CatholicCid Posted August 22, 2008 Posted August 22, 2008 I would wonder about the pyschological differences though. Been a while before I took any type of course covering 'mental development', but perhaps there is a difference.
Ash Wednesday Posted August 23, 2008 Posted August 23, 2008 Champions go by the rules. End of discussion.
XIX Posted August 23, 2008 Posted August 23, 2008 [quote name='VeniteAdoremus' post='1634565' date='Aug 22 2008, 01:02 PM']No... the rules are there to protect younger children, not because younger athletes are better than older ones.[/quote] Younger gymnasts are much better than older gymnasts. Gymnasts usually peak at around 13 or 14 or so, and then they become less flexible. So yes, the Chinese gained a huge advantage over the competition if they brought in younger gymnasts. Obviously, there's no reason to circumvent the rules unless you are going to gain an advantage by doing so.
XIX Posted August 23, 2008 Posted August 23, 2008 [quote name='Didacus' post='1634786' date='Aug 22 2008, 03:50 PM']She beat them without any undue advantage = she is champion, although informally at worst.[/quote] Under the age limit = an undue advantage. 13 year old gymnasts are MUCH better than 16 year old gymnasts.
geetarplayer Posted August 23, 2008 Posted August 23, 2008 Yes, they say that younger athletes are more flexible and "nimble" than older ones. But again, the rules are not so much in place because of undue advantage, but to protect the physical and mental well-being of the athletes. If she is underage, it is her coaches'/parents'/country's fault for pressuring her to perform in the Olympics at such a delicate age.
DemonSlayer Posted August 23, 2008 Posted August 23, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1634220' date='Aug 22 2008, 01:10 PM']Bah, I saw when she "won" that gold medal against Nastia Liukin. It was complete BS. The only reason she won was because that one Australian judge wasn't paying attention. Liukin actually gave a much better performance. He Kexin's gold medal is forever going to be in doubt just because of that regardless of her age.[/quote]Competitor's from Russia, China and the USA normally get better scores than everybody else anyway, for example, one of the Australian girls fell once from the beam, while another girl from Russia fell twice and got a much better score than her.
VeniteAdoremus Posted August 23, 2008 Posted August 23, 2008 [quote name='DemonSlayer' post='1635375' date='Aug 23 2008, 10:13 AM']Competitor's from Russia, China and the USA normally get better scores than everybody else anyway, for example, one of the Australian girls fell once from the beam, while another girl from Russia fell twice and got a much better score than her.[/quote] Jury sport. It's a bummer. By the way, did you know that there's a 14-year-old English boy performing legally in the... whatsitcalled... where you jump into a pool but make saltos and stuff And he also came out in the figure swimming, but he was too nervous to perform well (aaah so cute ). The age limits are probably different because there's so much less impact on the joints?
Didacus Posted August 25, 2008 Posted August 25, 2008 I would be very interested in reading from a frim source that a 14 year old gymnast has a distinct and measurable advantage over a 16 year old.
Madame Vengier Posted August 25, 2008 Posted August 25, 2008 [quote name='Didacus' post='1637426' date='Aug 25 2008, 08:00 AM']I would be very interested in reading from a frim source that a 14 year old gymnast has a distinct and measurable advantage over a 16 year old.[/quote] I'm guessing that she doesn't. I'm also guessing the reason why the Chinese have lied about this girl's age is because she turned out to be an amazing gymnast, probably began to excel rapidly at the sport and they knew she could be a major contender for the gold. Problem was, she was too young. But they wanted her in there anyway, 'cause they saw she's the best, so they fudged her records. I'd bet this is how it went down. It has nothing to do with the AGE given her an advantage. It's THIS girl.
homeschoolmom Posted August 25, 2008 Posted August 25, 2008 [quote name='VeniteAdoremus' post='1635391' date='Aug 23 2008, 04:36 AM']Jury sport. It's a bummer. By the way, did you know that there's a 14-year-old English boy performing legally in the... whatsitcalled... where you jump into a pool but make saltos and stuff And he also came out in the figure swimming, but he was too nervous to perform well (aaah so cute ). The age limits are probably different because there's so much less impact on the joints?[/quote] Yeah, I was wondering about this, too. Seems it's okey dokey to be 14 in the diving competitions, but not gymnastics...
SJRod55 Posted August 25, 2008 Posted August 25, 2008 There are arguments being put forward by many in sports to do away with the age limitations because they cause so many problems. I doubt there were age restrictions in the original games it would be more a matter of when they were physically able to compete.
CatherineM Posted August 25, 2008 Posted August 25, 2008 the arguments I heard when this debate first started several years ago had to do with body mass ratios. Being older helps male gymnasts because they put on muscle mass in the 14-18 ages. In females, we put on a different kind of mass. Females weight to upper body strength changes dramatically after puberty. It's that dang estrogen.
Didacus Posted August 25, 2008 Posted August 25, 2008 I believe it was the 1980 archer champion who best exemplified for me the olypic form and ideal. He was a smoker, grotestly overweight (his bow would bulge into his belly when he prepped himself for a shot for crying out loud!) - yet, he was the best and by every right an olympic champion. Must have been an inspiration for the 'breakfast of champions' skit by James Belushi! Back to you Bob...
Mercy me Posted August 25, 2008 Posted August 25, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1637534' date='Aug 25 2008, 12:12 PM']the arguments I heard when this debate first started several years ago had to do with body mass ratios. Being older helps male gymnasts because they put on muscle mass in the 14-18 ages. In females, we put on a different kind of mass. Females weight to upper body strength changes dramatically after puberty. It's that dang estrogen.[/quote] That and the weight is distributed unevenly which really causes trouble with twisting, spinning and somersaulting. I know quite a few former gymnasts and divers who can tell you all about having to relearn things that they had done for what seemed like their entire lives. This is why you have issues like eating disorders that were so prevalent. It is not just to keep the weight down. It is also to delay puberty.
Didacus Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1637534' date='Aug 25 2008, 12:12 PM']the arguments I heard when this debate first started several years ago had to do with body mass ratios. Being older helps male gymnasts because they put on muscle mass in the 14-18 ages. In females, we put on a different kind of mass. Females weight to upper body strength changes dramatically after puberty. It's that dang estrogen.[/quote] If that be true than HANG HER! Strip her medal and tell her to come back in four years. If that's true I mean...
homeschoolmom Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 [quote name='Rod' post='1637527' date='Aug 25 2008, 12:03 PM']There are arguments being put forward by many in sports to do away with the age limitations because they cause so many problems. I doubt there were age restrictions in the original games it would be more a matter of when they were physically able to compete.[/quote] There were also no female gymnasts... or gymnasts at all! And since they competed buck nekid, where would they put all the corporate logos? [quote name='CatherineM' post='1637534' date='Aug 25 2008, 12:12 PM']In females, we put on a different kind of mass.[/quote] [quote name='Mercy me' post='1637957' date='Aug 25 2008, 06:29 PM']That and the weight is distributed unevenly which really causes trouble with twisting, spinning and somersaulting.[/quote] Or in normal women, getting up off of the floor from a sitting position...
SJRod55 Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 Unfortunatelty the weight distribution thing is not just a female issue.... I wish it was .... alas on turning 30 I lost my lean, ruggedly handsome looks and gained those nasty pounds that seem to appear overnight! It has been a losing battle (no pun intended) since then! As for the naked female athletes ----- I won't even go there! I would have too many penalty points!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now