Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

+J.M.J.+
just was told by a co-worker that i shouldn't veil because it is an 'outward sign of piety and Jesus is very clear about being against that in the Bible'. and that it is 'appropriate to veil in private prayer but not in public prayer (Mass)'. and that in a 'position of leadership within the parish, i have a lot of influence'. that 'it doesn't jive with being modest if my dress doesn't reflect that (and she has a point there), but that if i'm going to do it maybe i should wear long skirts'. and 'that if i'm trying to go for a pre-vatican ii feeling, i wouldn't have a job, i would be a second-class citizen (as a woman), and that i wouldn't be married to my husband (since he's not Catholic)'.

and that people are saying all this stuff anyway. (:rolleyes:)

i told her that if our boss (the priest) has a problem, then he can come and tell me not to veil (after which i would go to the bishop). and that i wasn't going to take orders from her.

i'm very upset, and i need some help in refuting all of this. thanks.

HisChildForever
Posted

Perhaps you could tell her that while veiling is a personal issue ("issue" sounds negative but I'm not trying to be, I just can't find the proper word) between you and Jesus, it also shows the community your humble devotion, and you could very well be seen as a positive role model.

It might do well to explain that you're not trying to look "above" everyone else (You know, "holier than thou") and if anyone thinks that way, they were clearly not properly taught about this practice.

Posted

Whenever anyone asks me a personal question, or makes a statement to me about something that is personal, and frankly none of their business, I very politely say one of a couple things.

"Why would you want to know (ask) something that personal?"

"The way I was raised, folks just didn't ask each other such personal questions."

See my point. Oprah, Phil, and Springer have given our society the idea that we have the right to know everything about everybody. We don't. How, why, when, where, you choose to veil is not anyone's business, anymore than what color underwear you wear. Just because someone asks you a question, doesn't mean you have to answer it or discuss the topic in any way.

I don't veil, I don't wear dresses. The reasons for either aren't anyone's business outside my husband and/or priest. People with manners deal with those who don't by ignoring them.

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1637513' date='Aug 25 2008, 11:45 AM']+J.M.J.+
just was told by a co-worker that i shouldn't veil because it is an 'outward sign of piety and Jesus is very clear about being against that in the Bible'. and that it is 'appropriate to veil in private prayer but not in public prayer (Mass)'. and that in a 'position of leadership within the parish, i have a lot of influence'. that 'it doesn't jive with being modest if my dress doesn't reflect that (and she has a point there), but that if i'm going to do it maybe i should wear long skirts'. and 'that if i'm trying to go for a pre-vatican ii feeling, i wouldn't have a job, i would be a second-class citizen (as a woman), and that i wouldn't be married to my husband (since he's not Catholic)'.

and that people are saying all this stuff anyway. (:rolleyes:)

i told her that if our boss (the priest) has a problem, then he can come and tell me not to veil (after which i would go to the bishop). and that i wasn't going to take orders from her.

i'm very upset, and i need some help in refuting all of this. thanks.[/quote]

that's absurd For a Christian to say). St. Paul cammands it.

Of course he also demands that you keep silent in Church and do not have authority over a man :detective:

Plus, if my memory is good, the veil was not abolished by Vatican II, however the (I think) 1983 code of Cannon law did not list it as an obligation, meaning you do not have to wear it but can.

I think

dominicansoul
Posted

Lil Red,

The most important thing to do is not give this woman's opinion any influence over you. She's got some issues she's obviously frustrated with, and is using you to bellyache about them. You continue to do what you want, it's all for Jesus, no one else. The fact that you have even received some "persecution" for veiling is a good sign that you are doing what Jesus wants!

This woman seems afraid that others may take your good example and start wearing the veil. To many feminists, this is seen as a sign of submission. The comment she made about women being "second-class citizens" is a totally outrageous claim against the Holy Church. But if that's how she feels, it may have a lot to do with what she told you.

Posted

[quote name='dominicansoul' post='1637553' date='Aug 25 2008, 10:33 AM']Lil Red,

The most important thing to do is not give this woman's opinion any influence over you. She's got some issues she's obviously frustrated with, and is using you to bellyache about them. You continue to do what you want, it's all for Jesus, no one else. The fact that you have even received some "persecution" for veiling is a good sign that you are doing what Jesus wants!

This woman seems afraid that others may take your good example and start wearing the veil. To many feminists, this is seen as a sign of submission. The comment she made about women being "second-class citizens" is a totally outrageous claim against the Holy Church. But if that's how she feels, it may have a lot to do with what she told you.[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
thank you. :) but how do i address these issues when i know that she probably will go 'bellyaching' to the priest about them, and then i'll have to discuss it with him. :(

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1637541' date='Aug 25 2008, 10:22 AM']Whenever anyone asks me a personal question, or makes a statement to me about something that is personal, and frankly none of their business, I very politely say one of a couple things.

"Why would you want to know (ask) something that personal?"

"The way I was raised, folks just didn't ask each other such personal questions."

See my point. Oprah, Phil, and Springer have given our society the idea that we have the right to know everything about everybody. We don't. How, why, when, where, you choose to veil is not anyone's business, anymore than what color underwear you wear. Just because someone asks you a question, doesn't mean you have to answer it or discuss the topic in any way.

I don't veil, I don't wear dresses. The reasons for either aren't anyone's business outside my husband and/or priest. People with manners deal with those who don't by ignoring them.[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
thank you. :) you are right that it is a personal issue. i apologize and explain myself far too often (it's a bad habit).

dominicansoul
Posted

Just tell her the reasons you wear it is between you and Christ. If she keeps rattling off on all the nonsense, kindly tell her "thanks for your concern." And leave it at that. Don't pay her any mind. IF she takes it to the priest, respectfully talk to the priest about it, but if he suggests not wearing it, you would need to be obedient to the priest until you can speak to the Bishop about it. Pray, dear sister, and I'll pray for you, too. Pray before speaking, and the Holy Spirit will help you for sure!

Posted

[quote name='dominicansoul' post='1637569' date='Aug 25 2008, 10:41 AM']Just tell her the reasons you wear it is between you and Christ. If she keeps rattling off on all the nonsense, kindly tell her "thanks for your concern." And leave it at that. Don't pay her any mind. IF she takes it to the priest, respectfully talk to the priest about it, but if he suggests not wearing it, you would need to be obedient to the priest until you can speak to the Bishop about it. Pray, dear sister, and I'll pray for you, too. Pray before speaking, and the Holy Spirit will help you for sure![/quote]
+J.M.J.+
thank you for sure for the prayers. i think part of the problem too, is that i don't wear a 'traditional' lace veil, i wear a blue prayer shawl. but i figured that wearing a traditional lace veil really would give people the impression that i was going 'pre-vatican ii', and so i thought something a little non-traditional.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

If this is an inappropriate outward sign of piety, maybe it would be better if every woman wore extremely short skirts and showed middrifts and shoulders? After all, you don't want to appear too holy.
Don't listen to her. Do what you know is right. :D
...but you knew that already. :))

Ash Wednesday
Posted (edited)

Sounds like your co-worker is being irrational and feels inferior or threatened.

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1637513' date='Aug 25 2008, 10:45 AM']'outward sign of piety and Jesus is very clear about being against that in the Bible'.[/quote]
Jesus was against people using outward signs of piety being done in an effort to gain praise. If we weren't supposed to show any piety at all, then why wear crucifixes or religious shirts? Does she have a problem with that as well?

[quote]'appropriate to veil in private prayer but not in public prayer (Mass)'.[/quote]
Same as above applies. But even then, does she have some secret knowledge of Canon law or church precepts regarding veil wearing that nobody else does?

[quote]'position of leadership within the parish, i have a lot of influence'.[/quote]
So if other people choose to wear veils and cover their heads, especially considering that it's allowed and even often practiced in papal audiences and places like the Vatican, this is a bad thing?

[quote]'it doesn't jive with being modest if my dress doesn't reflect that (and she has a point there), but that if i'm going to do it maybe i should wear long skirts'.[/quote]

Hey ma! The fashion police are here!

She's contradicting herself with that comment. By the same rationale she used before, showing outward signs of piety (yes, that includes modesty) is a no no. So having a dress should reflect outward modesty, and this should be done. Yet this somehow can't apply when it comes to covering your head?


[quote]'that if i'm trying to go for a pre-vatican ii feeling, i wouldn't have a job, i would be a second-class citizen (as a woman), and that i wouldn't be married to my husband (since he's not Catholic)'.[/quote]

And by wearing a veil, how is it that this states that someone wants to go back in time before Vatican II? Pretty unfair to make that assumption about a person. And for the record, my grandfather married my grandmother when she was not a Catholic. This was long before Vatican II. She did become one, but that was years later.

[quote]and that people are saying all this stuff anyway. (:rolleyes:)[/quote]

Because Jesus *really* wanted us to worry about public opinion!



That's just amazing.

And the the thing is, I don't even veil. I'm not comfortable with it myself, but I have no problem with anyone who chooses to do so. It's sad that people get defensive and threatened by someone else's act of faith within our own church.

Edited by Ash Wednesday
Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1637513' date='Aug 25 2008, 11:45 AM']+J.M.J.+
just was told by a co-worker that i shouldn't veil because it is an 'outward sign of piety and Jesus is very clear about being against that in the Bible'. and that it is 'appropriate to veil in private prayer but not in public prayer (Mass)'. and that in a 'position of leadership within the parish, i have a lot of influence'. that 'it doesn't jive with being modest if my dress doesn't reflect that (and she has a point there), but that if i'm going to do it maybe i should wear long skirts'. and 'that if i'm trying to go for a pre-vatican ii feeling, i wouldn't have a job, i would be a second-class citizen (as a woman), and that i wouldn't be married to my husband (since he's not Catholic)'.

and that people are saying all this stuff anyway. (:rolleyes:)

i told her that if our boss (the priest) has a problem, then he can come and tell me not to veil (after which i would go to the bishop). and that i wasn't going to take orders from her.

i'm very upset, and i need some help in refuting all of this. thanks.[/quote]


Jesus speaks against outward signs of piety that weren't accompanied by pious practice. Meaning they dressed the part but they didn't act the part. Anything can be an outward sign of piety, including attending Mass or praying at all. If she has a problem with you veiling then she must have a problem with the priest wearing vestments. Afterall it was about vestments that Christ was addressing this issue with in the Bible. We would also have to remove all sacramentals from our person as well because these are all symbols of piety. Truly a very weak argument.

I believe you handled it the correct way. Only your priest should be able to correct you on this matter. The Church allows veiling and in saying that is not against veiling.

Posted

I certainly understand you being upset by what that woman said. She really has no right to make a judgement on your reasons or your piety.

I have had a very strong urge to wear a veil ever since I came back into the church. I know of only one woman who wears a veil all the time to Mass. I mentioned it to my sister about six months ago and she told me the same thing your lady did. She said it was an outward sign of piety which draws attention to a person. She went on to say that there was nothing wrong with me wearing a veil, but maybe I should wait until I gave up the makeup, quit coloring my hair, started wearing blouses that came up to my neck, no more sparkle shirts, ( :)) ) no more shirts with hoods and hearts all over them, (my trademark) and basically dress my age. I had to admit she had a point. In my case only. I may be modest in demeanor at Mass and I don't wear scandalous clothing, but the rest of me doesn't really fit the image of a veil.
I was ticked off at first. I realized my sister would be a model for a person to wear a veil and she doesn't because she adamently does not want to draw attention to herself. She never wore a veil growing up. I did and I liked it. Maybe when I hit 60 I will.

I say do whatever you want. I don't know if I agree that one has to look and dress like a frump to be veiled. I am not sure what being pious is. Is there a test for it? Do you have to sign something that you go to Mass every day, adoration every day and pray three hours a day to be issued one? That is between a person and God, not anyone else. I think it is a sign of respect and love and reverence for Our Lord and Our Church and I think everyone should be wearing one, even the men.

Posted

You could always tell them "stop looking at my head and pay attention to Jesus!"

Posted

Ummm.. I totally support you Red...

But I think that everyone is being a little insensitive about this.

You can't have a "Well, I like to veil, so shove off" attitude (I know that isn't precisely what people are saying, but you get the idea). The fact is, we work for the Church, and with that role, people are going to approach you, gossip about you and more.

The proper thing to do would be prepared with info you can tell her about veiling. Address her concern about piety and be pastoral in your approach. If you, as an employ of the Church, can't talk to someone about your practices, then who can they approach if they have questions or concerns? Seems to me that part of our role as staff is to be approachable by parishioners. Is it uncomfortable sometimes? Yes. But that is part of the job.

Next time, just present to her the readings that you present here. Let her know you feel more comfortable with doing it in your personal faith walk, and make sure to let your priest know that you were confronted in case she "goes over your head" to talk to him about it. He will appreciate the heads up.

Good luck!

cmotherofpirl
Posted

If she has a problem with outward signs of piety has she told the priest not to wear his collar? Explain you are simply following an ancient Catholic custom. Tell hger its perfectly appropriate to wear jeans outside of church and a veil inside, or does she never dress appropiately for differernt occasions?. Use it as a teaching moment and invite her here :D

Brother Adam
Posted

I agree about being pastoral, and being pastoral means being truthful. I would nip that "prevatican II" thing right in the but. That is my biggest pet peeve. Then simply point her to scripture and that should be enough. That's great that you veil and can influence other women to as well. I've noticed more and more people kneeling at Mass after the consecration because our family does. As someone who works for the church you will drive people crazy no matter what - just make sure you drive the right people crazy.

Posted

+J.M.J.+
[quote name='prose' post='1637609' date='Aug 25 2008, 11:26 AM']The proper thing to do would be prepared with info you can tell her about veiling. Address her concern about piety and be pastoral in your approach. If you, as an employ of the Church, can't talk to someone about your practices, then who can they approach if they have questions or concerns? Seems to me that part of our role as staff is to be approachable by parishioners. Is it uncomfortable sometimes? Yes. But that is part of the job.

Next time, just present to her the readings that you present here. Let her know you feel more comfortable with doing it in your personal faith walk, and make sure to let your priest know that you were confronted in case she "goes over your head" to talk to him about it. He will appreciate the heads up.

Good luck![/quote]
thanks prose, i really mean it. now, thanks to phatmassers, i have plenty of information to help her see this a little more pastorally. :)

[quote name='Paddington' post='1637780' date='Aug 25 2008, 01:58 PM']Lil Red! :) :thumbsup:[/quote]
thanks? :lol:

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='1637823' date='Aug 25 2008, 02:36 PM']As someone who works for the church you will drive people crazy no matter what - just make sure you drive the right people crazy.[/quote];) good point. :hehe:

Groo the Wanderer
Posted (edited)

or you could take this tact....tactfully?


[img]http://icanhascheezburger.files.wordpress.com/2008/08/funny-pictures-girl-lion-yells-at-boy-lion.jpg[/img]



I personally like veils, so tell her it is Groo-approved. Seriously, not her business really, though twere it me I would like to know the REAL reason the veiling bugs her.

Edited by Groo the Wanderer

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...