Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Not Voting For Obama/mccain?


Recommended Posts

Posted

I knew he was pretty much claiming it was a sin to do so, but did Ironmonk really say that Catholics would be [i]defiling the Eucharist[/i] if they go third party? I can't tell if you are exaggerating his position or if he really claimed that. I personally grew tired of his thread..

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

[quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1633651' date='Aug 21 2008, 03:19 PM']so i guess it's official that PM has gone from saying it's a mortal sin to vote third party, to not caring.
i mean,,, how convenient the people who wanted to vote third party before in the last two elections, could cast out mortal sins,, but now that there's a quasi liberal republican, no mortal sins are being cast out, even though abortion is still as live as it's ever been. how convenient.
maybe the people who said all that, are just not showing their faces.
i'm pretty sure cmom and most people here are doing an about face though.
there is cleraly ironmonk though,,, saying catholics who vote third party in this electiont are defiling the eucharist. i always found that interesting.[/quote]

I didn't know phatmass had any official stances defining mortal sins. :)

Which people are you referring to about the last two elections? That would cover eight years...

At any rate, we are all free to change our minds about something like this. Who you vote for is not directly a matter of faith and morals, but it should certainly be influenced by our faith and morals.

I'm surprised there hasn't been more said about Rick Warren's interviews. I don't follow the news a whole lot, so maybe that's why it seems like such an important event happened with little fanfare. Guess most people here are set against voting for either major candidate, so there wouldn't be much reason to discuss it.

Edited by LouisvilleFan
Posted

What??


I don't think most Catholics thought it was ever a mortal sin to vote third party.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

i remember it well.... just ask jaimie. they were saying it was a mortal sin to vote third party.
(the reason being, if it wasn't clear... is that you'd be arguably effectively voting for the prochoice person as the prolife one has one less person)
i guess i was for sure only here since the last presidentail election. i thikn i joined PM or knew of it in the first one, maybe not.

i wasn't exagerrating with what iron said, or making a conclusion from what he said. he explicitly said catholics would be defiling the eucharist. he even called out one person, and said they were... i forget who... wasn't it louisvillefan? i think it was him.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

i mean,, i realize there are no official stances at PM,,, but that idea of it being a mortal sin was pretty prevalent then. much less so now. peole like iron are the only consistent ones from his view.
like i said though,,, back then the peeps who thought different might not have argued, and the peeps who think it's a sin might not be now.
i think at any rate... what's popular opinion is definitely prevailing.... inconsistently from then and now.

Posted

[quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1633801' date='Aug 21 2008, 05:44 PM']i remember it well.... just ask jaimie. they were saying it was a mortal sin to vote third party.
(the reason being, if it wasn't clear... is that you'd be arguably effectively voting for the prochoice person as the prolife one has one less person)
i guess i was for sure only here since the last presidentail election. i thikn i joined PM or knew of it in the first one, maybe not.

i wasn't exagerrating with what iron said, or making a conclusion from what he said. he explicitly said catholics would be defiling the eucharist. he even called out one person, and said they were... i forget who... wasn't it louisvillefan? i think it was him.[/quote]

I don't doubt it. That thread was so frustrating.

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

[quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1633801' date='Aug 21 2008, 06:44 PM']i remember it well.... just ask jaimie. they were saying it was a mortal sin to vote third party.
(the reason being, if it wasn't clear... is that you'd be arguably effectively voting for the prochoice person as the prolife one has one less person)
i guess i was for sure only here since the last presidentail election. i thikn i joined PM or knew of it in the first one, maybe not.

i wasn't exagerrating with what iron said, or making a conclusion from what he said. he explicitly said catholics would be defiling the eucharist. he even called out one person, and said they were... i forget who... wasn't it louisvillefan? i think it was him.[/quote]

How about you search for this thread and give us a link? It sounds like a dumb discussion anyway with the substance of a Twinkie (or a peep... if picchick is reading this thread :) . People just don't seem to get that third party candidates draw votes away from [i]both[/i] major candidates. There are a few non-Christian, non-racist, non-Muslim-terrorist-fearing folks out there who aren't smitten by Obama.

[quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1633807' date='Aug 21 2008, 06:47 PM']i mean,, i realize there are no official stances at PM,,, but that idea of it being a mortal sin was pretty prevalent then. much less so now. peole like iron are the only consistent ones from his view.
like i said though,,, back then the peeps who thought different might not have argued, and the peeps who think it's a sin might not be now.
i think at any rate... what's popular opinion is definitely prevailing.... inconsistently from then and now.[/quote]

Probably a couple of people who highly vocal in expressing their silly opinion. I think these Election threads are probably some of the least popular, so you can't really judge the overall opinion of phatmass regulars based on the small number who participate in this threads.

Edited by LouisvilleFan

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...