Resurrexi Posted August 22, 2008 Posted August 22, 2008 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1634975' date='Aug 22 2008, 03:36 PM']The doctrine of infalliblity is just that, doctrine, right? However, dogma are things that are decided to be infallible, while doctrine can, in theory, be changed. Right? So how come it's not "dogma of infallibility', since it almost seems that a 'weaker' belief is creating 'stronger' beliefs. Sounds really irreverent when I say it that way. I'm sure you know what I mean though. Basically, how come infalliblity is not defined as dogma?[/quote] Papal Infallibility is a dogma. It was defined by the First Ecumenical Council of the Vatican. [quote name='D 838-840']But since in this very age, in which the salutary efficacy of the apostolic duty is especially required, not a few are found who disparage its authority, We deem it most necessary to assert solemnly the prerogative which the Only-begotten Son of God deigned to enjoin with the highest pastoral office. And so We, adhering faithfully to the tradition received from the beginning of the Christian faith, to the glory of God, our Savior, the elevation of the Catholic religion and the salvation of Christian peoples, with the approbation of the sacred Council, teach and explain that the dogma has been divinely revealed: that the Roman Pontiff, when he speaks ex cathedra, that is, when carrying out the duty of the pastor and teacher of all Christians by virtue of his supreme apostolic authority he defines a doctrine of faith or morals to be held by the universal Church, through the divine assistance promised him in blessed Peter, operates with that infallibility with which the divine Redeemer wished that His church be instructed in defining doctrine on faith and morals; and so such definitions of the Roman Pontiff from himself, but not from the consensus of the Church, are unalterable. But if anyone presumes to contradict this definition of Ours, which may God forbid: let him be anathema.[/quote]
Nihil Obstat Posted August 23, 2008 Posted August 23, 2008 Well there goes my question. How come I always hear "doctrine of infalliblity"? Is this just convenient wording, not necessarily accurate? Or have I been listening poorly? Anyway, glad to hear this. I was confused.
Resurrexi Posted August 23, 2008 Author Posted August 23, 2008 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1635361' date='Aug 22 2008, 11:47 PM']Well there goes my question. How come I always hear "doctrine of infalliblity"? Is this just convenient wording, not necessarily accurate? Or have I been listening poorly? Anyway, glad to hear this. I was confused.[/quote] Well, I would say since all dogmas are doctrines of the Church, you'd be correct saying either the "dogma of Papal Infallibility"or the "doctrine". Obviously, saying "dogma" would be giving more information
qfnol31 Posted August 23, 2008 Posted August 23, 2008 The doctrine of infallibility was expanded to include the Ordinary Episcopal Magisterium at the Second Vatican Council. Because of this, we can say infallibly that only men can be priests.
qfnol31 Posted August 23, 2008 Posted August 23, 2008 (edited) Actually, I shall correct what I had written here. Doctrines are simply teachings of the Magisterium, including all teachings. Dogmas are those infallibly taught doctrines. I shall explain with the following: And now that I see this was in the Q and A section, I'll give a much longer answer. There are different levels of teaching within the Catholic Church. These are spelled out partly in practice (such as using a motu proprio versus an encyclical) and partly in the two Vatican Councils. First we distinguish between infallible teachings and non-infallible teachings. Infallible means that they are true and without error. Non-infallible teachings does not mean that they are wrong, but that they are not preserved from being changed slightly over time. Within infallible teachings we have extraordinary and ordinary infallibility. Extraordinary infallibility is determined through councils and ex cathedra statements. (See [i]Pastor Aeternus[/i] from Vatican I and [i]Lumen Gentium[/i] at Vatican II.) Ordinary infallibility refers to general proclamations of the Magisterium. For instance, the Holy Father can confirm that a teaching is infallibly taught when the whole Magisterium has always taught it (see the state of priestly ordination being reserved solely to men in [i]Ordinatio Sacerdotalis[/i] by John Paul II and the response by Ratzinger while at the CDF). Within these various teachings we have Then we have the non-infallible authoritative teachings. In this we distinguish between doctrinal and prudential. Doctrinal means the essence of the teaching is true, though some elements are not always clear. Prudential refers to how a Catholic should respond to a certain contingent set of situations. Given A and B, then C. But given A and D but not B, then possibly E. I hope this clarifies me some. Doctrines are teachings of the Magisterium, and often should be treated as infallible in essence, while dogmas are those infallible doctrines of the Church. Edited August 23, 2008 by qfnol31
Nihil Obstat Posted August 23, 2008 Posted August 23, 2008 Thanks for that answer. I guess the confusion just comes from me never really hearing "Dogma of infallibility" instead of just hearing "doctrine".
Apotheoun Posted August 23, 2008 Posted August 23, 2008 The hard distinction made today between doctrines (things intimately related to divine revelation) and dogmas (things which are themselves divinely revealed) is not ancient, but is merely a couple hundred years old. Nevertheless, using that modern distinction the Magisteriium holds that both doctrines and dogmas can be infallible, and -- to understand this better -- I recommend reading the [url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/CURIA/CDFADTU.HTM"][u]CDF Commentary on the Professio Fidei[/u][/url], which was issued back in the late 1990s.
qfnol31 Posted August 24, 2008 Posted August 24, 2008 Yes, I would guess that it is more accurate to say that dogmas are directly from Revelation, while doctrines can be infallible teachings in support of Revelation: [quote name='The Compendium']16. To whom is given the task of authentically interpreting the deposit of faith? 85-90 100 The task of giving an authentic interpretation of the deposit of faith has been entrusted to the living teaching office of the Church alone, that is, to the successor of Peter, the Bishop of Rome, and to the bishops in communion with him. To this Magisterium, which in the service of the Word of God enjoys the certain charism of truth, belongs also the task of defining dogmas which are formulations of the truths contained in divine Revelation. This authority of the Magisterium also extends to those truths necessarily connected with Revelation.[/quote] An infallible doctrine might be Mary's Immaculate Conception, which is necessary for certain dogmas to be true. I would think that Papal Infallibility is more a doctrine than a dogma. I think in the end, most of the time dogma and doctrine are not fixed terms and have been used in different senses, even by theologians.
Nihil Obstat Posted August 24, 2008 Posted August 24, 2008 [quote name='qfnol31' post='1635965' date='Aug 23 2008, 08:20 PM']An infallible doctrine might be Mary's Immaculate Conception, which is necessary for certain dogmas to be true. I would think that Papal Infallibility is more a doctrine than a dogma.[/quote] I thought that was specifically defined as dogma? Or was it specifically defined as infallible? Wow, I thought I kinda had a good enough grasp on this stuff!!!
Aloysius Posted August 24, 2008 Posted August 24, 2008 all dogmas are doctrines but not all doctrines are dogmas there are infallible doctrines which are not dogmas basically, a dogma is an infallible doctrine that is ESSENTIAL to the Christian Faith. Jesus' Ressurection and many other such things are just understood as dogmata (did that just for you, STM, .. there are of course the Marian dogmas that were defined outright, anyway, there are dogmata (dogmas haha) about a great number of things... the best source for what is and isn't categorized as such would be Ott, I suppose.
Resurrexi Posted August 24, 2008 Author Posted August 24, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1636336' date='Aug 23 2008, 11:16 PM']I thought that was specifically defined as dogma? Or was it specifically defined as infallible? Wow, I thought I kinda had a good enough grasp on this stuff!!! [/quote] Both the Immaculate Conception and Papal Infallibility were defined as dogmas [quote name='Pope Bl. Pius IX: Ineffabilis Deus" with emphasis added']To the honor of the Holy and Undivided Trinity, to the glory and adornment of the Virgin Mother of God, to the exaltation of the Catholic Faith and the increase of the Christian religion, by the authority of our Lord Jesus Christ, of the blessed Apostles, Peter and Paul, and by Our own, [b]We declare, pronounce, and define[/b] that the doctrine, which holds that the most Blessed Virgin Mary at the first instant of her conception, by a singular grace and privilege of Almighty God, in virtue of the merits of Christ Jesus, the Savior of the human race, was preserved immaculate from all stain of original sin, has been revealed by God, and on this account must be firmly and constantly believed by all the faithful. Wherefore, if any should presume to think in their hearts otherwise than as it has been defined by Us, which God avert, let them know and understand that they are condemned by their own judgment; that they have suffered shipwreck in regard to faith, and have revolted from the unity of the Church; and what is more, that by their own act they subject themselves to the penalties established by law, if, what they think in their heart, they should to signify by word or writing or any other external means.[/quote] Pretty clear from the wording that it was being defined as a dogma. Even more clear in the case of the definition of the dogma of Papal Infallibility. [quote name='First Ecumenical Council of The Vatican: "Pastor Aeternus" with my emphasis added']And so We, adhering faithfully to the tradition received from the beginning of the Christian faith, to the glory of God, our Savior, the elevation of the Catholic religion and the salvation of Christian peoples, with the approbation of the sacred Council, [b]teach and explain that the dogma has been divinely revealed[/b]: that the Roman Pontiff, when he speaks ex cathedra, that is, when carrying out the duty of the pastor and teacher of all Christians by virtue of his supreme apostolic authority he defines a doctrine of faith or morals to be held by the universal Church, through the divine assistance promised him in blessed Peter, operates with that infallibility with which the divine Redeemer wished that His church be instructed in defining doctrine on faith and morals; and so such definitions of the Roman Pontiff from himself, but not from the consensus of the Church, are unalterable.[/quote] [quote name='Aloysius' post='1636554' date='Aug 24 2008, 08:12 AM']Jesus' Ressurection and many other such things are just understood as dogmata (did that just for you, STM, .[/quote] Edited August 24, 2008 by StThomasMore
Mr.Cat Posted August 25, 2008 Posted August 25, 2008 (edited) [quote][b]The Second Vatican Council - Lumen-gentium [/b](Saturday, November 21, 1964) This Sacred Council, [u]following closely in the footsteps of the First Vatican Council[/u], with that Council teaches and declares that Jesus Christ, the eternal Shepherd, established His holy Church, having sent forth the apostles as He Himself had been sent by the Father; and He willed that their successors, namely the bishops, should be shepherds in His Church even to the consummation of the world. And in order that the episcopate itself might be one and undivided, He placed Blessed Peter over the other apostles, and instituted in him a permanent and visible source and foundation of unity of faith and communion. [u]And all this teaching about the institution, the perpetuity, the meaning and reason for the[/u] sacred [u][b]primacy of the Roman Pontiff and of his infallible magisterium[/b][/u], [b]this Sacred Council again proposes to be firmly believed by all the faithful[/b]. Continuing in that same undertaking, this Council is resolved to declare and proclaim before all men the doctrine concerning bishops, the successors of the apostles, who together with the successor of Peter, the Vicar of Christ, the visible Head of the whole Church, govern the house of the living God. And this infallibility with which the Divine Redeemer willed His Church to be endowed in defining doctrine of faith and morals, extends as far as the deposit of Revelation extends, which must be religiously guarded and faithfully expounded. [b]And this is the infallibility which the Roman Pontiff, the head of the college of bishops, enjoys in virtue of his office, [u]when, as the supreme shepherd and teacher of all the faithful, who confirms his brethren in their faith, by a definitive act he proclaims a doctrine of faith or morals[/u][/b]. [b][u]And therefore his definitions, of themselves, and not from the consent of the Church, are justly styled irreformable[/u][/b], since they are pronounced with the assistance of the Holy Spirit, promised to him in blessed Peter, [u]and therefore they need no approval of others, nor do they allow an appeal to any other judgment[/u]. For then the Roman Pontiff is not pronouncing judgment as a private person, but as the supreme teacher of the universal Church, [b]in whom the charism of infallibility of the Church itself is individually present[/b], [u]he is expounding or defending a doctrine of Catholic faith[/u]. The infallibility promised to the Church resides also in the body of Bishops, when that body exercises the supreme magisterium with the successor of Peter. To these definitions the assent of the Church can never be wanting, on account of the activity of that same Holy Spirit, by which the whole flock of Christ is preserved and progresses in unity of faith. [url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/documents/vat-ii_const_19641121_lumen-gentium_en.html"]http://www.vatican.va/archive/hist_council...gentium_en.html[/url][/quote]This makes me ponder of Blessed Peter of Luxembourg ( [url="http://saints.sqpn.com/saintp5t.htm"]http://saints.sqpn.com/saintp5t.htm[/url] ) who during a cricises took the sides of Robert of Geneva, Anti-pope Clement VII ( [url="http://saints.sqpn.com/ncd07125.htm"]http://saints.sqpn.com/ncd07125.htm[/url] ), and even marched armed troops againts the forces of Pope Urban VI ( [url="http://saints.sqpn.com/pope0202.htm"]http://saints.sqpn.com/pope0202.htm[/url] ) to regain his see. He chose the wrong side in the dispute over the papacy, but was immediately recognized for his personal holiness. Reminds me also of a Saint, possibly Saint Rita of Cascia ( [url="http://saints.sqpn.com/saintr01.htm"]http://saints.sqpn.com/saintr01.htm[/url] ), while on her death bed she was told she did not understand the True Presence. She responded only that she believed it was truly our Blessed Lord, and that was enough. Edited August 25, 2008 by Mr.CatholicCat
Paddington Posted August 25, 2008 Posted August 25, 2008 [quote name='Mr.CatholicCat' post='1637405' date='Aug 25 2008, 07:22 AM']Saint Rita of Cascia ( [url="http://saints.sqpn.com/saintr01.htm"]http://saints.sqpn.com/saintr01.htm[/url] ),[/quote] Thanks for the link! She helps desperate causes and that is the coolest thing in the world to me!
Resurrexi Posted June 28, 2009 Author Posted June 28, 2009 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1635848' date='Aug 23 2008, 05:50 PM']The hard distinction made today between doctrines (things intimately related to divine revelation) and dogmas (things which are themselves divinely revealed) is not ancient, but is merely a couple hundred years old. Nevertheless, using that modern distinction the Magisteriium holds that both doctrines and dogmas can be infallible, and -- to understand this better -- I recommend reading the [url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/CURIA/CDFADTU.HTM"][u]CDF Commentary on the Professio Fidei[/u][/url], which was issued back in the late 1990s.[/quote] I cannot believe this. Apotheoun recommended the CDF commentary. These were the days.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now