Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Misconceptions Of Obama's


Recommended Posts

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

Infants born alive act
a couple tiem obama voted against the infants born alive act
[url="http://www.ilga.gov/senate/transcripts/strans92/ST033001.pdf"]http://www.ilga.gov/senate/transcripts/strans92/ST033001.pdf[/url]
[url="http://www.ilga.gov/senate/transcripts/strans92/ST040402.pdf"]http://www.ilga.gov/senate/transcripts/strans92/ST040402.pdf[/url]
text of obama... saying that the act he voted against required doctors to try to save infants that they deemed as not viable... and a constitutional problem was that the act tried to define the previable infants as persons in direct contradiction to Roe.
-he said infants that were viable were not affected... they were being treated as humans wtih rights and humanely. the act was a political ploy at worst.. and at worst, a genuine attempt to change
thigns beyond what is considered sound law
-he said he was still willing to compromise on the bill as per viable infants and all infants... but they wouldn't compromise on the bill.
-it just involved second guessing the doctor's discretion in the matter,,, it was essentially a political ploy, a pointless act. he wants to save the ones who are viable

Freedom of Choice Act
"it’s so extreme, I really don’t think it would ever reach his desk, even if the Democrats increased their numbers in Congress,” Fr. Pavone said.

Posted

+J.M.J.+
[url="http://dawneden.blogspot.com/2008/08/obama-covered-up-support-of-infanticide.html"]http://dawneden.blogspot.com/2008/08/obama...nfanticide.html[/url]

[quote]New information unearthed by Jill Stanek shows that news outlets have played a cover-up by the Obama campaign over the candidate's opposition to the Born Alive Infants Protection Act.

Obama claimed his opposition to an Illinois version of the bill was only because it lacked a "neutrality clause" later inserted into the federal bill that protected Roe vs. Wade.

Not so, Stanek writes:

[quote]Since then we have found 2 separate documents proving Barack Obama has been misrepresenting facts.

In fact, Barack Obama is more liberal than any U.S. senator, voting against identical language of a bill that body passed unanimously, 98-0. In fact, Barack Obama condones infanticide if it would otherwise interfere with abortion.[/quote]

She links to the Illinois Senate Action Committee Report and other documents and news reports which, she writes, "prove that in March 2003, state Senator Obama, then the chairman of the IL state Senate Health and Human Services Committee, presided over a committee meeting in which the 'neutrality clause' (copied verbatim from the federal bill) was added to the state [Born Alive Infants Protection Act], with Obama voting in support of adding the revision. Yet, immediately afterwards, Obama led the committee Democrats in voting against the amended bill, and it was killed, 6-4."[/quote]

And read what [url="http://www.jillstanek.com/archives/2008/08/breaking_news_n_1.html"]Jill Stanek[/url] has to say.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

posted mostly to show that even if a republican were voted in repeatedly,,, they put out just as many prochoice as prolife.
the notion that they would put out more prolife if it weren't for the denials of the appointments,,, is a good point but.. it doesn't happen much,,, and, it's still the reality of the situation that they're having ot put out procohice people. if that's teh reality, that's just the way it is... ie, the bottomline, is that as long as the public is for it, it's probably going to be preserved.
people who vote on this issue alone... are being charlie-brown-football-kick betrayed, over and over.


regan:
oconner - prochoice, preserve roe
rhenquist - prolife
scalia - prolife
kennedy - prochoice, preserve roe

bush:
souter - prochoice, preserve roe
thomas - prolife

clinton:
ginsberg -prochoice
breyer - prochoice

bush:
alito - probably prolife, but ambiguous
roberts - known as prolife, but preserve roe

list of appointees and their presidents, supreme court
[url="http://partners.is.asu.edu/~george/vacancy/justice_list.html"]http://partners.is.asu.edu/~george/vacancy/justice_list.html[/url]

robert bork: was denied during the senate hearings, with a 58 lead in majority, fairly close
douglass ginsburg: never voted on... regan
harriet miers: never voted on,,, bush jr
1969... time befre these when one was put down

[url="http://partners.is.asu.edu/~george/vacancy/justice_list.html"]http://partners.is.asu.edu/~george/vacancy/justice_list.html[/url]

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

i actually got most of my info from her. it's not an argument simply to point to an authority.
reading what she says... she draws lots of conclusions that are not based on much. i think she's one of the people causing misconceptions.

that shed held an infant in her hand for 45 minutes,, is sad, but erally an emotional argument only. that it lived for only 45 minutes shows that it was no viable. maybe it could have been saved... if it could have, even obama would say that it should be saved.

the bottomline.. is that obama is not for killing infants born alive that are viable.. and probably isn't for killing them when they're previable,,, i haven't seen anything to make me think otherwise on the postviability point.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

it looks like the federal bill and the state bill are diferent. ie, in what it does and doesn't do.
ie, the state bill requires doctors to get second guessed and langauge about "personhood" etc.
ie, the federal bill isn't changing anything, other than ensuring that by law a state can't deny rights. to viable born. what state was denying rights? it was more of a political statement.

it looks like obama was wrong,,, or lying,, about the "neutrality" clause. but the bills were different regardless of that clause. it looks like.

so the bottomline again.. is that obama is against the death or not helping viable born. and any other laws that were simply political statements and under the name of protecting newborns but that were really disguises,, he was against.

it may be a bad thing that he's prochoice,,, but it's not as bad as people say, and it doesn't justify saying he's for infanticide of born alive infants as a blank statement as people do.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

[url="http://www.jillstanek.com/archives/2008/02/links_to_barack.html"]http://www.jillstanek.com/archives/2008/02..._to_barack.html[/url]

the clause was never part of a bill as voted on, so technically he was not lying.

but, if it's true that he prevented it from being added, that could be a problem.

teh problem i see though, is that the way the bill is described in the state v. the way it's described in the federal, sounds different. the federal being something that no one wold be against. teh state looking like politics.

so it looks like he was using a technical point to avoid the underlying issues. probably, the issues he saw as too easy for people to misconstrue and so made the point about the clause lacking in the state version.
kind of like that lady stanek was using a technical point to say that he was against the bill with the clause, when really, he never was.
they're both using simplifications to communicate what are otherwise complex situations.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

[url="http://partners.is.asu.edu/~george/vacancy/failed.html"]http://partners.is.asu.edu/~george/vacancy/failed.html[/url]

that was suppose to be the last link i posted in the appointments post

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

plus.. as per the appointments that were denied.... they weren't necessarily any more prolife


[url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harriet_Miers"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harriet_Miers[/url]
ambiguos,,, but what she shows is arguable. she wanted to have the ABA be neutral on the stance of abortion, not saying they are prolife.
but then, newspapers say she was prolife 25 years ago,,, but currently unknown stance.

[url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Douglas_H._Ginsburg"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Douglas_H._Ginsburg[/url]
i didn't find anything about abortion offhand... but the reason he was denied was not because of abortion.. but because of his use of marijuana as a student, and continued use as an assistant professor at harvard.

[url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Bork"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Bork[/url]
this was pretty big about abortion actually. it still dosn't deny that stuff i said in my initial post on the issue tho.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

"In fact, Barack Obama is more liberal than any U.S. senator, voting against identical language of a bill that body passed unanimously, 98-0. In fact, Barack Obama condones infanticide if it would otherwise interfere with abortion."

in fact... if anyone is lying.. it is that woman.

the first sentence, is a lie, or misinformed
the clause was technically never part of the bills voted on.

the secondsentence, is a lie, or misinformed
he's for saving viable infants. previable he's not been shown to be for rights to kill them. he might be for allowing them to die, or to be killed,,, if the bill that prevents it, takes away abortion rights. but if this were the case, the most he could really be said to be,,, is prochoice. not proinfanticide.

so far the only ones lying if anyone is those on the prolife side in this debate of what happened in chicago

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

it is very interesting... bork was denied by the senate by only 58 to 42. that means, eight or nine different votes, and he would have won. if he'd have won, kennedy, the last regan appointee, wouldn't have been put on the bench... and kennedy wouldn't have cast the deciding vote upholding Roe in 92. Roe would ahve been overturned.
so basically,,, Roe would have been overtuned but for those eight or nine sentate members.
interesting.

also.. if roberts isn't as set on following roe as he said.. i may be wrong. he might just want to use it as precedent so longas there's not anyone willing to change... but this isn't the impression that he's given.

Madame Vengier
Posted

I totally and completely don't understand this thread.

(Anyone else confused?)

Posted

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1626423' date='Aug 13 2008, 08:17 PM']I totally and completely don't understand this thread.

(Anyone else confused?)[/quote]
Does anyone [i]ever[/i] understand any of dairy's posts?

Whatever election-time song-and-dance he might give, the undisputed fact remains that Obama's voting record as a senator is 100% pro-abortion (including voting against the partial-birth abortion ban). (http://www.ontheissues.org/Barack_Obama.htm) Not only that, but he has sworn to support the militantly pro-abortion proposed "Freedom of Choice Act."
And the fact is that as a state senator he voted to allow infanticide by voting against the Infants Born Alive Act. (On the grounds that this act would oppose "abortion rights.")

There is no reason a principled pro-lifer could even consider voting for Obama.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

says the man who on principle would rather let prochoice people remain prochoice rather than stop calling them proabortion. wow a lot of good those principles would do. soc probably is the type of fool who'd vote prolife,,, even when the candidate who is prochoice is everything he ever wanted other than abortion and the prochoice person is everything he ever didn't want except on abortion..... and five percent of the population is prolife and the law isn't going to change anyway,,, and that doesn't deter him from voting for the prolife person.
blind principles with no reference to reality isn't wise, but rather is foolish.

there's been no changes significantly to abortion in well over thirty years. i have a certain presumption of rightness to my arguemnts of not much expectations in change in abortion, in this alone.

here is someone who looks at the federal and state laws. there are indeed differences. other than the "neutrality" clause mentioned above.
viable born infants were already being protected in illinios. the state law banning it is simply was playing politics.
[url="http://writ.news.findlaw.com/colb/20080813.html"]http://writ.news.findlaw.com/colb/20080813.html[/url]

it blows my mind that people who claim to be informed and smart would call obama a supporter of infanticide. when i see this, i just see people who are the product of what the right tells them,,, what the media smears against obama want you to believe, zombies.
if there was merit to the claim, then that'd be another case, but there's not.
it's all rhetoric. it's all politics. and the people who follow it, are zombies.

i acknowledge my posts are a little all over the place. oh well.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

even NARAL backed the federal statute. obama is not more prochoice or infanticidical than NARAL..
look at that link.

i acknowledge that the fact he wants to pass the law stripping the states of their regulations on abortion... is the main thing that would make me not vote for him. but,,, as i quote from a catholic priest above... the liklihood of that getting any muster at all is very low and it doens't matter what a president woud think on it.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

people are always saying how mccain flip flopped on abortion. if he's sympathetic to the prolife cause... he's surely not going to put more prolife judges on the bench than the bushs and reagen.

right now... there are three truly prolife judges, out of nine. if you got any of the past republican presidents for president today,,,, and two vacancies,,,, nothing would change. ie, for every prolife appointment, there's a prochoice appointment.
don't expect more from mccain.

it's a reasonable posotion, if not the most reasonable position... to assume nothing significant is going to change as per abotion.
and to think that voting on that issue alone,,, is getting charlie brown football kick betrayed everytime you vote for them.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

[quote]From Obama's March 30, 2001, floor statement:

OBAMA: This bill was fairly extensively debated in the Judiciary Committee, and so I won't belabor the issue. I do want to just make sure that everybody in the Senate knows what this bill is about, as I understand it. Senator O'Malley, the testimony during the committee indicated that one of the key concerns was -- is that there was a method of abortion, an induced abortion, where the -- the fetus or child, as -- as some might describe it, is still temporarily alive outside the womb. And one of the concerns that came out in the testimony was the fact that they were not being properly cared for during that brief period of time that they were still living. Is that correct? Is that an accurate sort of description of one of the key concerns in the bill?

O'MALLEY: Senator Obama, it is certainly a key concern that the -- the way children are treated following their birth under these circumstances has been reported to be, without question, in my opinion, less than humane, and so this bill suggests that appropriate steps be taken to treat that baby as a -- a citizen of the United States and afforded all the rights and protections it deserves under the Constitution of the United States.

OBAMA: Well, it turned out -- that during the testimony a number of members who are typically in favor of a woman's right to choose an abortion were actually sympathetic to some of the concerns that your -- you raised and that were raised by witnesses in the testimony. And there was some suggestion that we might be able to craft something that might meet constitutional muster with respect to caring for fetuses or children who were delivered in this fashion. Unfortunately, this bill goes a little bit further, and so I just want to suggest, not that I think it'll make too much difference with respect to how we vote, that this is probably not going to survive constitutional scrutiny. Number one, whenever we define a previable fetus as a person that is protected by the equal protection clause or the other elements in the Constitution, what we're really saying is, in fact, that they are persons that are entitled to the kinds of protections that would be provided to a -- a child, a nine-month-old -- child that was delivered to term. That determination then, essentially, if it was accepted by a court, would forbid abortions to take place. I mean, it -- it would essentially bar abortions, because the equal protection clause does not allow somebody to kill a child, and if this is a child. Then this would be an antiabortion statute. For that purpose, I think it would probably be found unconstitutional.

The second reason that it would probably be found unconstitutional is that this essentially says that a doctor is required to provide treatment to a previable child, or fetus, however way you want to describe it. Viability is the line that has been drawn by the Supreme Court to determine whether or not an abortion can or cannot take place. And if we're placing a burden on the doctor that says you have to keep alive even a previable child as long as possible and give them as much medical attention as -- as is necessary to try to keep that child alive, then we're probably crossing the line in terms of unconstitutionality. Now, as I said before, this probably won't make any difference. I recall the last time we had a debate about abortion, we passed a bill out of here. I suggested to Members of the Judiciary Committee that it was unconstitutional and it would be struck down by the Seventh Circuit. It was. I recognize this is a passionate issue, and so I -- I won't, as I said, belabor the point. I think it's important to recognize though that this is an area where potentially we might have compromised and -- and arrived at a bill that dealt with the narrow concerns about how a -- a previable fetus or child was treated by a hospital. We decided not to do that. We're going much further than that in this bill. As a consequence, I think that we will probably end up in court once again, as we often do, on this issue. And as a consequence, I'll be voting Present.[/quote]

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

here is a quote from obama... from a person who quoted him. the person was criticizing that nurse stanek mentioned by lil red.
apparently i'm not the only one seeing the distortions she's making.

[quote]I lived in Chicago during the Obama-Keyes senate campaign, so I remember the debates quite well. It also included Keyes proclaiming who Jesus would vote for.

Here are Obama's actual words from State of Illinois, 92nd General Assembly, Regular Session, Senate Transcript:

Senator Obama:
Let me just go to the bill, very quickly. Essentially, I think, as – as this emerged during debate and during committee, the only plausible rationale, to my mind, for this legislation would be if you had a suspicion that a doctor, the attending physician, who has made an assessment that this is a nonviable fetus and that, let’s say for the purpose of the mother’s health, is being – that – that labor is being induced, that that physician (a) is going to make the wrong assessment and (b) if the physician discovered, after the labor had been induced, that, in fact, he made an error, or she made an error, and in fact, that this was not a nonviable fetus but, in fact, a live child, that that physician, of his own accord or her own accord, would not try to exercise the sort of medical measures and practices that would be involved in saving that child. Now, if – if you think that there are possibilities that doctors would not do that, than maybe this bill makes sense, but I – I suspect and my impression is, is that the Medical Society suspects as well that doctors feel that they would be under that obligation, that they would already be making these determinations and that, essentially, adding a – an additional doctor who then has to be called in an emergency situation to come in and make these assessments is really designed simply to burden the original decision of the woman and the physician to induce labor and perform an abortion. Now, if that’s the case – and – and I know that some of us feel very strongly one way or another on that issue – that’s fine, but I think it’s important to understand that this issue is about abortion and not live births. Because if these are children who are being born alive, I, at least, have confidence that a doctor who is in that room is going to try to make sure that they’re looked after. Thank you, Mr. President.

Does that sound like he's "supporting Infanticide," or perhaps that such language is hyperbole used by Ms. Stanek of the Pro-Life Pulse to demonize Senator Obama?[/quote]

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

here is obama addressing the infanticide claims.
i remember obama saying this in his debates with Alan keyes.

[quote]And lastly, here's a more specific quote that demonstrates Obama's position:

The other email rumor that’s been floating around is that somehow I’m unwilling to see doctors offer life-saving care to children who were born as a result of an induced abortion. That’s just false. There was a bill that came up in Illinois that was called the “Born Alive” bill that purported to require life-saving treatment to such infants. And I did vote against that bill. The reason was that there was already a law in place in Illinois that said that you always have to supply life-saving treatment to any infant under any circumstances, and this bill actually was designed to overturn Roe v. Wade, so I didn’t think it was going to pass constitutional muster.[/quote]

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

here is another obama quote.

[quote]While we're at it, does this sound like Obama is "abortion's biggest supporter in all forms" (from the same interview):

"I have repeatedly said that I think it’s entirely appropriate for states to restrict or even prohibit late-term abortions as long as there is a strict, well-defined exception for the health of the mother. Now, I don’t think that “mental distress” qualifies as the health of the mother. I think it has to be a serious physical issue that arises in pregnancy, where there are real, significant problems to the mother carrying that child to term. Otherwise, as long as there is such a medical exception in place, I think we can prohibit late-term abortions."[/quote]

dominicansoul
Posted (edited)

The man is 100% for Abortion-murder. You can't be against Abortion and continually vote to protect it. All your posts prove that he'll say anything to justify his stance of murdering children.

Thanks, you've convinced me even more why I shouldn't vote for that man!

Edited by dominicansoul

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...