Galloglasses Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 Howdy, long time no see. Comp troubles, so don't worry if I don't reply for anything from a few hours to...a month from now. Right long story short I went to confession the last week, I hadn't gone in a few months and confessed to the priest. It was related to the issues I brought up with the priest I confessed to the time before. Now here's the problem. at the end of it, the priest suggested I talk to my GP about this, as he suggest I might need psycological help. Now this actually offended me, but I knew better then to interupt him so I let him continue with his advice. This... sounded nothing like the advice my last priest told me, who mention nothing of saying this to anyone else, much less suggesting I might need a shrink. It was bad enough that I had ALREADY thought I was crasy, much less hearing it back from one of the few people who have actually heard about my issues. The issues I had were voices in my head, which I had since last hollowe'en, they all pretty much repeated the same things, (or at least were keeping to the same topic), each week, at the beginning of the next week, the topic would change, and I'd be tortured day and night by their constant observations and suggestions. I could always recognise my own voice considering it was the only one saying "No" to the other voices. I think this is the part that the priest forgot, the voices ended after the Easter Vigil, and haven't returned since, Thank God. The priest in question was an elderly Dominican, I had went to the Priory in Newry City, (last time I had a confession in my home town, my Mother freaked and I faced an inquisition), he wasn't wearing any clerical garb, (He was in plainclothes), which I suppose I can't fault him for, it was like 3-4 O clock when I visited. Any thoughts? This thread is primarily concerned with what this priest said in relation to the other. Considering the other told me to pray more and to 'Wait and See' (Believe me, those words have significence for me), who's advice should I follow more? (Also, I appreciate what i'm sure some of you will offer, but I'd rather not talk about the issues themselves again. Thank you.)
cmotherofpirl Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 Why don't you go to your GP and ask their opinion? Couldn't hurt.
Balthazor Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 I wouldn't be too offended. I think I am crazy and I am not hearing voices in my head (the screaming from my neighbors on the other hand... :mad:) As Cmom said it wouldn't hurt to ask your GP, why live with what you don't have to?
Galloglasses Posted August 26, 2008 Author Posted August 26, 2008 yes it could. Considering I can't drive on my own yet, One of my family will have to drive me in, so I'd face another Inquisition at home. And my Mother IS just looking for an excuse to justify taking my religious cards and the like from my room.
Madame Vengier Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 (edited) A priest telling you that you may need psychological help is NOT the same as a priest "making you feel crazy". That is over-dramatizing, which leads to a unfair presentation of what really occurred. Do what the priest tells you to do. Visit the shrink and get an opinion on whatever it is that ails you. The priest wants to help but he has his limits, so he's sending you to the next step. It doesn't mean you are crazy or that he thinks you're crazy. It just means you have something that needs to be sorted out. Edited August 26, 2008 by Madame Vengier
prose Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 Okay.. This is a pretty heavy subject. The priest was NOT trying to say you were crazy. As with any supernatural event, it is important to rule out natural causes. Sometimes things seem as though they are from God or Satan, when in fact they could have come from bad eggs for breakfast. Not only was it reasonable advice, but it was helpful in that you CAN rule out any natural causes. This certainly makes it easier to seek spiritual help on these matters. You can always tell your mother you want to go to the doctor for a physical, or some small ailment. She can't find out what happens when you get there because of doctor/patient privileges.
SJRod55 Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 You said it had stopped after the Easter Vigil, that was quite some time ago. DO you still feel there is something else? If so then a trip to the doctor would help but that again would only begin a process as he would more than likely make a referral and then there would be numerous trips to the 'professional'. Perhaps if the voices have stopped you might want to wait and keep a journal of events, should you then feel you needed to go then take the journal to show your experiences. The second priest is as the others have said only trying to rule out medical / psychological possibilities before looking at alternatives. What ever happens good luck.
CatherineM Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 I read your post to my husband. He has Schizophrenia, and is used by our Archdiocese to train priests on how they should deal with people who have a variety of mental health issues. I know you just want an opinion of what the priest said to you, but I wanted to make one side observation first. 25% of all people diagnosed with issues relating to voices in their head make complete recoveries and have no further trouble in their life unless later they hit a major stressor like the death of a loved one, job loss, divorce, that kind of thing. If you are feeling better now, that's great, just be careful of the things you do in your life since you are going to now be at a higher risk. Every episode like that basically causes a small amount of brain damage, especially if untreated. As to the priests, my husband said the first priest was not very helpful. Some priests haven't been trained by either education or experience to deal with these issues. The ones who haven't been, tend to either completely over-react or the opposite, and pretend like they didn't hear what you said, or it wasn't a big deal. The second priest was right. This is a medical issue. It doesn't mean you are crazy, and that's not what he said. If you had told him that you were having numbness in your left arm, I'd hope that he would also tell you to seek medical attention. There is nothing wrong with telling your parents that you would like to go in for a check up. That's a mature responsible thing for a male of your age anyway. Men should go once a year just like women, they just don't think that way. Your mind is part of your body, and a magnificent gift from our God. You have been given stewardship over it. Are you going to show our Lord that you are being a good steward of this gift by taking proper care of it? That includes regular visits to the GP and Dentist, and it also includes getting help when you need it. Older priests are often very experienced in life issues. Please do as he has instructed you. If your parents freak out, then so be it. They have also been given the responsibility of caring for you. Help them fulfill their duties as well.
Galloglasses Posted August 26, 2008 Author Posted August 26, 2008 Ok, since my previous, longer post that I was in the middle of writing got deleted by a computer glitch on the computer I was using (YAY FOR IRONY!), i'll have to shorten this a bit. and I will post said post again at a later date, (next week if i'm lucky), There's something I have to include here, while yes I'm still feeling miserable right now. (Yes miserable, but not like the time when I was fighting with the voices, which was probably the most brutal suffering I had psycologically speaking.), there was a point were I felt nigh completely well, (This happened a week or two ago actually) this only lasted for about an hour or two, and I could feel it fading again. And there is another peculior thing. The first priest I went to, after the confession, (You are getting this priest wrong by the way, yes he was young and inexperienced, I was merely giving the gist of what he was saying, he spent a good ten minutes giving me advice after I confessed), after that confession I had one night of peace, I actually felt euphoric, (which is something I can't say happened often even before this happened), altough the day after the voices seemed to hit me with redoubled efforts. After the second Priest, while I did feel better, I also, kinda felt like throwing up, but not in the usual way, I felt like their was a bubble of air I was trying to spit out, unusual I know, but it ended up making me cough for a bit. While the advice was startlingly different, I must also ask, why did I feel different after both Priests? I also must add that there was something I held back on at both confessions, in truth it was not on purpose, I actually forgot the first time to mention it and bitterly regretted it, it happened again the second time, when I actually tried to remember all I had done but my mind felt like lead, and I did not remember it again till later that night, it was the same thing both times. I doubt it would be significent to what I am feeling right now, but I'll go to confession again about it, i'll also bring up issues with this next priest, (If I don't get one of the previous Priests again that is), and see what he advises also.
Noel's angel Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 Not to be rude here or anything, but I often feel like people read things as being spiritual issues when they aren't that at all. I'm not saying that's what you're doing, but it is always best to seek medical advice first. Stress can bring things like this on, so look at that first. Going to see your GP doesn't mean you are crazy, it means you are seeking help for something that is making you feel bad. Considering 1 in 4 patients in our surgery is on some sort of anti-depressant, these things really aren't taboo.
XIX Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 I had a priest once tell me to go to a psychologist. I've had lots of people tell me to do so. I don't think I am a wacky kook, and neither did any of the people who suggested I seek professional help. Now granted, this was on campus help and it was all paid for by the university, but the point is that I have a pretty level head on my shoulders, yet talking to a shrink definitely helped me for a while. Shrinks are not just for people who has "serious issues." We all have complex brains. We all have psychological quirks. It can be helpful to talk with a professional who might see things about you that you can't see yourself (or that you can't see quite as clearly). And sometimes it helps just to get out of your own skin for awhile. Sometimes it helps just to have a sounding board. If money wasn't an issue, we could probably all benefit from a monthly meeting with a shrink.
Autumn Dusk Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 you can find busses to take or an extremely sympathetic friend who'll drive you. don't take this lightly. Do something about it before you find yourself in real trouble
Saint Therese Posted August 27, 2008 Posted August 27, 2008 I also really suggest seeing your physician.It IS possible that this could be caused by a physical or psychological issue. Whatever the case, its important to address it now so that if there is a problem it won't progress. The fact that you realized you were hearing voices and didn't think God was talking to you, or your dog, or whatever is a good sign.
Justin86 Posted August 27, 2008 Posted August 27, 2008 [quote name='prose' post='1638635' date='Aug 27 2008, 12:27 AM']You can always tell your mother you want to go to the doctor for a physical, or some small ailment. She can't find out what happens when you get there because of doctor/patient privileges.[/quote] That would depend on the privacy laws of Ireland. And if he just goes to see a medical doctor for a physical or "other ailment" he's going to just get a referral to shrink.
Noel's angel Posted August 27, 2008 Posted August 27, 2008 Since he's considered an adult, his mother cannot find out any medical information.
Tinkerlina Posted August 29, 2008 Posted August 29, 2008 Honestly, it sounds like he just wants to make sure he's covering all his bases helping you out. Voices, like many many other symptoms, could be a sign of emotional/psychological problems. Dont' feel like you're crazy though-mental problems often have physiological beginnings, making it no different than any other illness, malady etc. I have some OCD/anxiety issues and I saw my GP who was able to help me and was very understanding-worth a shot? Good luck and many prayers to you. -Katie
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now