Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

figured this should be addressed in its own thread. since it's important.
onea those "obama's a a nazi, the antichrist, a muslim in kahoots with bin laden" things that need addressed. well, the argument about experience has some merit more than that, but definitely not as much as most people think.

1. Theodore Roosevelt (42)
2. John F. Kennedy (43)
3. Bill Clinton (46)
4. Ulysses S. Grant (46)
5. Grover Cleveland (47)
6. Franklin Pierce (48)
7. James A. Garfield (49)
8. James K. Polk (49)
9. Millard Fillmore (50)
10. John Tyler (51)

first to dispell a myth, obama's not the yongest ever etc. here's the ten youngest presidents. obama's not even in the top five. and close to even the tenth in years. as far as age goes, he's old enough, not just techincally legally, but for practical purposes too. put smarts in there for fast learner etc, he's surely just as good as number 11 etc.

for example, for experience,,, he's been in politics just as long as clinton was, and no one complained about him. not that they couldn't have,,, but just making the point that this who issue is probably just media rhetoric that they want you to argue for them. he's older than clinton was. he's done more things than clinton has. obama legislator, clinton governor,,, both have pros and cons and neither is really much better than the other in terms of which is a bette rpsotion.

to insist on experience given what obama's done,, is probably just insisting on someone older,,, older for the sake of older cause that's the only way you could get more experience. can't expect much more from obama given his age. (i mean you could but it wouldn't be very realistic,,, and not that we shouldn't expect more, but just saying that it's totally reasonable what experience he has, and A or A-... maybe not an A+, in terms of raw experience anyways for his age)

obama's weak point is the military and international law. he does have a lot of politicans and former presidents beat right off the bat though, cause he specialized in international law at harvard law. there's surely someone better out there, concedely. but, when his competition is pretty much just mccain,,, and you consider the things i said in that mccain war thread,,, obama's got him beat just in terms of making good decisions or at least not making bad ones like mccain.

also... most presidents in the past, consider well beyond reagan,,, had no international or military experience. or not much. i can see insisting on someone better for president in today's global climate that wouldn't be neeed as much back int hte day for past presidents,,, but, you'd have to concede that they were all unqualified for president too, today, if they were running. bush I bush II clinton reagan carter ford nixon kennedy etc etc.

so for domestic stuff,, if all those other presidents were good,, then obama's surely good. for military etc,,, most people i've shown probably don't have a problem with it even if they say they do, cause they wouldn't for most presidents but only do cause the media tells them to. at any rate, obama's got the compeition that matters beat, ie mccain.

now, if you dont think he's got the competition beat,,, and/or you'd concede that the past presidents were unqualified for today's presidency,,, (maybe if you thought domestically you could have someone better, and A+ instead of an A or A- like obama, in experience for the age, or you just want more age by experience) then, and only then, would you have a position that i'd think is respectable and not just media zombie spouting off about a lack of inexperience.

Posted

Half of the presidents you listed as being younger than Obama had military experience in war prior to being in office. His age is the least important thing about his being unqualified for the office. Studying international law at Harvard doesn't make him any more qualified to be president than my studying agricultural law at OU made me qualified to be a farmer.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

i meant real military experience, calling shots, or voting etc. you can't get a rubber stamp as if you know what you're talking about, just cause you were in the military as a kid.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

and jsut for clarity's sake... i didn't mean that the international law studying in school was an ace up obama's sleeve. if anything,, i was saying, he's got just as much as they do, and that's all he's got,,. so shows what they got, nothing.
also, i'm not discounting the being in the military stuff as nothing, but just saying it's not a rubber stamp, and really does nto count for all that much. probably,,, well maybe,,, arguably,, just as good as studying international stuff in school.

Posted

Obama has the same amount of experience as Pres. Clinton? Clinton was attorney general and was a two term governor. Both are executive experience. What are you talking about when you say he has the same experience?

Obama was law school professor and served 7 years in the Illinois legislature and 2 years in the US Senate. I say 2 years because he launched his presidential campaign almost exactly 2 years into his senate term and has has been campaigning full time since.

Oh let me address his "community organizer" work. He worked for a faith based Developing Communities Project as director. I have some questions about it but have not really investigated thoroughly and he was heavily involved in Project Vote! which is a part of ACORN. ACORN has been in itself a bit sketchy. They have been in trouble all over the country with all improper voter registrations.

Does this qualify him for president? I don't think so. But he can give a great speech off a telepromptor.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

clinton was attonney general,, it's political somewhat, but it's basically jsut being an attorney. he was that for two years. i think obama's got that matched at least, by practicing law for seven or so years, and teaching constutional law for twelve, and all the other life experience that he's got on clinton.
i guess clinton was in politics for 14 years, but obama was only 11. clinton surely campaigned jsut as much as obama did etc. i'm not sure three years makes that much of a difference.
you could argue all the other stuff obama has that i mentioned. but i do concede it's still three years.
is three years enough to say he's not qualified and clinton is though? considering the other stuff, i would't think so.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

actually... looking at when elections are held and when they took office,,, obama's got twelve years. so make that two years difference.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

kennedy had fourteen years too.

Madame Vengier
Posted

Obama is a junior senator with a grand total of 143 working days on the Senate floor under his belt from the time he became a Senator until the time he began his run for Presidential office. This is a fact that cannot be denied. That says everything we need to know about his "experience".

Posted

I'm sorry, but trying to debate that Obama has more experience than someone like US Grant, a West Point graduate, and veteran of the Mexican American War and the Civil War is just boggling. The reason that many people put respect and attention to candidates who have military experience, is that it is one of the few places left in the world where people are trained to be leaders. When you are in a position of knowing that the decisions that you make may get someone killed, it changes who you are as a person from that point forward.

Obama still acts like someone running for highschool class president. It's all facade with nothing holding up the foundation like some kind of old movie set. A 17 year old Eagle Scout has probably had more real leadership experience than Obama.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1629559' date='Aug 17 2008, 10:12 AM'][b]Obama still acts like someone running for highschool class president. [/b] It's all facade with nothing holding up the foundation like some kind of old movie set. A 17 year old Eagle Scout has probably had more real leadership experience than Obama.[/quote]

Best description of Obama...evah.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1629559' date='Aug 17 2008, 11:12 AM']Obama still acts like someone running for highschool class president. It's all facade with nothing holding up the foundation like some kind of old movie set. A 17 year old Eagle Scout has probably had more real leadership experience than Obama.[/quote]
:hehe:

MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1629462' date='Aug 17 2008, 12:37 AM']clinton was attonney general,, it's political somewhat, but it's basically jsut being an attorney. he was that for two years. i think obama's got that matched at least, by practicing law for seven or so years, and teaching constutional law for twelve, and all the other life experience that he's got on clinton.
i guess clinton was in politics for 14 years, but obama was only 11. clinton surely campaigned jsut as much as obama did etc. i'm not sure three years makes that much of a difference.
you could argue all the other stuff obama has that i mentioned. but i do concede it's still three years.
[b]is three years enough to say he's not qualified and clinton is though?[/b] considering the other stuff, i would't think so.[/quote]
Where did anyone say that Clinton is qualified enough?

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1629462' date='Aug 17 2008, 01:37 AM']clinton was attonney general[/quote]

Um, what now? :blink:

Posted

[quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1629462' date='Aug 17 2008, 02:37 AM']clinton was attonney general,, it's political somewhat, but it's basically jsut being an attorney.[/quote]

Are you serious?

Posted

[quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1629462' date='Aug 17 2008, 01:37 AM']clinton was attonney general,, it's political somewhat, but it's basically jsut being an attorney. he was that for two years. i think obama's got that matched at least, by practicing law for seven or so years, and teaching constutional law for twelve, and all the other life experience that he's got on clinton.
i guess clinton was in politics for 14 years, but obama was only 11. clinton surely campaigned jsut as much as obama did etc. i'm not sure three years makes that much of a difference.
you could argue all the other stuff obama has that i mentioned. but i do concede it's still three years.
is three years enough to say he's not qualified and clinton is though? considering the other stuff, i would't think so.[/quote]

The only experience that I will give Obama over Clinton is that he hasn't spent most of his adult life living in public housing.

There is difference between an executive position which has responsibility attached to it and legislative experience. He has taken very few stands in his political career. On the big issues Obama votes present. Obama has never run anything bigger than a classroom.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...