Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Has anyone read this book?

I am veryyyy curious to get a 'catholic perspective' on it, or just anyone's
i LOVED it with all my heart and soul, actually :)

haha

soo tell me what you thought about it!

Posted

i wish i could help you there, but i haven't read it :(

Posted

*listens in*

I really want to read it.

Posted

i've also been tempted to read it.

puellapaschalis
Posted

Oh! Did the author do an interview on Oprah? Because I think I saw a bit of that and ended up watching the rest of it too. Then I saw the book in the shops and [i]almost[/i] bought it but a) I have perpetual guilt about buying books and b) I was wary it would be wishy-washy-new-agey and stuff.

But you've read it? And enjoyed it?

Madame Vengier
Posted (edited)

From the things I have heard and read about it, it never struck me an anything I could relate to as Catholic. Not that I'm opposed to reading non-Catholic perspectives on spirituality and other things, because I do read them. It's this particular book. It's the fact that she abandoned her marriage because the notion of "finding herself" on some "quest" was more important, and the fact that she equates entering into a sexual affair during her "quest" (that's the "love" part of the title) with love and romance as part of "finding herself", it all sits very badly with me. She struck me as a blatantly selfish woman. And I really don't have any use for books by people like her.

[quote]At the age of thirty-one, Gilbert moved with her husband to the suburbs of New York and began trying to get pregnant, only to realize that she wanted neither a child nor a husband. Three years later, after a protracted divorce, she embarked on a yearlong trip of recovery, with three main stops: Rome, for pleasure (mostly gustatory, with a special emphasis on gelato); an ashram outside of Mumbai, for spiritual searching; and Bali, for "balancing."[/quote]

BTW. it was in Bali that she had the affair so apparently she thinks sex will "balance" her.

[url="http://www.amazon.com/Eat-Pray-Love-Everything-Indonesia/dp/0670034711"]http://www.amazon.com/Eat-Pray-Love-Everyt...a/dp/0670034711[/url]

Edited by Madame Vengier
Posted

the affair wasn't the love part.

and i don't completely agree with the sex in bali..but that wasn't the completely balance

i absolutelyyyyyy loved it

yes it was the chick on oprah thats howi heard of it

ha :)


...i'm not sure what new-agey means really, because..everything she studied, and all the type of stuff, is ancient. its just that people are really taking more of an interest in it now.

Posted

I work at the library, so I know it's really popular... a lot of people have been putting it on hold. but I've never read it. :idontknow:

Maximilianus
Posted

From a Catholic perspective I'm wary of anything pushed by Oprah.

Posted

If it's recommended by Oprah I wouldn't buy it.

CoffeeCatholic
Posted

I started it, got about 10 pages in, and put it down. Not all it was hyped up to be in my opinion. Sure, some books take a bit to "get into", but when the first 10 pages disgust you, yeah....

Posted

Okay... I read it. I loved it.

Totally not Catholic, but certainly not non-Catholic.

It certainly gave me an insight into Eastern religions. Which I greatly appreciated about it.

It was a nice, light, sit-down-with-a-glass-of-wine kind of book.

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1637501' date='Aug 26 2008, 12:32 AM']Okay... I read it. I loved it.

Totally not Catholic, but certainly not non-Catholic.

It certainly gave me an insight into Eastern religions. Which I greatly appreciated about it.

It was a nice, light, sit-down-with-a-glass-of-wine kind of book.[/quote]
Sounds very chick, typical of Oprah. Still not interested.

Posted (edited)

ouch, you guys are harsh on oprah

but oprah was not the point




it was a very personal thing, it opened up so much to me.

its not a Chick book, its a soul book, it was for me anyway

none of you will understand, unless you read the book, (thoroughly)

so for any open mind thats intersted, i definitely recommend it :)

Edited by alimarie_11
Posted

[quote name='Maximilianus' post='1637392' date='Aug 25 2008, 03:24 AM']From a Catholic perspective I'm wary of anything pushed by Oprah.[/quote]

Me as well, as would many Christians, not just Catholics.

Not to say that I would completely disregard a certain book immediately if I was interested in it and saw that it happened to have her approval, but I would research it well beforehand.

Posted

I read it and I loved it as well. Sure, she definitely does not have a Catholic perspective. I spent a year living in Rome, so reading the Eat part of the book was lots of fun. In terms of the rest of the book, I identified with a lot of the general soul searching that she did.

Posted

I read it, it was OK. I liked the part in Italy the best.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...