add Posted August 25, 2008 Posted August 25, 2008 [url="http://hotair.com/archives/2008/08/24/pelosi-lies-about-catholicism-and-abortion/"]link to story[/url] she is running around now saying that God sent Barack Obama to lead us, so nothing she says would surprise me.
CatherineM Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 So he's not running for World President anymore, he wants to be Pope?
dairygirl4u2c Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 she may have a point... the actual documents from the popes need examined. the current popes have said that the death penalty is immoral and should be used conservatively,,, but half the people here say to use it liberally. they argue that the historical stance has been such that or at least arguable that death penalty can be used liberally. with abortion,,, they indeed early in the church taught that it was only a sin, not murder. if someone were to look at it as only a sin, why would we have to ban it, cause we don't ban every sin? we don't say,,, you can't curse, etc etc, imagine every sin being banned etc. a pope would have had to have used words of definitiveness,,, like I define etc etc,,, for it to be truly a stance that's final. (there's stuff about ordinary magisterium and how you're to follow it,,, but this argument would wrok only in so far as it would work with the death penalty stuff)
dairygirl4u2c Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 it's in fact telling for pelosi... that the person who wrote the article, simply ignored giants like augustine etc who said it was only murder after quickening, or when the baby kicks. he also didn't cite anything from the popes, let alone anything definitive.
add Posted August 26, 2008 Author Posted August 26, 2008 (edited) [b]Hay [/b]Nancy, check the facts “For you created my inmost being; you knit me together in my mother’s womb.” Psalm 139 v 13 “Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you, before you were born I set you apart; I appointed you as a prophet to the nations.” Jeremiah 1 v 5 You shall not kill by abortion the fruit of the womb. Didache (an early Christian document c100AD) Edited August 26, 2008 by apparently
add Posted August 26, 2008 Author Posted August 26, 2008 [url="http://thehill.com/leading-the-news/archbishop-pelosis-comments-on-abortion-are-false-2008-08-25.html"]news story link[/url] In a release issued Monday night, Washington Archbishop Donald W. Wuerl said Pelosi's comments on "Meet the Press" on Sunday "were incorrect." Wuerl pointed out that the Catechism of the Catholic Church is clear, and has been clear for 2,000 years.
Madame Vengier Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 (edited) [quote name='apparently' post='1638444' date='Aug 26 2008, 04:50 AM'][url="http://thehill.com/leading-the-news/archbishop-pelosis-comments-on-abortion-are-false-2008-08-25.html"]news story link[/url] In a release issued Monday night, Washington Archbishop Donald W. Wuerl said Pelosi's comments on "Meet the Press" on Sunday "were incorrect." Wuerl pointed out that the Catechism of the Catholic Church is clear, and has been clear for 2,000 years.[/quote] That's my Archbishop!! And generally, we conservative Catholics find him a bit lacking in some areas but he comes through when he is supposed to. Edited August 26, 2008 by Madame Vengier
homeschoolmom Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 Too bad the millions of people who saw that Meet the Press will never know of the Archbishop's comments.
dairygirl4u2c Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 it's not wrong to say history is clear, but saying it's clear can be deceptive. if there has been dispute over the issue, as there has been, eg augustine, quickening etc,,,, then it's only clear insofar as it's always been taught to be wrong, or insofar as some have said that it's murder, maybe. like the death penalty,,, surely one could find people in history who were conservative about it,,, but that doesn't mean there weren't more liberal about either, and that it wasn't a disputed issue. it's these kinds of issues that make protestants beleive that there's a magic hat which the CC pulls out some of its beliefs and says they've been believed all along. to be intellectually honest, one could at least concede the points about how views have varied, and expect the pope to issue something more definitive. (not that he is being intellectually dishonest,,, he probably just doesn't understand too well the theories that could oppose him)
Winchester Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 Augustine didn't write the doctrines. He wrote his philosophy. His writings are helpful, but not definitive.
dairygirl4u2c Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 well that could be the case. but, i remember the popes having views similar to his. doesn't mean they were necessarily infallible of course. the actual writings etc need examined. here's only a few. [quote]Pope Innocent III (circa 1161-1216): bullet He wrote a letter which ruled on a case of a Carthusian monk who had arranged for his female lover to obtain an abortion. The Pope decided that the monk was not guilty of homicide if the fetus was not "animated." bullet Early in the 13th century he stated that the soul enters the body of the fetus at the time of "quickening" - when the woman first feels movement of the fetus. After ensoulment, abortion was equated with murder; before that time, it was a less serious sin, because it terminated only potential human life, not human life. St. Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274) also considered only the abortion of an "animated" fetus as murder. Pope Sixtus V (1471-1484) issued a Papal bull "Effraenatam" in 1588 which threatened those who carried out abortions at any stage of gestation with excommunication and the death penalty. Pope Gregory XIV (1535-1591) revoked the Papal bull shortly after taking office in 1591. He reinstated the "quickening" test, which he determined happened 116 days into pregnancy (16½ weeks).[/quote]
kujo Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 (edited) Reminds me of every person I've ever met who feels their time in Catholic school qualifies them to be a prefect for the Doctrine of Faith! :puke: Edited August 26, 2008 by kujo
BG45 Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 [quote name='apparently' post='1638060' date='Aug 25 2008, 08:34 PM'][url="http://hotair.com/archives/2008/08/24/pelosi-lies-about-catholicism-and-abortion/"]link to story[/url] she is running around now saying that God sent Barack Obama to lead us, so nothing she says would surprise me.[/quote] Wow where have I heard this before...oh yes. "God wanted me to be President", "God sent George Bush to be our President" "God made me President" type quotes for the past eight years. Politics never changes, everyone in politics ignores rendering unto Caesar what is Caesar's, and unto God what is God's.
kujo Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 [quote name='BG45' post='1638672' date='Aug 26 2008, 01:42 PM']Wow where have I heard this before...oh yes. "God wanted me to be President", "God sent George Bush to be our President" "God made me President" type quotes for the past eight years. Politics never changes, everyone in politics ignores rendering unto Caesar what is Caesar's, and unto God what is God's.[/quote]
BG45 Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 Thanks, but just came out a bit more vicious than I wanted unfortunately. Heh.
kujo Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 [quote name='BG45' post='1638677' date='Aug 26 2008, 01:47 PM']Thanks, but just came out a bit more vicious than I wanted unfortunately. Heh.[/quote] Nah dude. It was [b]SPOT ON[/b].
Winchester Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 [quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1638502' date='Aug 26 2008, 09:37 AM']well that could be the case. but, i remember the popes having views similar to his. doesn't mean they were necessarily infallible of course. the actual writings etc need examined. here's only a few.[/quote] We're not talking actions or writings, but doctrine. When we speak of the teaching of the Church, we are talking very particularly. Private actions by the popes does not constitute official teaching. Only official teaching constitutes official teaching. We still don't know when ensoulment occurs, but that would not change the sinful nature of abortion.
Madame Vengier Posted August 27, 2008 Posted August 27, 2008 [quote name='BG45' post='1638672' date='Aug 26 2008, 12:42 PM']Wow where have I heard this before...oh yes. "God wanted me to be President", "God sent George Bush to be our President" "God made me President" type quotes for the past eight years. Politics never changes, everyone in politics ignores rendering unto Caesar what is Caesar's, and unto God what is God's.[/quote] Oh but then we've got Michelle Obama telling us that America is "soul sick" and that Obama is going to HEAL THE SOUL OF AMERICA. Arrogant and self-aggrandizing, all of them.
kamiller42 Posted August 27, 2008 Posted August 27, 2008 [quote name='Winchester' post='1638726' date='Aug 26 2008, 01:47 PM']We're not talking actions or writings, but doctrine. When we speak of the teaching of the Church, we are talking very particularly. Private actions by the popes does not constitute official teaching. Only official teaching constitutes official teaching. We still don't know when ensoulment occurs, but that would not change the sinful nature of abortion.[/quote] Spot on. dairygirl, the archbishop was clear in explaining the seemingly contradiction: [quote]Since Speaker Pelosi has, in her words, studied the issue "for a long time," she must know very well one of the premier works on the subject, Jesuit John Connery's Abortion: The Development of the Roman Catholic Perspective (Loyola, 1977). Here's how Connery concludes his study: "The Christian tradition from the earliest days reveals a firm antiabortion attitude . . . [b]The condemnation of abortion did not depend on and was not limited in any way by theories regarding the time of fetal animation[/b]. Even during the many centuries when Church penal and penitential practice was based on the theory of delayed animation, the condemnation of abortion was never affected by it. Whatever one would want to hold about the time of animation, or when the fetus became a human being in the strict sense of the term, abortion from the time of conception was considered wrong, and the time of animation was never looked on as a moral dividing line between permissible and impermissible abortion."[/quote]
add Posted August 27, 2008 Author Posted August 27, 2008 [url="http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2008/aug/27/catholic-bishops-assail-pelosi-over-her-remarks-on/"]http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2008/a...her-remarks-on/[/url] The crux of the dispute: the meditations of a fourth-century saint on whether abortion always constitutes homicide. Mrs. Pelosi's contention that it does not brought down the wrath of the 433-member U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) on her head. Both Joe Biden and Nancy Pelosi (along with many other “Catholic” politicians) are responsible for their own souls, but I think all the rest of Catholics have an absolute right to be offended and outraged when they completely misstate Catholic Church theology. [url="http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/medical_ethics/me0116.htm"]do embryos have souls? (read)[/url]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now