Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

so why not advocate trickle up instead of trickle down.

ie, trickle up being give tax breaks to the rich and hope that it trickles down to the poor and/or creates jobs.

i was skeptical about trickle up,,, cause, cause i thought if hte poor get money, and they spend it,,,that it'd at most usually increase production, and not expand any base. like, if you buy shirts, they'd just make more, probably not a whole lot of expansion giong on.
but, then i realized. that the money's is going to get to teh rich, and what are they going to do with it? they're going to invest it, exband the base like that somehow, or even just putting it in the bank, the bank's going to invest it, ie stocks etc.

so all the good points about trickle down, is going to happen soon enough anyway.

so if you have trickle up,,, you ensure the poor get it, and you know the rich will eventually too. trickle down is just here's to hoping, and giving the rich a bunch of money they odn't know what to do with without ensuring it helps anyone in the mean time.

so it seems to me the only real reason you might be against it, is simply on principle, that we shouldn't focus on only the poor.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

cause the engine of an economy is money exchanging hands. it's sure to be exhancing hands here, not just floatin around waiting for a good investment.
and,,, if the poorer get the money, it'd help with upward mobility, which would help with small business etc, which would help innovation.
innovation is what expands the economy.

(in my mind innovation is what expands the economy,,,, and money exchanging hands is what makes it function. like a top, that toy, where you push it and it expands.... the spinning is from money exchanges, and the expansion or pushing the button is from innovation)

Posted

tax breaks for both the rich AND the poor is the best idea ;)

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

there was a typo in the first post, second sentence or so "ie trick up" should say "ie tricle down"

considering our debt,,, and considering that all the tax breaks we've been getting from regan and bush etc is only causing it to go up exponentially,,, we have to be wise with out tax breaks. even if it's for stimulation.

i think most of the eocnomy is going to take care of itself eventually. if there's a slow down cause of the credit bubble pop, that's just the economy fixing itself, that's all. so it's not like we need to give tax breaks,,, but if we're going to we should do it frugally.

and since we hardly ever pay back the debt,,, we need to be weary about going into debt to begin with.
i mean, even ron paul would probably say,,,, ideally yes reduce spending and give tax cuts,,, but if you don't reduc spending and tax cuts mean debt, then don't compound the problem by getting interest to pay also by going into debt.
people lose sight of the basic conservative principle that what you borrow you have to pay back... with interest.


if hte poor are hurting, his will give them a break, and help the economy

so wise tax breaks, if any.... give it to the poor, but first and formost give to those who innovate.

Posted

Get rid of income tax. Use sales tax. Inescapable. Even drug dealers will have to pay taxes. Tax luxury items at a higher rate, necessities at a very low one.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

not a bad idea win. i had like the idea of a sales tax, then i got hesitant about it cause i think it might cause taxes to go up actually if govment is to break even in input output expneses and income. then i thought about maybe taxing the rich more,,, like with an income tax for the rich,,, but that'd be hard to do politically and is unevenhanded.
i had considered the idea of a luxury tax,,, but never really combined it with the idea of a sales tax. you made the connection.

i bet that'd work politically too. i know lotsa even conservative who'd be willing ot do the luxury tax, eg, Al etc. so you odn't need a compliated income tax on teh rich, and it's more fair too even handed on the rich, it's all your choice as a rich person what to do with it etc.
even some popes have said there should be a luxury tax. (which i can easy get a quot on,,, with a lot more, if anyone's interested)
course it all depends on how much you tax the luxury etc.

i'd say... welfare and things that the poor might need help with, if it's legitimate help which is complicated,,,, should be made up for, from the luxury tax. whatever it takes. gotta be responsibnle with it though.

i think i'm going to steal your idea.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

i also like how you say tax necessities lower. so profound yet so simple.
it's like the fair tax folks were almost there, but not quite. with thier rebate and all the same percetage stuff. etc etc. most didn't even know what they wre arguing for.
too bad win's systme wasn't called hte fair tax.
maybe there needs to be a "fair tax II" advocacy to fix what were mostly half thoughts in the first one.

Posted

How can the United States pay off debt without some big taxes? :unsure:

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

the US is always paying off some debt. then new debt comes along to replace the old debt etc.
that's what bonds are all about.
ie, bonds in case no one knows are what fund the debts etc.

some conservatives, and i think rightsly so... say to focus less on paying it back and more on growing the GDP etc. then the debt becomes smaller just as a matter of course.
what really needs to stop, is more debt from occurring, but keep paying off old debts as is done now. it'd be very gradual, so i guess it's still not a big tax all at once like you had mentioend.

Posted

I also think those on welfare should have to work. That would take big changes in the system, but they would either find ordinary labor or do odd jobs for the government.

Have you ever gone into section 8 housing? They destroy the places. Require them to maintain their homes in a decent manner.

This one might be too far for most: drug testing those on welfare. Government employees are subject to random drug tests, so it makes sense that anyone who is getting a check should have to submit to random drug tests.

1337 k4th0l1x0r
Posted

Spending on production != Spending on consumption

Income taxes generally tax production rather than consumption. Sales taxes tax consumption. Lowering income taxes will create an incentive for increased production. As it stands now, if someone successfully produces something a significant fraction of the returns go to the government whereas if the person fails the government has not lost anything. Corporate taxes work in much the same way. So reducing taxes on those who are responsible for much of the production in this country, i.e. corporations and SBOs, will result in an increase in production. The wealth that the rich in this country have is literally on paper. If someone owns $100 million of stock in a company, they don't have $100 million in hard assets. They aren't depriving a poor person of food or consumer goods. On the contrary, the company they own stock in may be producing something a poor or middle class person needs. If they are providing someone or many people with jobs, even better.

A common misconception is that rich people spend their money like poor or middle class people only scaled up. Someone worth $10M doesn't drive around in a car worth 100x that of someone only worth $100K.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

i don't see anything i disagree with, or that's incompatible with the fair tax system as proposed by winchester, and now me. not that there was meant to be anything disagreed with, jus saying.

that common misconception is why the first fair tax sucked. ie, the rich simply wouldn't spend enough to make the income and outgoing money for the government to break even. they'd have to make the poor and middle class spend more than they do now. with what win said.... the luxury tax can compensate for all that.
all the benefits of the fair tax I are being gotten, ie not taxing productivity etc, and all hte hindrances of it are mitigated.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted (edited)

except to say... maybe i shouldn't just think the luxury tax should be what's used to pay for welfare type stuff. maybe i should include a little more too, i don't know.

the complication and some background info. i like the idea of a flat tax, cause people would pay proportional to what they take from the earth and society. surely, the richer donald trumps, roads etc use more police and judicial system etc more than some random small family. So that they pay more dollar amount as proportioanl to their income etc is the way to deal with that.
To me, the progressive tax is even better, cause it's the richer who should pay for fixing social ills that are fundamentally broken (not every social ill, as charity has its place,,, but things like when A can't get ahead because of the very structure of society is flawed when there's no reason for it to be and not bc of his slack etc). So their progressive tax should be be what pays for all that.

if the rich don't spend nearly enough, with a sales tax,, they may have to pay more with a luxury tax too, not just enough to pay for welfare etc type things.

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
dairygirl4u2c
Posted

"(so every social ill, but things like when A can't get ahead because of the very structure of society and not bc of his slack etc)"

that's suppose to say "not every social ill"

Posted

But in addition to income tax, we pay property tax.

We rent our homes from the government.

The money goes out, regardless of what end, but collecting income tax is expensive and easily circumvented.

No, the rich might not drive "a" car worth that much more. But they often own multiple cars, and we can put different styles of cars in different tax brackets. The stupids want to increase the license fees for larger vehicles to encourage all of us to croutons money and buy more efficient cars. This is the typical stupid democrat idea that hurts those who work for their money. The rich will continue to buy luxury items and spend their money. We would have to target certain items.

Merely targeting money won't do it. Barack Stalin wants to tax "windfalls". He would hit my retirement account hard--money that I will have saved over the course of 30 years, hurting the monthly amount I'd get from interest. Is there a difference between my retirement money that I'll live off of and a large sum of money inherited from, say, Hilton to Hilton?

Yes, but dumbbutts like Barack and probably McCain don't seem to get that.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

i was just guessing above in my posts that that's what ron paul would have said. he in fact did say it too:

[quote]So, while the liberal economic agenda includes more taxes and spending, the neo-con economic program simply looks to target some tax cuts to preferred groups, but ignore the economic big picture. The neo-con economic agenda is to “borrow and spend” and it is that agenda, even more than the tax and spend ways of many liberals, that has cast us in economic peril at this time.[/quote]

he even appears to have advocated a targeted tax cut to the middle class etc. though the reasons aren't explained very well, and the context.
[quote]Over the years, I have offered several tax plans designed to assist hard working middle-class Americans to pay for their needs, whether these needs be health-care related, educational or to pay the costs of fuel. A few years back when I introduced one such bill, a prominent Republican approached me on the House Floor and asked, half in anger and half in amazement “why did you do that?” Shortly after that, the committee chairman at the time, also a Republican, sent out a release strongly attacking my tax cut bill.[/quote]

[url="http://www.the-peoples-forum.com/cgi-bin/readart.cgi?ArtNum=2820"]http://www.the-peoples-forum.com/cgi-bin/r...cgi?ArtNum=2820[/url]

Posted

When I retire, the money in my retirement account will put me in the "rich" category. It will be the money I've set aside to have a decent life, but O wants to hit it with a "windfall" tax. That's croutons.

In addition, the money I have take out pre-tax will no longer be pre-tax, if he gets his way. Up go my taxes.

Coming and going, as they say.

Posted

[quote name='Winchester' post='1637081' date='Aug 24 2008, 09:32 PM']I also think those on welfare should have to work. That would take big changes in the system, but they would either find ordinary labor or do odd jobs for the government.[/quote]
The only jobs people on welfare would be able to find is daycare jobs taking care of all the kids for the welfare people who had to get jobs.

Posted

Norseman82's law of taxes: for each tax, there will spawn more ways of avoiding that tax.

Personally, I believe in a hybrid of tax cuts targeted to lower income people and American businesses that provide jobs here. The best way to do that is to cut the FICA (social security) tax, since half is paid by the employee and half by the employer. It would also benefit the self-employed, since they pay both teh employee and employer portion of taxes.

After that, resurrect Ronald Reagan's idea of "enterprise zones" for economically depressed areas here in the USA.

Posted

[quote name='Winchester' post='1638718' date='Aug 26 2008, 01:36 PM']When I retire, the money in my retirement account will put me in the "rich" category. It will be the money I've set aside to have a decent life, but O wants to hit it with a "windfall" tax. That's croutons.

In addition, the money I have take out pre-tax will no longer be pre-tax, if he gets his way. Up go my taxes.

Coming and going, as they say.[/quote]

Another thing to worry about would be if someone wanted to tax Roth IRAs.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...