Holy Roman Pontiff and has tried to faithfully approach his own bishop only to be ignored it is my hope that the Holy Father will protect his servant, Fr Lawler, and set a standard for the renewal of the Latin Mass in the world.

Posted

The point I was trying to make is not that the Holy Father doesn't have authority over the Bishop of Leeds, he obviously does. My point was that there is a procedure in place for priests to have recourse if they disagree with their Bishop. They should show obedience while they are appealing to a higher authority. It does no one any good for dissent to be public, no matter what the topic. There is a chain of command for a reason. Most ordinary parishioners aren't familiar with the procedures, so non-Catholics certainly aren't. Just because you agree with this priest's position, you have to understand that the example he is setting is that obedience to his ordinary isn't required, and public dissent is something that everyone should try if they don't agree with something the church is doing. I'm from a military family, and understand how and why the chain of command works. It has to do with good order and discipline, and public dissent does nothing but give aid and comfort to our enemies.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

The priest has every right to appeal to the Holy Father, but no right to do it publicly. That is not in the spirit of obedience to a bishop he is bound to obey.

Posted (edited)

The priest is simply defending his parish's right to have a Latin mass. The Pope vindicated the position that the Latin Mass has never been abrogated and has further asserted that pastors should make it available if there is a stable group of people desiring it. From the article it appears the majority of the congregation ([b]100 parishioners!!![/b]) are desiring it, and the Bishop is not only *infringing* on the parish's *right* to have the mass, but he is also closing the church and removing the priest! The priest's courageous defense of his flock's needs in obedience to the dictates of the Pope is not dissent, especially since the Bishop's actions are *public* and have negative effects on the community.

With regards to the issue being brought out in public, it's questionable who approached who first, but ultimately I believe disclosing this issue is justified for several reasons. First of all this isn't simply between the priest and Bishop, it's actually between a congregation and it involves the closing of a church and the staining of a priest's good name. Since the congregation has *privately* petitioned the bishop *several* times, and since this affects the public, a public outcry is justified. Lastly, this is certainly not the only case where a pastor, whether bishop or priest, has squashed a congregation's desire for the Latin mass and so I feel this issue should be brought out into the open. The reality is many a prelate are doing what they can to [i]contain[/i] the effects of Summorum Pontificum.

Just my two cents, God knows best.

Edited by mortify
Posted

For those who actually believe in the Code of Canon Law (1983):

Can. 273 Clerics have a special obligation to show reverence and obedience to the Supreme Pontiff and to their own Ordinary.

Can. 274 §2 Unless excused by a lawful impediment, clerics are obliged to accept and faithfully fulfill the office committed to them by their Ordinary.
§2 The diocesan Bishop alone can establish, suppress or alter parishes.

Can. 1373 A person who publicly incites his or her subjects to hatred or animosity against the Apostolic See or the Ordinary because of some act of ecclesiastical authority or ministry, or who provokes the subjects to disobedience against them, is to be punished by interdict or other just penalties.

Posted

Although I understand where Fr. Lawler is coming from, he is being very imprudent in duking it out with his bishop in the press. That is certainly not the way to change his mind. I don't think the bishop is staining Fr. Lawler's name - it was the priest himself who printed an open letter to his parishoners referencing the bishop's private communication. Many priests are not "given" parishes and have effective ministries elsewhere.

The key phrase in the article is that this closure is part of a "larger programme of closures." Many dioceses including my own are going through this painful process. It doesn't sound like this particular parish is being targeted just because of its liturgical orthodoxy. A glance at the sacramental numbers and at the finances might better explain this sad event.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1623812' date='Aug 10 2008, 09:57 PM']For those who actually believe in the Code of Canon Law (1983):

Can. 273 Clerics have a special obligation to show reverence and obedience to the Supreme Pontiff and to their own Ordinary.

Can. 274 §2 Unless excused by a lawful impediment, clerics are obliged to accept and faithfully fulfill the office committed to them by their Ordinary.
§2 The diocesan Bishop alone can establish, suppress or alter parishes.

Can. 1373 A person who publicly incites his or her subjects to hatred or animosity against the Apostolic See or the Ordinary because of some act of ecclesiastical authority or ministry, or who provokes the subjects to disobedience against them, is to be punished by interdict or other just penalties.[/quote]
So what I get out of this...
"Do what the Bishop says, but tell the Pope the situation, let him deal with it however he sees fit."

KnightofChrist
Posted

Canon Law may well be in the Priest's favor. A priest or even a laymen does not have to follow unjust orders from a Bishop or a Pope. The priest is showing obedience to the Supreme Pontiff, the Bishop may be standing in the way that would be unjust if true.

I do not see where the Priest is provoking the subjects to disobedience. No where do I see the Priest asking anyone to disobey the Bishop. Again the Priest seems just to be trying to be obedient to the Pope, who has a Bishop which will not meet with him, or allow a TLM, which is not in standing with the wishes of the Pope.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1623881' date='Aug 11 2008, 03:56 AM']Canon Law may well be in the Priest's favor. A priest or even a laymen does not have to follow unjust orders from a Bishop or a Pope. The priest is showing obedience to the Supreme Pontiff, the Bishop may be standing in the way that would be unjust if true.

I do not see where the Priest is provoking the subjects to disobedience. No where do I see the Priest asking anyone to disobey the Bishop. Again the Priest seems just to be trying to be obedient to the Pope, who has a Bishop which will not meet with him, or allow a TLM, which is not in standing with the wishes of the Pope.[/quote]
The bottom line is you do NOT publicly dis your bishop, even if he is wrong. You call the Vatican, Papal Nuncio, the nearest Archbishop quickly and quietly, but you do NOT get in a public squabble. You cannot expect members of your parish to be obedient to God's word if you are not.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1623961' date='Aug 11 2008, 10:23 AM']The bottom line is you do NOT publicly dis your bishop, even if he is wrong. You call the Vatican, Papal Nuncio, the nearest Archbishop quickly and quietly, but you do NOT get in a public squabble. You cannot expect members of your parish to be obedient to God's word if you are not.[/quote]

:yes:

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1623961' date='Aug 11 2008, 08:23 AM']The bottom line is you do NOT publicly dis your bishop, even if he is wrong. You call the Vatican, Papal Nuncio, the nearest Archbishop quickly and quietly, but you do NOT get in a public squabble. You cannot expect members of your parish to be obedient to God's word if you are not.[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
yup yup!

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1623961' date='Aug 11 2008, 10:23 AM']The bottom line is you do NOT publicly dis your bishop, even if he is wrong. You call the Vatican, Papal Nuncio, the nearest Archbishop quickly and quietly, but you do NOT get in a public squabble. You cannot expect members of your parish to be obedient to God's word if you are not.[/quote]


Bottom lines are bottom lines. The priest should have done as he was told and taken the issue up with Rome quietly and with dignity. Satan's greatest tool is disunity. Playing into that is not helping the Church.

Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1623881' date='Aug 11 2008, 01:56 AM']I do not see where the Priest is provoking the subjects to disobedience. No where do I see the Priest asking anyone to disobey the Bishop. Again the Priest seems just to be trying to be obedient to the Pope, who has a Bishop which will not meet with him, or allow a TLM, which is not in standing with the wishes of the Pope.[/quote]

Do you think the Bishop made it public that 100 people had sent him letters. No that was this priest/parish. We can't get 100 parishioners to write letters unless we print them out to where they just had to sign their names. Even if every one of them did sit down and decide to write the Bishop, who asked them to? In my mind, inciting your parishioners to do a mass mailing to the Bishop is inciting a mutiny.

The Pope can certainly order the Bishops to make the Latin mass available, but it is up to the Bishop as to how and where that is best accomplished in his diocese, not to this priest. If all his parishioners want the Latin mass, perhaps that is because he attracted all those interested in the Latin mass in the area, and those who prefer the vernacular went elsewhere. That exodus may have a lot more to do with this parish closing than just their priest's shameful disobedience. If our parish began offering only Latin masses, I'd go elsewhere if that was an option. I don't know how we'd get the priest facing East though, he'd have to face to the right side of the church since ours runs North/South.

If you want to support the Latin mass, that is great. Just don't pick a disobedient priest as your champion.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1624053' date='Aug 11 2008, 11:43 AM']The Pope can certainly order the Bishops to make the Latin mass available, but it is up to the Bishop as to how and where that is best accomplished in his diocese, not to this priest. If all his parishioners want the Latin mass, perhaps that is because he attracted all those interested in the Latin mass in the area, and those who prefer the vernacular went elsewhere. That exodus may have a lot more to do with this parish closing than just their priest's shameful disobedience. If our parish began offering only Latin masses, I'd go elsewhere if that was an option. I don't know how we'd get the priest facing East though, he'd have to face to the right side of the church since ours runs North/South.

If you want to support the Latin mass, that is great. Just don't pick a disobedient priest as your champion.[/quote]

The thing is, the Pope didn't order the bishops to make the Latin Mass available, he said that it is the priest's right to say the Mass in the extraordinary form in private anytime or in a parish when there is a good sized community which desires it. I don't believe that it was the bishop's call.

I don't know whether the priest's actions were justified or not.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...