Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

St. Augustine And Abortion


Recommended Posts

MIKOTHEFREAKSHOW
Posted

I researched after hearing Pelosi's interview about what the early church fathers taught on abortion. her comment on St. Augustine left me speechless

this is what i found, please SOMEONE ANYONE correct this if i am wrong

St. Augustine (354-430 CE) accepted the Aristotelian Greek Pagan concept of "delayed ensoulment". He wrote that a human soul cannot live in an unformed body. 3 Thus, early in pregnancy, an abortion is not murder because no soul is destroyed (or, more accurately, only a vegetable or animal soul is terminated).

What was St. Augustine thinking?!?!?!

if this turns out to be true, he should have never been canonized.

Posted

even if he believed that, it was because at the time there were no real scientific ways of "seeing" the baby untl the mother started to show (around 3 mo's) I don't find it horrible or surprizing.

Consider this. Until the 1800's it was common practice in many cultures not to name a child until their 2nd birthday. Even catholics who baptzed at birth gave a saint name that was really just a "borrowed" name....to thank the saint the name was kept.

Posted

Just because he was a saint, does not mean he was without error and doesn't mean everything he said is considered Church teaching or doctrine.

Posted

where exactly did you get that quote from? I've never seen that exact interpretation of his teachings. I have seen some folks take out of context Augustine and Aquinas about when they speculated about the moment in which the soul would unite to the body.

I don't believe they ever were referring to abortion at all. It was insignificant speculation, due to the primitive medical and scientific knowledge at the time.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Didymus' post='1638485' date='Aug 26 2008, 09:03 AM']where exactly did you get that quote from? I've never seen that exact interpretation of his teachings. I have seen some folks take out of context Augustine and Aquinas about when they speculated about the moment in which the soul would unite to the body.

I don't believe they ever were referring to abortion at all. It was insignificant speculation, due to the primitive medical and scientific knowledge at the time.[/quote]

Do not think that abortion and brith control is a modern day invention, because it isn't.
Romans knew of ways to cause the termination of a pregnancy as did the egyptions. Aparently there was one plant called Silphium that was used for birth control/ or abortive purposes and was harvested to extinction in century.

Edited by Balthazor
Posted

I'm not familiar enough with St. Augustine's writings to know where this came from or what time period in his life this came from. I could always email one of my former professors. He's pretty well versed in early Church Fathers.

As it stands, Augustine doesn't speak for the Church in the form of Magisterial teaching. Lots of Saints wrote lots of things in the earlier developments of the Church that aren't Church teaching today. This was sometimes the case because as we all know teachings of the Church develop over time and become clearer. We weren't handed all our doctrines on a silver platter.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Just because you are a Saint doesn't mean you are free from error, you are not perfect.
Can you email your proff and find out?

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

I find it likely that someone is misrepresenting St. Augustine. Regardless, I would argue that St. Augustine suffered from a worldview that was not entirely correct (as should be obvious to anyone who's studied him, as he seems to have retained some measure of dualism for the rest of his life, although it was, I'm certain, not intentional).

Consider that medical science at that time had no way of seeing when the life of a baby began, except that at some point after conception, the mother could feel movement. Some of the ancients believed that this was when the soul entered the body, because the soul is the animating principle of the body and gives the body life and movement. Naturally, the first sign of movement would be an indication of ensoulment, and since some women could know for certain that conception had taken place many weeks before, it made logical sense to say that the body developed to a certain point and then the soul entered. St. Augustine had no way of knowing that movement occurs far earlier in pregnancy and at the cellular level as early as conception (they knew nothing of cells, remember).

Now, the quote that your source uses as "evidence" of the argument is from a prayer (which should be the first sign that it was not meant as a scientific or moral standard, but as a poetic device). The quote is: "Thou form from a little drop in the womb; and after the formation dost Thou bestow on it an immortal soul, and producest it into the light as a rational creature, even man" [url="http://www.piney.com/DocAposConstitu2.html"]click here to see the source[/url].

Now, had St. Augustine known that movement occurred as early as conception at the cellular level, his philosophical background would have brought him to the conclusion that the soul was in the body at the moment of conception. In fact, his quote can even be taken that way; he never says what "after the formation" means. When he speaks of "formation," he means what he thought to be the earliest human form available. The ancient philosophers believed that semen (literally, "seed;" semen is a liquid, which is why St. Augustine said that man was formed from a "drop") grew into a human being. What he was saying was that at the earliest moment that the semen was formed into a human, the soul came into the body. If he had had the medical advantages we have today, we can conclude without any doubt whatsoever that he would have said ensoulment occurs at conception, when the human form is present genetically.

Nancy Pelosi is putting spin on the Early Church Fathers to make them seem to say something they are not saying. This is an old trick and is very deceptive and anti-Christian.

That having been said, St. Augustine would still have been against abortion because he opposed contraception (heck, he even opposed make-up). To try to use his quote against him, which is based on 1700-year-old, out-of-date medical science, even though the philosophy and theology he applies to that science is accurate, just goes to show how deceptive the radical liberals are and how unreasonable they are as well; to say they know enough about medical science to legalize abortion and then use way outdated medicine as a justification is not just dishonest, it's foolish and dangerous. They are toying with millions of people's lives by their arrogance and shortsightedness.

God bless,

Micah

Madame Vengier
Posted

I believe Thomas Aquinas also wrote that romantic kissing was sinful, and there are tons of very chaste Catholics who would not agree with that. So yeah, not every word that comes from the pen of a saint or even a Doctor of the Church is 100% the correct thing.

Madame Vengier
Posted

I don't understand how a great spiritual master would need science to tell him when life begins. It's common sense for anyone who is a believer in God. If God made it, then it must be sacred. Period.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

So is Pelosi basing her reasoning on science that is over 1500 years old? Nice.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1638593' date='Aug 26 2008, 11:02 AM']So is Pelosi basing her reasoning on science that is over 1500 years old? Nice.[/quote]
Yep, basically. Beware when a liberal quotes the Early Church Fathers as his defense, such a thing is rarely seen, and always deceitful.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1638582' date='Aug 26 2008, 10:53 AM'][snip]

Consider that medical science at that time had no way of seeing when the life of a baby began, except that at some point after conception, the mother could feel movement. Some of the ancients believed that this was when the soul entered the body, because the soul is the animating principle of the body and gives the body life and movement. Naturally, the first sign of movement would be an indication of ensoulment, and since some women could know for certain that conception had taken place many weeks before, it made logical sense to say that the body developed to a certain point and then the soul entered. St. Augustine had no way of knowing that movement occurs far earlier in pregnancy and at the cellular level as early as conception (they knew nothing of cells, remember).



[snip]
They are toying with millions of people's lives by their arrogance and shortsightedness.

God bless,

Micah[/quote]
After reading 'City of God' by Saint Augustine, I am convinced that somehow Augustine knew the world was round. He referred to the world as a 'shpere' in several passages. However, he was also convinced that the world was no older than a few thousand years and went at length to justify it with scripture.

As far as pro-choice 'arrogance and shortsightedness', I wouldn't credit them with so much so easily. I remain copnvinced many amongst their ranks know precisely the wrong they commit and apply a well orchestrated plan that is far from 'shortsighted'.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Didacus' post='1638618' date='Aug 26 2008, 11:13 AM']After reading 'City of God' by Saint Augustine, I am convinced that somehow Augustine knew the world was round. He referred to the world as a 'shpere' in several passages. However, he was also convinced that the world was no older than a few thousand years and went at length to justify it with scripture.

As far as pro-choice 'arrogance and shortsightedness', I wouldn't credit them with so much so easily. I remain copnvinced many amongst their ranks know precisely the wrong they commit and apply a well orchestrated plan that is far from 'shortsighted'.[/quote]
Well, what I mean is that when they use arguments like this, they show that they aren't actually concerned with the deeper truth, just with what they want to see.

Posted

Augustine could not have been too against life because he had an illegitimate son with his cartheginian girlfriend.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Balthazor' post='1638628' date='Aug 26 2008, 11:20 AM']Augustine could not have been too against life because he had an illegitimate son with his cartheginian girlfriend.[/quote]
and he was quite sad when his son died.

Posted

Yeah that is right the poor kid was only 17. :(

Posted

+J.M.J.+
and regardless, augustine would've erred on the side of life, not on the side of death!

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1638621' date='Aug 26 2008, 10:14 AM']Well, what I mean is that when they use arguments like this, they show that they aren't actually concerned with the deeper truth, just with what they want to see.[/quote]

True. and Augstine had several comments to make with respect to that as well.

Seeking the Truth for the sake of Truth versus seeking the Truth for what the truth may do for you.

Both shall find what they seek, one will have the Turth, the other will have what the other wants.

Posted

cmon...this is Nancy Pelosi we're talking about!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...