Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

English-only Movement Targets Nashville


Recommended Posts

Posted

Actually, I think that not requiring immigrants to learn English is to close the door of opportunity to them.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1627494' date='Aug 14 2008, 08:58 PM']Oh, absolutely. And the real winners would be the immigrants themselves, because the language would be useful for so much more than just filling out papers. And anyway, think of all the great volunteer opportunities for people to get involved if immigrants had to learn the language and actually WANTED to. The government could turn it into a whole American-community-helping-others type thing like back in the day when we always had those literacy initiatives supported and promoted by the government.[/quote]
:woot: I would love that. I would so do that. RIght now I would have to drive up to St. Paul to volunteer for ESL and pay for my own training. If it were available right here in my town, I could do it and even bring my kids to help. It would be great for them, too.

Archaeology cat
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Roamin_Catholic' post='1627587' date='Aug 15 2008, 02:51 AM']So, we need to provide services in the 6,912 living languages known today??? Imagine how many states and local governments would be bankrupted due to this.[/quote]
And yet that's exactly what's happening to an extent. I know a lady who works for social security, and she said if someone comes in and wants services in any language, they have to provide that. I know they have at least one employee there who speaks Farsi, and I don't know what other languages they provide at that particular office. But, at least theoretically, if someone came in demanding to be served by someone who spoke Turkish or Swahili or whatever, they would have to provide it. Or at least that's my understanding of it.

I do think there needs to be a national language declared, and that immigrants should demonstrate proficiency in it to be naturalised.

Edited by Archaeology cat
Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1627953' date='Aug 15 2008, 09:05 AM']I do think there needs to be a national language declared, and that immigrants should demonstrate proficiency in it to be naturalised.[/quote]

Sounds far-out, doesn't it?? But that's exactly what loads of other countries do. Let me just show up at the immigration office in Japan and demand to have someone speak my language and translate for me. And watch the Japanese show me the door.

I've read the blogs of ESL teachers in Japan. They take a friend or a student with them to help them with complicated Japanese documents like tax forms and such. Japan ain't gonna use their tax dollars to fund foreign language services for you. And as well they shouldn't.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1627930' date='Aug 15 2008, 07:45 AM']:woot: I would love that. I would so do that. RIght now I would have to drive up to St. Paul to volunteer for ESL and pay for my own training. If it were available right here in my town, I could do it and even bring my kids to help. It would be great for them, too.[/quote]

I would love it, too. I love tutoring and there's nothing more rewarding that helping people who want to learn. I'm actually currently looking at tutoring in the Iraqi refugee community that is out this way. I have a contact who is out of town for a bit but when she gets back we're going to look into that, as she is involved in relief services. The Iraqi refugees really want to learn English. The children are already learning fast and becoming Americanized because they attend public school. But the parents (or other adults) need more help because they don't have the luxury of being immersed in the language like the kids do.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='Mercy me' post='1627869' date='Aug 15 2008, 01:04 AM']Actually, I think that not requiring immigrants to learn English is to close the door of opportunity to them.[/quote]


Exactly. And it's not an exaggeration when I say there are Hispanics in this country who have been here for years and don't lift a finger to learn English. And you know what? They are still cleaning bathrooms, which is the same job they got when they first came here. And in 20 years they will still be cleaning bathrooms.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='MissScripture' post='1627598' date='Aug 14 2008, 10:04 PM']I was just thinking about last winter when I was shadowing a physical therapist. One patient was a Somolian woman who didn't speak English. Luckily, she had brought someone with her to translate. The PT told me about a time that a Somolian woman came in and didn't speak English, and she couldn't treat her, because they couldn't communicate, and the translator didn't show up. It is NOT a good idea to try to treat someone with physical therapy (or in many other areas of health care) when you can't tell if they are in pain or what is going on with the patient.
Learning English would DEFINITELY be beneficial for more than just paperwork![/quote]


The anti-English panderers don't think about stuff like this when they are screaming about "heritage".

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1628179' date='Aug 15 2008, 04:59 PM']Sounds far-out, doesn't it?? But that's exactly what loads of other countries do. Let me just show up at the immigration office in Japan and demand to have someone speak my language and translate for me. And watch the Japanese show me the door.

I've read the blogs of ESL teachers in Japan. They take a friend or a student with them to help them with complicated Japanese documents like tax forms and such. Japan ain't gonna use their tax dollars to fund foreign language services for you. And as well they shouldn't.[/quote]

We have a friend of the family who is a Russian citizen. She wants to move to Germany because she's getting married (her fiance' is also a Russian, but he's working in Germany)... Anyway, in order to get a residency visa she has to pass a German language test. She had to learn it in order to move there (she speaks fluent English and French).

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1628205' date='Aug 15 2008, 05:14 PM']We have a friend of the family who is a Russian citizen. She wants to move to Germany because she's getting married (her fiance' is also a Russian, but he's working in Germany)... Anyway, in order to get a residency visa she has to pass a German language test. She had to learn it in order to move there (she speaks fluent English and French).[/quote]


In my conversations with people both IRL and online I have often challenged people to tell me WHY America should have a different standard of immigration norms and rules than every other country has. Those who pander to "immigration rights" (i.e. don't deport illegals, don't force English on immigrants, don't complain that they are sucking the tax dollars from our own economy, etc) cannot explain why they think America is shameful and wicked and unjust for having immigration laws and protecting our borders, like every other country. These bleeding heart panderers NEVER have an answer for me. Ever.

And besides, we don't deport illegals. Our borders are not protected. We don't enforce English. And tax dollars are spent annually in the millions to cater to illegals. So, the bleeding hearts are getting their way anyway and I don't know what they are whining about.

MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1628182' date='Aug 15 2008, 04:03 PM']I would love it, too. I love tutoring and there's nothing more rewarding that helping people who want to learn. I'm actually currently looking at tutoring in the Iraqi refugee community that is out this way. I have a contact who is out of town for a bit but when she gets back we're going to look into that, as she is involved in relief services. The Iraqi refugees really want to learn English. The children are already learning fast and becoming Americanized because they attend public school. But the parents (or other adults) need more help because they don't have the luxury of being immersed in the language like the kids do.[/quote]
Plus, it would be harder for them anyway, as they're adults, and they'd learn a language more slowly, anyway.


[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1628283' date='Aug 15 2008, 05:08 PM']In my conversations with people both IRL and online I have often challenged people to tell me WHY America should have a different standard of immigration norms and rules than every other country has. Those who pander to "immigration rights" (i.e. don't deport illegals, don't force English on immigrants, don't complain that they are sucking the tax dollars from our own economy, etc) cannot explain why they think America is shameful and wicked and unjust for having immigration laws and protecting our borders, like every other country. These bleeding heart panderers NEVER have an answer for me. Ever.

And besides, we don't deport illegals. Our borders are not protected. We don't enforce English. And tax dollars are spent annually in the millions to cater to illegals. So, the bleeding hearts are getting their way anyway and I don't know what they are whining about.[/quote]
If they didn't whine, they wouldn't know what else to do. :mellow:

Posted

[quote name='dominicansoul' post='1626161' date='Aug 13 2008, 03:09 PM']I agree with Madame V, in that it is the PC liberals who are the ones who are fighting this kind of thing. I believe most Mexican immigrants are very eager to assimilate to the American culture. They can't help it if some official tells them that they don't need to speak the language to become American Citizens. I think liberals are the ones who try to keep English from becoming the official language of the states, not immigrants.

My public library has programs teaching English as a Second Language. I was present in the library one night, while this program was going on. I was shocked to hear the instructor telling the immigrants that "Republicans are not interested in the poor." IF this is the kind of propaganda that is fed to immigrants, I don't see how they are supposed to know the truth otherwise.

I'm all for making English the official language. I don't think anyone should be denied a job just because they aren't bilingual! (As it is in some cases...)[/quote]

So, anyone who feels compassion towards a latin woman in the emergency room whose son cut his hand and needs stitches, but can't communicate because she doesn't speak English, is a "PC liberal?"

[quote name='Roamin_Catholic' post='1627587' date='Aug 14 2008, 10:51 PM']So, we need to provide services in the 6,912 living languages known today??? Imagine how many states and local governments would be bankrupted due to this.[/quote]

No, but having them in the 2 or 3 major languages in our country seems a lot more reasonable.

dominicansoul
Posted

nope. I define PC liberals as those who pander to minorities just to get their votes and once in office they do absolutely nothing for them at.all.

and for those not in the political sphere, I just feel PC liberals are those who push their agendas on unsuspecting groups of people, just to satisfy their need for control over these peoples.

I don't disagree with you, Kujo, that is a very sad situation when people of other languages cannot speak English in emergency circumstances. And I for one, understand that not every person can learn English...I have heard it can be a very difficult language to learn. But I believe what most of us are speaking of on this thread, is a real need to push English as the official language and to make those in our country who do not speak it, learn it to better these types of situations...I think the way things are now, many are choosing NOT to learn it, because they feel they don't really need to, and some don't even try...

Roamin Catholic
Posted

[quote name='kujo' post='1628856' date='Aug 16 2008, 11:47 AM']No, but having them in the 2 or 3 major languages in our country seems a lot more reasonable.[/quote]

So, we are telling the people that speak the other languages that they are out of luck? That they aren't a part of the lucky group of immigrants?

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='Roamin_Catholic' post='1629069' date='Aug 16 2008, 05:07 PM']So, we are telling the people that speak the other languages that they are out of luck? That they aren't a part of the lucky group of immigrants?[/quote]


That's exactly what we are expected to tell them. This nonsense of having "two or three major languages" represented is unjust and unfair. Especially when you consider that Hispanics are a "major" group because over 15 million of them are here illegally in the first place. Why should we pander to people who don't even have a legal right to be here? Learn the language, follow our laws, try to assimilate within reason into our society--or get out. It's simple. And it goes for everyone.

MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='kujo' post='1628856' date='Aug 16 2008, 11:47 AM']So, anyone who feels compassion towards a latin woman in the emergency room whose son cut his hand and needs stitches, but can't communicate because she doesn't speak English, is a "PC liberal?"[/quote]
Wow. Where in her post did you get this idea from?? :blink:

Roamin Catholic
Posted

[quote name='MissScripture' post='1629169' date='Aug 16 2008, 07:04 PM']Wow. Where in her post did you get this idea from?? :blink:[/quote]
I was kinda wondering the same thing. but oh well

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...