Madame Vengier Posted August 15, 2008 Posted August 15, 2008 (edited) This is a very interesting perspective, very rational and logical. I think it gives some important food for thought regarding the way news and current events are disseminated. Specifically, here, Diana West is talking about all the negative reactions to Russia's invasion of Georgia, while at the same time the world refuses to give the same negative attention to Islamic oppression and violence which we are witnessing in modern times. Sources [url="http://www.jihadwatch.org/archives/022225.php"]here[/url] and [url="http://www.dianawest.net/Home/tabid/36/EntryID/414/Default.aspx"]here[/url]. [b]Diana West: Roars about Russia, Nary a Whisper about Islam[/b] [...] Historical memory somewhat refreshed, Western media were ready with the headlines -- "[b]The evil empire is back"; "Welcome to the 19th century"; "The Russian bear's new teeth" [/b]-- to promote the main thrust of most stories: namely, that Russia is reverting to tsarist, expansionist, Soviet-style, empire-amassing type. It's not that there's anything controversial in this journalistic approach, although I do tend to think there remain aspects of the Georgian story we haven't reconciled. What's noteworthy about this narrative consensus, however, is that the invocation of Russia's historical and cultural record is being made so frankly and without hedging. [b]That is, no one's blaming "Russian extremists," "tsarismists," or "hijackers of a great history."[/b] On the contrary, the implication behind most Russia-versus-Georgia stories is that the Russians' world-stage behavior as they smash Georgia is something that this same historical and cultural record tells us that Russians do. [...] And why is this important? When I started seeing these stories and statements -- even making some of them myself -- I realized there was something free-wheeling about the style of expression that made it different from what has been the norm. I first wondered if there was a somewhat perverse trace of nostalgia in dealing again with the Russians. And then it hit me.[b] In the nearly seven years since Islam has wholly dominated current events, neither our media nor our leaders have ever, not even once, looked at similarly characteristic behavior from the Islamic world and labeled it accordingly. In other words, no pattern of avowedly Islam-inspired violence in the world has ever earned a headline nearly as straightforward as "Islamic jihad is back." [/b]Not even the Islamic success of Motoon Rage, which has severely repressed Western modes of expression regarding Muhammad in particular and Islam in general, inspired anything as descriptive as, for example, "Sharia's new teeth." Ask yourself: Would any British foreign secretary of the postmodern age look at, say, last year's trial of a British teacher in Sudan for "blasphemy" in naming a teddy bear "Muhammad," and conclude: "It's a reversion to not just post-colonial politics. It is a seventh century way of doing politics"? Hah. [b]And what American presidential candidate would ever explain the Islamic push, financial and otherwise, in the West for mosque construction, Islamic schools (madrassas), campus Islamic studies (apologetics) departments, Sharia law-inspired legal challenges, lobbying for Sharia-compliant banking and the like as a matter of Islamic imperialism?[/b] I quoted McCain above discussing, matter-of-fact, what he considers to be catchall "Russian" ambitions to restore the "old Russian empire." Would he, or any other American politician, ever say the same regarding catchall "Islamic" ambitions? While both Russia and Islam claim similarly long histories and cultures of conquest for reference, it's [b]mighty tough to imagine any U.S. politician ever saying the following: "I think it's very clear that Islamic ambitions are to restore the old caliphate."[/b] (And that's despite a growing body of statements, even polling data, reflecting the persistence of Islamic caliphate dreams.) I'm afraid all the radical, fasco-Russian tsarismists will have to abandon their quest for world domination before we hear anything like that. Edited August 15, 2008 by Madame Vengier
aalpha1989 Posted August 15, 2008 Posted August 15, 2008 That IS interesting. Thank you for posting it. Madame, you always talk about Islam and the dangers therein... May I make a small point? I believe that the important warfare to come is not between the West and Islam. There will be (and is currently) physical, spiritual, and cultural violence between the two, but I think that a more important war will occur. I believe it will be between relativism and Truth. Here's why. Islam is quickly growing, but it is not growing nearly as quickly as secularism. Modern secularism and relativism go hand in hand, methinks. As you have pointed out, many people are extremely careful to be politically correct. You focus on pcness when it affects muslim relations, and you also point out that Christians get the shaft. I think that the important part of it is not that muslims are granted freedoms, because many of these freedoms are legitimate. The important part is that Christians' freedoms are taken away. Slowly and surely we will become a culture of dictatorship, as Ratzinger calls it. The culture of relativism and "tolerance" will restrict more and more Christian rights. I do not think that Islam will destroy the West. I think the West will destroy the West. Islam is not the biggest threat, a pervading sense of "non-religion" is.
Apotheoun Posted August 15, 2008 Posted August 15, 2008 I still consider Russia to be a natural ally of the West, even though I am adamantly opposed to Russia's unprovoked attack on Georgia.
J.P. Posted August 15, 2008 Posted August 15, 2008 [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1628279' date='Aug 15 2008, 05:06 PM']That IS interesting. Thank you for posting it. Madame, you always talk about Islam and the dangers therein... May I make a small point? I believe that the important warfare to come is not between the West and Islam. There will be (and is currently) physical, spiritual, and cultural violence between the two, but I think that a more important war will occur. I believe it will be between relativism and Truth. Here's why. Islam is quickly growing, but it is not growing nearly as quickly as secularism. Modern secularism and relativism go hand in hand, methinks. As you have pointed out, many people are extremely careful to be politically correct. You focus on pcness when it affects muslim relations, and you also point out that Christians get the shaft. I think that the important part of it is not that muslims are granted freedoms, because many of these freedoms are legitimate. The important part is that Christians' freedoms are taken away. Slowly and surely we will become a culture of dictatorship, as Ratzinger calls it. The culture of relativism and "tolerance" will restrict more and more Christian rights. I do not think that Islam will destroy the West. I think the West will destroy the West. Islam is not the biggest threat, a pervading sense of "non-religion" is.[/quote] Well said.
Madame Vengier Posted August 15, 2008 Author Posted August 15, 2008 [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1628279' date='Aug 15 2008, 05:06 PM']That IS interesting. Thank you for posting it. Madame, you always talk about Islam and the dangers therein... May I make a small point? I believe that the important warfare to come is not between the West and Islam. There will be (and is currently) physical, spiritual, and cultural violence between the two, but I think that a more important war will occur. I believe it will be between relativism and Truth. Here's why. Islam is quickly growing, but it is not growing nearly as quickly as secularism. Modern secularism and relativism go hand in hand, methinks. As you have pointed out, many people are extremely careful to be politically correct. You focus on pcness when it affects muslim relations, and you also point out that Christians get the shaft. I think that the important part of it is not that muslims are granted freedoms, because many of these freedoms are legitimate. The important part is that Christians' freedoms are taken away. Slowly and surely we will become a culture of dictatorship, as Ratzinger calls it. The culture of relativism and "tolerance" will restrict more and more Christian rights. I do not think that Islam will destroy the West. I think the West will destroy the West. Islam is not the biggest threat, a pervading sense of "non-religion" is.[/quote] I agree and disagree. 1: Believe me, I am WITH you on the secularization of our civilization. But we faced that during Communist and Nazi eras and the Faith (and civilization withstood it--even strengthened it). Islamic domininance is another animal altogether. You need to look at history. Don't just look at my posts. Don't just look at the sources I quote with every post. Look at Islamic history itself. You find this hair-raising fact: Christianity has NEVER bounced back from Islamic domination. Ever. Wait. Okay--maybe Spain. But look at what price. The Church will forever be accused of tyranny because of the Crusades, even though those Crusades won Spain back for Christ. 2: Islam is the single greatest threat the world is facing today. Not Muslims. They are victims of Islam. I mean ISLAM. What is unique about the threat of Islamic domination is that the whole of civilization is in danger for different reasons. Let us say: You and I both have a house. My house is strong but the roof is leaky. Your house is strong but the hinges on your back door are weak. We both have pretty strong houses but more importantly we both have small but significant weak points in our house. If I don't fix my leaky roof, theives can easily enter through the holes in the roof. If you don't fix the hinges on your back door, theives can easily tear down your back door and enter your home. We both have weak spots that need to be repaired. We are both in danger of infiltration from an enemy. I may have priceless family heirlooms that can be stolen. You may have priceless pieces of art. We both stand to lose something, by different means, from a common enemy. 3: Secularization makes my roof leaky and makes the hinges on your back door weak. But secularization is not the common enemy. The ones who would break into our homes by taken advantage of our weaknesses--that's who we need to fear.
Madame Vengier Posted August 15, 2008 Author Posted August 15, 2008 (edited) [quote name='J.P.' post='1628290' date='Aug 15 2008, 05:13 PM']Well said.[/quote] Good. Then you both can sit around with your daughters in burqas and your sons marching off for glory in the Great Jihad, while you complain about how "secularization" did your culture in. And there's this, too: [url="http://www.jihadwatch.org/dhimmiwatch/archives/022219.php"]http://www.jihadwatch.org/dhimmiwatch/archives/022219.php[/url] Secularization never did this a child. Edited August 15, 2008 by Madame Vengier
Madame Vengier Posted August 15, 2008 Author Posted August 15, 2008 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1628286' date='Aug 15 2008, 05:09 PM']I still consider Russia to be a natural ally of the West, even though I am adamantly opposed to Russia's unprovoked attack on Georgia.[/quote] Sure, but the article is about how quick the world is to condemn Russia while ignoring the threat of Islam. I don't think Russia is a threat to world peace. But surely it's a threat to tiny Georgia. Islam is a threat to world peace. I too think Russia should naturally be aligned with the West. They would make a great and powerful ally. And I don't want to see Russian culture and history fall to Islam. So, we need them and they need us.
J.P. Posted August 15, 2008 Posted August 15, 2008 [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1628301' date='Aug 15 2008, 05:28 PM']Good. Then you both can sit around with your daughters in burqas and your sons marching off for glory in the Great Jihad, while you complain about how "secularization" did your culture in. And there's this, too: [url="http://www.jihadwatch.org/dhimmiwatch/archives/022219.php"]http://www.jihadwatch.org/dhimmiwatch/archives/022219.php[/url] Secularization never did this a child.[/quote] Agree to disagree.
Apotheoun Posted August 15, 2008 Posted August 15, 2008 The West (especially Europe) may just become the Byzantium of the present day.
aalpha1989 Posted August 16, 2008 Posted August 16, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1628300' date='Aug 15 2008, 06:24 PM']I agree and disagree. 1: Believe me, I am WITH you on the secularization of our civilization. But we faced that during Communist and Nazi eras and the Faith (and civilization withstood it--even strengthened it). Islamic domininance is another animal altogether. You need to look at history. Don't just look at my posts. Don't just look at the sources I quote with every post. Look at Islamic history itself. You find this hair-raising fact: Christianity has NEVER bounced back from Islamic domination. Ever. Wait. Okay--maybe Spain. But look at what price. The Church will forever be accused of tyranny because of the Crusades, even though those Crusades won Spain back for Christ. 2: Islam is the single greatest threat the world is facing today. Not Muslims. They are victims of Islam. I mean ISLAM. What is unique about the threat of Islamic domination is that the whole of civilization is in danger for different reasons. Let us say: You and I both have a house. My house is strong but the roof is leaky. Your house is strong but the hinges on your back door are weak. We both have pretty strong houses but more importantly we both have small but significant weak points in our house. If I don't fix my leaky roof, theives can easily enter through the holes in the roof. If you don't fix the hinges on your back door, theives can easily tear down your back door and enter your home. We both have weak spots that need to be repaired. We are both in danger of infiltration from an enemy. I may have priceless family heirlooms that can be stolen. You may have priceless pieces of art. We both stand to lose something, by different means, from a common enemy. 3: Secularization makes my roof leaky and makes the hinges on your back door weak. But secularization is not the common enemy. The ones who would break into our homes by taken advantage of our weaknesses--that's who we need to fear.[/quote] I disagree. Secularization during Nazi and Communist eras (which occured only in the respective countries) did not strengthen society or religion. Europe is literally dead in its faith, and if you read any post-WWII literature at all it is not hard to guess the reason. WWII killed whatever hope Europeans held in their hearts after WWI. The atrocities revealed at the Nuremburg trials made Germans ashamed to be German, and some Christians ashamed to be Christians- it was primarily Christian officers and enlisted men, after all, who perpetrated the Holocaust. Many Germans abandoned Christianity. The French quarter of Christendom was weak already because of the secularization which occured in the French Revolution. Spain's Catholic population (98% as of 2005, I think) was largely Catholic in name only- I think less than 20% attended Mass (those statistics are about right, i think, but it has been a while since I really looked it up). Austria is 98% Catholic but is following Germany's lead. Russian Orthodox Churches were state-controlled and have lost much of the great tradition they once had. The people no longer believe, because what good God would allow a single man to kill 20 million of his own countrymen? What good God would allow the KGB to incarcerate and interrogate whoever they wanted? I do not know how you can say that Christianity survived and was strengthened by those periods of secularization. First of all, Christianity survived by the grace of God only, and it always will do so. Second of all, it was far from strengthened, in fact Europe itself demonstrates what happens when secularization is given free reign. Holland is one big red light district, as are select cities in other countries, and Holland is pulling Europe down with it via the European Union. Christianity is weakened to the point of being considered a bad joke by most of secular Europe. Secularization has killed European Christendom. Islam can kill people. Secularization can kill souls. Islam (in the radical fashion in which you view it) is comparable to the Roman empire. It creates Christian martyrs and takes many innocent lives, but cannot touch the true Faith. Secularization is comparable to the Protestant Reformation. It takes some truths and runs with them, abandoning the rest of the faith. It threatens to kill the future of the Church (it never will, She is eternal, but it can certainly cut many members off). Secularization works inside people's minds and persuades them to abandon their faith of their own free will. Islam has no such power. The Protestant Reformation was a greater tragedy than the Roman persecution could ever be. Also I didn't really see the point of including sarcasm in your reply to JP. He didn't ask for it, it wasn't really cool. Edited August 16, 2008 by aalpha1989
Apotheoun Posted August 16, 2008 Posted August 16, 2008 I doubt that Europe will be secular in a hundred years; instead, it will be Muslim.
Madame Vengier Posted August 16, 2008 Author Posted August 16, 2008 [quote name='J.P.' post='1628323' date='Aug 15 2008, 06:50 PM']Agree to disagree.[/quote] You are only saying that b/c you are ill-informed about Islam and the history of Islamic domination. I mean, the fact that you would say "agree to disagree" immediately following a link about 10 year old girls being subjected to rape under Islamic law is simply breath-taking to me. The irony is that you will still insist on spreading Christ West videos and declaring Katy Perry's stupid song "a part of the culture of death" but your response to Islamic-law protected child rape is to--effectively--shrug your shoulders. Sad.
Madame Vengier Posted August 16, 2008 Author Posted August 16, 2008 (edited) [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1628669' date='Aug 16 2008, 02:28 AM']I do not know how you can say that Christianity survived and was strengthened by those periods of secularization.[/quote] Because it still exists and ANYONE is free to pratice it. Christianity is allowed and no one forbidden to practice their faith in the West. The Church has been going through the new evangelization for the past almost 30 years. The Faith is strong. More and more young people know their Faith instead of going through the motions like their parents did. The numbers of conversions are up. Religious orders are growing. WYD events are in massive attendance. Catholic websites and blogs are all over the internet. The list could go on and on that proves that the Faith is not dead. If people are not practicing their Faith that is THEIR choice. Everything can't be blamed on "secularization". Each person exercises their own God-given free will. Stop placing blame on this invisible so-called evil force of "secularization". When Islam dominates, you will really have something to complain about. There won't be any more Christianity when that happens. Do you think I spend so much time trying to engage people in a dialouge about Islam becuase I'm just BORED and have nothing better to worry about? Edited August 16, 2008 by Madame Vengier
Madame Vengier Posted August 16, 2008 Author Posted August 16, 2008 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1628670' date='Aug 16 2008, 02:33 AM']I doubt that Europe will be secular in a hundred years; instead, it will be Muslim.[/quote] But don't try to convince anyone here that this is something to be deeply worried about.
Madame Vengier Posted August 16, 2008 Author Posted August 16, 2008 [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1628669' date='Aug 16 2008, 02:28 AM']Also I didn't really see the point of including sarcasm in your reply to JP. He didn't ask for it, it wasn't really cool.[/quote] There was no sarcasm. It was atually meant as a valid point. But valid points are easier to ignore when you can write them off as "sarcasm". BTW, while you're complaining about my supposed "uncool" sarcasm, I noticed that you conveniently ignored where I said that no country has ever bounced back from Islam. With the (barely) exception of Spain. And even that took 700 years and a lot of bloodshed. And I'm supposed to care that you think my supposed sarcasm is uncool to you.
Balthazor Posted August 16, 2008 Posted August 16, 2008 Part of the problem is political correctness. I hate to say it but we have neutered Europe to the point where it will not fight back for feaqr of someone saying that they are not politically correct. Let us get one thing straight: no one in Europe likes the muslim presence no one. In fact Europeans hate the headscarves, the halal food stands and the Mosques being constructed. But as soon as anyone protests they get jumped on for being racist or something like that. I really feel bad for Germany in particular. They have to put up with everything. And as soon as one German says that he doesn't like the Turkish gangs and riots and the way that German law caters to the Muslims he is called a Nazi. Which isn't true. It really Stinks! I wish the Mexicans would come here to Europe instead of to the States..... we need some awesome Christian people immigrating here speaking a European language. All we have are Turks and Lebonese who are hostile to Christianity, and treat non-Islamic women like they are whores. That and I would take a Carnita anyday over doner Kebab.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now