Vincent Vega Posted August 11, 2008 Posted August 11, 2008 [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1624224' date='Aug 11 2008, 01:05 PM']And nothing white's complain about now can ever be equal to what minorities had to endure for the last 200 years...[/quote] I guess you've never heard of the discrimination against European Jews or Italians or Irish people...or white [b]Catholics[/b]! There has been plenty of discrimination against whites. To think (or imply!) that all white people are descended from plantation-owning, slave-whipping, cross-burning, immigrant-fearing bigots, and that no white people have ever in history been discriminated against is foolish.
Madame Vengier Posted August 11, 2008 Posted August 11, 2008 [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1624345' date='Aug 11 2008, 03:18 PM']but hopefully, this will enlighten you to understand better why you can't have a white pride parade down mainstreet America without people getting bent out of shape....[/quote] It's unfortunate that you don't see/understand how incredibly insulting it is that you think you need to clue me in about why "white pride" is rejected. You've mentioned it three times--that you specifically are saying all this because you apparently think I'm totally stupid, ignorant, clueless, blind, or have no interest/concern for other races/cultures/heritages and so you HAVE TO HELP ME UNDERSTAND. Wow. And no one said anything about white parades down mainstreet, although I still argue that if blacks and hispanics can have one then whites should, too. I find it extremely disappointing that you still think that white people are the only Americans who have ever been cruel to other races in America. I live in Washington, DC and I can't tell you the number of times we non-blacks (and I don't mean just whites) encounter massive amounts of racism against us from blacks. (and don't even get me started on the Hispanic illegal aliens and how they treat white people) It goes both ways. You have your experiences and I have mine.
Madame Vengier Posted August 11, 2008 Posted August 11, 2008 [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1624398' date='Aug 11 2008, 03:57 PM']I guess you've never heard of the discrimination against European Jews or Italians or Irish people...or white [b]Catholics[/b]! There has been plenty of discrimination against whites. To think (or imply!) that all white people are descended from plantation-owning, slave-whipping, cross-burning, immigrant-fearing bigots, and that no white people have ever in history been discriminated against is foolish.[/quote] Exactly. THIS is what I was getting at--though I was making an effort to keep it limited to American history. But yeah.
Vincent Vega Posted August 11, 2008 Posted August 11, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1624410' date='Aug 11 2008, 04:05 PM']Exactly. THIS is what I was getting at--though I was making an effort to keep it limited to American history. But yeah.[/quote] All of those groups [i]have[/i] been persecuted in American history (the Jews, not as much as the others, but still to some extent). You need look no further back than the first two decades of the 20th century. Edited August 11, 2008 by USAirwaysIHS
Lil Red Posted August 11, 2008 Posted August 11, 2008 [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1624398' date='Aug 11 2008, 02:57 PM']I guess you've never heard of the discrimination against European Jews or Italians or Irish people...or white [b]Catholics[/b]! There has been plenty of discrimination against whites. To think (or imply!) that all white people are descended from plantation-owning, slave-whipping, cross-burning, immigrant-fearing bigots, and that no white people have ever in history been discriminated against is foolish.[/quote] +J.M.J.+ i was talking with a lovely elderly fellow a year or two ago, and he said (in my city) that back in the 50s, men wouldn't attend Mass with their wives and children because they wanted to keep their jobs. And if a priest was seen walking down the street in his cassock, people would cross the street so that they would not even be near a Catholic.
dominicansoul Posted August 11, 2008 Posted August 11, 2008 [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1624398' date='Aug 11 2008, 03:57 PM']I guess you've never heard of the discrimination against European Jews or Italians or Irish people...or white [b]Catholics[/b]! There has been plenty of discrimination against whites. To think (or imply!) that all white people are descended from plantation-owning, slave-whipping, cross-burning, immigrant-fearing bigots, and that no white people have ever in history been discriminated against is foolish.[/quote] In the history of our country....can you cite some examples of where white people have been killed at the hands of people over just their race, and the murderers get off scott free? (I'm not speaking of religious persecutions.) Can you tell me where white people have been lynched? Or denied seating at restaurants? Can you tell me of incidents of white people not being allowed to worship God in a church designated for whites only? Can you tell me where white people couldn't eat or drink from water fountains? Can you cite one incident where their children were dragged out of their beds at night and found in a pond brutally murdered without justice prevailing? I think you know what it is I'm getting at. No one can deny the fact that our country's history shows that whites have enjoyed a very privileged status. You can't possibly try to deny this. I'm just trying to explain why it's easier for someone who isn't white to complain more about racial inequality than it is for a white person to do it. After all the history in our country, I can't understand how any white person could seriously wonder why they can't go around expressing their pride. [b]It may not be fair, but there is a reason for the antagonism. That's all I'm trying to express here. [/b]
Vincent Vega Posted August 11, 2008 Posted August 11, 2008 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1624420' date='Aug 11 2008, 04:12 PM']+J.M.J.+ i was talking with a lovely elderly fellow a year or two ago, and he said (in my city) that back in the 50s, men wouldn't attend Mass with their wives and children because they wanted to keep their jobs. And if a priest was seen walking down the street in his cassock, people would cross the street so that they would not even be near a Catholic. [/quote] The way we've been treated in the past in this country has been terrible (yes, I can say 'we' - though I am a convert, my ancestors were Catholics that immigrated to this country...I sometimes have to wonder if their children didn't drop the faith to avoid prejuces. Anyway...). I took AP US History this year, and somewhere between 1890 and 1920 there was a convent and church somewhere in the midatlantic (Maryland, I want to say) that some anti-immigrant, anti-Catholic bigots burned to the ground. Several nuns and a priest were killed. It shocked me, because as some have said, anti-Catholicism is the last acceptable prejudice. The history of anti-Catholicism in this country is not taugh nearly as widely as certain racisms and xenophobias.
Vincent Vega Posted August 11, 2008 Posted August 11, 2008 [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1624429' date='Aug 11 2008, 04:21 PM']In the history of our country....can you cite some examples of where white people have been killed at the hands of people over just their race, and the murderers get off scott free? (I'm not speaking of religious persecutions.) Can you tell me where white people have been lynched? Or denied seating at restaurants? Can you tell me of incidents of white people not being allowed to worship God in a church designated for whites only? Can you tell me where white people couldn't eat or drink from water fountains? Can you cite one incident where their children were dragged out of their beds at night and found in a pond brutally murdered without justice prevailing? I think you know what it is I'm getting at. No one can deny the fact that our country's history shows that whites have enjoyed a very privileged status. You can't possibly try to deny this.[/quote] Religious persecutions and white-on-white prejudices are inseperable, because the xenophobia against the Irish, Germans, and Italians was very closely tied in with Anti-Catholicism, because most Catholics were Irish, German, or Italian immigrants, and most Irish, German, and Italian immigrants were Catholic. The two go hand in hand. You want examples of white-against-white violence? [quote]Irish and Germans were reviled for their Roman Catholicism, and in 1834 a Catholic convent near Boston was burned by a mob, followed by subsequent attacks on Catholic schools and churches. In 1844, a several-day riot in Philadelphia left thirteen citizens dead and fifty wounded. Violence against Catholics on the East coast was so common that insurance companies practically refused to insure them (Daniels 267). It is difficult for us to imagine such malice being directed towards Irish or German people.[/quote] [url="http://www.cjd.org/paper/truth.html"]http://www.cjd.org/paper/truth.html[/url] If you'd like more, feel free to read up on the Know-Nothing Party (http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08677a.htm), or research Xenophobia in the period of 1880-1920. [quote]I'm just trying to explain why it's easier for someone who isn't white to complain more about racial inequality than it is for a white person to do it. After all the history in our country, I can't understand how any white person could seriously wonder why they can't go around expressing their pride. [b]It may not be fair, but there is a reason for the antagonism. That's all I'm trying to express here. [/b][/quote] Who is denying that non-whites have undergone hardships? No one, I think. But to say that whites have never undergone any sort of prejudice or hardship...again, that's just foolish. Not every white is a WASP, you know.
dominicansoul Posted August 11, 2008 Posted August 11, 2008 [quote]Who is denying that non-whites have undergone hardships? No one, I think. But to say that whites have never undergone any sort of prejudice or hardship...again, that's just foolish. Not every white is a WASP, you know.[/quote] I was responding to Madame V's post where she was complaining about how difficult it is for white's to display any form of white pride. I was giving her my opinion as to why there is antagonism for this... I find it very ironic that most of the racism and bigotry in my neck of the woods came to us not only at the hands of WASP but those very people who were our brothers and sisters in Christ...White "Catholics"...our history here is filled with examples of this, and like I posted already, even in my short lifetime I have experienced this hatred...
MissScripture Posted August 12, 2008 Posted August 12, 2008 [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1624434' date='Aug 11 2008, 04:25 PM']The way we've been treated in the past in this country has been terrible (yes, I can say 'we' - though I am a convert, my ancestors were Catholics that immigrated to this country...I sometimes have to wonder if their children didn't drop the faith to avoid prejuces. Anyway...). I took AP US History this year, and somewhere between 1890 and 1920 there was a convent and church somewhere in the midatlantic (Maryland, I want to say) that some anti-immigrant, anti-Catholic bigots burned to the ground. Several nuns and a priest were killed. It shocked me, because as some have said, anti-Catholicism is the last acceptable prejudice. The history of anti-Catholicism in this country is not taugh nearly as widely as certain racisms and xenophobias.[/quote] I find the use of the word "we" interesting...I've been told so many times in school about the things "we" (referring to white people, because I grew up in a predominantly German area) did to black people with slavery, and what "we" did to the Native Americans. I've always wondered why I had to be included in that "we," since my family historically couldn't even be implicated in that "we" seeing as how WE hadn't even left Europe yet!
CatherineM Posted August 12, 2008 Posted August 12, 2008 My family did own slaves in Virginia, South Carolina, and Maryland. One ancestor even captained a slave trade ship. That may be a reason why I took such a strong stand against white supremacists.
Madame Vengier Posted August 12, 2008 Posted August 12, 2008 [quote name='MissScripture' post='1624960' date='Aug 11 2008, 11:21 PM']I find the use of the word "we" interesting...I've been told so many times in school about the things "we" (referring to white people, because I grew up in a predominantly German area) did to black people with slavery, and what "we" did to the Native Americans. I've always wondered why I had to be included in that "we," since my family historically couldn't even be implicated in that "we" seeing as how WE hadn't even left Europe yet![/quote] Exactly. But this is part of the plan. Keep white people collectively feeling guilty, then everyone else can collectively play the victim. You can't play the victim if you don't have someone playing the villain.
Madame Vengier Posted August 12, 2008 Posted August 12, 2008 [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1624458' date='Aug 11 2008, 04:44 PM']I was responding to Madame V's post where she was complaining about how difficult it is for white's to display any form of white pride. I was giving her my opinion as to why there is antagonism for this...[/quote] And again, I was not asking for an explanation of WHY. As I pointed out to you, it's insulting that think you needed to "help" me figure this out. Did you reall, really, truly think I didn't KNOW why? I didn't write that post because I was puzzled as to why there is antagonism. I wrote it because I think the antagonism is unfair and unjust. I was trying to defend the right for ALL races to feel pride, and pointing out that whites are the only race for whom it is "politically incorrect" to do so. This is not complicated.
Apotheoun Posted August 12, 2008 Posted August 12, 2008 Group politics are foolish, we are all part of the human race.
Madame Vengier Posted August 12, 2008 Posted August 12, 2008 [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1624434' date='Aug 11 2008, 04:25 PM']The history of anti-Catholicism in this country is not taugh nearly as widely as certain racisms and xenophobias.[/quote] Absolutely! And the overall history against Catholics around the world is something most non-Catholics are even aware of. They couldn't care less about all the Catholics that have been murdered throughout Christian history for no other reason than that they were Catholics. Look at what the British did to the Irish Catholics. Stole their property and their land, pushed them into the potato famine, and finally loaded them onto ships and dumped then on Australia. Talk about white-on-white suffering!
Madame Vengier Posted August 12, 2008 Posted August 12, 2008 [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1624429' date='Aug 11 2008, 04:21 PM']I can't understand how any white person could seriously wonder why they can't go around expressing their pride.[/quote] No one was "seriously wondering" about it. No one. YOU took it upon yourself to "school" me on it, as if I were too stupid to know. The fact that I said it was UNFAIR doesn't mean I didn't UNDERSTAND. We've been talking about apples and oranges from the beginning, and no matter what I say you can't seem to accept this. My issue was never that I didn't understand or that I was "wondering". It was that I simply pointed out that it exists and that it's unfair.
dUSt Posted August 13, 2008 Posted August 13, 2008 Comparing or equating white suffering to religious suffering is a bad argument. It trips me out when y'all keep going on about "white" suffering. What is "white"? All it is is a term created by society to define a "race", also created by society. A black pride parade is a legitimate celebration that celebrates a [b]culture[/b]. A hispanic pride parade is a legitimate celebration that celebrates a [b]culture[/b]. A St Patty's day parade is a legitimate celebration that celebrates a [b]culture[/b]. A Mardi Gras parade is a legitimate celebration that celebrates a [b]culture[/b]. An Oktoberfest parade is a legitimate celebration that celebrates a [b]culture[/b]. A [b]white[/b] pride parade is a [b]racist [/b]event that celebrates a person's skin color. It has nothing to do with culture other than promoting a culture of racism.
Lil Red Posted August 13, 2008 Posted August 13, 2008 [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1624434' date='Aug 11 2008, 03:25 PM']The history of anti-Catholicism in this country is not taught nearly as widely as certain racisms and xenophobias.[/quote] +J.M.J.+ have you read "[url="http://www.amazon.com/New-Anti-Catholicism-Last-Acceptable-Prejudice/dp/0195176049/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1218640888&sr=8-1"]The New Anti-Catholicism: The Last Acceptable Prejudice in America[/url]" ? it really is quite a good read, covers the Know-Nothing party that you talked about too.
desertwoman Posted August 13, 2008 Posted August 13, 2008 Sadly white pride has been connected to neo nazis and the sort, so when you see someone talk about white pride or have a white pride parade nazis and other separatist groups will be there. This is another reason why many people view the battle flag of the confederate army as racist. We always see it during KKK rallies and the like. I don't care if my white brother or sister shows pride in their culture, do so. I guess we just dont refer to it as white pride when it is done.
Vincent Vega Posted August 13, 2008 Posted August 13, 2008 [quote name='dUSt' post='1625997' date='Aug 13 2008, 09:39 AM']Comparing or equating white suffering to religious suffering is a bad argument. It trips me out when y'all keep going on about "white" suffering. What is "white"? All it is is a term created by society to define a "race", also created by society.... A [b]white[/b] pride parade is a [b]racist [/b]event that celebrates the invention of a society based on the color of one's skin. It has nothing to do with culture other than promoting a culture of racism.[/quote] I don't see the connection between the two paragraphs. I would agree with the latter; not so with the former. As I stated, many Irish, German, and Italian immigrants were discriminated against when they first came to this country. Some of those who already lived here didn't like that. Catholicism was very deeply interwoven into the fibres of the cultures of these three countries, so the nativist bigots disdained the immigrants themselves, and subsequently their cultures, and subsequently the Church. Those three ethnicities are generally defined as being 'white', 'caucasian', 'fair-skinned', however you'd like to say it. But just as not every 'white' person suffered, neither did every 'non-white' person, be they hispanic, black, asian, or otherwise. Naturally more non-whites have suffered (look at slavery, for instance), but saying that whites can't know what suffering is or that nothing 'we' have gone through can ever "be equal to what minorities had to endure for the last 200 years" is just a little ignorant. Most all groups have had their crosses to bear; whites are no different. [quote name='desertwoman' post='1626137' date='Aug 13 2008, 12:46 PM']I don't care if my white brother or sister shows pride in their culture, do so. I guess we just dont refer to it as white pride when it is done.[/quote] Amen, DW. I wouldn't want to participate in a 'white pride' parade, even if it were completely separate from any sort of supremacist feelings; the colour of my skin has very little to do with how I see myself. [i]Ethnic[/i] festivals and events, thought, are different in my opinion. I take pride in my national heritages, especially my Scottish side (I'm a MacGregor and beaver dam proud of it!), because it provides a tangible sense of ancestral connection and inspires some sort of pride in me. Most of all, though, the most important thing to my personal identity is...well, me. I'm not my ancestors, nor am I the same person as all of my countrymen, nor am I the same person as all other white people. I am comfortable with myself because of the person I am and what I have accomplished, not because of where my ancestors were born or the shade of my complexion. I hope all of that wasn't too convoluted.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now