IcePrincessKRS Posted August 14, 2008 Posted August 14, 2008 The Mayo Clinic website has a section on NFP with its Birth Control information, but a quick scan didn't reveal a citation for its effectiveness. It lists pros and cons. This site states up to 98% effectiveness. But I don't know if it will qualify as 3rd party since it seems to be pretty much devoted to types of NFP. [url="http://www.fertilityuk.org/nfps1.html#fertilityawarenessslug"]http://www.fertilityuk.org/nfps1.html#fertilityawarenessslug[/url] This site: [url="http://www.aafcp.org/"]http://www.aafcp.org/[/url] has a FAQ that specifically states that it is NOT a Catholic organization (or religiously affilitated in any way), but it supports the Creighton method of NFP. It also has a page of links to effectiveness studies. [url="http://www.aafcp.org/effectiveness_studies.html"]http://www.aafcp.org/effectiveness_studies.html[/url] Here: [url="http://www.aafcp.org/family_planning_facts.html"]http://www.aafcp.org/family_planning_facts.html[/url] they give effectiveness ratings for Creighton, Billings, and Sympto-Thermal. Science Daily reports that NFP is as effective as the pill: [url="http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/02/070221065200.htm"]http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/...70221065200.htm[/url] [url="http://www.infoforhealth.org/pr/j44/j44chap10.shtml"]http://www.infoforhealth.org/pr/j44/j44chap10.shtml[/url] [url="http://www.doctorslounge.com/gynecology/news/contraception_natural.shtml"]http://www.doctorslounge.com/gynecology/ne...n_natural.shtml[/url] [url="http://web.ncf.ca/an588/nfp.html"]http://web.ncf.ca/an588/nfp.html[/url] [quote]No birth control method 20% Calendar Rhythm (Ogino-Knaus) 87% Withdrawal 91% Ovulation (or Billings) method 96% Diaphragm with spermicide 97% Foam 97% LAM (breastfeeding) (first 6 months) 98% Condom 99% IUD 99% Pill 99.7% Sympto-Thermal method 99.8% Tubal Ligation 99.6% Vasectomy 99.85% Castration, removal of ovaries, abstinence: 100%[/quote] BBC, they're pretty liberal... can anyone argue with them as a source? lol [url="http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/6375261.stm"]http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/6375261.stm[/url] It should be noted, also, that women from other "strict" religious backgrounds, Jews for example, also turn to NFP. It's not just a Catholic thing. There are several secular websites (generally forums for fertility charting and pregnancy) where women use it to chart to achieve a pregnancy, and while some turn to ABC after they have their babies, others choose to continue with NFP. I have had non-Catholic friends turn to it because of the hormonal and health risks of ABC. It would be interesting to try and find sources or testimonials from people with experiences like that. Anyway, the above links are what I found with a couple quick google searches. I don't know if they fit the criteria of Wiki sources or not, but I think it's a decent start. I'm not up for going in and editing (too much on my plate right now to keep up with it), but I can assist by doing some searches for sources. Somewhere there is a John Hopkins article supporting NFP as equally effective as the pill, its referenced in a couple of those links, but I don't think I manage to find the original article (unless it's there and I missed it). ETA: (I know this post is lengthy already, but please bear with me) I think it is also especially important to gather a plethora of secular sources about NFP and its effectiveness to offset the claim that it's a Catholic thing. Prove that its secular, too. KWIM? Thats why (as far as I recall) none of these links are directly religious.
IcePrincessKRS Posted August 14, 2008 Posted August 14, 2008 I'm not sure how reliable Wiki would consider these, but here are a couple of about.com links as well. (I do think some of their statistics are wrong, though.) [url="http://pms.about.com/od/glossary/g/NFP.htm"]http://pms.about.com/od/glossary/g/NFP.htm[/url] [url="http://adam.about.com/encyclopedia/Birth-control-and-family-planning.htm"]http://adam.about.com/encyclopedia/Birth-c...ly-planning.htm[/url] (this one covers all types of birth control and contraceptives) [url="http://yourtotalhealth.ivillage.com/doctors-need-more-training-in-natural-birth-control.html"]http://yourtotalhealth.ivillage.com/doctor...th-control.html[/url] [quote]Even though they play an important role in helping women choose appropriate contraception, many doctors aren't adequately trained in natural (fertility awareness-based) methods, say Georgetown University Medical Center experts.[/quote] G-town medical center experts... not a church. [i]medical experts.[/i]
Farsight one Posted August 14, 2008 Posted August 14, 2008 Most of those seem like pretty good ones. And it's good to have multiple sources too, so your sources can outnumber their's. I'm semi busy for the next couple days and working so much into the article can be extremely time consuming, but if no one's done anything themselves after a while, I'll see what I can do (when I have the time of course)
IcePrincessKRS Posted August 14, 2008 Posted August 14, 2008 I also found this from quest diagnostics--more links to the NFP section topics on the right--they are NOT religiously affiliated. When I had my first two babies my very much non-Christian (a couple of them seemed very hippyish) midwives used this company as the source for my blood tests and such. They have a "why it is done" section, but they refer to the fertility awareness method, and falsely state that a woman should have regular cycles... I'm not sure how well this source will work, but I leave it at the discretion of the editors. I'm just compiling sources for you guys. [url="http://www.questdiagnostics.com/kbase/topic/medtest/hw214032/whydone.htm"]http://www.questdiagnostics.com/kbase/topi...032/whydone.htm[/url]
prose Posted August 14, 2008 Author Posted August 14, 2008 The previous editor's problem right now is that he doesn't know any secular sources that use the term NFP.
prose Posted August 14, 2008 Author Posted August 14, 2008 (edited) They use this letter: [url="http://www.openembrace.com/"]http://www.openembrace.com/[/url] as a reference to reasons why NFP is bad in the wikipedia article. sigh. I give up. Any phatmasser wanna help? I wish I had some good quality quotes (maybe from Kimberly Hahn??) to add up there about how NFP improves marriage for women. This article poster quotes that [quote]t’s a theological attack on women to always require that abstinence during the time of the wife’s peak sexual desire (ovulation) for the entire duration of her fertile life, except for the handful of times when she conceives.[/quote] Sigh. Anyone else wanna edit for a while?? Edited August 14, 2008 by prose
Farsight one Posted August 14, 2008 Posted August 14, 2008 [quote name='prose' post='1627315' date='Aug 14 2008, 05:43 PM']They use this letter: [url="http://www.openembrace.com/"]http://www.openembrace.com/[/url] as a reference to reasons why NFP is bad in the wikipedia article. sigh. I give up. Any phatmasser wanna help? I wish I had some good quality quotes (maybe from Kimberly Hahn??) to add up there about how NFP improves marriage for women. This article poster quotes that Sigh. Anyone else wanna edit for a while??[/quote]Well, like I said a while back, I'll be at it in a few days hopefully. But what I can tell you now is that the letter you just linked is most definitely NOT a reliable source according to wikipedia. It shouldn't be used at all.
XIX Posted August 15, 2008 Posted August 15, 2008 Oh yeah, that is definitely not a neutral source. The article clearly isn't neutral either.
1337 k4th0l1x0r Posted August 15, 2008 Posted August 15, 2008 Perhaps the right course of action is to merge Natural Family Planning and Fertility Awareness together. The two articles have similar content. Also, there are plenty of NFP resources that are not tied to Catholicism at all (quickly gathered from The Google): [url="http://familydoctor.org/online/famdocen/home/women/contraceptive/126.html"]http://familydoctor.org/online/famdocen/ho...eptive/126.html[/url] [url="http://www.irh.org/nfp.htm"]http://www.irh.org/nfp.htm[/url] [url="http://www.familyplanning.net/"]http://www.familyplanning.net/[/url] Argue heavily that "Natural Family Planning" is used heavily by secular sources much more often than "Fertility Awareness." Google returns about 872,000 hits for "Natural Family Planning" and only 107,000 for "Fertility Awareness."
1337 k4th0l1x0r Posted August 15, 2008 Posted August 15, 2008 I'd also argue that that Catholic Church has not approved of any Natural Family Planning method specifically. Plus, Fertility Awareness is only used mainly by one source, "Taking Charge of Your Fertility," which isn't a bad source if you take out the use of barrier methods. I would not say that NFP is a form of a FAM, rather FAM developed out of NFP.
prose Posted August 15, 2008 Author Posted August 15, 2008 I think my biggest problem is that when I am introducing new couples to NFP, they are often put off with the fact like it seems like some fairytale thing that the Catholic Church has made up. I totally agree there should be theology online about Catholicism in relation to NFP, but to phrase NFP as a solely catholic concept is misleading and confusing.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now