Lil Red Posted August 21, 2008 Posted August 21, 2008 +J.M.J.+ [url="http://redcardigan.blogspot.com/2008/08/why-catholics-shouldnt-vote-for-obama.html"]Blog link[/url] [quote]Why Catholics Shouldn't Vote For Obama You have to hear this: it's audio of Obama discussing the "burden" of trying to save the life of a child born alive during an abortion (Hat Tip: Kathryn Jean Lopez at The Corner). The important quote is as follows (unofficial transcript): "...and that essentially adding an additional doctor who then has to be called in an emergency situation to come in and make these assessments is really designed simply to burden the original decision of the woman and the physician to induce labor and perform an abortion." Barack Obama on the Born Alive Infants Protection Act Bear in mind the following: The "emergency situation" is that the child has survived the induction abortion--he or she has emerged from the womb alive despite the efforts taken to kill him or her. The "assessments" referred to means noting whether the child is still alive. The "original decision" is the woman's decision to kill her baby. In other words, the baby, by living, places an undue burden on his or her mother because he or she didn't get the memo and came into the world alive; rather than summon an additional doctor, whisk the baby to the neonatal intensive care unit and try to save his or her life, Obama thinks the abortionist should get to carry out the abortion by neglect after the child has entered the world. Make no mistake. What this man supports and stands for is evil in its rawest and most diabolical form. Though I recognize that others may disagree, I honestly see no way whatsoever that a Catholic in good conscience could lend his support to someone who so openly, blatantly, coldly and determinedly fought for the "right" of women undergoing an induction abortion to continue the "abortion" and achieve the death of the child after the child's birth. You think McCain will get us into wars and engage in unjust empire-building? Possibly. But Barack Obama has shown beyond any shadow of a doubt that he has no respect for the intrinsic value of a human life, and it is from such men that dictators are made.[/quote] Original audio is at the linked site.
dairygirl4u2c Posted August 21, 2008 Posted August 21, 2008 [quote]In other words, the baby, by living, places an undue burden on his or her mother because he or she didn't get the memo and came into the world alive; rather than summon an additional doctor, whisk the baby to the neonatal intensive care unit and try to save his or her life, Obama thinks the abortionist should get to carry out the abortion by neglect after the child has entered the world.[/quote] i'm not sure what he meant. but, it could also be that by requiring another doctor,,, that might deter women from having a partial birth, privacy etc. obama's saying he trusts the original doctor to save the life if there's a chance it will live. or having doctors fight about something that reasonable professionals could disagree about, in front of the woman or even regardless of the woman, seems contrived. obama conceded that if original doctors were abusing it, he'd be for that legislation,,, but he said he didn't see that they were abusing it. incidentally, probably people think it cold. but keep in mind these are babies of questionable viability. catholic teaching ist hat you can let someone die of natural death, you don't have to use inflated means to save someone, juyst can't kill them. it's almost cruel to get a baby that's going ot live a wretched life like many pre-me babies do, to do that. to my understanding of how all that works, i mean. i'm not an expert of course. not sure exactly how this is relevant, but i'm sure it is somehow.
dominicansoul Posted August 21, 2008 Posted August 21, 2008 [quote]catholic teaching ist hat you can let someone die of natural death, you don't have to use inflated means to save someone, juyst can't kill them. it's almost cruel to get a baby that's going ot live a wretched life like many pre-me babies do, to do that. to my understanding of how all that works, i mean. i'm not an expert of course.[/quote] These babies are not dying of natural causes. They are being murdered so none of this applies in this situation. Also, the Holy Church does not allow for us to murder a person just because they may be disabled or have health problems. ALL life is sacred. No one can judge a person's right to life by judging their "quality" of life. GOD is the creator of life. Only HE has the right to take it, no one else...
Didacus Posted August 21, 2008 Posted August 21, 2008 [quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1633644' date='Aug 21 2008, 02:14 PM'][snip] probably people think it cold. but keep in mind these are babies of questionable viability. [snip][/quote] That's like saying you won't try to catch someone falling off a building because your chances of suceeding are too small. And viability is such a loose term - should babies with down-syndrome be considered viable? Isn't that the question Nazis used to justify their ends? Questioning the vialibility of individual human life?
dairygirl4u2c Posted August 21, 2008 Posted August 21, 2008 my understanding is that the legislation is only about giving aid to the babies. if i am wrong, and they were proactively killing them, then i stand corrected. i don't think this is the case though. that one example that nruse gave about holding hte baby for 45 minutes before it died, as case in point. [quote]That's like saying you won't try to catch someone falling off a building because your chances of suceeding are too small.[/quote] that's actually not anaolous. it does make your point, but it's misleading, this analogy. you save them cause there's no hindrances to trying to... if you fail, they fall. in the baby case, if you succeed, they live a life maimed etc. i'm sure you could find an alogy that makes the point better,,, but i doubt any that you could think of would be such that i'd be for saving them.... ie, successfully saiving them leads them to live tortured lives, wouldn't be good in any book. but with that said... i guess it depends on how often, empiraclly, they live wretchedly, and how often they don't. i don't know the numbers. and then it'd depend on how far along they are, etc. this coplexity is another reason i coudl see respecting the original doctor's decision, as per letting die or not,,, who's gonna decide, why is one position better? reasonable people can disagree so let the original is the argment. you have an interesting idea about a disease... what if someone is living a tortured life,,, why not just let them die? i don't think it'd be against catholic teaching to say let them die, necessarily. ?? it seems sorta gray, they can't do it themself so letting die would be justified in that sense, but another says you should tend to them etc. the issues isn't just with pre-me;s then... it's with the any situation where someone thnks they can just let a person die, ie, on a feeding tube etc. that's normally thought of as okay to let them die,,, so why not some diseased person who just lies ona bed their whole life? ie, the question isnt' limited to just this sisutaion, so you shou;dn't try to limit it to this istuation. if reasonable perople can disagree generally, they could argualy disagree here, reasonable catholics even.
MissScripture Posted August 21, 2008 Posted August 21, 2008 [quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1633788' date='Aug 21 2008, 05:33 PM']my understanding is that the legislation is only about giving aid to the babies. if i am wrong, and they were proactively killing them, then i stand corrected. i don't think this is the case though. that one example that nruse gave about holding hte baby for 45 minutes before it died, as case in point.[/quote] Not "giving aid" to a baby IS killing it.
Maximilianus Posted August 22, 2008 Posted August 22, 2008 (edited) A quote from Obama that has really stuck with me is when he said; "Look, I got two daughters. 9 years old and 6 years old, I am going to teach them first about values and morals, but if they make a mistake, I don’t want them [b]punished with a baby[/b]..." Edited August 22, 2008 by Maximilianus
Madame Vengier Posted August 22, 2008 Posted August 22, 2008 [quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1633644' date='Aug 21 2008, 01:14 PM']i'm not sure what he meant.[/quote] He meant exactly what he said. Is that clear enough for you?
kujo Posted August 22, 2008 Posted August 22, 2008 I posted links in [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=83900"]THIS THREAD[/url] regarding his explanation of his votes against the BA bills.
dairygirl4u2c Posted August 22, 2008 Posted August 22, 2008 [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1634089' date='Aug 21 2008, 09:31 PM']He meant exactly what he said. Is that clear enough for you?[/quote] "another doctor poses a burden" obviously, how does the other doctor pose a burden is the question. obviously, it's ambiguous, cause the implications are unclear and could mean many things. "meant exactly what he said" is something that a simpleton would say. or, maybe, someone trying to provoke a fight? are you irritable cause of the spats you've been getting into, with al justin etc, or something? cause what you claim makes no sense, so it's got to be something.
dairygirl4u2c Posted August 22, 2008 Posted August 22, 2008 [quote]the issues isn't just with pre-me;s then... it's with the any situation where someone thnks they can just let a person die, ie, on a feeding tube etc. that's normally thought of as okay to let them die,,, so why not some diseased person who just lies ona bed their whole life? ie, the question isnt' limited to just this sisutaion, so you shou;dn't try to limit it to this istuation. if reasonable perople can disagree generally, they could argualy disagree here, reasonable catholics even.[/quote] to be clearer... consider the many possibilities. a baby who is destined to live in an incubator, but also destined to die. a baby who grows up but is relegated to a bed, much like someone on a feeding tube, and vegetive like but not still like those on feeding tubes. someone with simple diseases like down's syndrome etc isn't what i was referring to when i said you could dispute it. i mean, in a way you could, in theory (they can't help themself, but then what baby can... and as adults they might not be able to, but we also respect tending to the handicap etc),,, but intutitively, and in practice, that is considered something you should try to save. there's not a clear cut off,,, and when you get to someone who's like a vegetable, it gets thorny. when you have a baby who simply moves a little, the odds of it being like that mentioned about are humongous. there's lots of scales here. it's disappointing people can't see it, and lump it all together. (and then call it infanticide at that. (esp since there were other laws, and all the other stuff i pointed out in my other thread, but that's another post and thread, and related but different topic)
dairygirl4u2c Posted August 22, 2008 Posted August 22, 2008 "shows signs of life" v. "can be saved" i heard the test for saving described both ways, but it makes a pretty big difference which it is. this issue with obama,, is at most for him something that's being contrived against him, but at least, something that's a whole lot more complicated that people make it out to be.
Justin86 Posted August 22, 2008 Posted August 22, 2008 I thought Obama's worst quote was at Rick Warren's church when asked when he felt an unborn baby deserved rights said something like "I think that's decdied by people above my paygrade." Who the heck is above his paygrade as President? He just compltely avoided the issue by making a stupid comment. Of course given his audience I'm sure he knew better than to state his actual opinion. Cowardly little piece of c[i][/i]rap that he is.
Didacus Posted August 22, 2008 Posted August 22, 2008 There are many abortion survivors today that will well above normal lives. Wasn't there one who addressed the senate none too long ago? Find me an abortion survivor that supports abortion if you can. As Saint Augustine said; I've met all sorts of people, and all people regretted their miseries but none regretted having lived.
dairygirl4u2c Posted August 22, 2008 Posted August 22, 2008 when he said it was "above his paygrade" he was responding to the idea of whether it has a soul etc, theological ideas. i thought it was pretty clear that he meant, that's something only God would know. but i might be mistaken, and haven't looked into how people took it or what he meant by it.
Justin86 Posted August 22, 2008 Posted August 22, 2008 [quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1634540' date='Aug 23 2008, 12:31 AM']when he said it was "above his paygrade" he was responding to the idea of whether it has a soul etc, theological ideas. i thought it was pretty clear that he meant, that's something only God would know. but i might be mistaken, and haven't looked into how people took it or what he meant by it.[/quote] Um, no. The question was specifically about when rights should be given. Rick Warren was not asking Obama for his spiritual opinions.
dairygirl4u2c Posted August 22, 2008 Posted August 22, 2008 Obama: “. . . whether you’re looking at it from a theological perspective or a scientific perspective, answering that question with specificity . . . is above my pay grade.” he used theological terminology in answering hte question though. and it doesnt' seem like he'd be implying that someone knows more htan he does. i don't see many people claiming ot know what he meant. they just point out that it was a dodge of giving his opinion of it. there's many interpretations. i thought mine was th way it was,,, but since you think different, maybe it's not necessarily. i don't see how you would think he's saying anything other than what i said though, ie, he's not God. it was designed to be evasive like that though so, i'd question anyone who really thinks they knew waht he meant.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now